Skip to main content
Loading video...

Scholars of the South Tigris | The Third Trilogy Just Keeps Getting Better | Board Game Review

Transcript 33:34

hello everybody my name is Elia and my name is Tyler together we make up coffee a couple that loves to play board games and today we have a very very exciting video because we will be doing a preview of the brand new Garfield games Scholars of the South Tigress that was slow well because you will take it so Wayfarers was actually our top game of 2022. in our top 10 of 2022 video so there has been some hype and some expectations that were put on Scholars of the South Tigris I feel like there's always an expectation from me especially for Garfield games and why is that paladins what about paladins me favorite game oh I don't think I've ever heard that oh well you heard it here first well today we're gonna dive into Scholars of the South Tigris this game is designed by Shem Phillips and Sam McDonald and is published by Garfield games Who provided us this early copy of the game and it's coming to Kickstarter very soon if not right now so you can check the link Out Below down below Down Below in Scholars you'll be working to obtain knowledge the way you'll do this is by finding Scrolls delivering them to the house of wisdom and translating them back to Arabic in order to get the knowledge

score yourself points well with that out of the way let's give you a quick overview of how this game works in Scholars your goal is to score the most points you'll do this by translating Scrolls increasing knowledge influencing the guilds and retiring translators after their years of faithful service the game is played in rounds where each player will take a turn the end game triggers when all four K-LOVE cards have been revealed from the draw Pile in each turn you'll decide to work or rest working allows you to play an action card along one to two dice to take actions while resting allows you to gain income from research tracks draw Dice and collect back your action cards to your hand when you work you'll place an action card from your hand into one of the five action slots each actions law corresponds to an action you can take on the main board you'll Place workers and dice onto the card and take the action based on the color and value of your dice the dice value and color is a core concept of this game when placing your dice you'll add up the Pips to determine the value and the colors to determine the color workers allow you to manipulate the dice if the color matches the value becomes a six if the color does not match this changes the color of the die to the color of the worker now there's a few rules to keep in mind secondary dice always take priority over primary primary dice take priority over white Dice and two primary dice create a secondary die it'll be best to show some examples this is a red eight

this is a green 12. here it's a purple 10. here it's an orange tan and finally this is a yellow nine there's a handy color wheel to help you visualize the mix of colors and the last note we'll mention here is that you cannot use two colored workers on a single die to create a secondary color now let's look at the actions you'll place your card Dice and sometimes workers there are some retired translators under this action slot which means there's three additional actions you can resolve including the primary action from the space you can resolve any of these actions in any order let's go over the primary actions on the board this action corresponds to the recruit action you'll either dispatch or employ a translator from the top section of the main board the color of this action does not matter however the value does each adjacent pair of translators requires a minimum dice value to recruit now you can dispatch or employ here dispatching gives you the immediate benefits that can help you in your game if you dispatch you'll resolve the effects of the top rate and move the car to the bottom of the deck employing gives you the opportunity to recruit translators that can later help you translate Scrolls and even offer you points upon their retirement you'll select the translator and place them in one of the spaces along the bottom of the main board each space has a silver cost you must pay immediate effects from placing a translator and the gold the translator requires before retiring you'll flip the translator after paying the cost and

acquiring the benefits and place one of your influence markers onto them travel allows you to deliver Scrolls to the House of Wisdom the dice value and color matters within this section the value of the dice indicates up to how many spaces you can move in the map you must move at least one step however as there are 12 steps you may do a full loop and end up in the same space the color is important as if you pass through a passage of your color you gain the benefits on it whether it be coins or influence on a card there are two spaces you will land the white spots are smaller actions such as gaining workers go with drying dice Etc while the black spaces are places where you may deliver scroll carts to the House of Wisdom if you land on a black spot and wish to deliver the corresponding scroll you'll follow these steps you'll pick up the scroll pay for silver gain the benefits on the space you've placed your scroll on move up on the corresponding research track and draw and reveal the top card from the draw pile to refill the space that you took from these Scrolls in the House of Wisdom are now ready for translation the next action is a research action color and value matters here there's four options available to you in this section as printed along the top of the board any die you have can be just used to gain a silver and a worker of any color this option requires a color and a value of at least four you'll pay gold to move up once on the matching color research track and game 2 silver value of at least eight and a color is similar except you don't have to pay one gold

now if your value is at least 10 and you have a color you may pay up to two gold to move up twice and get two points when moving up on the research tracks if you move into a transparent space you'll gain the corresponding benefits immediately the colored spaces have no immediate benefit but they may take effect when you rest you'll also notice victory points here associated with how high you get up on the research tracks finally translate this is where you can score significant points the color here matters but the value of the dice does not you'll need to make a secondary color to match the guild you wish to translate from some scrolls are more difficult to translate but you'll always want to translate to Arabic sometimes I'll just take multiple translations there are multiple tiers that you will often have to work through to get to Arabic however some translators may be able to skip a tier or be able to speak more than just two languages when translating you'll first select a scroll in the guild that matches your color then Place one gold on each translator needed to translate the scroll to Arabic you'll also pay a silver to the owner of each translator used you'll then take the scroll and place it above your board and in either order move up on the corresponding research track and take any immediate effects printed on the scroll finally you'll slide up the scroll cards in the House of Wisdom to fill any empty spaces if needed and retire any translators that have met their gold requirement to retire the translator you remove all the gold to the main Supply return influence

and the owner May tuck the translator under one of the four Brown action slots on their player board the first card you talk is always free but if you talk more than one you'll pay a coin or gain a white die per card already there now instead of working and placing action cards you may rest if you rest you'll first reveal the bottom scroll card which will potentially replace the card in the map or the House of Wisdom or be discarded based on a few conditions this essentially helps refresh and keep the flow of Scrolls and information going you'll then gain income income from left to right on your player board you resolve the effects these will include gaining white dice workers and activating the research tracks on the research tracks you'll only obtain the single highest space that your marker has reached if your marker is on the transparent space you'll take the benefits of the space below it you'll notice the blue benefit always being taken which grants you Dice from the bag up to a certain amount based on your position on the track after you've done this you'll return all the dice to the bag and take all the action cards back to your hand and that's all the actions you may take on your turn now in your scroll deck there are K-LOVE cards they're distributed in a way that you never quite know when you draw them but they are spaced out to a degree you also at the start of the game have the option to choose to have an epic or casual game which will affect the length of your game when one is drawn you'll place it at the top right section of the board in the leftmost space you'll resolve any events tied to that space

and proceed by having each player select a space utilizing influence from the guilds from left to right the player who has control of the guilds will get to select an award while everyone else who has a presence there will obtain a small consolation now in all four K-LOVE cards have been revealed the game end is triggered the route continues until every player has had equal churns and then one final round is played at the end of the final round players will take gold still in their employee translators and move it to their supply now let's take a look at how victory points are tallied you'll first calculate your dice sum deducting your total amount of white Dice from your amount of Colored Days the player with the lowest value places their player marker in the lowest position and so on so you'll want to slowly get rid of your white Dice and claim as many colored dice as you can throughout the game you'll add up the points from that dice sum then your retired translators any Guild you control at the end of the game along with points on calf cards victory points from the research tracks and finally victory points from your scroll cards you'll notice your starting scroll will have a conversion for coins to gold and gold to point and as well as negative points if you have more than six white dice you'll tally the points and the player with the most wins well will you be the most wise will you translate the most Scrolls where you have them the most knowledge the must knowledge the must

knowledge will you must the knowledge well you must incur I don't words are hard words are hard but good thing we have translators well let's talk Scholars we're gonna start by giving you some key standouts that we think this game really really uh does a good job at and we'll start with one of the obvious ones on my end on my end okay you get to start go what is it it was pretty simple is like most scarful games um especially the heavier ones this is a game of tight Resource Management you need to use your resources wisely you need to figure out an engine that can build you those resources and on top of that there are so many different strategies that are existing within the plane of the game so you've gotta be able to adapt to what's in front of you and collect all of these things to be able to create yourself an engine that might Veer you in a different direction yeah the core of the game is definitely Resource Management in your head you're going to plan and want to do this so that means I need to have this but in order to have this I need to do this so you can create almost like a flow chart yeah sometimes make it interrupted exactly so it's always adapting to that flow chart of resource management which is like Tyler said at the core of a lot of Garfield games my next key standout and I don't think any other game has this if it does maybe I'm wrong comment down below but the use of the color wheel in the dice placement and worker

placement and the actions you're allowed to yeah and the actions you're allowed to take so when you play a car you're gonna play dice and sometimes workers and the dice and worker and dice workers and the colors of the dice together will give you a color and a value and it's really cool because if you have two primary colors of dice you can combine them you have to combine them or you make you have to have to yeah in order to get that secondary color now if you want to change a color you can place a worker to change the color and there's just a lot of layers around that which make it really exciting and I've never seen it before but part of it is figuring out I really need a green dice dye and that dye needs to have a value of eight or higher I didn't have a good roll so I need to get Workers I also need to find to get a way to get a yellow dye or a yellow worker to make sure I can pair it with this blue to get the green and it's just a lot of layers and I like the little even the little assisting diagram of the color yeah yeah there's just I was really intrigued by that and really drawn to it so I anyway was in practice it's beautifully done and there's like there's a great example too of like how the game really um progresses forward because of the banners in the center of the game when you are moving them up the ones that are really easy to move for example are the primary colors because you're always or most likely have easier access to a primary color however once you get into those secondary colors those will offer you more benefits but also be harder to move up in so it's this interesting when do I make that transition how do I make

that transition what do I rush for a lot of planning can go into that piece of the board that will help you really Excel on the other pieces of the board it's a good layer of complexity that's for sure exactly now I think the next point we had was sent out is the translation piece of it yes not only is it very thematic because you're employing translators who speak only maybe two languages sometimes three if you're lucky but then you also have to find the scroll of that language and work your way through tiers of languages in order to translate it back to Arabic which is what your goal is yes yeah and the cool thing about that is you can use however you feel so you can go through all of these different translators to help you get to the spot I mean it costs resources so you usually I would say maybe Max use three um from my experience either yeah and you can't like use another translator or translator twice so there are ways to maybe just use one translator but it is really neat to see the um like the translation actually go through the steps and you can strategically plan for it obviously you want the translators to be on uh or part of your team so you don't have to pay them more I want to pay Tyler's translators mine are the best in the business yeah so there is like this give and take of that when it comes to the translation and although when I first saw the translation it seemed a little complex once you see

that like straight arrow diagram of the languages that can translate to another language that can go to another can go to another it makes so much sense and then the flow just kind of like naturally happens which I really really appreciated about it speaking of natural flow I think the next point is the Thematic integration of this game yes I will say that this is the most thematic Garfield game that I have played yeah I think I would actually agree with you because everything you're doing like your actions you're either dispatching translators or employing them then you're actually looking for Scrolls of knowledge and you're delivering them to the house of wisdom and then you're utilizing the house of wisdom and your translators to translate those Scrolls and get your points and the translators that you pay eventually retire and give you points as well so there's just layers upon layers of layers of thematic integration and I think they've done a remarkable job in this game with it because I was drawn I love theme and I was drawn from the start I was brought in right away and it was very fun to play this yeah I think the major thing for me and how well the theme is presented in this game is the fact that this is a very heavy game don't get me wrong it's a it's it's a tough game to play it's got some meat to it but the theme itself and the way that it fits into the game just helps the game Run smoothly and it doesn't feel as heavy because of that and that's something

that like I think should be praised so yeah so now with some of the key standouts out of the way let's jump into some considerations or some of the questions that came up with us particularly before and after we played the game and dive a little bit through them well then maybe they're going to come up for you too maybe they're a decision point in whether or not you're going to play this game uh especially if you've played other Garfield games this might help alleviate some of the considerations that we had coming into this game so you've watched our overview you've seen us talk for a little bit the question you may be wondering is is there too many mechanics in this game yeah is there just too much going on because there's a little bit of bag building there's area control there's hand management there's resource manipulation there's work replacement yes there's honestly a little bit of everything if you name a mechanic it's likely in this game so is it too much no I don't think so I think like I think this comes back to our first point is the theme makes so much sense in this game and because they've done such a good job with the theme the incorporation of the actions just make it seem um so uh like cohesive I think with for bag building for example like we say that as if it's a major mechanic and yes it is a mechanic that you're going to come across in the game because you will be putting dice into your bag is it

something that is going to be an overpowering presence in the game no because at the end of the day you're just using it to store Dice and take dice out and that only happens when you rest sure when you see a specific action on the board which is very clear and presentable throughout the game and that can be said for all of these mechanics the dice manipulation yeah you're only ever going to do that at the very beginning of your turn and the worker placements same thing always going to be at the beginning of your turn and you can manipulate them only in certain ways that never changes and it just makes it it just makes sense so my answer to the question is yes and no I do think it is a lot of mechanics but as somebody who has played so many different board games I love it because it's a Sprinkle it's a little bit of a little bit of a little bit of fun everywhere and it reminds me a lot of things I love and it brings a lot of joy to me but obviously if you're teaching this to somebody who hasn't played a lot of board games it can be it can't feel like a lot it can be and I know there's a few friends that I think we I don't think it'd be the great idea to introduce it to right away like I feel like we'd have to play some Architects play some other games to kind of work our way up to this game so they can have the best experience playing this game yeah and hopefully join the hobby exactly more people to play board games exactly now the second kind of consideration that comes to mind when we

were thinking about these kind of things and how this game plays is because there's so many mechanics and it feels like there there's a lot going on how is the flow of your turn looking is it is it is it too long um is there a lot of like downtime kind of thing and I guess like how do you feel about that I love the flow in this game because I really like games where you just keep taking turns till the game ends yeah and they're still classified as rounds here like you play around of everyone taking a turn but different people can rest at different times and it doesn't feel like there's too many actions within a trend that you take that you're cashing out between Trends because you're always thinking of what's the next thing you're gonna do um I really liked it for the sole purpose of you play a card you put dice on that card you put workers on the card potentially and then you take the actions associated with that card and then within those actions they're step by steps so like there's a lot of steps within the game and sometimes your turn can be longer than others but it all flows and there's support mechanism in the game to help you remember everything that needs to happen yes yeah so like Ilia is saying is I think it's very it comes down to a simple simplified turn where you're playing a card adding dice to it and potentially adding workers to it based on what you want to do I think that makes the your turn very easy to just do it's what comes next that is going to be something that you do need to pay attention to because sometimes there is this cascading effect because

you've got this engine because you've got a variety of other things going on but I don't think it's overwhelming at all again the flow of your turn really makes sense just make sure that when you place your dice your workers and you go to take your action you do so in a like methodical way so you are taking time to make sure you've done all of the single action yeah don't forget the Little Steps but there are a lot of that is a consideration is that there's a lot of not necessarily administrations but steps within some of these actions so making sure that you have paid everything you've got all the resources that you use the actions below your action as well if you have any retired translators so there's a lot of things to pay attention to but I think the game does everything it can to support you and set you up for success to remember all of those things as well and it does a good job at it so I would say that the flow of your turn seems uh seems pretty straightforward once you really get into it and then to the point of does that mean there's a lot of downtime I don't think so there's not a whole lot of player interaction that ends up happening on your turn per se so you do have that time to like plan for your next turn the only possible player interaction that comes to my mind is having your scroll um taken from you by somebody translating it yeah having a translator retire um faster than you had thought or just

like these smaller things that would have naturally just happened at some point anyways and I don't think it's to the it's not like a take that kind of thing so I think that brings to our last consideration and question and that is what is the complexity of this game what would you compare it to how complex is Scholars of the South Tigress yeah I go back and forth with this question a lot and we had a discussion on our Discord Channel about it I just like I can't decide whether or not this is heavier than paladins or not on BGG it says that it is and I I don't know if I agree yet but I have to play a couple more times overall though this game is of like high complexity I think it's a pretty tough game to play I think it's tough to like strategize around you really do need to play it a few times to understand how it works and with that said I think we've talked about this previously where the theme stands out so much and works so well that it pulls away from that complexity helping the player like really really get into it with ease I agree I agree with everything you said I think I do think this is the most complex powerful game that from my perspective I mind media kind of linked to it was similar to a vitala starter game oh yeah because you have like the one kind of core action you're doing but then you

have multiple different areas that interact in different ways which are seeing a lot of other games and even weather machine was the one that we most recently played and I saw links I saw links to both of these games in terms of complexity um that there are step-by-step instructions for each of the sections there's a ways to kind of reset different things and so it is a fairly complex game but like Tyler said I think the theme really makes up for it and just the flow of the game really makes up for it as well it makes it feel less complex than it actually is at least to me I think if you enjoyed Wayfarers and uh paladins and even Architects that this game is definitely something you will enjoy uh which kind of brings me to our next little section here and how it compares to Wayfarers I think one of the similarities and the similarities across all of the South Tigress Trilogy is the dice manipulation dice placement yeah and that it's intentional with the with the trilogies for sure so here you the way that you'll be using dice is you'll be again placing one action spaces and then based on the color and the value you'll take certain actions in Wayfarers it was basically based on the symbol associated with the dice and sometimes it gave you other benefits based on that little map that you have other than that I think these games are quite different in what they try to approach I feel like this game is very much you're going through it's almost like like the whole the whole the circle of life in the game you're getting a translator you're getting a scroll you translate the scroll you're a Tang translator and getting the translator game yeah where I

feel like Wafers was more exploration let's let's look at the depths of the world and see what's out there and it was very less I think circular and more like you could choose which direction you really want to go in yeah yeah I think um Wayfarer is really stuck true to like the set collection piece of the um mechanics like that was happening in the Wayfarers so you were really trying to focus on Gathering certain symbols um Gathering a variety of different symbols and then getting space cards that helped you like do those goals even further and make those set collections even more worth it and again then those inspiration cards doubling up those points so I think it all kind of connected to this set collection um the dice uh I'll be obviously were important because you were able to take actions on the exploration tracks that are on the things that you had explored so it was really exciting to build out that engine where I think yeah like Ilya said is um Scholars is definitely like this whole circle moment where you are having to do a lot of different things that end up coming back to basically end of game scoring it's more Collective as well because you're all working from the same board like you all have access to the same scroll as the same kind of like and the same actions because you're never actually you don't actually get any different actions than anybody you could if you retired translators if you retire oh yeah but those are those are in

addition to the actions that you're taking that's true so it's like a bonus on top of an action that already exists another point is like even the cards in your hand those actions don't change the only thing that changes is if you are able to do your uh farthest right a goal the fastest you get an additional action card and that action card can be super valuable and uh I'm one of my strategy tips would be try to get that as fast as possible God you tip with Tyler so now the ultimate question of them all Wayfarers Scholars how does it compare in the overall grand scheme of Garfield games does it Dethrone paladins for Tyler will we find out yes we will right now today I don't I have to play Scholars a little bit more to be able to type what I can tell you right now is that I do think it's better than Wayfarers I want to play it at a four player okay we have not played at four players I also wouldn't mind trying the solo okay so and then I would just like play to play it a few more times I think with paladins I've played it so much so many times that I just get um excited when I show other people okay I do get excited because this is new however is it the newness I I think that this is I said this about Wayfarers but I think that Scholars is an even closer Contender to Knocking paladins but we'll see after a few more plays at this game my thoughts are I think this is my favorite Garfield game now

I think Wayfarers I think beats paladins for me after playing Wayfarer so many times I just really like the theme and I loved everything that I did and I also really like dice dice has always been something for me that I enjoy especially when done in a clever strategic way not in a luck way and where yeah so like pause that I guess because that that's a very good point it is a very good point because with dice you always worry about love it's going to be like this lock-based thing but there are a lot of a lot of ways to manipulate your dice so it doesn't feel but sometimes it's still tragic because you've got something you don't have to wear patterns yeah but so what I was gonna say is I think this game I liked I think I liked it significantly more than Wayfarers and I think it's because I like the circular action of like almost like you do this do this do this do this because sometimes it's overwhelming to know even when to start or to build a strategy and I really like welfare is because you it only fits thematically because you're exploring your strategies they're exploring the lands but here I think it's it's very you know what's good you know where you can go and you have like a solid options they get taken away often and it's more of a test of adaptability which I love in games it's one of my favorite things is something gets taken away and how do you best adapt that situation so I've loved every single playthrough of it I think the only thing that said it a bit a bit below that was just uh there's times where I kept forgetting certain things and as hard as I tried to remember it's like to forget to take one coin or to forget to pay like there's a

lot of the slight step-by-step Administration and once I got the hang of it I got there easier but in the beginning it was a little bit hard to oh we need to check this again I mean you could do that so that's not like any heavy yeah like any heavy game but that's but that's why like I think this is my new favorite Garfield game and uh there are hikes I still don't know I can't call which Trilogy is my favorite because I still think the West Kingdom Trilogy because I think there's only two of these exactly so I was gonna say I think bicounts just didn't land as much for me but I love like Architects I think is one of my favorite games to introduce in general in a worker places setting and it holds a really high space in paladins because it's your favorite game because you play quite often I also really really enjoy so I think right now both the trilogies are on par and the third game there's a lot of expectations because it will really determine if it dethrones the last Kingdom Trilogy because I think by West Kingdom trilogy still could be my favorite overall even though I prefer this game more yeah than some of the others I think VI counts needs to be played at a higher player for us yeah you haven't played too many yeah we did yeah anyways that's a whole other conversation a whole other conversation overall thoughts clearly we really like this love it and we recommend you checking it out is it the game of the year who knows you'll have to wait and find out but this is the end of the year yeah this has been a fantastic experience for us to play and Ilia just wants it to be the end of the year so that we can announce that this is our top game I guess I feel like there's a lot of contenders

for this very very early in early yes yeah um but I really enjoyed this I'm really curious to see how it Stacks over time because obviously I think with Wayfarers I really have grown to love the game more and more as we played it and even at varying player cosplaying F4 is very different than two and feeling getting the whole feel for it so yeah I big fan of this game which brings us to the end of our video unfortunately where we get to ask you folks a question which is an exciting part and it's about garful games what's your favorite Garfield game have you played many of the Garfield games uh yeah and let us know if you haven't played one which one are you most interested and that is Scholars of the South Tigris if you have any questions go in that comment box let us know we're always happy to chat about this game there's a lot in this game that we haven't shared because there's a lot in this game yes so if you have questions we're happy to dive into it in the comments down below also do check out the kickstarter it's also down there go in that description learn all about it and if you found this video helpful you know what to do hit that Thumbs Up Hit That subscribe button if you're new here because we talk about board games on a weekly basis lots of board games and lots of fun we do love love love love love love well thank you so much for watching we hope you have a wonderful rest of your day until next time bye foreign

Progress saved