Ulm Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm taking a look at Alm which is a two to four player board game designed by Gunter Burkhart this one takes around 60 Minutes to play on average before I get into my review of ULM I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go-to online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order so om is a euro strategy game where you're trying to get as many victory points as you can over the 10 Rounds that you play through so the main board is going to look like this which is divided up into eight different segments and you have a river running through the center of the board here which is going to be a way you can lose or gain points at the end of the game you've got a deck of cards here which play quite a significant part uh in the game you've got the cathedral which doesn't really do anything it's just there for Aesthetics but it does act as a little storage point where you can put these little round counters on to show how far through the game you've progressed and as opposed to the main feature of the board is this three by three grid here which is how you take and resolve your actions you also have these Guild crests which again can come into play later and some generic resources such as these om sparrows your coins and a bag full of other tiles which will come into play a bit later so the turn structure for this game couldn't really be more simple what all you're going to do is going to lean into the bag you're going to grab one of the tokens at random and then you're going to play it on one of these rows or
columns in this three by three grid now optionally you can choose to cash in one of these old sparrows in order to take one of these tokens from the little dockyard here just to give you that more kind of certainty about the actions you want to take but let's just say I did choose this coin at random now what I'm going to do is I'm going to either put it on one of these rows or columns and slide all the corresponding tokens already there to the um to the relevant directions so let's just say I played this coin in this direction therefore I'd push this one up like so and the three remaining tokens in the one I've just played or in the Royal column I've just played in will be the actions that I take this turn so in this example I'll take two coins from the supply so and you'll also move your boat once so what I'll do is I'll move my boat along the track here which you can see is going to start kind of losing me fewer and fewer points as the game goes on and potentially gaining me points um as I cross this bridge here I could even acquire some bonuses if I push right to the very end so once you've played your token and resolved the actions in any order that you choose you will voluntarily get to choose to play a card or not and provided you have one in your hand but at this point I don't have one now what's important to say is that now this part of the dock is blocked nobody else will be able to activate a token in that column until these are cleared now let's talk about what some of the other actions actually do so you've already covered the coin one and we've covered the uh the boat one now this one here this kind of
checkerboard will allow you to take a bunch of tiles from one of the docking areas so therefore you know if I end up taking this action I could take that one there and put it in my personal Supply meaning that somebody else could Now activate that column again the seal action allows you to cash in two coins and take one of these seal actions depending on where your boat is um along the river so you can see here in the first segment I'll be able to activate this seal or this seal action and when you do that again you pay your two coins and then take the corresponding bonus so these do all kind of different things um such as being able to take from the kind of docking area gaining a coin moving your boat um drawing these shields from here and then choosing one of them I need to do all kind of different things such as giving you victory points uh these ones here with the very specific locations on will will allow you to claim one of these spots as your own so you'd find the matching symbol like so put it on there now it means that anytime anybody goes there you will gain two points you know points you'll also gain two points uh immediately now additionally whenever you draw one of those sales you'll put one of your markers on the Scott on the corresponding image on the grid here like so meaning that when any whenever anybody uses that um that row and pushes it onto the segment next to your marker you will gain an OM Sparrow this selection will unlock a permanent power for yourself such as being able to gain two points whenever you align three of the same symbols in a
uh in a column a row or a diagonal Direction whenever you gain a coin you've got an additional coin you can clear an additional dock space um whenever you whenever you take that action or you can even move your boat faster along the river and there are even some more of these ones you can play with so each game is going to feel slightly different uh these are the ones are a bit more self-explanatory drawing cards um this one here again another seal action I'm sorry another um Guild Crest action this one here allows you to put or gain a point that each marker you've already got on the board in each quarter and so on so you can see you get some quite nice little bonuses and the final action you can take is the card action itself now when you do this action you can either play another card from your hand or you can cache in tokens that you've collected from taking the dock action here and if you cash in at two different tokens two different types then you'll get to draw one card from the deck here and keep it in your hand or if you do two of the same you get to draw two cards and keep one of them putting the other one on the discard pile so let's take a look at what these cards actually do so you've got ones like this and I should say all these cars are broken down into two pieces of or two choices I suppose one of which is going to be able to play immediately and the other one you can store for in-game conditions like this city wall card here for example says I can use one seal action to place a seal in a city quarter of your choice you know without being restricted to where your boat is well this one here says at the end of
the game for each City courser in which you have the sole majority of Stills I'll gain two points so it's got a bit of a majority mechanism there or a lot of the cards will look like this we're provided you have a certain um token in your supply you can throw it back into the bag and get the corresponding reward so in this example I get a coin two points and I'll get to move my boat zero to two spaces and a lot of the cards will have these kind of set collection bonuses on it like this where it means that you can see this card has like a painting symbol so this painting card will give me three points if I have three of them I'll get 15 points or if I have a painting a barrel and one of these cloth symbols then I'd get 12 points that's essentially how the game is going to play and what's those 10 rounds are over you're gonna add up all the points you've gained throughout the game and you're gonna add up all the um victory points you've gained from your card play and the ones that you've got from traveling along the river or potentially lose some if you don't make it past the bridge and also for every remaining on Sparrow you have you're going to get an additional point okay so let's share some thoughts on Alm and I think the best place to start is with the key mechanism at least in my opinion is this three by three grid I think this is very clever um it works nice and smoothly you know just draw that token from the bag take a roller column and the three actions that remain in the uh in the main segment are the actions you get to take this is like a dynamic thing you know sometimes you'll play something which will leave something on the plate for another player because you know inevitably you're going to interact with
each other but you're getting opportunities and tokens in certain in certain places if somebody really needs to fly along that boat track then they can potentially line up a huge boat action and fly along that River yeah very simple but it works well and it's something we didn't really see very often in fact I can barely think of any games that use this mechanism in order to resolve the actions you take you normally use it see in some kind of draft or stuff like that but not in actual the actions you're taking so it's a really nice touch there and I'd love to see this be used um in more games to be honest I also thought that um some of the player Powers were really cool like uh particularly I think this is my favorite one because it adds a whole new dimension to this part of the game where if you start lining up um certain actions like for example in a future turn if I ended up taking a coin action like this and I've left these three here therefore I would get an additional two points there so it adds a whole new dimension to that um that three by three Grid or even like ones getting more income taking more um you know more segments from the dock and stuff like that moving your boat faster they're all worth having which is really nice now something I will say is that sometimes and I say sometimes actually happen quite often the times I played this you are left without many choices on this grid just by the way that the um that the tiles come out like for example when we played this the other day um there were there was no money on the grid at all there was no money left in the um in the dockyard here so therefore I think both
of us were completely broke and there was no way we could get any money so therefore it was like Not only was the money actions out of the picture we also couldn't take a Steel action because we had no money to do it in the first place so it does feel like sometimes you are wasting your whole turn because you can't really pull anything off and because you don't have the resources to back the action up I did enjoy the way this seal action works with the boat action because you have that very limited time window in which you can take that specific boat out through that specific seal action because you know as soon as you've gone past here then you can kiss goodbye to this action so that those two things are you know they do conflict with each other you want to stay and take the actions you exactly want but time is ticking and you want to be moving your boat along as quickly as possible because that is a lot of points you're bleeding if you don't make it past this bridge here see I thought that those two things worked really well to each other and nice conflicting mechanism there I also thought it was pretty cool that you can use the cards in two different ways whether to get that quick grab now and you know back those points early and secure them or take that risk and build towards end game set collection so that in theory I think it's a really good touch in practice it didn't Quirk quite work the way I would have liked because what I thought was that most of the time in fact all the time we ended up taking the instant action because there were very easy ways to get points like for example this steeple card you only need to throw in one of these seal tokens or in or one of these
car tokens into the bag and you'll get six points instantly which felt like that's quite a healthy amount of points for very little work whereas you could you know maybe get three different cars at the end of the game just to get 18 points so it was like yeah it didn't quite work and it felt quite an unsatisfying way to gain posts and it's like a lot of the time you felt like you didn't earn your points at least in my opinion I also thought the use of these shields was okay um because you do get to draw two of them and keep one of them um much like the cards I usually found like you would always just take the quick grab rather than taking the you know the smaller amount of points but potentially getting points if anybody else goes to that region because normally especially later in the game some of these um seals you'll draw these shields you'll draw um you'll put on the board here but everybody's already gone past that point anyway so they're not going to go back and you're not going to get any more points from it which usually meant you just take the you know the Silver Shield and get the points that way uh instead additionally if they know that the building belongs to somebody else they're probably not going to go there because they don't want to give you any points so a good idea um you know we've seen a lot of worker placement Games and Things use this ownership of buildings where you know it only gets the only gets a benefit if somebody else goes there in this one it didn't quite work and that kind of ties in to the ownership of these different buildings here as well you know when you put your token on there you're just going to passively start Gathering These Arms fires which is really useful you know they're really good to have but I don't think it's really going to affect or impact on the decision space when it
comes to the other players just because you've got a still there it doesn't mean that I'm not going to take that action anymore it's not going to make me think twice and it's just like a passive benefit to the owner which again just didn't feel that crunchy or didn't add that much more weight to the key decision I think the round structure for this game is really good I'm gonna just draw that tile move the slide one along and take those three actions potentially play a card if you want to they're nice and smooth and I you know it works nice and cleanly and it means that no matter what player account you're playing with the game does Move Along at a pretty good speed um interaction is mainly passive through the use of the um the other three by three grid the opportunities you're leaving to other players and the boats do interact with each other in quite an interesting way where you don't actually share spaces with other people so for example if these two spots were filled with boats and then this player wanted to move they'd actually skip over all three onto the next spot so you could use that to your benefit and of course you've got the other stuff as well such as using buildings that other people have claimed but I've already talked about that not being such a big part it doesn't play a huge factor in the overall experience I think the production for this game is of a very high standard the components themselves are good quality and particularly the tiles that you play with they're nice chunky pieces I'm going to hold up well and you've got your other traditional Euro bits such as your wooden pieces the weatherboard and the game looks I think it's you know looks great this is exactly my taste when it comes to how board games um how I like my board games to look um yeah very atmospheric love the way it looks just feels like a cool traditional um Euro and yeah nothing overdone
nothing overdone cards are well written um so yeah no issues at all with the production I suppose the cathedral is a little bit Superfluous but um you know it adds a little bit of um you know a little bit of table presence to the game okay so it shares some final thoughts on almonds so there are quite a few positives and quite a few negatives I have to say um about this game so positives mechanically uh this part here the three by three grid I think is great I would love this would love to see this be used again and again it's a great system intuitive it's fun it's interactive and dynamic so that's really cool and I also like that the game um scales well it's nice and quick it only takes around an hour to play and those 10 rounds do fly by pretty quickly um and it's just it's generally well put together I'd like the um I also like the pressure of you know the river system you know you want to move along as quick as you can but you don't want to leave some of these opportunities behind so you might want to sit there for a while but as you're doing that time is ticking and um every every time you're not moving along the river means you're potentially giving up the additional victory points that's a really cool touch now as I said I do have some negatives to say and that is mainly due to the card play it feels like the kind of the Crux of the game or the way you're going to get all your points is through the use of these cards and a lot of it is going to come down to the luck of the draw if you keep on drawing your cards that are play part of your set here then you're probably going to do well and because you don't get much mitigation to flip you know to filter through the deck that's either going to work for you or it's going to work
against you additionally as I mentioned during the main bulk of the review um when you get these cards here where you can just Chuck a tile into the bag and get a whopping six points it feels very unsatisfying and it doesn't feel like you earn those points so that for me just left me feeling a little bit empty and just like yeah not not very satisfied and not feel like I not does make me feel like I played well so it kind of feels like all the stuff is Loosely tied a bit kind of pointless when all ultimately it's all going to come down to which cards you play and which cars you draw um so yeah sadly that's kind of my sticking point with this game a lot of potential here would love to see it kind of revamped into a version two or something because there is some real cool redeemable features here but ultimately it's not going to stand up to the great Euros despite looking awesome you know the board looks fantastic yeah the gameplay is just a little bit short of the mark and I'll probably rate it somewhere around a six out of ten so certainly not a not a negative review not a bad game at all but um considering the amount of Euros I have in my collection this one would no way um hit the table anymore so that is om