Raiders of the North Sea: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocking today I'm doing a no run-through review for Raiders of the North Sea so caveat before get into this and before I give my opinions and you guys probably hate me I have now played this game with any of the expansions so this is just base game as it is nothing extra but I know what the expansions do so Raiders of the North Sea is kind of I'm kind of on a mixed mixed you know mixed bag mixed feelings I have mixed feelings about it because it does a lot of things that I really like in a work replacement and then others that I don't like so as per in my discussions let's talk about things that I don't like in Raiders of the North Sea you are basically obviously pillaging Vikings trying to just you just get a point to get a bunch of points well in this game you it doesn't it does a really interesting mechanic of worker placement that I want in a bunch of other yeah worker placements this is where I'm getting that mixed feeling so what I don't like about this game there are two things one is the biggest one it's the fact that the resources that are available on the on the board not the Valkyrie but the the gold the the iron and the the cattle
are limited and what I mean by that is like when you raid or when you pillage you have to have a certain number of crew which is fine if they have a certain number of uh provisions which is also fine um and once you do that you go there you grab all the stuff there and now you have that okay so that's that's all fine and dandy but except if if people are happen to go into the spot that have all the stone like or they're going to the stone and you don't really realize that you that oh hey I don't have any stone you can't really get any now there are very few cuckoo cards that allow you to grab resources from the supplier from the discard area but you have to be lucky enough to get those so it's like whenever you are because there was there is no limit to those resources you could only have there's a rule of eight you only have eight cards eight coins and eight provisions plunder which are the resource I just I just mentioned the gold the stone or the yeah the gold the iron then the in the cattle one person can hoard all of that the entire game they're not gonna because others unless others aren't just you know pillaging which is the whole point the game like they're gonna hold on to that and what sucks about that is within the town the only action that you can really do there's actions to do cattle which allow you to turn in for uh oh I can't remote
they call but basically their endgame points or you can use stone a game in that stone iron to increase your total strength like there's there's a track that you turn those in or you can turn in two coins to increase by one but if you turn into iron or one iron you increase it by two it's like okay so if you happen to knock at any iron the entire game which yes you could argue well that's just your fault but except there's definitely better places that others could get you before you bill comment grab more the place with the most iron because the way the places to plunder work the resources that are there are all different so it can be thrown out evenly it can be spread out hey this one spot has a bunch of iron and someone's gonna go there before you because turn order doesn't change so if you're going last you're kind of screwed because oh you all were able to pull it pillage before me I just have to sit back and watch it's not like okay I go you go you go you go okay now it's you know your first player and then he goes around Oh your first player it doesn't do that you just continue around the board so that was a big problem for me and it's not really the fact that yes someone can hoard all that it's the fact that there's no way to exchange for those resources I can't go to a spot in the village that says Oh turnin you know three cattle for Gold or turn in to silver for an iron there's none of that all the resources you get the only way to do is like 90
and then there's a spot for the silversmith which you just go there with a pawn or with a worker and get silver like it's it's like what why can't I do that with the other resources why can't I go there and get I mean there's a fight you can chest card to cards to get a gold why is iron so difficult to get even though that's what increases your your strength which helps you you know defeat the later on um so that was kind of kind of a you know a pain for me like I didn't like the fact that there was really no variety in the fact that resource resources which are in a lot of other work replacements the second thing about this game is I feel like as the base game it gets very se me meaning cuz like there's three well there's there's four different places to to pillage the very first thing that everyone's gonna get to do is the harbor because what's really cool and this was the thing I do like about the game so I'm kind of changing it is there are three different types of workers there's a black worker a grey worker and a white worker and they all do different things kind of so if you go to the silversmiths with a black work that you get three silver if you go there with a white or a grey worker you get two silvers so depending on where you go you need a specific type of worker to read more benefits but later on so only the black workers can go to the harbor which is what everyone starts with so obviously everyone has to go there then once you go there you take
as the the pillager spots have given to grey workers and white workers then once you take that worker and then you because whoever you pillage with they stay there so eventually all black workers will be gone and then they'll be replaced with gray then you know gray and white workers will kind of intermingle and then yeah eventually it'll kind of lead to just white workers so once everyone does the harbor then they're able to go up to the I think was outposts and temples and then fortresses in for says were the hardest once again they're the ones that give you the most points not any more resources or anything like that but they just give you more points for successfully rating them but since you have to go in this progression of okay because you can't skip it's like now I'm not gonna do the harbor I must save up and wait to go to well I guess you technically could it wouldn't be in your best interest though because you could technically just save up and do all this stuff any wait for someone else to do a harbor and then grab the white worker and then you know aha okay now I can go or gray work or whatever then you can just jump ahead but in all reality you're gonna be going Harbor outposts you know temples then for tree like it's going to go in that progression and that's the way the kind of board is laid out as well is in this series of you're gonna go this way everyone's gonna go this way and that's that and that to me is incredibly boring to be like well Oh
yep everyone goes for the harbor again oh yeah like there's once you've played the game you know I would say two maybe three times you're like okay that's that that's the game forever and that's just the base game like like I want to reiterate that because you might will the expansions do this and it's like that's fine I'll get to that in a sec those were my two biggest complaints about this game now maybe a third one that turn order actually is a factor because you do get all your points from raiding what I really really like about this game and this is kind of where you'll have to judge because it is kind of more of a gateway work the placement they do this really interesting work of mechanic is that when you place the worker everyone starts with a black worker when you place a worker you do that action of the spot then you take a worker from some other building and you pull that off and you do the action of that spot as well so you're doing two actions but you're you're placing and taking and doing these actions and that will that is that is so cool and strategic because one you can't take something you can't play someone then take them on the same turn so what you're doing is you're essentially blocked not really blocking because you don't really block people like most work replacement sort I'm gonna go there haha no you can't go there until we all recall our workers nope it's like okay we'll find you place
someone there then I will just pull them off there and still do the same action so if I went to the silversmith I get three silver then I can take off of the what's the other one the the longhouse and you do an action there
and then it's you you don't block anyone now it does lead to some interesting combinations because there are times where it's like someone will take off the spot before you and you're like well crap I really wanted to place something there and then pull off somewhere else or or if there are two spaces you want to go to but there's there was a worker there and now both of them don't have a worker it's like well crap I can't place them in place again I have to place one of them and take somewhere else so it's very interesting and whenever I mentioned ok you could hold off on JIT on doing the same harbour anyway it's because if someone has a white worker they have to leave it at some point they will have to put a gray worker down then take somewhere else so now if you're after them you can take the gray worker or you can place your black worker somewhere and pull the gray worker now you have a great worker to be like oh now I can go an attacking outpost because it requires a grey worker I think that is insanely smart it's insanely intuitive because I don't know of any worker placement does some other work replacements like charter stone for example they do a bump mechanic which was interesting and new it was like oh ok no there's no blocking each other like at all we can all go to the same spot but if I go to a spot that you're at you get your worker back and you might have been ready to recall so it's like how much do I want to go there to give you an extra turn that's how you make work replacement stuff interesting I mean there's nothing wrong with ok I'm gonna go here and then you know we can
go there then we're all gonna place our workers then we're all going to recall let's donate something like that nothing wrong with that but that can get stale after a while Raiders of the North Sea made that you know place take thing really cool and I like that a lot the vidi culture did something different where they had a Grande worker was like standard work replacement for your Grande can go anywhere and that's kind of it's like it's made people think how how could we make what work replacements different so Raiders of the North Sea is kind of a you know generic Viking game find out my friend was like man you must hate Viking games because I give him crap about not liking champions of Midgard grand I've only play that game at two players I'm sure I would like it with more but this one we were all like hmm I mean yeah okay yeah you uh you did that but there's other things in here that I do like there are I mentioned the three plunder which were you know gold iron and and cavil which were used for different different purposes but there's a fourth one which are called Valkyrie and there are these black circles essentially whenever you go so you have to hire crew which comes from a deck of crew cards and the art is fantastic we really like the are is very bright very pretty component-wise everything is great the game the base game came with metal coins which i thought was amazing because not most games like last one i thought that wasn't a Kickstarter game was rattle battle grab the loot which came with metal coins so I thought that was
awesome but so you have a deck of crew cards which have unique abilities and they also have strengths and stuff like that and you have to hire them which with the silver I and I really like that so you would hire them based off a spot you can go and you'd have your crew and whenever you because you need a certain number of crew and provisions to go to attack a spot and then you discard the provisions and your crew has a certain number of strengths and abilities and the crew actually has two abilities one is kind of like if you have them like in your crew some of them like hey get an extra point for attacking a harbor they have a secondary ability which is if you go to I think it's like the Town Hall where you discard them and you use their secondary ability which is like take a provision from some other player or or that's something that's just one of them and I thought that was interesting you had the variety with the different crew crew members um but whenever you go in and raid a spot if it has a Valkyrie token you have to kill off one of your crew and some of them yeah what some of them were like if this dies in a raid put it back into your hand or if this dies another player has to kill one of their crew and stuff like that so I thought that was pretty interesting and then if you whenever you took a Valkyrie you went up on the Valkyrie track and this was another way you can get a bunch of points so and there's a limited excuse me number of Valkyrie on the board and that's actually an endgame condition is
that if all the Valkyries are gone I finished off the round and then in then that's the game but if you have more crude I go up this track and I think if you do seven if you're if you happen to kill all the Valkyrie then you'll get like an extra 15 points at the end of the game which is a lot cuz like there isn't there are a bunch of points to get but it's not like incremental like it's not like everyone's getting 15 points that is a lot at endgame and then obviously your your armor rating will will give you a few points up but not as much as 15 now granted there's a risk reward because you have to kill off a crew member so it kind of in my field you might push you back a little bit but move you up for endgame so I there is a race to kind of get those Valkyries killed because if me and another person we were both going for that victory condition I just happen to be able to go before him and have the stuff to raid a spot that had to Valkyrie which killed to my people but I jumped up twice and he wasn't able to do that so raids are pretty interesting I kind of like it it's very simple like I mentioned crew provisions and then they have a strength number which some of them will say hey roll two dice and the dice range from two to five so you have your crew numbers a top left you have your strength you add your whatever shield or armor bonuses from that you've raised with iron that no one is able to get and then you roll dice okay and so let's it let's say you roll really well you roll to five so you add
ten let's say you had 20 total 23 because you have three armor and then the ten so you have thirty three you look at that spot that you attacked and this is something I really like and it's like okay if you got 15 you get six points if you got 22 or higher you get ten points and that's kind of how how that works so how well you raided you got more points for it I did really like that like this isn't a bad worker placement game by any means this was I felt it was kind of lackluster because people like her like this worker placement game ever and I disagree I mean I was able to look at my collection and think of multiple work replacement games I'd rather play than this one now I looked up the expansions of what the expansions did and I will say if I have the expansions this game would probably be fantastic one adds like a mead hall and stuff like that and go and you go on quests for people which allow you to get you know another way to get resources another way to get points that expansion alone I think would fix the negatives I have here but as you guys know if you've watched this channel enough you know I don't think expansions should fix a game like it's not like and granite that's just fixing it for me so it's like some people may think this is great and these fences are just more but it's like for me my problems are fixed by an expansion and it's like I have to spend more money to be able to enjoy your game initially I don't want to do
that now Nessus one expansion they have there's two and the other that just it adds like I think it adds urals and like another way to raid so though both of those expansions which give you more points by the way with the URLs and stuff like that those two expansions plus lists I think would make the game like more gamer II and and open it up a lot more where one poor person can't hoard all the iron it's like okay fine you keep raiding whatever and getting that stuff I'm gonna do these quests and be able to get the same resources that I need granddad's are still no exchanging that I know of but at least you're not hosed by just turn order and oh I got I was gonna go there and get the iron but you went there now I can't do it so um that's pretty much it if I had to so on the scale of one to ten the base game alone I'm gonna give a six point five so not quite a seven because I'm not keeping this game in my collection because I have a bunch of other work replacements I'd rather play verses that won't get stale after after a couple plays I don't have to buy expansions to make to make them better so a 6.5 it's a little bit above average I think that with the the place take mechanic I think that that is amazing that's probably why it's not just an average work replacement for me everything else is
pretty generic but I really do like that that work or mechanic so six point five out of ten let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like home a share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you liked this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and write nice to that subscribe button it's a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day of this for you