Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dead Reckoning Roundtable Review - Friendly Ties Podcast

Transcript 1:02:53

hey there welcome to the friendly ties podcast uh in this episode we're talking about a board game in particular and that one is dead reckoning I'm joined with my friends Nick and Anastasia we've played this one a bunch recently and we have a lot to say about it um speaking of that though uh there's a lot going on with this game like a whole bunch of rules and um interesting systems for sure but we are not going to be teaching you how to play the game today in this podcast it just would not work I do want to say that I made a sponsored tutorial video for this game when it went up on Kickstarter that uses a prototype but it still teaches the game like 99 correctly uh so I'll put a link to that in the description of this episode and we'll try to give you some context as we go but you know fair warning we're not teaching all of the rules uh so at a ridiculously high level this is a card crafting sandbox Style game it's the same made by the same designer as Mystic Veil and it uses the same system where players have a deck of cards that have sleeves and instead of swapping out your cards you you upgrade your cards by sliding transparent Cards into your sleeves in dead reckoning you do a whole bunch of other stuff you sail a ship around the Seas You explore and find new stuff you are going to fight each other by tossing things into a cube Tower you'll also be picking up and delivering and making achievements and there's just a lot going on here so over the course of the last week we've played this game a whole bunch um I I liked my first play of it and then I played it a second time and I I still really enjoyed it while also being

kind of frustrated by it there's a lot of there's like a lot of very cool moments in this game you know like the crafting like that's the backbone of this game right putting cards together trying to make combos that seem imbalanced sometimes they they they can kind of feel that way but you know maybe somebody let you get there I I like I like this game when I'm playing it but there's a lot of down time too right I mean we we played the three-player game and then a two-player game those are my two experiences and even in the two-player game uh when you're not taking your turn there's a lot of stuff that's happening for other people this is the perfect uh friendly ties kind of podcast topic game right because it's yeah for sure I feel exactly the same way right like there's a lot of stuff I really dig about this game it's I don't play a game three times in a week and I'm like I'm not so sure about it right like yeah I was into it especially like a two-ish hour game right oh yeah this is not a short game yeah right and it has its problems so it's it's it's cool to look at like the stuff that really stay stands out is unique and fun and and also tear forth the things that are just like not just don't work for me right yeah yeah it's been a long time actually since we we made it in our Discord like about a game yeah like I was reminding me like how we felt about Arc Nova or Anna or like some of those games that we played we would just like go like every time we

play even if you weren't playing it it was like well you better get on chat and like explain your entire play so that you know everyone can take take it apart YouTube played yesterday and I was uh out at lunch and then I like looked at my phone after lunch it was like 25 messages I gotta like yeah yeah we played a couple nights ago Anastasia and me and then like the moment the game was over I couldn't help but I took screenshots and sent them to Nick and it was like a session report because yeah Nick needs to know what happened in this place look at my card look what I did look at the things that came together I mean it is it's definitely that kind of game it's the kind of game that you want to explore and you feel like you're exploring it like I was saying to Nick we we sat down so we've played it once three player and I played it two player with each of you and Nick we played a two player twice actually yeah a whole bunch of two-player games which was funny because we didn't even think it would be good at two player right like we were like I don't know it's a worry yeah yeah because there's like there's an area control component here in the game like John said like a very high level there's all these things going on the card crafting and there's Islands to explore you really do feel like Pirates I Gotta Give it that like a hundred percent and I but we were worried that the two-player game that they're there's also with a I don't know you guys have played a bunch of Forex games and I haven't so I barely understand the sort of like what all the X's are but I do understand that conflict is part of them taking over things as part of them and both of

those things don't seem like they'd be very good at two um but the more we've plated it to the more I think we like keep kind of going back to it I'm like oh wait no I I kind of like it here I I kind of want to I I just it's we sat down to play games today and Nick and I were like yeah let's just play that again like let's just see like it's just like you just want to keep going into it yeah I'm I'm eager I'm still concerned the two player doesn't quite work I'm eager to play it at three again now that all of us have a little bit more sense of what we're doing I really want to play it at four I also really don't want to play it at four because they don't want to be sitting there for a really long time but yeah but I do want to see what the game experience is like at four because I I feel to your point exactly Anastasia like the fighting aspect of the game I think opens up when there's more people on the on the board the area control I I went into this in Cape May and I think I'm like learning now that I just don't love area control if it is not the flagship that's the wrong choice of words if it's not the flagship like point of a game like El Grande is an area control game I like oh Grande but this is not a this is a game that has area control it isn't fundamentally area control and I'm I'm think I'm learning that I just maybe not that much of a fan of that especially not a two players although it does it does do some nice balancing for that it too but not enough I think we all agree like that the area if you don't like area control that it's a piece of this right like it's I mean and and John you don't mind you don't

like you've said actively you don't like error control but then you didn't mind it so much in this one right yeah that is true that is true um I I tend to not like area control even when it is the uh the flagship mechanic in a game um for for one reason or another I've never played El Grande someday that'll happen I'm sure um that's that's a merit badge I want to get um young one yeah uh but with my two plays of this one so far I I I'm gonna kind of speak for Nick for a moment and it'll probably he'll probably come in here because I know that when we played our very first play um you were worried Nick that area control was important but also not important in this game like you got a whole bunch of points and you didn't even for area control and you didn't even really pay attention to it in that first play I focused on it I wasn't even a pirate in our first game I I never took a cannon I never attacked anything I was completely passive just influencing Islands which is the area of control uh making stuff on them doing pick up and deliver just going back and forth getting points and I ended up winning by a slim margin um and then in the second game that I played it was two players with Anastasia and I was like I'm gonna try something different and I I just built a bunch of guns in my boat I upgraded all my cards with guns at and I sunk Anastasia uh I I sunk like four Merchant ships and I still to Nick the point that I'm making for Nick I still made up about the same amount of victory points on the area control even though in that second

game I never upgraded for putting the influence down which is the way you Vie for it and you know to finish talking for you Nick that was like your main issue with it right yeah I mean you you've got it basically like the in the last game Anastasia and I played both of us essentially didn't really compete for cubes we just kind of like did our other things that we were doing in this game um and I'm really glad that we tried that and it felt like you were most rewarded for just like oh I just dropped a little Cube over here a little Cube over here just kind of like being around and being like don't forget about me guys and yeah like that's that's in that's intelligent play but it's not it's not terribly fun or interesting or it doesn't like generate much of a narrative except for like I just ran over and like put my pirate flag on this island I guess I was like I've been here Nick was here um and then yeah there are aspects of the area control that I do really like in this game though um that I think are are nice so one thing that this game has is a neutral player that you have to compete with which I think is good for that criticism that I'm loving of like just poop a guy somewhere and move on with your life but the thing that I actually like most is once you take control of an island you get a freebie permanent extra control marker which is really nice because you get rewarded for controlling Things Early whereas in a lot of these area control games it's like just wait and see is really the strategy and and that is cool I do like that aspect of it also it leads into the theme of the

story a little bit you're like oh look at that Cube there way back when when I control that Island before everybody else came here I went crazy yeah yeah and I think that like I think that part of it the the leave behind Cube aspect is actually what I'm sort of ambivalent on area control I see you guys as criticisms I'm also like it's a game mechanic that I put up with like fine um but I think that that leave behind mechanism is actually what I really like about it because I don't like people kicking over my sand castle I don't think that comes at any surprise says the sand castle kicker hey talking about game one

he just like will not let that go and I feel like in a game like this I I you know when you've gone to a bunch of effort to take control of an eyelid and then someone comes over like Nick did yesterday and it takes over your Island from you you know it's like you still get a little reward for it and so I know I'm just restating what you said but it it's that feeling of like the effort I put in wasn't wasted especially in a game like this where there is battling your ship can get sunk um you can lose things as you go along you know there is some Randomness but there's still like this very strong Euro core like you really feel like you're building something and maybe you guys are going to tell me other Forex games feel like this too but like I really more than I felt and John what was that game we played that took like six hours and you're in space and you're like that was Eclipse second uh second Dawn for the Galaxy got it okay that was fun it took six hours I don't ever need to play it again and I felt more in dead reckoning like I was building this thing I was really proud of really what I was building was like my deck of cards and their like little abilities but it it's cool that you could do that in two hours and you feel really like it's just tight um but as you guys talked about I feel like you you have to focus a little bit on everything and do a couple of pass

really well and that is a little bit hard for me and I'm curious what you guys think about this where like you have to you do have to like Drop cubes on every island it seems to compete and you do you can't completely ignore the military but then you also part of the fun of the game is just like focusing on a strategy like picking one or two cards or two strategy like that you're gonna like build up that you're gonna kind of go at and how to balance all of that I'm not even making sense because I don't even quite have my brain wrapped around it's not like Great Western Trail where you could just be like I'm gonna do a cowboy strategy and you can do that pretty successfully Without Really focusing on anything else like in this game it feels like it wants you to focus on a couple of things and do that well but you also can't ignore everything else and where I've lost every game I play it against you guys and where I in some cases by a very small margin like one point um but it feels like that's a thing I'm kind of trying to wrap my mind around I don't know make more sense of that for me guys I'm I'm with you I actually love that you say that it's it makes total sense to me um that the game wants you to do a lot of things part of that I think is because of the way the you draw the cards in your deck right you can only essentially like keep so many cards in your hand which means that you have to play the rest of them so you can never get rid of cards in this game so it's like you have you have to select these actions like you have to drop cubes in this game you're gonna be doing these other things so like you can ignore one

or two facets of the game but fundamentally you're gonna have to like interact with the majority of it and I like that I like games that demand your attention to be in different places and you're like all right I acknowledge that I have to deal with this over here at least get some points from this system but really this is where I'm making my money I think that's fun yeah and you know this is not a I mean it should come as no surprise this is not a multiplayer solitaire game um you are really paying attention to what other people are doing uh and you know to bring back to that first game where I did like literally completely ignore the aggressive part of the game to a certain extent I was allowed to do that because you two were just in each other's faces it was great like for me like to see you were beating each other up on Islands removing influence I was doing none of that Nick was over I had no Pirates if I remember correctly I'm pretty sure Anastasia shot first yeah I did not so I was just passively hanging out in the western part of the ocean the whole game long neither of you two came into my area neither of you competed with me for islands and you were just um shooting each other sinking each other fighting each other for influence and and honestly I was thinking I was gonna run away with the game because that's kind of a thing in board games right three player game two people beat each other up the person the other person just you know runs away with it and I didn't I won by like three points like 93 to 90 or something like that so I was

surprised at how competitive all the other stuff was um but that was also just our our first game and then when we played the second game and this is going to speak I think a little bit to uh to Anastasia's incentives uh because this has happened before um Anastasia does not like getting her sand castle kicked over as she just said Anastasia wants to stop other people from kicking over her sand castle so Anastasia frequently buys guns in games when Jake owls can get kicked over kind of as a defense thing but then what I've found this happened once we played Through the Ages too uh she was so scared that other people were going to beat her with military that she became just this horrifying military Monster uh that you know subjugated the rest of the world and you know when we played that second game of dead reckoning the first advancement Anastasia took was a card that let her fight me because that's the thing normally you can't fight each other you need to be allowed to there's like a you know a special icon and literally the first card she took was let me fight John and I was like okay all right and so the first card I took out a couple cannons on it and then like the second card she took was the other thing that let her fight me I was like okay I'm gonna take some more cannons because apparently Anastasia's coming for me but then my next question is real yeah it was a cold war escalation and then we got like a third way through the game and suddenly I had a hand with all these cannons I was like I'm gonna go sink that Merchant and then like halfway through the game Anastasia is like it's time to fight John because I think I'd

taken a couple damage from a merchant she thought I was weak and I wasn't and I dropped down like two cards with a million guns on them and from that point on I was the aggressor I went crazy on guns I became the the terror in that game and I my last turn I hunted you down in the port and annihilated your ship by throwing like 15 cubes into this Cube tower that the combat's wonderful in this game you all toss simultaneously cubes into this Tower which looks like a ship it's like broadside cannons and then they fly out onto a board and you you get stuff but anyway so I felt like I was pushed into destroying it okay because hold on I want to be perfectly clear about something here okay let's hear your side for anybody who wants to do this defend your sand castle strategy it doesn't work it it just fails every time for all the reasons to understand because I am so good at buying stuff to defend myself but I apparently for some reason am not if I get probably because I just don't like it in games I've never liked attacking in games I'm not very good at executing with that attack or I just have really terrible luck with this you know Cube dice Nick keeps calling it dice really but it's not dice rolling because it reminds you of dice rolling right like it's key Cube dropping Tower thing which is super fun but it's totally luck based and I'm my point here is that I had zero intention of attacking John I hit zero

into all I wanted to do was exist in my corner of the world and I didn't want you to come take it from me and then I was perfectly happy destroying all the merchant ships but no you had to go destroy them first and Nick did the same thing yesterday I was like fine I'm gonna do super hard military in this game and I went and I was like I'm just gonna fight all the merchant ships and then Nick had to go block them all like what were you why why did you have to do that it's because I'm evil to play two-player games with like more of a reflection of that I actually do think that that is more interesting in a four-player game because you can't have as much like as me being like I'm gonna tag this merchant ship so you can't like that's a that's like a ridiculous thought process that only this is a two-player game and then actually is one of my critiques of the game it's just that in a two-player game this this element of military like John you're totally right like there's a cold war like I don't know we didn't do anything especially at two players especially with two players but honestly I think that would be the case at any player count because now that we've played it a bunch there's no way I'm not going despite what I just said there's no way I'm not gonna buy a bunch of military to try to protect myself against one of you going rogue and trying to like come for me and that is inherently gonna Force you guys to build up military like there's no way I'm gonna ignore military the more we play this game and I haven't been even if it

hasn't been all that successful but in a two-player game like I it is you know I do feel like the achievements uh promote military military is obviously one of the x's in the Forex and there's a lot of stuff that promotes military and I have tried to go harder on it now in like one and a half games and I would say that there especially in two player there's just there's not enough stuff to fight there isn't enough ships other people to fight there's like unless you really want to chase like my plan in my or in the game I played Nick yesterday was just Chase Nick around the board until I destroyed him and that just like didn't work because for reasons but Nick is very good and there's a lot of ocean to hide in and no one else is forcing him to move I just went home and I was like please protect me Mommy I need someone here pirate ship is coming for me you know I had all this stuff to fight and I was just like floating around an empty ocean being like what can I destroy I mean that's that's that's a bit of luck though right like when we played our two player game and I went crazy on Military I sunk four Merchant ships and you you didn't fight any Merchant ships in that game but you like traded with them which made them go away so we saw like six Merchant ships over the course of that game and I think that's the same amount of merchant ships that I suspect anyway that you've seen in like every

other play of this you've had combined I think you call the merchant ships forward in the deck somehow because Nick and I have seen none of them I think you have have a special connection with them and they so I think I just got kind of lucky you know I went I went crazy guns and then there's all these targets um and I ended up targeting you on the very last turn but like there were a couple times where I was like which merchant do I want to destroy and I was that was kind of luck of the draw like you you pull these Merchants they're they're kind of advancements you pull them out of the deck the the ocean is essentially the market like if you've played a deck building game like Ascension before or something like that you know with a scrolling Market of cards you can buy the ocean is essentially that so you're you're essentially doing area control and pick up and deliver on top of the card Market which is very cool from a mechanical perspective but you know again there's luck of the draw there okay well while we're here talking about combat I actually want to talk about my favorite part of the design of this game with combat John a while ago mentioned that in that first game he felt like he was going to crush us because the two of us were slapping each other back and forth and it's true like we already talked about like how in the area control like you're still going to score points you know if you're second place so like yes we are hurting each other John did win that game right but we're still getting points for doing that and the combat is actually like that too getting sunk really sucks because you have to pay your five coins to the other player or whatever but just fighting someone even if they beat you even if you take some consequences for it when you throw those cubes in the tower you're gonna get some

free rewards you're gonna get some money you're gonna get some plunder and so everybody that gets engaged in a fight I get something and and so like as in this game when you are getting smacked down by someone overtaking your island with area control or by someone coming and shooting you in the face both times you are still getting some at the very least consolation prize along the way which I think serves to tighten up that like if you were if your sandcastles getting kicked down the game is like it's it's okay like we've got your back still and it keeps you competitive in the game um I think it's pretty hard to like kill someone in this game right like just like completely knock them off the board if you're playing you know with with some semblance of paying attention to things and I think that's a great part of the design yeah I mean if your ship gets sunk all you lose is points like even if you if you have cargo which is like the currency that you spend to get stuff you keep all your cargo and you probably just got cargo like because you said like every Cube they thrown into that Tower is gonna do something it's going to either damage the opponent which is good it's going to help you win the battle which is good it's going to give you a coin or it's going to give you a barrel which you can spend on things um or it'll you know get re-rolled with more cubes so yeah like I mean in that that last play Anastasia that one ill-fated attack on me um and I happen to have all these guns in my hand I got a whole bunch of stuff you know even though it wasn't my turn and then a really peculiar thing about this game is like I played the cards with the guns on them on Anastasia's turn but then when it was my turn that card is still technically in play and I

could use it so I had all these guns out so I was like well I guess I'm gonna go fight that Merchant over there because I've already committed to playing these guns I mean in The Last Action when I sunk you Anastasia in that game you still got like I stole Five Points from you but you still got probably at least three or four points worth of stuff from the defending cubes that you talked to tossed into that Tower yeah no I I totally agree with you Nick I love that mechanic I love that you get all of this plunder I love that you don't have that feeling of like oh I just wasted all this effort on this battle and I got nothing out of it I mean that's one of the reasons I don't like a lot of the games that have battle in them because it doesn't matter how much I add to my dice like you know I at the end of the day it's complete luck and so is this right it's complete luck how these cubes are going to come out of this Dice Tower but the fact that in that particular play John I had a card that actually benefited the resource you know the barrels which is the one resource in this game other than gold and that I had a card that gave me points for that so you attacking me even though we figured it out that you attacking me in that game is how you button because I only lost by like three points which is also kind of nuts that this game can come down to and all of our plays except for the one yesterday uh even the first one it all came down to like one point between me and Nick three points between like we the game is so very close scores yeah which is actually something I want to talk about more in a second but it's nevertheless the fighting getting the stuff and the fact that I remember asking you guys

like 15 times whether or not you could take my barrels off my ship and then I could like those are like protected that there just isn't yeah you were really worried I was because the resources they're like no your barrels are fine I can't touch them yeah and because you know in this ocean mechanic you'll go out to the deep ocean and you need those barrels to buy Cards and you can't pick them up unless you fight and then they they actually do come onto your boat so actually getting in a fight can also be good like you could get damaged but you might get the resources you need because in that battle you were able to pick them up so it's one of the I don't want to say trickier mechanics but it definitely adds this complexity of that pick up and deliver of like a lot of the resources that you make you make at your home port and so like you can only take so much with you and it slows you down and you can only add things kind of like where your resources are generated whether they're on the islands you're on or whether they're on your home Port is a bit of a puzzle in and of itself and and battle is one of the ways to kind of like short circuit that puzzle which I I really enjoy it's very thematic yeah yeah it seems like when we first got Nick taught the game we first taught it I was like oh gosh this game's gonna be too competitive for me like two in your face too interactive but I remember after that first battle that happened in the first game I wasn't in it but between the two of you I think the person who lost was like oh that wasn't so bad I got I got this I got that you didn't even nobody got sunk even in that first battle it was like hard to think it's hard well that actually that leads me a

little bit into uh card combos right because like we've talked a lot about combat and area majority but like this is a card crafting game and in our last game I built a card that if it had enough guns on it would do extra damage whenever I went to a spot and every time I battled if I won I would do extra damage and that's actually why I went into Port sailed right into port with all the defenses to try and destroy you in that last turn because I knew I was doing a minimum of three damage normally you do a minimum of one if you win but I I had crafted this card that was was Punchy and when the dust settled I did like seven damage you only need five damage to win to sink a ship and you I think I think your ship already had two on it so like I also felt that way like oh it's really hard to sink ships in this game you just do one damage but then if you start to put together ludicrous combos on cards actually you can get crazy destroyers but again like even if somebody coming crazy destroys you you just lost like Five Points usually but you also might take damage that's one of the other benefits yeah I might damage you you just sunk me honey 100 percent but also it's still turds or it still took me having some damage like it's not one of the nice aspects is that it seems somewhat difficult to sync someone in one turn completely possible but it seems like yeah sorry I'm distracted because I'm trying to think of that card that you played John if I saw it and it specifically says you can't do damage people in Port it does it does say that you don't do an

extra damage when import but uh in general I was still doing more than enough damage with that card great super love that okay that is however how Nick hid for me by the way is because I made one of those cards and then Nick was like I'm gonna go hide and port and the card literally is like can't attack import which is probably a good thing because if you don't like conflict in this game if you just end your turn in Port you're pretty safe there's a couple of mechanics that like protect you and so you can kind of avoid it nevertheless I really really needed to sink him like I think I wanted well what's cool what's cool too is to hide in Port you're probably gonna suck at the game because you like want to go places to do things yeah if you're just doing it on those starting islands that sucks so the only way to do that and be successful is that you have to spend time getting sales on your ship and I did I did put sales I had a sales on one of my cards and I had sales on my ship as well so I could like go out do something and then run away back home and of course the like one time that I didn't you came and attacked me and didn't sink me so it was fine but you won the battle and like got your cool rewards for it so yeah it was legit but John I'm really glad you brought up the card crafting because we spent all this time talking about the combat we spent all the time talking about the area majority I think the combat but like demands your attention because when you walk by a table of someone with this you're like what's with the pirate ship on the table Yeah it demands your attention like it's very cool looking um but to me actually the card crafting

the like voltroning up each of your cards is the coolest part 100 yeah awesome and the reason that it's awesome is not car like card crafting and Mystic fails like oh neat like you can build this little combo this game has it on two axes and that is brilliant the two axes that I'm talking about here is you can go out you can buy advancements Which slot under your card you can have up to three advancements and you can level you get to level up one card of return which is like the base cards it basically just like upgrades their actions so like the Gunner starts off giving you some barrels he doesn't even gun and then he learns how got a gun and then he's awesome at gunning and now he's the best in the world right like yeah so you get these like opportunities to upgrade them and put the advancements on them so you can build these like little combos uh that you're just like oh I've played you know Captain Mega over here I'm gonna sail over to your place and like mess everything up they've been talking here John's John was just talking about like the violence combos which certainly exists but there are other combos that are really cool too and super passive amazing combos yeah it was a two-player game that I played with Anastasia where she's like yeah I have some cannons but really what I could do is play like a million cubes I just conquer an entire Island and then like I had one where I like played it it was like get seven resources and I was like it's not even a combo I'm just rich like really satisfying yeah well Anastasia you made a crazy captain in our game oh my God I was so sad I didn't get to use this card more he was you used it once yeah cool yeah he like for the number I

don't remember exactly but for the number of there's a lot of like for the number of icons that you have of this which is just to your point Nick like I kept buying cannons in that game because the game I played with you because I had this card that let me put cute that like benefited my strategy of playing defensively like let me buy cannons to then just do area majority and so I just passed yeah I just happened to my Canon's on this card but really what it did was let me take over islands and I loved that and it with you John yeah I had this Captain who if he just sailed through Islands he would just pick up things he would they would just produce we haven't even talked about that but the islands produce resources and that's part of the pickup and deliver but they would just produce on to hit onto my ship which really would have benefited me also like doing a boson strategy which is like how you upgrade your strips which is something that you guys both did a ton like in each of my two-player games with you guys you both upgraded your ship so it's something I opt to admit I haven't fully explored but I'm curious because it felt like I actually started to feel jealous I was like my ship feels so lame compared to to your guys's ships um how you will start it in like I want to go on that strategy yeah I mean you have to spend you spend stuff in this game um in a lot of ways you know be by advancement slotted your cards make your cards better or if you go into abortion strategy and upgrade your ship itself you spend stuff to upgrade your ship and um and actually when I had that one game that second play where I went hard on

the boson and I just upgraded my ship a bunch I felt a lot of grass's Greener moments because I was like I'm never getting advancements like I'm just not picking up these cards I'm not I'm not upgrading my deck but what I was doing was permanently upgrading my ship which gave me extra sales and then I put a bunch of guns on there and then you know the rest is history like I said before but when the dust settled on that game and we like count up the advancements I had eight I think and you had like 15 like almost twice as many but that's because I sunk my stuff into those other things and while my ship was you know guns out like crazy you had combos like that Captain I mean like you didn't just sail through islands and produce you had another effect on that Captain that doubled the effect of one of your benefits oh yeah I forgot about that so like it was isn't just that you had like this one good aspect you built this combo there's a you slotted a third thing and that happened I don't even know what it did but it was good but I remember on that last turn you sailed your captain around and made like 12 points moving with one card play which is a lot when the end game score is like 90. yeah move it more it would have been double that like it just I was short on sales or something yeah it was a cool it was a really cool card but at the same time like we talked about this afterwards I I won that game even though I felt grass is greener like oh my cards are way less interesting than Anastasia's but that's just because there's a consistency to upgrading your ship of just like permanent sale permanent Canon it's you it's hard to Discount that and be like oh well that's not good because clearly that is but it's not flashy it's not a flashy combo I think grass is greener is actually part of the good design of the different

professions what are crewmates uh yeah that are that are in the game right because when we first played it was like oh my God upgrading the buccaneer is insane why wouldn't you upgrade the buccaneer like you need to put lots of Cubes places okay hold on upgrading the Gunner is clearly what you needed to do because like they they go hard and then you're like yeah okay fine um upgrading crew can't be good Kenneth it's like both Anastasia and I have tried it now we're like all right you get pretty rich when you upgrade this is pretty cool too like yeah there's only one card that I I haven't been convinced that upgrading the deckhand is cool and I'm sure that we'll play a game where I'm like all right I take it back duck hand is awesome because because all of them feel cool and they're their own different way and those the ones that I mentioned aren't even like the spicy one where it's like build a ton of buildings or I actually think upgrading your ship is cool because I like just seeing it like all specked out I think it's awesome but uh yeah I mean they all of them seem great and that I think is is that's exciting design I think it's a common mistake in Euro games that it's like you can do this or you can do this but they kind of feel Samy and in this one it's like oh I wish I could be doing that and the other players has I wish I could be doing what you're doing that's good yeah very first play when you and Anastasia were going nuts on the islands and I was kind of hanging out on the side in this issue you upgraded your card to let you construct buildings I've yet to build I think I've only built like one building in in my entirety my two games but in that first game you built actually in

both the games that we played you built a ton of buildings and like they're defensive like get the heck away from here they their production they like make more stuff when you go there and I've I've felt that grass is greener like I wish my Islands were were littered with buildings but you know I was doing other things instead um and like I want to go over there and take over that island but holy cow there's a freaking Fortress and a Garrison and I I'm gonna go somewhere else I mean I love that I like I I completely it's like I I let about this game that there feels like there there's so many different like well I did buildings and those in my first two games and the game I played yesterday with Nick I didn't build buildings at all I was like I don't want buildings this game but I remember that first game and I do this a lot with a game it has so many complexities the first time I play a game I sort of pick a couple of things and then I just like just do that so like I didn't explore I didn't go deep in the ocean that first thing I just like stayed near Port and like pick up and deliver the whole game and then I built buildings you tried to build a wall I tried to build a wall of like yeah you control the close islands and then you like built garrisons and forts on on just almost expensive guys it's just defensive that's the funny part is I was like I wasn't I wasn't aggressive at all in that game I was just defensive but you could you just tried to wall us out into the ocean come on through here but it's nice because those things like they force people to fight with your Island instead of with you like there's just and you

protect your Island it really allows you to protect yourself pretty well but that was that was really interesting but I do think what's what you know I think Nick it's after you and I played our first two player game we we took we looked at this board so you start with 12. everybody starts with the same 12 card deck the same 12 people if you will and you like Nick said you can upgrade them every turn which is so much fun the choice and you do it between turns so even though they're we we've touched on this but there is a ton of downtime in this game like it we thought it would go away it doesn't really go away there's so much to think about it you just have more to think about the more you get to know the game and even in two players there's still a ton of downtime but you're always thinking about things so you're sitting there like thinking what card do I want to upgrade and you get to do that in between turns so you have a lot of it it just creates a really nice choice in addition to the card crafting and putting things on your cards and and building them up so when we were looking at these upgrades and Nick you you touched on this let's like see these cards like the crew card that you seems so lame and then to realize when you get it to level four you can put barrels on your ship you can put them on the port you can do like like the the abilities that are unexpected when you get them up and then the choices that you make when you're starting the game to be like okay well this is how at least how I've been playing which has not been successful so I don't take this as advice uh I've been sitting there being like what cards do I want to upgrade this game right and like

what strategy am I gonna kind of go at and you kind of get to choose like sure the games can dictate a little bit because there's the randomness of what you're gonna draw like what's in your starting hand is somewhat gonna dictate I know Nick was like I want to do a boasting strategy and then the boson was at the bottom of his deck so like he was like I guess I gotta do something else yeah and you know like John said chip upgrades are permanent like they're a thing but that's still a strategy you have to pick or a card that you have to choose to upgrade to so that you can do that but those are things that you get every turn but you know there's still a fair amount of Randomness like I could upgrade this massive super captain and he never comes out I mean the drawing is a factor here I mean you only have 12 of cards he will he will eventually come out he will eventually come out and and he might he might hide that one turn where you really freaking need him the game does a good job though of like some of the islands that you have a bigger hand size and true yeah some of the cards that you draw an extra card and like wow you control like see there's a lot of ways to control your deck which is just so much fun and then pick like I said kind of pick the strategies that you kind of want to go at I've done a lot of like just holding a card for four turns and like just upgrading it to level four just like in my hand and then playing it just to kind of get the benefits of that going out and I I just I love that it reminds me a lot of Arc Nova and I've already kind of mentioned this but there's this feeling of what do you want to do this game like what are you going to upgrade what you you can't do everything you can't upgrade

everything like what are you gonna choose and like what are you gonna go hard on and you can do different things and there's just so much to explore and I think that's so cool yeah I do you you mentioned two of the things that I I'm so hyped right now this conversation makes me want to play the game again yeah we should just stop I do want to I do want to take some wind out of the sails here pun completely intended of two of the things that you mentioned in there that are that are my two hold ups for this game one is the down time the down time is long legitimate and yes you you have to pay attention to what other people are doing on their turn but you're it's also like I'm waiting for it to be my turn like it's it's not the kind of thing where like paying attention during someone else's turn really adds like a ton of value to my gameplay experience and unless you're attacking me I'm not interacting really with what you're doing um and you know we've talked about this in an earlier um episodes but like generally of the three of us I'm a pretty quick player and there are times in this game where I'm like I'm playing these and I know I'm gonna do this but then hold on let me figure out how to sequence it and I can feel myself being like make a decision make a decision everyone's waiting on you right now move the boat drop the cube and like move on with your life but if I move this way it's like shut up keep going like yeah um that like cycle is is very real and then you're like oh wait but there's an advancement I could buy crap right yeah yeah I don't think I've ever played a game with you before Nick where you were like

I think I'm thinking slower than you in this game like I don't think that's ever happened yeah in the last game that we played because Anastasia was playing a primarily fighting strategy and I was like all right well I'm gonna hide from her how could I hide from her and accomplish what I want to do and she's like I'm just waiting for you come on out and then you never did yeah really it really it was rough it was rough I was I definitely I felt the pressure of that time um I know the two of you mentioned it too so I mean I know everyone feels this way right so we played we played all of our games on tabletop simulator uh up to this point we don't actually own a copy of this game and the tabletop simulator mod that exists is quite good but I remember in our first play at one point I took my turn and then Nick's taking this turn and then Anastasia comes back and she's like sorry sorry and we're like what do you mean sorry she's like oh I left I got a snack I talked to my partner I came back I assumed it was my turn and we're like no I was gone for a while and and the other thing too is when someone steps away right she comes back it's like what'd you do it's like I sailed over here and bought this car great like it's not like yeah at the end of the day it's like I would this and then I conquer the four you know it doesn't like go on and on and on oh I bought that card you're trying to figure out how to sequence it appropriately and even after right like three play like my third play was my slowest of this game yeah yeah I played twice and my second play was slower as well and I commented the initiation I'm like I thought I'd be faster but like oh I'm sorry like you do get faster at

some things and you do grock the game more and you are spending less time being like okay guys let's stop and let's look up a rule like you do get faster and I and I I like that's good but like I said it just gives you more to think about because suddenly you're aware of so much more and you realize you have to plot and this actually kind of goes back to like I think my major critique of the game I will say I had some smaller critiques like I was like oh it's not really a deck builder that all has kind of been washed away the more I played it the more I've realized I have control over my deck more the I did more advancements and I I realized you know like all of a lot of the little things like you do with a lot of games the game shows you why it was that way those decisions yeah it reminded me of Anna were we like after our first play we talked about it for like two hours and we're like all these things we want to change and then the more we played as like the it's perfect don't change it in my opinion uh but in this one I do have one and a half major complaints and for me my biggest issue is the end game because of everything you guys are talking about that how much thinking can get into it especially as you keep going make sure the first few turns you don't have to think that hard and even as you're playing in the middle like you're starting to kind of feel like okay this is what I'm doing and it doesn't feel like every decision super matters like it does matter but like you can kind of kind of flow with it but when you get to the end it this game ends super abruptly there

and this is my like half criticism which is actually the I think they're called they're called achievements right there's achievements and advances achievements which are essentially uh like I don't know a number of end game it's just like Scythe or beyond the sun their goals and when you when you meet enough of them the game ends right but the game just ends like when someone meets them you get one more turn it doesn't matter how much you've been building doesn't matter that maybe you just drew the worst cards in your deck it's over you've got one turn there's no way to draw more there's no way to like fix it there's no way to adapt it ends and as a benefit for the player that ended the game they get displacing their cubes costs a double for you attacking them is harder for you like it just it makes it really hard so this so when you get to this end point you've done all of this thinking all of this plotting and if you weren't like super careful paying attention to whether or not you think someone else is going to end it at this point I've never ended it despite trying you can your game can just kind of like fall on its face in this like last moment and it just leads into the whimper and in a whimper exactly after you played this amazing two-hour game and had this fantastic experience and then I've had I'd say two out of the four games I I just it left me with a bad taste of my mouth it's not because I lost I great at losing at playing

against Nick you become so good at losing games you just you don't it doesn't even phase you I it's not about the losing it's just about that feeling of like when these scores are so close it comes down to a couple of points and like Nick and I played yesterday and I had so much regret about what I'd done in my second to last turn not realizing that Nick was gonna end it not pacing that well not because he threw out like three advancements in one turn and just yeah that's a thing the game ends when somebody has four achievements and you can do them all at once very very easy to do two on a turn yeah and it's it's somewhat easy to do three in the late game because you kind of get so close to so many of them exactly and then he just and then I was just like and so he like had to go and I was like he's like are you gonna finish playing I was like no I'm just gonna about what I did last turn for 10 minutes because I'm so pissed at myself that I didn't plan correctly like just for my brain because there's so much you can control and there's so it's such a hero to get to that moment and be like I it just all fell on its face it just it felt so bad and the game is so good so anyways I'm curious you gotta think of that I mean you and I were talking about it a little bit afterwards too and I I agree I think that a lot of Forex games or a lot of like area control or territory control type games they struggle with the end game because because the scoring system of controlling stuff at the end is so significant that like getting to go last

is huge and I I've not seen a ton of especially Forex style games find good solutions to this problem they tend to not be elegant they tend to not they tend to feel abrupt and I think part of it is right you've built this boat you have all these upgraded crew you know there's all these islands and the game's over you know like the game has to end at some point and like what do you determine is like good or bad at the end of the game is up to the design right and I I would not say that dead reckoning has solved this problem I I'm not as frustrated as Anastasia is by the endgame experience uh but maybe um but but even still like I think I think that even if someone else ended it on me like I generally would have a sense of like at least at this point I feel like I have a sense of what the Arc of the game is gonna be like that when it ends I'm not gonna be like completely befuddled by it but I do see what you're saying I do think that it's it's valid so I played it twice and I ended the game in one of those two plays and I'll admit it's kind of thrilling to do that and even though in that second play I will admit it was it was telegraphed like uh one of the achievements is is upgrade your boat enough times and in fact uh I had three out of the four and Anastasia thought it was going to be your last turn because you assumed I had the card that let me upgrade my ship but then I didn't try it and so you actually took like uh what you thought was your second to last turn as a setup and then you were like oh actually surprised you get

another second to last turn and you were able to set that up and I think I think it really the the vibe of it just totally depends on if you're surprised like you were you didn't end it but you weren't surprised in that game no in the first game we were but also in the first game we didn't know what we were doing I remember dick went away for just a couple of minutes and you and I were just chatting and we're like I feel like we're like two-thirds away through the game and then it came back to do his turn and literally ended the game yeah

this is really fun we got like another 30 minutes here no I'm gonna end it you know the amount of times that Nick says that and it just fills me with Dread he he's this thing he sits down and he's like all right I think I'm gonna end it and I'm like what you know what's really funny is I I I know that I generate anxiety for people when I do that so that's part of the reason why I say it because I think that if I went through executing it and then like Dawning realization of it ending is worse so that's why I like announced it is coming like yeah you're portent of the future I'm getting it right now one day we'll have merch and it's gonna have that I think I'm gonna end it it's gonna be one of the shirts the last thing that I kind of want to say like on this whole end game thing is that the achievements they're the same every game and I really like how the achievements are handled in like beyond the sun where which for me that end game I prefer to this because not only are the achievements variable so they promote different strategies a little bit some of them are the same but you also if I remember correctly you finish the round and then play another one and that's really what I wish happened here is that you just you would just either finish around or like everybody else gets two more turns and you get one more and I know like I'm sure there are great many reasons why that isn't the case but it just feels like it allows someone who maybe played

a strategy that doesn't play into the achievements because up to this point four games in despite all of my efforts I have never felt like I was in a good position to get four achievements because I haven't done the build ship upgrade strategy which I feel like you need to focus half your game on to do well the in the two-player game exploring is very very tight and I keep not being the one to get to get to it there's just like I haven't been a position to satisfy all those achievements half of them are battling which aren't that good in two player and they're the same every game so you you are somewhat bound to them and that's my like other half criticism is just that those achievements I don't want to look at them and feel this like trapped feeling I don't complain about that a lot where I'm like there's a saviness to them and and I don't think you need to but it feels that way when the end game when triggered by someone else can feel so disadvantageous to me not being the one to trigger it so I don't know we'll see how more plays and getting to know the feel of the timing is and like John said in the game where I was I wasn't taken by surprise I was a lot more prepared and I had a Bonkers last turn so you know I'll see how that goes but that's still probably my biggest criticism with the game I do want to talk about one other thing that I I don't even know that I would call it a criticism because it's got good and bad parts to it it's just something that I think a person needs to be aware of when they're stepping into this game is the randomness of this game so I'm gonna

give this the randomness in this game accomplice we're gonna start with the compliment side of it the compliment side of it is that the randomness is very hidden which means that you don't feel like the game is screwing you you don't feel like things just didn't pan out your way if the cards that are really good kind of are at the bottom of your deck then what happens is you like end up like kind of like redrawing on a reshuffle and you essentially get to execute those cards fewer times over the course of the game and if you're not paying attention you're just like okay I drew my cards everything is good so everything gets to do something but if Anastasia's playing a game where she gets to do good things and I get to I get to repeatedly do very good things I'm gonna come out on top um so that information again that Randomness is not in your face so I don't think that it feels quite as bad but when I'm sitting there and analyzing it I can't turn my brain off for that and I'm like no my my super cards at the bottom of the deck again yeah it does it does stomp on it it can stomp on it particularly given how much of a deep thinky plotting Euro game this can feel like I mean you feel like you you really can sit there and calculate your turns and plot you know the the chances of these things happening given how much Randomness like you said is like within this game it surprises me how much I step back from it and think oh yeah this is just like a really deep engine building Europe

it's not an engine builder dagger don't poke the bear I mean we we've discussed uh a little bit about you know ways to kind of get around that maybe some some subtle things like you know you have a base hand size of six and you have a base draw of four so that means kind of a typical thing to do is to to kind of keep two cards back that might not be good right now um and when you keep those back your deck is functionally smaller and if you have a hand size of nine like Anastasia had near the end of our last game and you have 12 cards in your deck like there's a situation where you could you could uh sequester a whole bunch of cards um essentially in your enormous hand and then just play your really good ones and then just cycle through your deck over and over again that's also something that might be more possible like a two-player game because a lot of your ability to augment your deck has to do with the islands you control and I think you're right Nick like I sort of I really want to play this at four but I sort of am dreading playing it for not just because of the Epic downtime it really takes six hours like Eclipse just kidding it won't but not just because of the downtime but because of the lack of control I mean that's just theme in general with these games right like when you're playing with with gaming in general when you play two player game you have more ability to control that Randomness and when you play with higher player accounts in a tight field like you have less of it so I've played this less than both of you at this point but um you know with my only two plays but it's been really exciting uh kind of

like watching these games happen seeing like the session reports of the ones that you guys are playing you know typing the one out for for the one that we did this game is has been really fun like when you're taking your turn and piecing stuff together I just I I find it so satisfying even if it does become a little bit of an analysis paralysis hole and I kind of thought I was gonna like this game I remember when I made my video for this like a year and a half ago I remember thinking this game looks cool and and I'm glad to see that I've I've really enjoyed it um even though you know the downtime and whatnot has been lower uh I think the one thing that shines is pretty interesting uh for me I mean lots of things shine is pretty interesting but one thing um the kind of sum up my feelings is is how this is like a stealthy Euro in a lot of ways uh you know we've talked about uh the randomness we just talked about the randomness and that definitely exists here but also there's a lot of your we decisions even with the decision is do I go into Harbor and try to punch Anastasia in the face which doesn't sound like a very euro-y decision but actually it kind of is because am I giving too many points there and also am I giving up points over here and there and one thing I've found with this game with my couple of plays is that I need to kind of force myself to to step back from the crunching and just do the fun thing yeah because frequently the fun thing is actually the right thing to do um I've mentioned it many times but that last turn of our last game where I sunk you in the harbor I had two options I could go to the harbor and sync you or I could have run around and taken second place on like five Islands or four islands and that would have been worth a

bunch of points I remember saying you know what one of these options is fun and one of these options might actually get me more points I'm going to do the fun thing I ended up winning maybe if I done the the euroe thing of just taking second place on a bunch of islands maybe I would have won by more I don't know but I I leaned into the fun thing and I had fun and you know ultimately that is what you're trying to do here but I I can't help but wonder if the the ap-ness of it it's just because there is so many euroesque type of things that you can Crunch and uh you know in future plays I just got to keep telling myself like look at your hand of cards what's the funnest option do it don't crunch don't crunch don't crunch um and I'll probably enjoy it even more um and you know I've been trying quite a lot already I gotta admit like I was kind of skeptical on it it's like an hour teach there was like a lot even after our first play I was like okay like that was a good game but I thought I thought that this was going to be like a possible one in that like I really enjoyed myself maybe we'd play it again it brought up a lot of conversation but I didn't expect it to be one with some staying power I didn't expect it to be like hey do you want to go play dead reckoning and we have games like that you know that we just kind of we always go back to you know Anna is one of them holler towel is one of them um uh beyond the sun is one of them too like we just there's games where it's like oh great you want to just play something like let's just let's just break that out and I don't know like I don't know you know we're gonna have to touch base on this in a couple months and see how much we played it but Nick is right like I like

playing as a game like this like four times in a week like that that that means I like it like I just like that's that's beyond doing that for podcasts no that's that's beyond I want to explore it and give a well-rounded opinion for this episode that's like I don't know I'm really curious to see like you know if this is going to become we sort of call it a game we Jam like is this gonna be one of those games because it's just fun it's just for all of my complaints aside it's just fun and to see it improve when we first played it two-player I was like Nick and I were both that was the first time we played it two player with each other and I think we both were like I don't know if this is a good two player game but then I played it with John two player then we played it again two player and I was like you know it's solid it I I'm having a great time like it's just it's just fun and I sure there's like little tweaks especially for the randomness we'd even talk about the randomness in the in the advancements that come out in the cards for the card crafting yeah do I want to see more Merchant ships maybe would I thin the deck a little bit for two players sure like I don't know yeah like I there's I've got some complaints you know is there less fighting um options than two player yeah but for a game that that does seem to be getting a little bit faster I think we played it in under two hours yesterday but like a game that just just like you could sit down and just gonna like dive into and just have so much fun I don't know I don't know if it's got staying power I don't know if I'm gonna buy it I don't even know how I feel about it but I've just been having fun with it and that is

great that's good for me yes the staying power question is so good I I don't know what I'm like in a month with this game right like us having this conversation I'm as like hyped for playing the game I feel like as in the times that we were playing the game and that's making me think that part of what I really enjoy about this game is sort of the the components that are very amazing about it like the card crafting system the upgrading the voltronic it's so cool like I'm just I really really like it and the fighting is like it's a nice novel way to resolve fighting where it feels like even when you're you know the person who's just getting like beat on there's like something to be had there and I think that's cool too so those are those are really really Nifty um but I don't I don't love the scoring of the area control stuff the like game it can run a little bit too long for what it is like when I describe like what it is at the course over the game that I accomplished I do Wonder like if certain systems in the game if they were not there if it would still do just be just as good like if we took this with this one little thing out here there I don't know like I you know it's it's it's tough to say for sure but I think what you said Anastasia about like it's just fun like I've been enjoying playing it I want to go jam it again right now and I'll have to see like is this something that we play in a month in three months um because you know it's been surprising the games that have lasted in the games

that haven't lasted and this one's definitely a contender yeah yeah it is well this is a fun conversation too I think that definitely adds into the enjoyment of uh like what games we play is the one that that Fosters such intense discussion I mean man I do like talking about this stuff absolutely and so grab lunch and then we'll uh we'll play everyone good afternoon I think that's going to bring this episode to a close uh thanks everybody for uh for listening I hope you found this enjoyable uh we'd love to hear what you think about dead reckoning if you've tried it if you're curious to try it uh please uh leave comments uh if you're listening to the podcast version of this there is a YouTube version you can find a link to it in the description of this and uh please leave comments over there and yeah thanks again for watching

Progress saved