Skip to main content
Loading video...

Boonlake Roundtable Review - Friendly Ties Podcast

Transcript 50:44

hello and welcome to the friendly ties podcast i am here today with my friends jonathan and nick and we are here to talk about boone lake which we have played we've each played a handful of times we played a handful of times together and we have a lot to talk about this is a pretty meaty game and uh we're really excited to dive into it yeah we've talked about it a lot offline so now we got the recorders going yeah so uh where should we start this is a big one i mean i think the first question right is what is what is a boon like right that's that's where we we need to start here yeah yeah i mean thematically you are unnamed people who have arrived at this area that is uninhabited and it is very bountiful and you all competitively you know take part in the bounty together it's a very bland theme obviously it seems like it's doing everything i can to like not be anywhere in particular or at any time in particular and all the things that you do kind of help everybody and i guess i mean we should probably start with a super brief overview of it i mean the it's a like you said a medium to heavyweight game usually takes a couple hours to play and the central mechanic involves uh on your turn you select one action tile out of seven and then you do something and then everybody does something with that action including yourself and each action tile is kind of different like one lets you put pastures and cows on the board and another one lets you make levers and that kind of stuff um so it's a game where the

downtime is usually not that bad because everybody's kind of doing something on everybody's turn and the big things that you're doing involve you know putting tiles into a communal board and then putting your own pieces on those tiles so like there's kind of a race to get to places where uh you want to get there before somebody else blocks you and that kind of thing but there's a lot more to the game than that but that's kind of the mindset that you should be in uh when we start talking about this right this is an alexander fister design the great western trail maracaibo mombasa like and this is another one of his loop games where you're playing you know in kind of going around this river that is kind of a big player timed loop i don't know what what's the mechanic for that called like i think it's just a timer it's yeah you go around the river enough times the game is over yeah uh now i think before we move on to talking a lot about this game i do want to briefly say that i did make a sponsored tutorial for this game it's on the jungle games youtube channel and i'll put a link to it in the description of this podcast i do also want to point out that i am biased right capstone games is a client of mine so keep that in mind as i talk a lot about my uh ups and downs with this game uh the other thing i want to say is that we did not film a playthrough video to go along with this so uh if you want to see how it's played then you can go ahead and check that tutorial out i'd love to kick off talking about that sort of central core mechanism of the game the i select an action tile and then i do that action and then everybody does kind of the secondary action there's like a main action and a secondary

action because that's easily my favorite part about this game i think that getting to do something on every player's turn feels like you're never disengaged with from the game and it's interesting you know someone won't always take kind of what you expect you can either play the game where you're trying to anticipate what people are taking or just kind of like as they take it like you know come see kamsa like as it shows up you do with it what seems best and then on your turn you get to choose sort of like what the main action is followed by the secondary action and i just think that that mechanic is it is a really wonderful way of doing player interaction in a in a euro game yeah especially one where traditionally if you weren't doing stuff on other people's turns i feel like there's enough going on here that downtime could potentially be a factor waiting for somebody to go through so much but you know in this game you know if it's my turn and i select whatever action it is maybe it's the upgrade a couple of uh people on the board well after i get to do an upgrade everybody else gets to do an upgrade or development action kind of thing and so i select that tile and now everybody's can think okay you know do i want to upgrade do i want to develop and sure the person it's my turn and i get to do this twice because that's kind of a perk for this specific action but even while i'm thinking about it everybody else is thinking about it and that one in particular you kind of have to do in turn order because when you develop you put a person out and you take a spot that somebody else might want to go to but many of the other ones aren't like that it might be a situation like the levers i briefly mentioned before

you can build these little levers which are you know like like literally a you handle you grab it with a handle and you pull it down well it's a cardboard token but it looks like a handle and when that's selected everybody can just build a lever at the same time like that's kind of fully simultaneous the lever i build has no impact on somebody else's and oftentimes the secondary effect is just anybody can play a card from their hand any card and sometimes when it's your turn you have some restrictions so again you know now it's nick's turn and nick decides to do this thing and that thing but i know just from him choosing that tile i get to play a card for my hand so while he's doing his turn i'm looking at my hand and i'm doing it and then once he finishes he asks is everybody done and usually everybody is and then you move on to the next person yeah yeah i mean i want to agree like i think that's my favorite part of this game too nick and i love that action selection multiple role you know mechanic if you will you know and i feel like that is one of my favorite mechanics and i've yet to find a game that i i truly love that does it i mean i i love it in puerto rico and san juan and race for the galaxy and so many games have have utilized it but i've yet to see it done for me personally kind of in the way it's done here in boone lake where it's like it's done in like a kind of a heavier engine building euro where you're kind of trying to do something like where it it feels so central to this game but there's so much built around it and i do think that it's it's done really well here and i i i really enjoy it for that because as i

was like looking after we played it the first time the rest of my collection being like i actually realized i don't own you know i mean i don't own boone lake either but i don't own any game that actually utilizes that mechanism despite how much i like it because a lot of those games that i mentioned in other games the amount of thinking that kind of goes into that choice it becomes all the game is and there's so much more that happens in boon lake if if that makes sense yeah i mean the reward for being leader in boone lake too is unique it's this is a heavier game than puerto rico race for the galaxy by like a fair margin right but in those games whoever's the leader you get like a minor perk right like it's a discount of one or plus one at this or get an extra card or something like that whereas in this one when you're the leader on something you usually get to do something unique right like i place a tile or i break the rule about this it's it's rare that it's like you get some minor discount it's like you have a fundamentally different turn structure than other people and i can't think of any other heavy games that have this kind of mechanism and i really think this is a good prototype for what that could look like for other games doing that in the future yeah i totally agree yeah on top of this it's kind of a two-for-one when it comes to mechanics because i mentioned there's these seven actions and they kind of sit in a stack and you there's an incentivization mechanic baked in to this you know everybody gets to do an action thing because the location that you take that tile from will dictate how far you go down that river that we talked about earlier that's kind of like the game clock for the game uh the higher up the stack you

choose the farther you can go on the river with your little ship and the lower on the stack you choose the slower you go and that's important because when you select a tile you take it and you put it to the bottom of the stack so that means if i choose the action to uh let's say uh put a pasture down and put some cows down on my turn well i put a pasture i put a cow and now it's anastasia's turn and maybe she's got some reason that she needs to put a lot of cows down she could do that she could on her turn choose that same action but she's gonna barely move on the river and actually lose points if you choose tiles that have been selected too recently you're actually gonna lose a point or two which is not that big of a deal when you usually win this game with around 200 points so losing a point or two maybe it's not that that big of a thing but it's definitely incentivizing you to say you know you don't need to do pastures again maybe pick this region scoring that's sitting up there at the top spot lets you move four times and uh it's just a neat way that they they filter up the longer it has been since they've been selected and you know i think it's interesting because you might think you hear all that and you might think oh that's gonna that's gonna garner like a lot of ap right like not only am i trying to pick which of the seven actions i want to do and there's going to be these like you know additional bonuses that my opponents are going to do and now i have to think about them in the order but what i actually you know because that order is going to like you said dictate how i move so i have to think about how many spots do i need to move and while that is all going on one of the things i do really enjoy about that aspect of them being in that order is that it almost actually

is self-limiting in a way like your choice of tile becomes much more obvious because you're likely not going to want to repeat what was just done because the follow action if you will of like john placing cows like i also got to place a cow so like i don't necessarily need i don't need to do it unless i really really need to do it i'm likely not going to do it but i also don't want to lose those points and i know nick you've talked about playing it where you like almost always take the top two let you move the furthest and being the leader we're using in multiple ways but being the leader on the river if you will um being ahead being that being the the player who is kind of like essentially setting the pace um which you know will be very familiar to those who played maracaibo you know you kind of like who is setting the pace for each round and so doing that you in order to do that you need to take more of the spots let you move four times or three times on the river and those are at the top and likely those actions are going to be not always the ones other people would potentially take and i think nikki because they're up there right right right and you've talked about kind of planning your game where you just always take those and you just kind of make your strategy work around what you take so it's like i guess what i'm trying to say is your options actually get narrower and the decisions get a little bit easier by the nature of the way these tiles are laid out right i mean i'm just such an opportunist that i have a hard time leaving those things there and it's you know there's seven actions all of them are good right like in some way or another

um you might not want to do you know region scoring in one moment because what region scoring really does is it's not scoring often so much as paying resources and so if you don't need resources it doesn't feel great to take region scoring as your unique action so you might skip over that and then say well am i going to play a bunch of cards no i'm not going to play a bunch of cards so i'll skip over that one then you look at the next one that says you can put some tiles down on the board and put some some you know cow meeples on top of them and say okay great that's exactly what i want to do right now so i'll dive into that um so you can kind of like go through this like exit process of like what it is that you want in the moment and pick the thing at the top that seems juiciest of those options so yeah i think that it's it's nice it's satisfying um in terms of picking those and that that flow is really interesting you know a game ostensibly the number of turns that you personally will take in this game depends on the player count is going to be like 10 like really only 10 turns but usually when you hear that in a game you know you're thinking of something like grand austria hotel where it's like you only take 16 actions and like it is very tight but in this game me taking 10 actions means that i take 10 main actions 10 secondary actions on my turn 10 secondary actions on john's turn 10 secondary actions on anastasia's turn and then in each of the scorings you get two free actions there as well so it sounds like not a lot but it stacks up really quickly yeah yeah the one critique that i have and is that of this mechanic is that it does lend itself to being better at more players like i think three is

the sweet spot on that mechanic because having played it several times two players with each of you and we did play it our first time as well we did play it four players as well i i think it's a little long of four players but that was the first play so i can't actually speak to four players beyond that so i feel like three is the sweet spot but four is probably you know it's it's good in a different way and the and the river does accommodate that supposedly to kind of help keep that timing down i shouldn't say supposedly it does but at two exactly what you just said nick you have well you just said you're gonna take 10 actions plus 30 secondary actions at two players you're only going to take 20 secondary actions if you will and i think that not having those additional actions from another player for me does make the game a a little bit less bountiful it's just it's just like a little bit less i just i sort of miss out on having those additional actions come out i mean i think the the quantity of bounty is relatively similar uh in the sense that like probably in a two-player game you end up taking more turns where you're the main action person right but there's something really satisfying about like taking secondary actions on other people's turns and making them work for you yeah and i think that's for me the part that's missing in the two-player game because i agree with you i think that three or four players feels nicer than the two-player game not that the two-player game doesn't work totally fine honestly i think it's kind of hilarious that that we're like this game lets you take

too many turns it's better when other people take more turns than you which is you know kind of feel like we're in upside down world when we say that but i totally totally see what you're saying with it um in the two-player game i feel like i enjoyed two maybe a little bit more than both of you but i totally see where you're coming from we're just like oh it's my turn again look there's almost this uh you could you could sink into the comfort of somebody else telling you what you're gonna do on your turn and like yeah yeah you still have choices like you know nick goes and he says everybody can play a card like okay well what card do i play like i still have choices but you know it's like oh nick went there i guess i'm playing a card cool it's almost like a little you know endorphin gift hit thing it's very strange when we think about it well and one of the secondary the main there are a lot of secondary actions that you can do you're kind of specific to the tile but on i think five of them you have a choice whether you're going to do something that is kind of a can like we're talking about placing cows you can also place a cow or you can play a card and you can play any card and we haven't really started to talk about the card mechanic in this game which is just another layer we probably should it's a huge yeah we should kind of pivot to there but but i guess i guess we'll talk about it so you know you have this giant deck of cards so you've got cards they come in what is it four different suits three three different three different suits and so just when you thought we had talked about the seven tiles and there

was enough decisions to make when you choose your main action if if if you have a card in your hand that you you that you can play that matches the suit of the tile you're allowed to play it or you can discard it and get two money which is actually one of the main income generators in the game there's there's other ways to get money but this is this is a way that you can do especially in the early game if you don't have cards that you're quite ready to play you can discard them and and make money or you can play them and so again there's this like added layer of choice which does the tile i take gonna correspond to a card i'm able to play but to like loop this back into this idea of the secondary actions and being able to take those five out of the seven let you just play any card you want or discard any card you want to make two money and there's something very freeing about that so i guess what i was sort of alluding to when i was saying i feel like three player is better than two is actually just the fact that i feel like i can play more cards in three player and the cards you know are big part of this game they're like they're the meat of this game it's kind of getting well you can argue a lot of things are the meat of this game but they're they feel like like at least a leg yeah that makes sense i mean there have been many times playing the game where i will really want to do a red tile you know the tiles again they have three essentially colors and the action on the red tile is just what i really want to do maybe i want to make a lever and i look at my hand and i have no red cards i've got you know the light blue cards and the dark blue cards because apparently those are the colors well it's the the time of day right the

the more exactly in the evening and i i like the suits i like this i like it too i do too i do it's daytime it's sunset and it's night it's not light blue red and dark blue you're right you're right you're right um but so you have a sunset tile and you don't have a sunset card and it feels bad like like i want to take this tile but i can't even discard a card for too many i can't play a card well i guess maybe i'll do something else but yeah i think that really does kind of close the loop on why it's nice to often have turns when it's other people because you could play or discard any card um and and you're like well cool i didn't want to play any night actions for a while anyway so let's get rid of this and get the two money that i exactly need to do the next thing yeah i think it's one of the aspects of the cards that demand you'd pay attention to them right is it's the hand management component of it if you want to keep your options open you need to have a viable version of you know each suits card sitting in your hand so that you have the flexibility to do that on your turn and if not then you just need to be aware that you don't really have those options at the same level of efficiency that you would otherwise and this game is uh largely a tactical game right because we're all doing kind of similar things throughout right like if i'm taking the same secondary actions of the action that you're taking we're we're largely going on the same path right this is not a game where you're developing a unique strategy you know you might have some nuances and what it is that you're doing but at the end of the day you're trying to like win by like small these small edges in every one of these places yeah

yeah and before we move on from cards um there's two other things i think we should touch on uh the one is that i really do think there's a solid argument to be made that this is a card game with a board there's a lot of important things that you do on the the board i don't want to minimize them but but as you said every single main action the first thing that you get to do is play a card that's just baked into every single action on your turn like we mentioned before like putting pastures down in cows well cool before we got to put the pasture in the cow you also got to play a daytime card or discard it for a couple of bucks so that's really baked in there and i think i don't think i played a game where anybody played less than like 10 cards by the end and we've certainly seen games where at lea where somebody has played like 20 plus cards over the course of this game and these cards often times have end game uh conditional endgame things on it like you know one point for every cow you put down uh they're frequently just one shots like increase yourself on a track uh and sometimes they have a conditional thing like every time you go to a certain spot in the river draw an extra two cards or that kind of thing so you really like there's cards everywhere like there's a bunch of other stuff going on but like you can't not play cards cards feel almost like the backbone of the game to me anyway i was a little i do want to talk about the cards because they were a little bit of a whiff for me and i was really surprised about that because i one of um fister's other designs americaibo is like one of my favorite games of all time and that game is very card driven in terms of how it interacts with the the board and in this game the cards uh i think are not quite as impactful as they are in maracaibo um

another game that i want to draw comparison to is terraforming mars because you know that's another game where you end up playing a ton of cards throughout the game and they actually the the cards in that game have very similar feel to this game and then a lot of them like you play them it's one and done right you like you pay the costs that are associated you get the rewards it like impacts something on the board or one of your tracks or something like that and then it basically just sits there until the end of the game maybe it scores you some points at the end of the game and that's cool i mean i like that idea i like games with big decks that make you make those kinds of decisions uh but the reason it's a little bit of a whiff in this game for me is that i didn't feel enough diversity of the impact of the cards um as i would have liked and i'm i'm i wonder if the two of you feel the same way about that yeah yeah i think i feel that too nick i mean that cuts in a little bit to like kind of my larger thoughts on the game one of the things i love about maracaibo just like you is that you get these cards whether they're the story cards or otherwise but you do get some cards that come out that just have a very unique feel that make you want to be like hey i want to build a strategy around this and i don't find myself i don't feel like there are any cards that i want to sit there and i'm like okay yeah i'm gonna i'm gonna like go this path i mean they do direct you enough like you might have one that like discounts cows or something or sorry it gives you extra money for cows and you're like okay cool maybe i'm gonna build some more cows we're really focusing on cows it's a very one aspect

of many in the game but i don't i too miss just that feeling of like like a wow card or a like hey i want to do this and i actually there there is one card in the game i feel that way about and it's the statues um which essentially these are cards that let you discard other cards and give you a mass amount of points as you're playing the game and then our last game of this i think i played two or three of them i think i played two of them yeah they cost a lot they're hard to play and you have to discard cards to get those points but i do think those are cool and so i found myself in situations where i was like okay i need to like get enough money so that i can like play this down this game has i think 165 cards in it so it's not quite terraforming mars and it's not quite arc nova but it's a big deck of cards there on the table and i think i've heard this term of baby steps games before where some games let you take little baby steps you know like putting together a little plan and then you know you end up with like putting everything together over the course of many turns and like boom i do the thing that i've been setting up for lots of turns and other games are like like golem or something like i have 12 turns every turn needs to be big like baby steps in golem then you're in real trouble and this is a game where it almost feels like that massive deck of cards they're all a baby step like every little card and there really aren't cards that you play down and it's big and it's impactful um i

played this game five times and i i can't think of honestly a single moment where like anastasia you played a card and you were like i'm playing this card and i'm going to do x or y and i say wait what are you doing yeah it's just you you play a card and that card probably lets you do something you could have done some other way with like a tiny discount or yeah maybe now when you uh go back to the cows maybe now the next time you put a cow down it's going to be slightly cheaper um or you know maybe now when you discard a certain type of card you get a couple extra money you're just piecing together all these little things and i feel like it's because cards are again like this flowy backbone to the game where every single main action that you have you can play cards and on most other people's turns you can also play cards you have so many opportunities to play them that it seems like the design pushed towards making them simpler less flashy and unfortunately less interesting compared to other games i mean we played boone lake for the first time within a month of playing arcanova for the first time and uh that game has a you know 200 cards or so and i feel like we were five games into arc nova and we'd still draw a car to be like holy cow wait until just you all wait wait until i play this card and then like two rounds later you play like this is the card i was telling you about you know like you have a give this excitement about drawing whatever like a massive crocodile or something like that and in uh in boone lake they're just these tiny little benefits um that cost money and money's made like essentially the resource of the game and if you're not playing cards then you're not gonna

win um so play the cards and you know do the tactics of the things you have in your hand it's just it's interesting like i don't fault it for the fact that the card deck is a little lackluster when i think about it from a baby steps perspective like if you play 20 cards and every card is huge what's that going to do to the decision space and the analysis paralysis and all that kind of stuff i don't even know yeah and one thing that we've noticed about this game is that it seems to be very well tuned for a game that you score like 200 points in the game has like balances between these like different options and there are a lot of options of things that you can do and so i think that's probably part of why those baby steps are required right for the like game to not just explode with i drew this card and so it sucks for you guys i'm about to run away with this game yeah yeah i mean this is this is not being balanced is not a critique that i would ever ever say about this game i mean like the joke on this game is that in our first two or three plays i did completely different things like utterly different strategies you played four the first four plays your score was within four points yeah and it was all about two of them nine 191 you just no matter what you did no matter what i did and in fact that was uh that was actually a critique of mine i was like this game is too it's still a critique this game is too well balanced like for me to score 189 twice and then 191 and 187 like and do utterly different strategies one time i think i did all levers one time i cleared my board one time i did like i

just i went in different directions and then and we're going to talk i think a little bit about how you kind of have to do everything in this game you know to do it well but nevertheless you can still kind of specialize and i did that and yeah it's just i actually thought i had an upper threshold i i think i still do i still don't think i've gone above one day one i was i was i was almost mad at it i was like i can't do better than this score you also couldn't do worse apparently exactly yeah yeah yeah so i i just want to comment and agree with you nick on that i don't think we should wander too far off before giving just a little bit more attention to the resource system at a very high level uh i mentioned that money is the main resource of the game you just coins whatever and every card well most cards cost money um and also most cards cost resources there's four resources in the game uh wood loam stone and steel i think and it's got this really funky thing that i'm not going to go into the details of in a podcast but on your player board you have a river that goes wood loam stone steel and you have these two little canoes and wherever a canoe is it's making you one of that thing if it's on wood it's making one wood if it's on steel it's making one steal and the cards you play cost money which you spend and then you need to prove that you're making the resources so if you have a card that needs you know five money a wood and a steel well here's the five money i have a canoe on wood i have a canoe on steel boom um but if the next card you play needs stone you need to move your boats and i'm already going in too many

specifics but it's a little mini game of sliding your two little canoes back and forth one direction's free the other one costs money and you know money's the main resource so within the mini-game of sliding your resource boats around you still need to make sure you have the money to play the cards that you have in your hand right and then the other component of that is you have opportunities throughout the game to increase your resource production in one of each of those things or yes two of each of the things and i really like a dopey little mini game in games and this one definitely works for me um the feeling of you know i've looked at my hand and i've i i want to play like this one and this one and this one and if i like move my canoes in this way that's the correct order to play them after you like lay down those cards you're like oh i'm so i'm so crafty because i've organized my news in the best way and that's a good feeling i like it well you know actually speaking about the cards we haven't talked a lot about the income phase of this game and there's a lot of ways you can get you can draw cards and get gold in this game but one of the ways in which that happens is during these four income or scoring phases that happen in the game so basically you've got this river and there are four dams along the river and whenever a player crosses over one of those dams you do a scoring and during that scoring a bunch of things happen you're going to get to do a couple of actions it's very similar to the end of loop scoring in maracaibo but one of the things that happens is there is a gold track and a card track both of which are going to give you gold and card income and what's interesting and

i'm really curious to hear guys thoughts on this is that these tracks are kind of self-limiting right you gain more gold but then at a certain point that gold kind of stalls out and i think at one point it goes down and you draw more cards but then at a certain point you draw less cards as you keep going but then of course as you get higher on the tracks you start making more and more points right so then you're scoring more points every round than you were before yeah i mean the a lot of the stuff in this game is i think just about ultimately scoring points this is not like you have an income in this game but it's not a game where you build an income system like a lot of other euros that we're probably accustomed to playing because exactly as you pointed out that money track is only going to go up so much that card track is only going to go up a teeny amount we haven't talked about removing pieces from your board but when you play onto the board you remove things on your track much like terra mystica or any kind of game like that and reveal income that's there and what seems to be important is that you do a little bit of each of them to get your resource generation and once you start doing more of any of them removing things from your board moving up the money track moving up the card track then they say all right now you just get victory point income instead so the game basically says look dabble early to get more resources and then beyond that i'm just giving you points in whichever way you decide to go yeah and honestly that kind of that does kind of bum me out uh the more i think about it like the board specifically like you're removing things

on your board you have these little houses um and you have these little cow people inhabitants of the region and then you have settlements so you put a person on the board through an action and then you can turn a person into a house and when you do that you remove the house from the board you put it onto the main board and you can turn a house into a settlement and even here like it feels like there should be like a very clear delineation like houses do something different than settlements perhaps and at the beginning of the game they do the first two houses that you remove give you two money income cool every single settlement that you remove gives you three victory point income so it feels like all right i get it i put a person on the board i get something immediately then i put a house and i get money income then i put a settlement and i get victory point income but that's not it because only the first two houses give you money income every house after that i think you could put up to six of them gives you victory points and this this brings me back to the point about the the tracks where it seems like from a tuning perspective there's these real breaks that are kind of stopping runaway engines of of certain types like you're not going to get a crazy car draw engine the car draw track it doesn't let you you're not going to get a crazy money engine because the money track doesn't let you it caps out at seven and sure now you get more and more points off of it and then even again with the houses like i was surprised when i saw that i kind of expected that like all houses would you would give you money income and then like all settlements would get you victory point income so you know if you want to lean hard into settlements leonhard harden getting points you put the settlements out or maybe you're struggling for money will go hard on those houses but it's almost like the

game took that decision away from you to like maybe even dig your own grave by making too much of a money engine and not much of a victory point engine it's it's saying you know sure the first couple houses will give you money but after that it's points the first couple of this you know increase your card job but after that it's points like you've had enough and it's a little weird like we've we've all commented that we kind of want it to let us go nuts it almost feels like the design is a bartender that's cutting you off like you have drank too much of that coin and card draw alcohol i'm cutting you off and you're getting glasses of victory point water for the rest of the night i mean it's exactly like what we were saying about the cards right this game has so many ways to earn points or rewards right like so many little ways so just like you were saying with the cards it's like every card will give you like a baby step it feels like that's exactly the same thing with the boards uh with your player board and frankly with the main board itself i mean one of the things we haven't talked about yet is that one of the actions you can do is place people on the board and those people will turn into the houses you were talking about john and those houses will turn into settlements and when you place those people you're going to get a reward for everything that you place and that's great it feels good and like when you move along a couple of books a couple of cards what do you need exactly and it does create for some interesting choices there's a lot of variability there's tiles that come out that kind of that cover the board and where you place those are interesting and they change the game and and

there's also points or a reward you know whether that's points money cards uh and some other things every time you place a spot in the river so while this game doesn't like kind of allow you to run away with anything or to really build an engine that's just gonna like give you that constant you know churning of stuff it does let you build and build and build and as we're talking about it i'm actually starting to even appreciate that more from within this conversation that it really is like how are you gonna build all of these tiny tiny little rewards that you're going to get from all sorts of places you're like oh no matter what you're doing you're always getting bored i mean frankly when you're when someone else takes an action you're getting a reward you're like constantly getting rewards yeah so um it's almost like i almost feel like we're being greedy and i'm going against my own point but i always feel like we're being greedy being like well it's not enough it's not enough that i'm constantly getting stuff everywhere i want more and yet and yet i say that and i still i wish there were ways uh to get a little bit more yeah i mean there's there's a bunch of psychology behind like rewards and like the most impactful is actually like variable reward systems right where you don't just get something every time but in this game you get something every time and so i think that maybe mutes it a little bit over the time i think one place actually where the um rewards or the income that you get that actually is the most diverse in this game are the levers and uh i have i have a couple pros by the levers and then like one con about the levers so the levers first of all i'm not usually

one for tactile components in games but i really like that they like sit in their little lever slots and you like ding them down and like ding them up i actually think it's like yeah and it's like a just a very good like intuitive euro mechanic for like you get this reward and now you can't see it anymore so you can't get this reward i think that's actually like a literally wonderful yeah it really works for me i don't know why but it uh it's it's quite satisfying um and there's a diverse option of of what they can do they can get you more people if you do this or like change the condition of this or like get these rewards immediately or like skip this kind of action and get this bonus they have quite a variety of options in the levers more so than i would say a lot of other aspects of the game which i think is cool too because you can kind of like choose where you want to go in the game my con though for the levers is that i find myself buying the same ones every game it seems to me and maybe i'm just a coward when it comes to playing the game and like i really need to like be braver but i'm having a hard time not buying the same ones because they strike me as the best and maybe that's just because it's the way i play but i i i do worry about that in a sense yeah there's 12 different levers and when i first saw that i kind of figured that would be kind of a big variability uh launch off point um like 12 different levers a focus on one one game focus one on one another um but it does seem like there's not much there to stop you from just accidentally doing the same thing from each game to game

well i think one aspect of that is actually that scoring for the levers incentivizes you to buy more of them right so it's not like you can you can go through the game and just you know buy a couple but if you have even four of them you're gonna score two points for every one and if you have seven of them you're gonna score three points for everyone and so like as you play the game you you're sort of like okay wait now i need to do like my levers and i need to get them and so you sort of encouraged to get a lot of them and i do feel like there is a sort of pattern of like which ones will be most effective for me to get the most out of this um you know having said that in our last play of this i used a lever that i did there's this element of the game that we i don't think we'll really touch on but this is another resource called either bases essentially and they're they're very specific and you don't often need to use them but but if you do need to use them you do and they're fairly hard to get and there's a lever that lets you get rid of them or use them in so anyways it sort of felt like a unique strategy to use this particular lever and it used it as like an income generator and it worked pretty well for me and i was actually i agree with you john that like for me it was fun to do that as a point of variability i was like ooh this is the thing i did this game but i still built all of the other levers that i would normally have built and then that was kind of like my your jump off one yeah yeah i i don't want to harp on it too much but it does often feel like

you get the lever for the points and then you're like well which one should i take you're like well i'm definitely taking a lever i can afford it it's worth the points uh this one as opposed to when i first saw it i thought it'd be the kind of thing where i'd be like salivating to get one lever and then like can't wait to get the next one i just felt a little bit uh disappointed by ultimately the the effects and the impacts that they they've had in our plays yeah i mean the first two you buy really matter but i think we just seem to find that we keep buying the ones that are like give you more money or give you more cow meatballs because those seem to be the ones that we just get choked on all the time yeah yeah yeah well i mean speaking of the variability in the game we've talked about you know the different kind of paths you can take if you want to go heavy in levers and that can be what we hoped was more of a point of variability that we've talked a little bit about the tiles that come out that kind of create a different board state that are going to give you different rewards and different things but i think the main and the cards obviously but i actually think the main point of variability in this game is the is the scoring tiles right that yeah which we haven't talked about at all yet no so i kind of wanted to like take us over there and talk a little bit about them so yeah i mean there's so much going on into this game and as part of setup everybody gets their own little scoring tile and there's always going to be four of them and there's always four scorings in the game and in each scoring you have to you have to pick one and this is i fully agree one of the largest points of variability at least as far as like what am i going to do what what was my

pattern going to be because like in the last game that we played the one i chose was cows um you want to have a lot of cows that's all we talked about right this whole podcast so much going on i went into that game like trying to have five cows in the fourth round not going in all the specifics of it but you have to score each one of them exactly once and it's better to score yours later on um but i know nick had a tile to have lots of settlements so nick was really focused on getting a lot of settlements out uh in some games it's regional like have certain um pieces and in different regions of the board and you know we keep saying like the scores have been somewhat tight and they're often in the high 100s and the amount of points you get for these scoring titles is actually relatively small uh like the the biggest uh uh benefit that you're gonna get uh if you you like i said i planned all game long to have five cows and i got eight points out of that like that was my my big kudegra essentially right at the end that it all came together and i had the right amount of cows but i guess if all your scores are released tight then even in the 200s eight points can be a big swing but yeah like looking to see what those scoring tiles are not only what you picked because that's kind of your long-term strategy to try and get those eight points out of it but also seeing what your opponents picked to figure out the kind of path you want to get there it's worth thinking about because you actually lose points for the scoring tiles you don't pull off and again it's like oh i lost two points instead of i got two points or i lost three points instead of gaining three points all these things seem small but i mean that's kind of the game right the

game is just full of all these small things that add up into a mountain of points anyway yeah i have a little split on the tiles which are the end game points but they're also the interim scoring right which ones you you end up choosing to to cash in on throughout the course of the game i like that they sort of set a restriction on you and they say hey you really need to pay attention to these four things and you know the first one that you do you can kind of more or less ignore they're always very easy at the beginning but then you kind of need to pay attention a certain amount and if i was like play testing this game i also wonder if this this would be probably the component of the game that i would say does this game really lose anything if i cut these out of here so i i i'm torn because i like that they sort of like put you in an alley but there's already so much going on in this game that i don't know that i would really miss if they weren't there yeah yeah i mean i think it depends on the tile like some of them are to be pranked pretty boring like where it's just like okay have some houses or you know cows or they just they kind of align with strategies that you're naturally going to take i mean we've talked a ton about cows but one of the really cool things about cows is actually one of the more interactive elements is that cows earn points by being near lots of settlements and as the game goes on you kind of want to strategically position your cows to make points off of other people so that's one of the advantages of cows for example but if you have a scoring title that just benefits you for something that you're probably already gonna do

have a couple cows have a couple of this because this game is really one of those games where you kind of need to do a little bit of everything so you're probably going to do a little bit of everything and sure it encouraged you john to specialize in cows but there aren't a lot of tiles that really ask you to do something very specific and in fact i did have one of those last game and i had a i had a lot of fun kind of aiming my strategy towards that and it did allow me to do somewhat unique things like use a lever i wouldn't normally have used because i needed to do more money or whatever so i i i like this aspect of the game but i do wish there was more variability in the scoring tiles and more opportunities or encouragement to do unique things with them one thing i've spent a lot of time thinking about this game because i've really enjoyed playing it um quite a lot uh honestly this is one of my favorite alexander fister games i think are arguably my favorite of his games right now as far as just pure enjoyment of playing um and being interested in in playing more and it's been a really interesting thing for me to think about because i can get fixated on many of the parts of the game that do disappoint me i am disappointed by the levers i am disappointed by you know the income tracks as i said i have i do have a feeling of like i wish that draw deck was was more vibrant with its you know ability to draw a card and be excited about it as opposed to just you know piecing all these cards together with all these other ones but at the same

time i've had a ball every time i've played this game so i have this really interesting situation where the critic in me i feel like it doesn't quite match up with the just gamer in me that just likes playing games and and playing cards like so many cards the cards get you stuff and doing actions on my turn doing actions on other people's turns i just really enjoy the process of playing this game even though i've i've complained about it quite a bit yeah i mean it's a it's a good game maybe even a very good game uh there's a lot of sort of you know kind of intuitive euro-y mechanics in here it's a lot of rewards which are obviously satisfying to have um it is it is fun i just think that it's uh these things that were that i'm i'm harping on the the design to me doesn't make enough of like a brave choice or a bold decision there aren't i don't feel like at the end of this game like i could go and tell someone else to be like oh man like i executed this in boone lake and they'd be like that sounds rad i want to do that like at the end of the game it's like cool that was fun to play i you know edged you out here so it just doesn't have like a a very like oomphy like powerful narrative and i think that's the part that just keeps it below feeling super exciting and i think all these things that we're talking about loop around that like it's tight it's

well designed and there's also just like this grander component that it feels like it's reaching for i really wanted to have and just doesn't quite get there yeah i i agree with both of you i mean honestly coming into into tonight to to record this this podcast with you guys like i i was having a hard time and i mean even to a certain extent during this discussion like having a hard time collecting my thoughts on boone lake and i feel like i've had a hard time collecting my thoughts on it uh playing it over the last six weeks or so um because i i really like this game it has so many things that i like i've already said it's the best action selection mechanism with the with the you know follow actions that i have seen and enjoy i love that i think the little resource mini game no matter how you play it is is is is a really cool way of thinking that just i like that there's so many benefits that you just get things everywhere and like i like all of that i like i i like alexander fister's designs he's one of my favorite designers i like his games i like the way he approaches designs design i like the way this game is designed it's just it's still unique right like that's a cool thing about a lot of his a lot of his designs they take modern board gaming pieces and and turn them around like this idea of the loops

and the the river and the variable endings and and the pacing and all of that so i like all of that so for me there was a point after our first play where i thought oh this is going to be it this is going to be my favorite fister i can i can get rid of america i book and get rid of great russian trail like this is this is going to be this is going to be it for me and what has been difficult for me is that i really like this game but i don't love it and i almost frustrated that i don't love it like but it is such an enjoyable two hours like it's well worth the time to to learn it to play it it's very enjoyable to play there's very little down time because of everything we've talked about yeah so i i i really like all of that stuff and so i mean this is truly one for me where i i can't wait to see if there's going to be an expansion for this game and i'm not someone who's like that normally where i was like oh an expansion to fix the game or an expansion to do this but just because sometimes expansions can add elements to games for better for worse that just push them in a specific direction or take them to a new level or just add just enough additional variability that you can start to pull out some different strategies so they do add an additional layer that's just like hey this is that thing and whether that that fixes any of the things that we've talked about or whether that just adds some freshness that makes me want to keep exploring

this game i i can't wait to see that because i do think there's a lot of really cool elements here it's just and this is just it sounds so weird for how often i complain or you know we as as board gamers we complain about balance or tuned-ness and games and all that i just it's it's it's almost like it's just it's too perfect it's just it's it's and i just i want i want some some piece of it that i can just i can work and and and feel like really really proud of and and and and i just haven't been able to find that here and um i wish i could the flow of the game is really good and i designers do this often but i really hope that fister more so than an expansion actually takes the idea of the flow of this game that main action secondary action and the way that that works and incorporates it into a design in the future which i think is totally viable i'd love to see that yeah well i think that's going to wrap up everything we have to say about boone lake obviously we didn't really touch on how this game compares to maracaibo our great russian trail you know alexander fister's other you know great hits and i think that's something that we've talked about maybe doing another episode just talking about that because honestly that'd be fun i think we could talk for another hour just comparing that but we do have a lot of thoughts about that in fact john and i just finished a game of great western trail which is john's i think what first time playing great western trail in like five years yeah i think since i made the review

yeah and uh nick is a total guru at both maracaibo and great western trail i have more to say add that too but you know for now i mean i think i think boone lake is a is a great game that is well worth checking out and you know obviously we have we have talked about a little bit some of it's uh some of the things we have issues with but we would love to hear your thoughts if you played the game if you have any questions about the game uh please check out the youtube uh version of this we'll put a link in the description we'd love to hear your feedback we'd love to see your comments so thanks for joining us to chat about boon lake and we look forward to talking with you guys more see you next time

Progress saved