Cascadia: Alpine Lakes ►►► What did we think?
Transcript
Hey everybody, final thoughts time for Cascadia Alpine. But before we get to that, please remember folks, this was a sponsored preview of an early prototype of the game. And with that out of the way, I am not alone today, folks. As you might imagine, I am joined by Amy and Maggie. Hey, everybody. How's it going?
We're great.
We're great. How are you?
Uh, it is good here. I am in a little campground gown in the middle of the Netherlands, not too far from Tuben Mill, I think. Uh there's a nearby restaurant called Patatu we ate at last night that we had the best fry mayonnaise I've ever had anywhere in the world. Um so I'm still riding high from that. But what I'm really riding high on is our triumphant victory.
I am so glad Jen isn't here. A
no, she has not gotten the bad news yet. Um, I'm actually filming alone today. But I I'll break it to her gently. Although, you know, it's interesting
having watched you guys. And actually, it was interesting midway through um while you were thinking out loud, Amy, you mentioned you tend to build go small,
right?
Yes.
Um, in your plays, Jen, it's rare. I don't think I don't even know if she's made it to the third level yet. She just sprawls every single time we played and so she sets you up for failure. There was a mismatch.
No. Yeah, there was a mismatch in our styles, but she had the whole glacia thing going and I Well, I try I just needed to finish that. I needed to finish the job she had started. So, I felt pretty good about that. Um, but I was pretty surprised. The the scores were really close to the end.
Pretty close.
That was a nailbiter.
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Me, too. Honestly, I thought, "Oh, uh, another loss for the uh for the thinkers triumphant again." But no, today theme won the day. Um, and so anyway, yeah, folks, uh, in case you don't know what we're talking about and you just jumped to this, we have done a uh full demonstration playthrough in two parts with my wife Jen and I playing the first 10 turns and Amy and Maggie taking the last 10 turns. And spoiler alert, u Maggie and I won. But even still, if you haven't watched it yet, there's links down in the show notes. It was so much fun to do and it was so much fun to watch you guys squirm with what we left you. And I think at one point Amy talked about, oh, I'm I'm I'm failing at Jen's legacy or something like that. It was hilarious.
I never felt so much pressure. Just like it's okay when you lose for yourself, but when you're you know, it's like cooperative gaming. It's like now I've got someone else's fate on my shoulders.
Added pressure.
Added pressure. Yeah. Yeah.
And honestly, I thought, Maggie, I had set you up terribly. The last move I made, which um you know, I I honestly I I just had totally frozen. I had no idea what to do. And just on the spot. Okay. Boom. And you're right. I completely forgot what I was trying to do. Um cuz I Okay, nothing else. Just go high. Just go higher. It'll all work out if we just climb. If we keep climbing. And at the end of the day, Maggie, throughout the video, you kept mentioning, I don't even know if it's worth bending over backwards for these couple extra.
Yeah. It was like surely I'm not going to win or lose. We're not It's not going to We're It's our game is not going to be a twopoint difference. It was so close because whenever we've played it's never really been that close. Uh and so yeah. Yeah.
I do a lot better off camera and I I feel like you know people are not going to believe that anymore. The number of times I have lost doing a run through camera is my edge. It's like this is this is where I get to shine. It's like yes, I promise I do win sometimes. It's the it's the great equalizer.
I know the feeling. I I know the feeling. I I just need to bring in a uh a ringer to help me beat Jen every once in a while. I still remember that one time we all played a game at Dice Tower West and throughout the entire game it looks like Maggie was just being utterly obliterated. Um and then at the end final scoring, she just destroyed us all. That was I'll never forget that. But anyway, folks, we're not here to talk about games we played. We're not here to talk about life on the road. We're here to actually talk about Cascadia Alpine because you might be deciding whether you want to back it while it's crowdfunding or just buy it in a store somewhere in the far far future. So, um, you're the guest. What did you think? How have you been enjoying Cascadia Alpine?
Well, look, I'm going to give a bit of context and it's interesting because I have a really unpopular opinion about the regular Cascadia. I think I think it's I know I think it's fine, but I've talked about it quite a bit on our channel that it's probably not my favorite. And what's interesting is this is actually really changed my mind about Cascadia.
Yeah. So,
yeah. So, it's a huge turnaround for me. So, I I like the game. I'll play it with other people. It's, you know, lots of people love Cascadia. We played the roll and right, and that was kind of a little similar, you know. I was kind of like, yeah, that's good. But this one, the added dimensions to the puzzle, I something about it just clicked and I just enjoyed I enjoyed my time with it so much more. And with Cascadia, the 20 turns always felt like, you know, a little long in the tooth. I'm like, oh, is the game going to end soon? This I'm like, I've only got 20 turns.
How am I going to achieve everything? And towards the end, I'm like, I've only got this many turns. So, I was like wanting it to be longer. So, that was like it was really strange because it has so much of the same DNA
as Cascadia and then it's just adding, you know, those the different way of scoring and that extra level at 3D puzzle element of it
completely completely turned it around for me.
Yeah, I'm going to agree with that. Like I actually found like the like the previous Cascadias I've been like, "Yeah, it's fine. It's you know, they're on the abstract side." So I tend to in general not connect as much with the sort of the more abstract puzzles. Um and but yeah with this one I was I was actually I found again having that option of now building up and do you sprawl out or do you just kind of keep it contained and all of a sudden it's like ooh like the the tension of oh but I don't want to I don't want to cover this thing that I've already been working on.
You're throwing things away.
Yeah. Exactly. So it's it's so it just ramps up that that internal tension so much more that I actually found myself so much more engaged. And yet I never sort of felt like h you know okay I feel like I've kind of played this like could this end you know one or two turns sooner. I was Yeah. It was the same kind of like oh no I just need a few more turns. Yeah. So that was way better. Yeah.
What do you think?
I'm curious Maggie are are you are before we go to me are you in the Cascadia Yeah. It's fine camp as well.
Absolutely. Yeah. It's like it's always been like it's fine. We don't actually own it. So like we've played it. Yeah. We've played it and it's something that, you know, sort of been in our household for times, but it's usually a game that we've kind of eventually moved on.
Yeah. And I love FlatOut games because they just, you know, they keep sending us versions of Cascadia. And we keep saying,
we were like, look, we're like, okay. And I was like, they're going to keep sending us, you know, and this is the proper
this is the proper sequel. And I was like, okay, I'm not willing to give it another go. And this time I'm like, wow. Okay, they they finally really got me. It worked. It did work. We're going to get you one day, Amy. And they did.
They keep on trying. They finally Okay, so now they can put the series to rest. Although this is just getting started.
Yes, I agree.
Well, to answer your question, um, yeah, we both liked it a lot. Both Jen and I are huge Cascadia fans both for the puzzle and I mean you're right Maggie, there are definitely thematic exercises, but I've always found in regular Cascadia the way the different ways the animals can score, you know, there is a thematic grounding to them that I appreciate even if the whole thing is still a fairly abstract puzzle because what are we just like the spirit of nature making thing, you know, it makes no sense. We we have no role in this world. But I always appreciated those touches. And actually, as while you were um recording your second half, you mentioned um a very nice thematic flourish, the idea that the animals can adapt to changing environments. And I hadn't even thought of that, you know, the thematic versitude, too. You mentioned it, but it's it's very very cool. So, I think there's enough theme and I'm just a huge fan. I mean, I like tileing. I mean, I like building something physical and real. And you know, hey, if it's threedimensional, so much the better. More 3D tile layers, please. I love them. Um, but I've always been a huge fan of the entwined drafting. The I want that, but I want that. Do I throw a point away to grab both of them or do I take that? And that'll be okay. Um, you know, the drafting is what has always made them so engaging. And now effectively, where in Cascadia you were only drafting two things, now you're drafting three things because we're playing with dominoes instead of just hex's. Um, you know, and so I I I think that does elevate things uh quite a bit.
I'm not sure. I I think I probably still like Cascadia more because
Interesting.
Yeah. Well, the the focus in Cascadia is on the animals.
Yes.
Whereas clearly the focus here is on the terrain and the animals are almost interchangeable, whereas it's kind of the opposite in the original. And at the end of the day, I like animals more than I like biomes. I think it really is kind of a, you know, a thematic. I, you know, I'm more engaged when I know, oh, this is the one where the Eagles all have to see each other, you know, so we have to do, you know, you know, because they're, you know, all that kind of stuff as opposed to, I mean, it's, it is nice that on the scoring cards they actually do put little thematic names for them. So, there is still a bit of, oh yeah, you know, this is, you know, big big glacier country or whatever it is. But, um, I guess if anything, it's it feels a little bit more abstracted. Although, I it is hard not to say that I don't like the gameplay more. However, I probably have you at a disadvantage because I have played Cascadia with the expansion, the original, which I assume you have not.
No, no, no, we haven't.
Right. Well, the interesting thing about the uh expansion for Cascadia is um it, you know, it doesn't change Cascadia. It adds some more animals, but it also adds new ways you can score based on the environments. Okay. Uh, and Cascadia Alpine right out of the gate feels like Cascadia plus the expansion
because they threw the expansion in basically with those additional I for what they're called, but the square cards, the uh the environment cards or whatever. I mean, you can have up to six things you're six metrics you are scoring on throughout the game and that's a lot.
Um, but I mean, I do think, you know, I maybe I I wonder Amy, if that's another thing that pulls you inact. Yes, it is. But interestingly, what you said about the animals, I actually find it easier for my brain to process. I think that they're mostly spatial um elements with the habitats. And so having those layered together reminds me of like, you know, other puzzle games like the, you know, Calico or Harmonies where you've kind of got multiple spatial puzzles that you're trying to work out at the same time. I didn't I didn't for some reason I didn't connect as much with that part of the original Cascadia when it was the animal form. But now that it's much more about that and there's still, you know, the wildlife um scoring cards in this one as well, but um now that it's much more about the terrain. Yeah. I I don't know.
It just works a bit. Yeah. And the 3D element as well and the covering up and the trying to optimize the number of turns. It just all fell came together for me like really neatly this time. Yeah.
It's It's still not very interactive, though. I will say that. Like, it's a very quiet game.
Yeah. Well, I mean, I I guess if you're playing a two-player, you could be trying to hate draft and whatnot, but honestly, as you said, you feel like you have so little time, there's just no time to do that.
I mean, you're just scraping by every turn.
One thing that's really interesting to me about the 3D tiling, I've actually played a bunch of games that do that, you know, going all the way back to uh to Louva. I think it was the first one. I don't know if it's the first one I ever did it, but it was the first one I ever saw. Um, and there's always this steadfast rule that this game breaks in that you must put tiles across multiple tiles. You can't just stack them on top of each other. And I appreciate that they I I honestly I've never understood why that rule needs to be there because all that does is it makes it harder to do the most fun thing of the game, which is stack stuff up. And this game really seems to want you to be doing it. Um, it's interesting. both. It sounds like both of you tend to play um you know ver more vertically focused rather than sprawling. Jen only sprawls and I find myself drawn to sprawling as well because I just have I you know in and if you watched my first half I was struggling to force myself to build up force myself not to just get bigger and bigger. Not only because I have a very very tiny table here in this caravan.
Um, but because I I really I knew Jim was going to play the way she always plays and I wanted to show off the other hand, not knowing that both of you had the prediliction to climb. Um, but I guess that's a strength of the game.
That was a new thing for me. I actually started sprawling and then Amy kept uh winning by such a large margin that I'm like, wait a second, I'm going to start going up and that's when I started my score started to improve. So I think I don't know if this is a reflection on what happens with the game but it just seemed like it made more sense like as you're starting to go up things start kind of multiplying better. It depends on the score like the scoring cards that you got each particular game as well. Obviously you need to adapt your strategy a little bit but I do like that it gives you the ability to draft some tiles that you may have no intention of using. Like sometimes you just need a building block, you know, you've got to have one level that's just one step below, you know, so you have that path up. Um that Yeah, I really like that as well because it doesn't it means you just can't stack them for the sake of stacking them in one big pile. Um but you've really got to work at like you know optimizing that around as well.
Yep. Yeah. So okay, obviously we're all fans. I mean we've all been fans of flatout stuff in general. I am genuinely surprised though, folks. You heard it here first. If you don't like Cascadia, don't necessarily walk past this. When you get the opportunity, it might pull you in in a way that the previous games didn't. And if you do love Cascadia, like me and Jen, well, um, actually, I think Jen's number one comment was, "Oh, it's nice that it doesn't take up as much table space now."
Even though she was still sprawling.
Yeah. Even though Yeah. Well, I mean, she needs to take all the table and the rest of us are just kind of oh, we're over here in the corner trying to build up cuz there's no table space for us. But we've often found Cascadia, just the base game is such an excellent um you know, we do a lot of road trips and that's always the game we have at the ready. Uh in case some people say, "What do you guys do for fun um you know, in the evenings?" Oh, well, let us show you. And Cascadia is just always a surefire hit. Um and uh but you know and so I think this one would you say which game is the more puzzly ch you know brain burnery?
Oo I think this one.
I think this one too.
I think with the roll and right there was a lot more like math that you were doing and figure out. So it just felt more fiddly um and sort of that cognitive load. But I think from a puzzle crunch, by far I would say this was at least for me the most satisfying. Just lost my just lost it. Yeah.
Um Yeah. But definitely between the original and this one. This one.
Yeah.
Yeah. Do you in the plays you've been doing, have you been playing with three extras every time or?
Yeah. Every time. Yeah. Yeah.
We play a lot of games though. You know, and I I kind of like that you can challenge yourself um you know, as you work up to it as well. So maybe you can just put one in the first game or none and then you can add two three. But I really like actually the game that you set up for our run through there like a lot of the scoring conditions didn't quite work with each other. Um but then we've had other games where they all really connect really well. Um so that kind of changes the way you play as well. It's like oh I can't do everything like I need to focus here.
Um and so I really like that.
Yeah. Okay. Well, um I continue to be a big fan and uh I I I guess another I'm trying to think of things that people would want to know.
Yeah.
Um I think and I think the other big
Yes. requests I have like we've got well I've got requests um for things that I would love to see and I think you mentioned this as well as part of your run through. It definitely does need some kind of player aid cuz there were certain um certain scoring things that initially were like this is this is simple enough that you could remember it but but there's enough of them that it's like actually know it'd be good to be able to along along the way. Yes. Yes.
It's just easy to forget. Don't forget highest animal highest animal if you were right there with all the other cards. I mean I understand you know the developers they've played it each of them you know 200 times each. So, it's ingrained in them. But for us, for regular fe people, you know, especially, I mean, having that seventh card out there, I think would really help quite a bit.
Um, for at least the first dozen or so games.
Yeah. Yeah, and in the run through you will see um if you watched it that I got a little bit tripped up in one of the scoring conditions and I think that's just a bit of wording in the rule book which I might give a little feedback about but it was basically the wildlife scoring for their elevation but then it's kind of as follows and I I kind of read the you know they score according to their height and I was like oh that's right and so I didn't like continue reading the rest of the rule book. So, if it had have been neatly on a reference card, I probably, you know, wouldn't have made that mistake as I was playing. I'm not saying that that would have won me the game, Jen and I, the game. But it may not
It may have.
Yeah.
Well, I'll take the win anyway, I can get it, quite frankly. Even if uh Flatout had to uh help out. It's, you know, it's actually interesting. Um, you know, we've all played a bunch of flatout prototypes over the years, and I have always found, um, as I'm doing it, I give them like a big laundry list of, well, you really, if you said this here, that's really kind of misleading, and I I, you know, so, but I think they've always tend to clean them up in the end. Yeah.
So, I think to me, if I were watching this and I I mean, you can't answer this, but uh, since I am a Cascadia fan, um, I can
I own Cascadia. Do I need to own Cascadia Alpine? I mean, for you too, that's easy. Well, obviously. Yeah. Chuck,
now we'll own Cascadia.
Yeah. Now we'll learn.
Yeah. There you go. You know that. And that's a huge thing for me. I would say, you know, I liken it to um, you know, fans who love Ticket to Ride, after they've had enough of it, they go out and get Ticket to Ride Europe, and then they they really enjoy that. And then they go out and get Ticket to Ride Netherlands or, you know, whatever all the various ones, and next thing you know, they've got six boxes on the shelf. Um, I think I I certainly plan on owning both. There's just not there's no reason not to own both because they do provide, you know, the the same core DNA, you know, the entwined drafting and the the tiles with other tiles stacked on top and they just give you a different feel, a different vibe. Um, you know, for me and Jen, I don't think we would ever want to play Cascadia Alpine in the evening. Um, as we're um, you know, getting a a little slower as, you know, our brains start to wind down for the day. I mean, it's a day, it's a midday, bright sun, you know, um, kind of game for us, whereas Cascadia can be a bit more laid-back. Although, again, if you play Cascadia with the Landmarks expansion, oh my gosh, that game can just become insanely brain burn, too.
Um, yeah, I I think any Cascadia fan, there's just no reason you won't just want to put, and I'm assuming the boxes will all be the same, so they'll look nice next to each other on the shelf. Although, unfortunately, the Cascadia rolling rights are not the same size box, so they are the odd ones out. You can't even stack them together to fit next. But anyway, that's neither here nor there. Um, so I mean I think for people who would be curious about that, if you really love Cascadia, I think you will love this too. And you will find moments when you feel like playing one or the other. Do you feel more like the animals? Do you feel more like the terrain? Do you um want a bit more laid-back? You know, I Yeah, I can't imagine somebody not wanting to own both. But again, you surprised me. Um,
I do watch your channel. I I guess I've just I've never heard you talking about Cascadia for whatever reason. probably because I probably skipped whatever section of that video that was because well of course they're gonna say the same thing everybody says about Cascadia, you know. Well, Ernie is Jarus winner. But
boy, you heard it. You heard it and then you blocked it out so we could still be friends.
Yes.
Yeah. Yeah. Clearly they clearly misspoke. I misheard. Um that that couldn't be the case. Uh but yeah, I I I am really impressed by it. I really enjoyed it. But you know, I say that being a diehard for the longest time actually. Um, what was the other? There was another game that came out right around the same time as Cascadia. I can't think of what it is now that did a lot of the same stuff. Um, and I really enjoyed that one, but then once I got Landmarks and really started playing Cascadia a lot with that, I I never looked back. And I really enjoyed the uh rolling rights. I mean, they're not as good, but I love conveyor belts in games, you know, things moving and, you know, having, okay, I got to wait till the third round and then do it kind of stuff. Uh, yeah. I mean, the Cascadia series has just been fantastic. So, I can just say hats off to Randy Flynn um for making a beautiful, lovely, fast playing little game. And yeah, I hadn't thought about it, but you're right. I think the game I they're both 20 rounds, right? But this one feels so much faster. I don't know why.
Yes. Yes, it does. And not just because we only played half of it when we did our run through. You know, all the other games that we played, all the all the other games we played, I was just I felt like the pressure was on and I didn't feel that before, but you know, we haven't played with the expansion of the original, Granton. Um, but yeah, this one just straight out of the box
captivated me. So, you know, yeah, likewise, if you're watching and you haven't, you know, never connected with Cascadia, I'd urge you to try this one because it just it tickled my brain in a different way.
Yeah.
Yeah, very much so. While still being true to the original and still, you know, capturing the same vibe. It's really nice.
Um, yeah, maybe it was a bad idea to draw parallels to Ticket to Ride because the Ticket to Ride spin-offs are all, oh, there's just, oh, now there's tunnels. This is a this is a pretty sizable change um unlike tunnels in ticket ride Europe.
Yeah. Yeah. But the rules are not that different. Yeah. No, I was just gonna say but the rules the rules are not that different. When I was reading it, I didn't I was like okay. Yes. Very very Cascadiaesque, but when you play it, I did feel like it the little changes made a big difference. So, you'll be able to jump into it if you've played Cascadia really quickly.
The stakes feel higher, if you will. Higher, if you will. I apologize for that.
Oh my goodness.
Oh, we should have wrapped.
We're going to have to end on that. So, that lives in infamy.
You're welcome, everyone.
Okay. Well, it was good seeing you again and I look forward to seeing whatever you have next on your channel. I hope you're I know I know you've been going through a lot of stuff and and but you're you're starting to pick back up. I love your new shorter videos. I think those are great. Uh folks, if you don't know what I'm talking about, there's links down in the show notes. Um I mean, they are one of the best. why I love hanging out and chatting with you and having you on the channel. Uh, Thinker Themur has such a unique vibe that speaks, I think, to a lot of people and you are two of the best people I know. So, it was nice to chat and
it was also nice to get a win every once in a while.
Yeah. Well, thank you for having us. Lots of love to you both and my apologies to Jen. I will make it up to her. I'm so sorry.
Yep. Yep. Yep. She'll get over it somehow. Um, I'm I'm She's got plenty of wins under her belt in this caravan so far on this trip, so she can she can let me have one. Okay, well folks, that's it then. Um, thank you very much for watching. There's links down the notes if you want to go check out the crowdfunding page. Otherwise, have a very nice day. Talk to you later. So long. Bye-bye.
Bye. Bye.
Boop. Boop.