Encyclopedia - "Quick Draw" Game Review - THIS IS NOT LIKE WINGSPAN!!
Transcript
thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences so today I'm taking a look at encyclopedia recently fulfilled on Kickstarter and just come out on retail this is a game that has definitely had a lot of Buzz this one is getting hyped up by quite a few people lately from initial plays although let's clarify one or two things I remember seeing comments that this was being compared to wingspan particularly by some creators and it's like um no this game is nothing like wingspan get that out of your head right now some of these cards have pictures of birds on them and there is your entire link to Wings man okay so get that out your heads but encyclopedia is basically a kind of in a sense a card Tableau game you are researchers going out and researching different animals but the theme is very abstracted it's mainly a mechanical game what you're doing is that you are rolling dice which you draw out of a bag at the start of a turn you roll them and you place them on your player board as such you have four of them you roll them and you choose where you want to put them on the spaces because if you take a dive from someone else they get the bonus that's pictured by the die so there's an element of choice there but then what you're doing is that you are gaining cards which have all these different animals on even with the Latin pronunciations of them which I cannot pronounce any of them to save my life but each of them has Types on them different terrain different climate different food or different animal types and they're from different continents represented by color you build up this Tableau of cards in front of you and
through other actions you are placing research cubes on the actual cards based on what types you're trying to research ideally you're trying to do set collections so it's about researching a lot of the same type if that makes sense but once you've got a bunch of cards with the cubes on them you then go and publish your findings which means that you choose which set you want and there's a bunch of these category spaces on the bottom of the board here see if you can see it in the light or on the photos but essentially different ones are worth different points depending on how rare they are and once you've used the cubes off them the cards then either go out of play or if they're from the same continent you can basically say right I'm going to put these face down and at the end of the game there's some scoring for having a lot of cards for the same continent to help you on your way though you've got money which allows you to boost the value of your dice you've got Expedition tokens to boost the value of some actions you've got special seals which are like almost like jumbo versions of the two I've just mentioned you know these are you know where if they're weight in gold but then you can also grab experts which are kind of like little special abilities and bonuses so your dice your blue dice are worth more points you get money every time you go to a certain space you get points at the end of the game for having experts you get to put two more cubes on a particular category at the end you know stuff like that of which of course you're interested in their color for the consonant scoring but also you may just want to get a nice combo of abilities going that help you on your way aesthetically it's definitely a pleaser it looks very nice on the table this is a very big board I mean this is like
just it folded up but it really does expand out to a nice long board you've got a beautiful bag with like the sort of like writing and pictures on them the dice are pretty basic but the cardboard tokens are decent quality you've got three tuck boxes for various tokens that you can assemble which is a nice little touch and the artwork on the cards and the box and the rule book is Stellar I really do like the art they've used for these cards it looks the part and definitely is a pleasing sight on the table and nothing here feels cheap and chinsy solo mode is fine nothing amazing but it enables you to play the game solo so it is in there two to four players yeah 25 minutes a player no not I played a two-player game of it the other night it did not take us 50 minutes and we both knew the rules in advance that is a stupid time on there four player games of this can easily exceed two hours possibly longer particularly if you've got to teach the game as well to which there's a reasonable amount in here to teach but yeah 25 minutes a player is extremely extremely optimistic there's no real interaction in this game apart from the choosing of Dice from other players but then that's the same in two three or four it doesn't matter how many players you've got but the scaling's really weird with the board because you have a certain amount of cards on the offer you always have the same amount of expert cards so that doesn't change the only thing that changes is how many of these animal cards are on offer but in a two-player game you have six of them out three player you have seven four you have eight it's incredibly tight having four players choose from eight animal cards but it two for six I mean you've
got the world as your oyster at that point only one card added per player that's a really small scaling aspect it's not not that difficult the rulebook and the graphic design on the other hand though does not want to make life easy for you the rulebook is not terrible but it is a bit on the wordy side and it also does like to gloss over a few actions and a few definitions without realizing it it refers to collections at the end of the game and doesn't stipulate what a collection is by definition so I had to ask a question of board game geek to find out the answer to that and then it kind of made sense but man it gave me a headache trying to understand the end game scoring at first but then also the two main actions in this the the Expeditions and the Publications are not worded the best in there you'll kind of understand it but I guarantee you're going to need at least a couple of read throughs through how Publications work before you fully get it because it uses some weird terminology and just doesn't do a great deal of like a good job of explaining it but the graphic design is a massive issue because when you choose these dice some of the actions require you to consider the value some require you to consider the color some both but the graphic design on the board is not very clear as to which actions are what and the game has no reference AIDS all you get is this tile here which you know tells you some endgame scoring on one side and then tells you how a couple of bits of two actions work on the other side no other reference Aid other than the gaming Aid on the back of the book which is all words and frankly isn't the
easiest one to refer to I have improved this game by printing out a list of all the experts and what they do because their list of experts is in the middle of the rulebook what kind of decided that was a good thing but also because I have printed out two reference eight on Board Game Geek which are a lot better with this I know exactly what all the actions do by memory I can see all the important things like I need this many points to do this I need this many points to do that but most of all it tells me what dice values are required what colors I need and more importantly it tells you how you spend the coins seals and Expedition tokens because nowhere on the board does it tell you this so you have to remember a lot of stuff your first game is going to involve a decent amount of rules checking and for a game that's relatively straightforward you know a light possibly midweight game it really could have done a slightly better job just one rules editor look could have sold a few problems here in terms of replay value it's lacking a bit as well I mean the different cards are just different cards there's no real sense of you know oh this card's really different from that one no it's just what four types does it have what color it is it's very abstracted you're always going to go to these same actions quite a lot some of the actions you won't even go to barely Expedition one to get free Expedition tokens you can get these pretty easily during the game by using reputation in other means that you really don't need to go visit it but then there's no other way to differentiate players because they give you this pointless little thing to bolt onto the end of your board here and there's nothing to it it's just a portrait there's no asymmetric powers or
anything so this piece is completely pointless so I can just Chuck it away and just not even bother slotting it on my board what was the point of it even the pasta Victory on that varied you know you've got all these different categories that you have I mean there's six of them there there's another six that you can't see so there's 12 different categories you need to think oh that's loads yep the categories are just points that's it there's no there's nothing special about elephants versus meat versus hot climate it's just a symbol and the game can say right oh wait do I diversify or do I focus you focus and you focus hard if you diversify you will score very few points for the whole majority thing here the set collection part so there's no point diversifying it really doesn't work that well you want to focus hard on a particular color so you want to have a lot of green of experts and cards because you know the difference between scoring a measly three points for having a little bit of it versus 40 points for having 12 of it is pretty substantial but then when you do these categories you also don't want to do a lot of different symbols you want to grab a couple and go right that's my focus the last game I took the omnivore and I took uh water climate so I took those water terrain or whatever so I took those two focused on them hard gained 12 purple cards and I completely obliterated my opponent it's you it's just very one track it's very one note a lot of the times I don't even find myself using these seals for some reason because half the time I build up a decent engine from the expert cards which are probably the most fun thing in the game frankly the fact that you can create these cool combos here although again some of these
are more powerful than others I mean adding value to your dice is nice but trust me get the ones that say when you go to get animal cards or when you go to get experts and stuff that you get more money and more uh reputation because trust me you build up a bunch of those it adds up don't get the ones that add points no get the money ones because you get a two or three of those you can basically make those actions such good money generators or reputation generators that the bonuses and the ability to augment your actions you get from there is sick so encyclopedia is a fine but flawed game it looks great not problem there with Aesthetics it certainly isn't the hardest game to play and it's a relatively easy straightforward game I just wish that the rule book and the graphic design made a better job of explaining it without me having to fix the game's issues by grabbing a reference Aid which I'll try to remember to put a link in the description so you can find this yourself because trust me you want it but the game feels very Hollow and samey the dice aspect of choosing from other boards gets pretty old very quickly all you're doing is just grabbing cards to put cubes on them and then take cubes off for points you know it's very abstracted so I don't really feel any kind of connection to what I'm doing here and the balance issues is questionable where you know these seals are insanely good maxing out the reputation track like crazy gets you a ton of bonuses which are really useful and some of the expert cards are just downright rubbish versus a few of them which are amazing and kind of I want to get every single game I play not to mention that the past the victory is kind of one though because
you really are gunning to have a lot of set collection stuff I find that every time I play this game I'm just doing the same thing every time and for a game that's 55 pounds and you know like quite a you know a big box and that higher price point I kind of wanted a bit more value out of it but as such I feel that I'll play this a few times I've played enough for the review and now I'm kind of done I give this one a six out of 10 overall it's above average I don't think it's bad I was tempted to give this one a five but I feel that some of the problems I have are easily fixed I mean if you grab a reference off Board Game Geek it is it does fix a few problems but again they could have just made the effort to make it a lot more approachable in that sense but those other aspects and the fact that the game just feels Hollow does bring it down I can't give it a seal I give it a six I think it's fine but just nothing to really write home about so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see please remember you can thumb it up on YouTube and Board Game Geek please do it helps to get the video more exposed but get your comments down below do you agree with the points I've made or disagree I like to read them and of course feedback when I can but until next time you can check out more content on the channel including a quick draw review I've done for Marvel United but also check out the recent top 10 I did where I look at my sort of anticipated games for 2023. take care and remember as always regardless of whether you can pronounce a single name on any of these cards or not it's still only a game bye for now
foreign