Skip to main content
Loading video...

Through the Ages: A New Story of Civilization - Discussion

Transcript 31:01

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for through the ages a new story of civilization one quick caveat that we have to mention if you watch the run through um the josh and i uh forgot one uh rule um i don't know i was gonna say major rule but it is a rule uh which is the food upkeep like how much you have to pay in food uh otherwise for each food you can't pay you lose culture for uh for culture per food that you can't pay uh we for some reason attributed the level of happiness was you didn't have to pay it's just like hey you guys are so happy you don't have to you know you're not starving you don't need to eat so the final scores in the run-through are higher than what they would be um but honestly by the end of the game anyway like we we had so much extra food that we would have been able to pay that upkeep oh yeah um so it really only hurts you in the early game anyway but just want to throw that out because i know i'm gonna [ __ ] hear about it uh anyway anyway this is uh this is a game that has been out for quite some time this expansion took forever to come out and it really just rebalanced the game um and just added a few literally just new leaders and and wonders uh this is a game that we've done on the channel before but it's in three parts i hate doing that for one game if it's not a campaign um and it was four players and it was

just a miserable miserable experience um but uh josh what do you think what did you think i mean i like the game yep um as is as a what's it called a 4x game exploration oh yeah uh expand exploit and exterminate i don't know i know it's called a 4x game as a board game version of that this does a pretty decent job of executing what like sid meier civilization does um it's a little more tedious because all the cube management and uh i do apologize for not commentating a whole lot during our playthrough i was thinking very hard yeah this is this is a hard one to do a run through for because yeah it takes a lot of thought process there's not a whole i mean there's not really a lot of banter when you're playing actual sieve yeah like it's it's a lot of i mean because there's a lot of turns where you do nothing you just click yep and it's like your next turn i'm waiting four turns before that wonder's done um say there's this and then like crusader kings and age of empires and all that straight uh strategy games that require a lot of thinking you don't talk a whole lot i don't know how many times my wife has showed up and been like what are you doing i'm thinking i have to yeah um no but i thought this did a pretty decent job of executing that idea

on a board game yeah i was really surprised this uh i remember specifically saying like the first time i did the discussion for this game that it's like it does civilization so well like i think it does a fantastic job in terms of yeah the the uh upkeep the the progression that you should be making because if you're behind in food or resources um and you don't know the ways to actually upgrade uh you're going to be behind you're going to have a miserable time it's the exact same way in civilization if you aren't generating happiness your people are going to be pissed off then you're getting no resources if you're not generating culture you're not getting this if you're not doing religion and of course in this game there's no multiple ways to victory there's no religion victory or there's no uh technology victory that is like my my biggest downside i think of this yeah it's that you have to win through cultural points i think it's all lumped together it's like if you think about it like i did win through military or i could have like i literally had war of culture that i could have just swiped 60 points from you yeah i mean you had the culture of the generated but it's like that's okay you're not losing 60 but i'm gaining 60. yeah um through that if i went to be a lot more aggressive i could have knowing full well you weren't going military but i was like i don't want to do that because i know you're not going to battle me in that so i would just be an [ __ ] just to be an [ __ ] so i mean going for wonders and there's no i don't think there's a wonder

victory i they just ben give you benefits um and sieve uh wonders give you culture yeah and that's a accumulate cultural victory so and you might be like why the [ __ ] are you talking about civilization and not through the ages is because this game is basically that oh yeah and they had a sid meier's card they did yeah there is actually a sid meier civilization board game it's not that great um but here's here's where i have a problem with this and i i mentioned this in the original discussion this game takes about three hours as a two-player game yeah i mentioned do you know quadruple that i mean because i think it took about six maybe six or eight in a four-player game uh in that game you have you have packed cards and there's more negotiation uh i only wanted to do this run through with two players because i knew nothing was really getting missed out on yeah no but what i mean by that is this game still took about three hours it does civilization so well why would i play this when i can go play civilization exactly it's like if i can go place i and that was my other thing we were playing and i was having fun but it's like if i wanted to do this i would just play the game which is i mean video game which is a huge testament to the game exactly very good if you want to play civilization but you don't have a pc or you don't have an xbox i mean that because i think civ's going on xbox game pass if you don't want to do

the technology um you only are a purist with board games then this is the perfect game to go out and get because it replicates that so well it does yeah there's no four ways to victory but it's more of kind of an abstract thing where it's like if like i think in technology it's first one to space flight right yep it's first one that can create a space station which i mean first space flight you and me to score one per level of each technology you have in place so this is the tech if i got this one you know i would have gotten uh 1 36 9 10 i would have gotten 12 points yeah for for having that so they lump it all in together as culture um which is it's the best way to balance a board game yeah yeah exactly like it'd be it'd be wait it's like if it was really four ways to victory then i would be like throw this away and just get the [ __ ] yeah i mean yes three hours in a two-player game granny you wouldn't play civilization with two is way less time than an actual full game uh civilization actually takes i think i've been playing civ 6 for as long as it's been out and i don't think i've completed a full age or like a whole game yet yeah and i started from prehistoric and i think i'm just now in the medieval and that's like i don't even know that was an option of like starting that early and then just try and go through the the

whole age um but with like dark ages or whatever cavemen and with this and i always kind of had a weird disconnect i mean maybe that's just kind of the nice aspect of civilization is whenever you look at the military it's like it doesn't your whole civilization doesn't progress and this game it does that as well it's like i have an ocean liner hollywood transcontinental railroad but yet my warriors still use spears yeah like it's it is a weird kind of thematic uh it's like yeah we we do selective breeding we we have oil we do but we still do alchemy like we didn't go up into the computers or scientific method it was always kind of a weird thing that your your civilization doesn't all like it doesn't all uh upgrade to modern times yeah but i feel like it could be kind of the fun of the game though is like this is how my my civilization kind of panned out yeah and i i mean i like it you had so many wonders from across different areas of the world whenever um because i just grabbed the two and then whenever i had i think it was michelangelo and he was like hey you don't have to pay extra actions to get get a wonder um i was like oh that's that's what i'm doing and then he gave me a [ __ ] ton more culture granted that was only for that age and i liked that i liked about this game how the ages you you gain benefits through that if like like if there was an h4 and charlie or maybe an h5 charlie chaplin would go away you wouldn't have as much culture

points by the end of it yeah uh i believe in like because the only comparison we really have is the civilization video game uh in that once you get a great person like charlie chaplin he's alive until the game's over yeah and this it made it feel like oh they have a life span yeah and they follow it well with um i mean other thematic elements territories are similar to if you expand this is the the expansion like you've got settling cities yeah you go and explore and then you're like oh i'm gonna settle the city here and it gives me these resources yeah these hexes and all yeah it did a very excellent job and i mean in terms of us i mean i will say this is a lot easier to grasp granted we did miss the the food upkeep which is actually it's really it's really punishing um and i actually do have a few negatives about this game um the food upkeep would be fine if you had a surefire way to be able to upgrade your food but the fact that it's random through the the way the cards are coming out and there's a chance that you can miss the level two the or the age uh the age one irrigation or um you're you're struggling the entire game uh because you you don't have like you you'll have to to be able to do everything or not everything to be able to do certain things well and keep up with other players who did oh hey lucky me i got irrigation oh

sorry do you return the second car yeah they go away then it's like lucky me now i don't have to worry about food as much as you do and so you're sitting there putting all these workers just so you can produce like five yeah but that means that you have five workers down and then you just kind of have to then start delegating more a little bit so i get that thematically yes you haven't figured out how to produce food better to to you know accommodate for the population but it's still not fun uh when trying to play a board game that takes about three hours and you're struggling for three hours so i wish there were ways that you could for sure get those upgrades um instead of like i would have much preferred because the way that your turn starts is that you replenish the car drill which i get why they did that because it otherwise the game would be super long it would be very long because it's like if it was oh hey it replenishes at the beginning of the start you know the start player's turn that would just suck yeah cause it's like oh well you get all the stuff as it becomes cheaper mm-hmm and i have to buy one that's super [ __ ] oh yeah that's another good point i was just more thinking of the fact that it would be super long oh yeah and the cards would cycle it would increase the length of the game like like this would never come down on my turn yeah so i would have to pay three or risk you getting it for one that's true yeah so it's just it's kind of frustrating when

there there are the way that the cards come out is more of just like well i could have really used that but even though you didn't get it i can't get it because it's getting cycled out and and that could be that could be a little bit frustrating um the other thing about the game that i think is uh oh what i was saying was this game is still kind of easier to grasp because civilization has such a steep learning curve oh yeah uh it's it's even one of those games that if you if you're playing with people who even know a little bit more than you do you are you're gonna be sitting there looking yeah you're gonna be like why why don't i like why am i not gaining any science like i don't understand i have this i bought this technology that says i gained science oh it's because of these four things you didn't take into consideration here this is a it's all very straightforward like oh i have a philosophy i have a cube on it i get one science i'm gonna put another cube on it i get two scions uh the iconography also real real easy it's like obviously this is a stone that's what you use to build stuff yeah um yeah they just said yeah it's all just resources and food which food literally does nothing except pay for more workers and keep them keep them happy um the aspect of what can also be a little bit frustrating which is kind of random is the military cards like literally

like once again you got three of that card culture right there yep yep there's three literally all right there it takes five plus but i mean this wouldn't be as as bad oh i had war over culture it wouldn't have been as bad had you actually kept the military we even talked about that i think uh at the beginning it's just like if you you don't it's like i never try to win through military anyway i think that's just boring but still you'll lose otherwise so you kind of have to have some military say when i play civ i have played civ as every civilization just to see which one i like the most and the military ones you have it feels like you have to play them as military otherwise it doesn't feel like they're it's achievable to win yeah um actually that's a good that's a good you can keep going but i do have a question for you and this does a good job it since everything's based around culture even warfare is a part of your culture in this and it generates points uh you could be whatever kind of leader you really wanted like i was a democracy there at the end going from death uh despot to despotism to theophysical theocracy and to constitutional monarchy than democracies yeah like it's it's very nice uh but you also don't get like the i the i how would you say that the

nationality bonus or the i don't want to say racial bonus it's like the civilization bonus yeah like japan gets uh samurai and extra combats oh yeah uh china has advancements in technology faster there is nothing unique about who you are that was actually my question was in in lieu of that they just had a bunch of leaders but you could only ever have one leader per age and that was kind of i think their work around because you don't you're not handed a civilization be like okay you're alexander great you you have to play military um otherwise if you try to go if you try to go wonders you weren't mahatma gandhi and uh you didn't know you didn't nuke everyone yeah exactly and so that was that's kind of my question i i almost would prefer i i personally like uh looking through all the civilizations and being like oh who do i want to play as and what are they specialized in um but i think that takes a lot more balancing definitely because you there are definitely civilizations in the in the game that are absolutely broken and here i feel like yeah okay you have you know these six total leaders for each age you only get to pick one of them so you're you're gonna pick the one that benefits your strategy the most the way that you play yeah like i went wonders with um

i already forgot his name uh michelangelo michelangelo and he's just like oh yeah build wonders it's like okay yeah i will do that and see how that works out for me just like i swapped from i swapped really fast the charlie chaplin from isaac newton yeah yeah cause you went you went it's interesting i i do like that everyone starts out the same the game kind of everyone plays relatively similar but it does quickly spread out yeah it does diversify um i didn't get theaters till the very end um so i was i i was actually kind of more military even though i never exactly i had ways i mean because i had aggression cards in my hand like this one armed intervention take up the seven uh culture from your rival but for those if i attack you it was kind of like a uh you it you always were drawing a lot of military cards and that's where you could play bonuses to try and be like and i wasn't that high up there so i was it was never worth it to try and fight you um but it was really more i had military through my transcontinental railroad cartography strategy and satellites and then i had one for bread and circuses and i was really kind of going i think i went more kind of exploration was oh yeah territories and having the military might to be able to do stuff like spanish inquisition pretty much yeah is is how i went um which is still fun

so i i i do like this game but it still comes down to i would just rather play civ on my pc absolutely um just like the way i started was how i usually start in civ i try and focus heavily on science and like get as many technologies which they didn't come up as often as i thought they would yeah um i took them all yeah you took them um but i focus on science which science helped with the governments and the the buildings oh yeah uh and then i flipped like i usually do in civ and i go heavy into culture because at this point i'm usually the most advanced so i can focus on making people happy right um the other thing that is is in the game that goes to military which one once again neither of us did for the run through are the tactics and those can become just incredibly gross like if i absolutely wanted to i pr i'm pretty sure i could have like i could have you could have easily made it to where i was less than a hundred yeah because i mean there was some in here that i was actually gonna do i wanted to do at least one aggression act but it was like i think it was aggression ray destroyed up to two-year rivals urban buildings and so whenever you first got it wasn't movies it was your other one that charlie chaplin was the uh it was the officer when because you spent like all your resources to put a building on it and the very next turn i was gonna blow

i was gonna attack you and just destroy it and then gain resources for myself um which is it's about valid it is like one thing i do actually like about this game is the events like the fact that whenever you play them a new one's gonna come out so like the players kind of have an idea of what what uh what's going to come up so you can plan a little bit and those i was banking on at more anyway i had one in my hand that was literally about wonders and i was super hoping i drew and not you because you never would have played it yeah i never would have played it uh but so i got it and instead of attacking you i was like i think i can still win by end game points and then you ramped up in culture and i'm like is this still gonna math out right for me uh ended up being actually extremely close granted we would have lost more points because of food but none of us none of us would have ever had disgruntled workers yeah i know which is at least good this is very good uh because that's where you don't produce and if you don't produce then that would have affected the game a lot more so at least we were good there we just probably would have we i wouldn't be at 279 or whatever 229 you wouldn't have been at 205 yeah like it's really the difference here's the other thing i got to bring up about this game this company made this into an app and yeah it and i have played that app multiple times this is absolutely unnecessary now yeah which is extremely i mean it's it's

kind of unfortunate because i mean i know there are people out there who absolutely hate apps like or they they don't want to play board games as apps but we could have literally like done a pass and play like we could have just played on my on my phone i don't want that to affect my rating of this game knowing that now but the fact that it exists it it completely removes all the tediousness of of moving it up it makes it obviously it it really does and they essentially made their board game a video game they did so they and if i have to pick this or set up i'm going to go play safe exactly i don't remember how much it is i might actually look that up for this for this run through um but it the app is so damn good it's not like it's like one of those those apps where it's like it's kind of like this um it is this game it just like automated everything it comes yep completely gets rid of like like the the console okay i'm gonna pay 15 okay so now i need to take three and move it down here okay so these give me extra blue do i just stack the blue like like it's it just completely yeah makes it makes this game obsolete it's 10 bucks but app yeah how much is this board game not ten dollars it is live save yourself some money i think it's 60 well it's been it's been out for a while but so i'm not i'm not 100 but that's probably around how much it

was 60 or 70. no no offense to cge or um uh well the company made the app yeah so like so it's not like a fan-made app that made that screwed them out of money they're the ones who designed it you guys dropped the ball on that one uh i mean some people it's weird apps for in the board game community some people love app assisted games others [ __ ] hate it how am i going to play the game in 30 years when the app's not supported and it's like you don't even play the game a year later yeah [ __ ] idiot it's like how i don't know um that will that's going to affect my score though knowing that it's it's crisper it works better and they they we could have played it with me and you and two computers yeah like and it just goes it's it's why wouldn't i just play it turns this into a three-hour experience into about maybe an hour yeah if you were if you're in fact i think it's like it might actually be less in a two-player game i haven't played it too i've always tried four and i get my ass kicked like i i suck uh on for some reason on on the app but i also whenever i play app games i'm not as involved you're not trying to comment well yeah i mean even cooperative games i played aeon's end on steam and i just don't care as much i don't i don't read every card i'm not as involved so i just kind of quickly go through

that i'm just like oh wait why is stuff happening i did the same thing in through the gauges the app like i'm not as like looking through my hand of cards strategizing for turns ahead but there are people who do that and ten dollars versus six sixty plus if you if you get the rebalanced expansion then yeah i mean it's this game's not needed you don't need to own it if you have a phone or an ipad or steam like yeah and it doesn't yeah at that point get it as the app if you get on steam then might as well just pay for civilization yeah i know because yeah they're pretty close it's it's a double-edged sword this does such a fantastic job at being a civilization game however it's so close to an actual already well-established video game that it's like i'd rather just play that because there are more options um that's that's disheartening it really is i yeah it's this is easier to understand um oh by far the rule book they did a great job like your first game handbook you kind of it kind of explains to you what you do on your turn um things to uh like what what the cards are you go through the the different ages um like as as history kind of has unfolded you know and bill you know earlier you know dark ages military medieval

to modern era so um but i mean the packed cards they're there if you have three players that two people can benefit off that um the war cards are still in it for a two-player game that i like the war cards uh because it's like at least gives another person a at least a chance to try and lessen the blow like yeah you probably couldn't have gotten 15 military but you might have been able to get five and lose and be like oh okay well and now i'm only losing 15 points instead of instead of 20. uh so i do like that um because the war is only in between you and another person in a four-player game it's not like i'm attacking everyone like and say if you're having to take that and taking that like the it would be vastly different right so actually yeah because it would have been it was 20 points so uh that would put me at 159 yeah so you actually would have won had that had i not put in that um but it was it was a smart strategy on your plan to do the one fight and it was just enough right so it ended up paying off uh other than that yeah i mean the the verdict for the game is that it's a it's a really good board game however they've it they've made an outlet where you don't have to even set up the game yeah and deal with the weird cubes and these boards actually from a i know this game's older but like now

games need like have like should have like uh dual layers so these are insets so you're not bumping like if you're sitting here just like oh oh no [ __ ] uh yeah they have little divots in them yeah where did oh crap i had so like there's all my resources it's like it's i had this many i have all the movies um but yeah no i don't know but uh does it say when this game came out i want to say like i mean this is there was actually an original version um a while back and then this is obviously the new version uh this came out in 2015. yeah so um civ 6 came out 2019 20. a few years later civ six it's like two yeah it's like two or three years old so and it's like sieve six is nuts how in depth it but we're we're going on about a game that we're not playing currently right so so yeah i mean other than that like i don't know uh a whole lot else to say about it i mean if you absolutely hate technology get it you will get a civilization game but if you have any of four like those four options where we get a phone a computer or a gaming console

you have better better options out there um so on a scale of one to ten uh after knowing that they've kind of eliminated all this and honestly if i were to have the option i would be okay with playing on the app uh i'm gonna give this a seven okay it's a good game yeah uh seven is good it's not average it's halfway between five and ten right so five is average tens is excellent seven it's good yeah it's a good game yeah that's actually what i would give it to is a seven out of ten um yeah for the exact same reasons like it's it's not aggravating like the the final scores are really close um yeah i mean you commended for making it so close to a well does i mean a game that's been out for years uh and i mean it's just it's it's a fantastic civilization game it is it's very well done but get the app if get the app it's just it's cheaper and uh if you don't want to get the app get civ because civ is just as good so that's true so all right that's our thoughts on 3d ages a new story of civilization let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day just for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content

if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved