Ultimate Railroads | Review
Transcript
thank you hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and today I'm going to be reviewing ultimate railroads this is a giant compilation of all the games starting with Russian railroads including all the expansions published by z-man games and designed by helmets only and Leonard ergler alright so here is a game of Russian railroads all set up for solo so there are a bunch of different expansions in the box but Russian railroads is the original it's the simplest version of the game so that's the one I chose to set up and I recommend that if you do play this that you start with just plain old Russian railroads and it is great just in its base form but this is set up for solo and if you've never played Russian railroads before at all basically what you're doing is you are playing work replacement game where you are going to advance your tracks and there are different tracks that you can advance you're going to power your locomotives so you can go further down those tracks and then you're also going to push up this industry track so when you get locomotives if you flip them to the other side there are also factories so you're able to get yourself little bonuses along the way depending on whether you use the locomotive to power your train further down the track or flip it over to a factory side put it in your industry and get the bonuses that are on those tiles but what makes the game interesting is that you have to advance certain kinds of track and then upgrade so you have this Bass track that's not really worth any points but you have to advance it out to certain distances along this
Railroad in order to unlock the tracks that do score you something so for example here this plain neutral code track if you get it to space two you unlock your greens which are worth some points so if you look here when you score greens are worth one point per track they're out this copper colors were two silver four and then the fancy big gold one is seven but you have to get all the way out here and then also be advancing that track and then of course building the track is enough you do actually have to run trains on it so you start with just this one little locomotive but then you have to purchase higher value ones as the game goes on and then I don't know why a meal ended up here but we're gonna talk about him in a moment if you look at the spaces on this board uh basically these are just different spots you can go to to try to achieve those goals so if you want to advance tracks you come here if you want to get locomotives or factories you'll come here if you want to advance your industry track and score for it you come here and then these are doublers that increase the value of the spaces scored on this top track you score at the end of every round and your first score is always going to be kind of puny but by the end of six rounds your score is huge the way that you track rounds is with these Engineers who are also cool because when you purchase them which you can purchase one per turn they give you some pretty sweet bonuses including victory points just your own personal action in general is great and they give you cheaper and better ways to advance your tracks so the engineers are also pretty awesome and worth considering and Energy Adventure tracks you'll notice there's a whole bunch of different little bonuses that pop up you can get extra workers these little
tokens here are basically rewards where you can pick one and then place it here to show that you've got that reward and then this is a special scoring bonus there are also keys on here that when reached allow you to perform a special action which is detailed here in the middle of the board this game is a relatively simple game but at the same time it's brutal because you're gonna be fighting over spaces on the board and in a multiplayer game of Russian railroads I can get absolutely vicious in a really good way if you're playing solo what happens is that you play against a meal who is an automated opponent who doesn't actually score points or do anything in particular except block spaces so when you are playing the solo version of Russian railroads and or any of his expansions you're using Emil's deck you're setting up the same way basically every time you give them some workers you put some workers here for when you hit certain scoring thresholds because when you do he will and so Emil has no real resource management or anything just the cards that he will use to block off spaces one of the rules in fact for using a meal is that he can only go to spaces where he will block you so if he draws a space that you can't even do anything with yet um you're supposed to skip that card and keep going until you can get something he'll do that's actually irritating because the space you had access to so for example here if we flip this card over we see that this is the pay two workers to move three green tracks so if we have access to Green tracks then he will come over here and block us from moving them even though he's not going to move any tracks himself and on his turn you'll just keep working through his deck so for example if I've already gone to this space then
he'll skip this and draw another card until he goes somewhere that is actually irritating to me and that's basically how a meal Works he's very very simple um not at all in difficult AI to run and he's really just there to allow you to play this game against yourself because it's your high score that's going to count for the most every time so that's a very very basic overview of Russian railroads and if you want to add more from the expansions that's entirely possible so German railroads gives you some more track options there's like a coal expansion that adds a different kind of action to the game the American version has stock markets and then the Asian railroads lets you get these crazy high scores with some of the stuff that they add into that module so that's my brief overview let's go ahead and go into some final thoughts all right so now for some final thoughts when I saw ultimate railroads in the store I bought it immediately I wanted it so bad I've played Russian railroad it's a game night and I loved it I really really love this game in groups um and so I could not wait to get my hands on so I could sell it at home and try all the expansions like my excitement for this was big and I'm just gonna be blunt maybe it shouldn't have been and it's not because the game itself isn't great I absolutely stand by my opinion that Russian railroads is awesome and um you know it's really just great to play with other people with other people it's very dramatic all work Replacements seem extremely important moment to moment um you know the competition is really Fierce it's a very intense game to play
and so I really like this game with other people I did not like the solo and honestly a lot of that is probably that times have changed solo modes have really changed I looked up German railroads and it was released in 2015 and they were pretty good solo games around at that time but you know not all games with solo modes were to the standards that I think a lot of solo Gamers have now so the Emile deck is not terrible it's simple to operate but basically a meal blocks spaces without scoring any points so you're really just competing against yourself every time and a meal is just kind of a lackluster opponent especially you know if you just have to keep going through the deck until there's something a meal can do because maybe taking up a lot of spaces already or you know you just keep drawing stuff that you know doesn't really apply to that moment you know dealing with a meal is a mixture of like easy and tedious and I never really felt any tension when I was playing solo ultimate railroads all the real thrill and snap that comes from the game and my experience has come from playing it with other people and it's fun to try to generate a high score but it's way more fun to do that when you are fighting with somebody else like the AI in this particular game just doesn't put up enough of a fight for me and you know makes too many decisions that are either a little too perfect or totally not depending on you know just the random draw of the deck so even your high scores aren't really about how skillful you played necessarily once you get to a certain
level in the game it's more about just oh how optimally did a meal play and if you are kind of in that space then it's just it's just not as good it's just not as good and I think they're much much better solo modes for for Euro games for work replacement games coming out in like our more modern era of 2022 um then we're available in 2015 so you can't really like blame that solo mode for being what it is in its time but I also think that maybe for this reprint it would have been wise to think a little harder about it instead of just reprint it straight up and just throw it out there into the world and like there are some other issues that I had with this particular Edition um there were some issues in the rule book with its printing where you could tell the typing was sloppy uh some of the changes that were made from the original Russian railroads I thought were aesthetically displeasing so the base black track markers that you use to lay track are now replaced like a neutral color and then the gray ones are replaced with green and it was just super mind bending and weird to adjust to in a way that I didn't really think was necessary I didn't like frankly so I guess what it boils down to is like I went and blew 110 bucks on on this game of my personal money because I wanted it so bad to play this solo and I regret that choice I mean no regrets rights or regrets or regrets I'm just gonna you know turn into Channel fodder and like move on with my life but the solo I found was
just never a solo that I'm gonna pick first this game is wonderful with a group but there are other people in my gaming group who have it so I'm probably going to offload my copy of ultimate railroads at some point in the future and that breaks my heart because I really really like the game itself and I'm down to play at any time but also Russian railroads is on BGA and they're people in my group who have this game it's a huge you know box and the solo just for me wasn't really that good so that's where I'm personally at on it I'm sure there are people who disagree with me but hey it's my channel you want in my opinion there you go so I'm I'm really sorry that I ended up not liking this one very much um I think that you know this is just a I guess a consequence of you know times changing and expectations of solo modes being higher I think that if I'd played this solo mode in 2016 when I was first getting really serious about solo games it would have seemed really fresh and now it doesn't so you know your mileage may vary um if you have a game group to play with I actually really really recommend this game still because it's fantastic as a game but the solo is pretty lackluster um or at least that's how I feel about it so thank you so much for watching please like subscribe comment support me on patreon if you're feeling extra generous and most of all happy gaming
thank you foreign