Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hamburg (Bruges) Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 18:34

hey everybody today I'm taking a look at Hamburg which is a one to five player board game designed by steffenfeld and published by Queen games as part of the stefenfeld city collection this is a reprint of an older Stephen fell game called Bruges now before I get started on my review of Hamburg I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer when it comes to buying games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so Hamburg is going to look like this when it's set up and I should say there are certain things you could add in or take away depending on the experience that you want in this little overview I will be ignoring this part of the board here because I don't think it's going to sway you either way but essentially in the middle you have this track that you're trying to climb up with your mequel throughout the game the further you climb is going to give you more end game scoring at this part here to the top right of the board is going to be a storage area where you're going to store these five different colored meeples you have these tokens here and you also have an area here where these coins are supposed to be but I put them in the storage pot and you have these wall segments too you have a section here where the dice are stored you have this section down here where this Harbor is where you can use these boats this is another optional module but I think this one is pretty simple so I don't mind explaining it with this you know initial overview and you have this little kind of church area down here where these priests can go which can increase the value of different buildings that you build throughout the

game you also have this card display which shows the five different decks you can draw from throughout the game all of which correspond to a different color which will also tie in with the dice color and also these Maple colors as well because this is a very color-coded game and everybody is going to have their personal player board that looks like this we're just going to monitor these five different threats that you need to manage throughout the game if these reach Breaking Point by you know reaching the end here then you're going to suffer a pretty nasty penalty which um we'll talk about a bit later you also have these segments here where you can build the wall and potentially get in-game points and also claim the statues which are available and also you know the order which you claim them is going to decrease the value of those statues and you also have these kind of temporary majority tokens which are all placed spaced up for each player at the start of the game but as the game develops they can potentially be flipped over to score you end game scoring um additionally every player is going to start with five cards in the hand and then you're gonna be good to go so the first thing you're going to do in each of the eight rounds is to replenish your hand of cards to five and when you do that you can draw from any of these five decks and the colors can be very important after that you are going to roll the sixth Dice and that is going to affect a number of different things so if you ever roll a five or a six like I have here on this um on this blue Dice and the uh the silver dice here you are going to increase your Threat Level of

that type so you can see here this one has slid up and also this one has slid up now as I mentioned earlier if these ever reach all the way to the end here they're going to give you quite a nastier effect there such as losing a wall piece losing a building you've built losing all your money losing all your workers or losing a foundation of a building whatever is rolled on the black dye is going to associate to this part of the board here and you're going to put that little priest here on the matching spot you've just rolled so for example I rolled a four with the Black die therefore I put it on the four area like so now what this means is that at the end of the game every single building of these types is going to be worth a point and the more the um priests build up on a certain section it means the more those buildings are going to be worth if you choose to play with the boat module here the threes and the fours are going to determine which boats are going to be available to be used at this round and then the ones and the twos are going to associate to the track here where each player can choose to spend the cumulative value of all the ones and twos rolled in order to climb the track so at this moment there's only one value two here therefore each player can choose to spend two money from their supply in order to climb one step on that track so after you've drawn your cards and you've resolved all those dice rolls then you are going to go into the main bulk of the actions where you're going to using your player cards to do different things now there are six different things you can do with these cards the first of which is to Simply take money and when you take money you

are going to discard a card of a certain color and take an amount of coins equal to the pit values here so I could get rid of this card here in order to take six money from the bank the next thing you can do is to reduce the risk of one of these disasters affecting you and when you do that you are going to discard a card of the matching disasters color like for example if I wanted to get rid of this gray card I could choose to reduce the risk by sliding this down making me a lot safer and less vulnerable to being affected by that and whenever you do that you're also going to gain a victory point you can also discard a card in order to take three workers of a particular color so if I just chose to discard this brown card I could take three Brown workers from the supply and add them on to my player board now these workers are useful for one of the other actions and they're also useful for activating in certain buildings the next thing you can do is to build a piece of your wall working from the inside outwards so you can see here the first one I have to build is a gray colored card so therefore I would discard that gray card I would spend the coins on display there so it's going to get more expensive as you do so and then you're going to take a wall segment and put it on that spot like so now if you have enough wall built where you cross this um three point Market at the end of the game you're going to get those as end game scoring additionally if you ever reach the very extremities here you are going to take the highest available statue and you're going to place it on your player board like so which again is going to count towards

end game scoring additionally if you're playing with the boat module here after you build a piece of wall you can discard a worker of the matching color in order to activate one of these active boats here and these can do let you do different things such as taking money and letting you take more workers and let you activate single-use buildings again letting you reduce their disaster risks Etc and the final two actions relate to actually building and constructing buildings uh the first one is to build a foundation for a building and when you do that you're going to take the card you're going to discard a worker of the matching color so in this example Brown and then you're going to build that face down like so meaning that you now have the capacity to build buildings on top of it so let's say in a future term I chose to build this card here then I can choose to spend this from um or spend the amount of money this one is free just by chance and you can build it on top of one of those foundations you cannot build a building without a foundation and when you build these buildings they're going to give you a bunch of different abilities there are a ton of them um so you've got tons of different engines and things you can build and abilities that you can trigger at certain points in the game and we'll talk about what some of them do very shortly now something to bear in mind is that a lot of these buildings have the three symbol here which means that as a free action you can choose to basically tap that card or use one of these um used markers here to show that you've used it in order to use the relevant ability so in this example if I had constructed this card bearing in mind I would need

to build a foundation in the first place I could choose to discard a pink worker in order to take three money from the bank the round is going to end when each player has taken four actions and then you're gonna check a few things the first of which is you're going to remove any of your action markers that you have on cards ready to be used again for the next turn but then you will also go to check for these majorities there are five different different categories here and if at the end of that particular round you are leading in one of these categories you are going to be able to flip that token over so these different categories are by having the most segments of wall built are to have the most of these zoos built so you can see that some of these cards have this kind of giraffe's head on it and if at any time at the end of the round you have I think most of these cars built then you're going to be able to flip that one over to have the most buildings built to have the most points or to be the highest up that Central track and that is essentially how the game is played once the eight rounds are over you're going to calculate all the points you've gained during the game you're going to add up all your flipped over majority markers you're going to add up the points from your statues then if you've got these um you know three points unlocked by building walls you're going to add up all the points you've got from building your buildings because you can see here that a lot of them do have points values on them and some of which have end game scoring criteria on them as well and we'll talk about what some of them do in a bit and you also have to bear in mind that every building you built is going to correspond to where these priests have been deployed so if you have a big kind of stock up on an area then you might be really

incentivized to build like pink buildings in this example because you can get additional points for doing so let's take a brief look at some of the cards that will come out now there are a ton of these so this is obviously only scratching the surface here so you've got ones like this which means that whenever you build a wall you can pay fees equal to the die roll of the Black die rather than the actual printed cost on the player board so that could be very efficient if you keep rolling low with that black dice there oh you've got ones like this where you can actually build two buildings on a foundation rather than just one again you've got the zoo cards here to Simply give you a good conversion of points uh ones like this where you can cash in workers to get benefits like this where you instantly get to you know go down four disasters on your player board and once where you can force other people down on the track and once which when you draw the black um tiles when you roll the five or six on the Black die and normally you'd actually have to draw one of these random tokens which can kind of um do lots of different things and are normally a bit more you know unpredictable because you're not sure what you're going to get there um and additionally you've got things such as you know being able to build buildings at Half Price uh being able to get end game points based on certain types of buildings Etc so there are so many different options here and tons of engines that can be built okay so let's get into my review of Hamburg and I want to start with the main element of the game which I think is most definitely the hand management here and that multi-use card system this does put the players under a lot of conundrums and can add some pretty um you know

agonizing decisions at times because you may have a plan a you know you were anticipating to build a certain type of building and then all of a sudden the dice rolls happen and think oh my God all these threats are happening now I need to make sure I do something about these let's forgo my initial plan in order to keep myself safe and not risk me losing all my meeples or not risk me losing all my money or actually losing a building that I spent so much time and effort to build in the first place on top of that you might want the workers because the worker is going to activate all the buildings that you've already invested in again you might have the opportunity to you know grab a ton of money where initially you thought well I wasn't really planning on using my blue card to gain six coins um but I need to kind of seize that opportunity while it's there because that money is going to be you know the foundation of me doing a lot of different things here I'm gonna go building the walls is great because being the quickest to do it is going to be you're going to have the option of getting more and more points and those are certainly significant if you're grabbing the high point value ones by getting those tens nines Etc so yeah I love that factor of having to do one thing but or wanting to do one thing but having to sacrifice another in order to do so some great decision making there now perhaps surprisingly one of my favorite things about this game is this temporary majority system here I think this is genius and I don't think I've ever seen that before the idea of just wanting to be just a slightly bit ahead at any point at the end of a round in order to flip over that particular categories token and have those points locked in for the remainder of the game is fascinating to me because it does

mean that you can seize those opportunities and again once it's locked in it's locked in you can start to relax and focus on something else while everybody else is still trying to nudge ahead and try to flip that token over very minor detail there are quite a clever but you know a subtle mechanism but I think it is fantastic as I alluded to earlier there are a ton of different engines you can build with this game and you can really tailor your strategy around that engine you build like for example you might have one that makes it very efficient for you to climb up this main track if you pull ahead that could be some ground that you make there where you're not getting points elsewhere you know you can really focus on building those buildings of course you can really retainer strategy to where the priests are landing there are even cars that manipulate these priests so you can really tailor it to what you're building towards so yeah there are loads of different things you can do here and it's always quite fascinating to see what you can pull off now with that being said you do have to bear in mind that there are a lot of cards in this game and of course the way you acquire these cards is by top decking them from these five different parts you do have some limited control there because you do get to pick the color which is very relevant of course but if you are looking for cars to you know tailor towards your strategy then you're going to have very little control in doing that you really do have to kind of literally deal with the cars that you are dealt here you have to roll the punches and roll with the luck at times sometimes just by chance somebody is going to get dealt a bunch of cars that work for their engine and sometimes you simply are not now I don't mean that as a criticism because I do quite like working with what you have here and tactically managing those hand of cards

but I know that could players who like more control and more autonomy might be put off by that factor there is also some potential for swinginess when it comes to the deployment of these priests here yes you are drip fed the information because you can't really you know foreplan that they're all going to land on you know the pink buildings for example but it can happen where just by chance somebody is been building a lot of pink buildings and then every time the black dye is rolled it lands back on those pink buildings meaning that there's a lot of points to be had there sometimes that's even very hard to come back from I do think the game scales well because you know you are mostly doing your own thing here um two or three players would be my sweet spot because again it is mostly multiplayer Solitaire you're not worrying too much about what the other players are doing um if four players it's pretty much just going to extend the length of the game but that being said I wouldn't really be hesitant to play at that Play account it just wouldn't be my preference and there is a solo mode with this game as well and while I haven't played the solo mode I can see its mechanisms lending itself quite well to a solo game because again you are building your own personal engine here and I'm again not worrying too much about what the other players are doing the replayability in itself is quite astonishing there are a ton of cards here as I said you are going to have to tactically react to the cards you have making each game feel vastly different from the next ones the production is a bit of a strange one um I think the game itself doesn't look bad I think it looks better in person than it does through the lens of a camera and however I will admit that the game does feel a little bit soulless as

compared to the original bruise which had a certain charm to it and a certain throwback Euro appeal this one it feels a little bit um again a little feels a little bit clinical I suppose the actual components themselves are fine um you know mostly is just you know standard wooden meeples um you know all the cardboard stuff is a fine cardboard stock it's nothing bad at all however this is quite an expensive game so it is quite pricely and you're probably wanting a deluxe product for that price tag and the card quality is actually good um they are linen finished cards um feel very nice you know nice and robust the actual look of the cards again feels a little bit drab a little bit soulless some cards do look better than others um but I suppose the main comment I wanted to mention is the symbology so the symbology for this game is certainly a mixed bag it can be quite confusing especially in your initial couple of plays to understand what all these cards do and that can kind of break the flow of the game you know you've got to constantly reference this um addendum here which lists all the card very conveniently actually this is a very good companion um booklet um but you are going to be constantly breaking that play to look what your cards do in order to utilize them and sometimes you might think it means one thing and you'll actually be wrong and it means something slightly different some of them are a bit more obvious but um yeah that is really something to bear in mind and there are language dependent cards versions of these out there which if that really is going to be an issue for you then I would encourage you to get them so that at least that is an option and the player boards are good you know these are dual lead which are nice and these fit in quite nicely and

slide up and down without being able to knock them okay so let's share some final thoughts on Hamburg now I'd be waiting to play this game for a very long time and I'm so happy to say that I'm not one bit disappointed and in fact I'm quite impressed with this one and with each play my enjoyment is increasing and I think a big factor of that thought process is because I know what I'm getting now now I know one of the big criticisms of this game is that you do have such limited capacity in order to do what you want to do you but I actually don't think that's a negative at all I actually quite like embracing the Carnage and trying to make the most with the cards I'm dealt now if you go into this game with a mindset of that I want a complete control I want perfect balance and I want to go in with a game plan and pull off that game plan to the best of my ability then you're probably going to leave feeling frustrated and not going to get the most from the game whereas if you Embrace that Randomness and try to overcome those obstacles then I think you can have a lot of fun with this one the hand management is absolutely fantastic as you need the cards to do lots of different things and um you know opportunities come and go as you um as you go throughout your turns I love the threat system here all of these are devastating so you cannot ignore these and I also adore this temporary majority system I think that's one of my favorite little rules that I've seen in the board game for quite some time yeah tons of strategies you can go down get some amazing abilities and a group really cool little Tableau Builder that feels quite distinct from a lot of other games on the market so this one is definitely

going to get my um my Chairman's Commendation bear in mind that there is going to be a little bit of a learning curve with the um symbology at first but it's definitely worth you know persevering and trying to overcome that because the gameplay itself is a hell of a lot of fun so that is Hamburg by steffenfeld definitely gets my recommendation

Progress saved