A Feast For Odin Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at a feast for odin which is a board game dating back to 2016. this one accommodates one to four players and takes around two hours to play so this is by very prolific designer uve rosenberg who is known for his farming kind of simulators and this one is a massive sprawling game that's got a lot going on in more ways than one so please do not use this video as a rules tutorial or anything like that because no doubt we'll be making some rules mistakes along the way but before i get into my review for a feast for odin i just want to give a shout out to kianda dot co uk who are my go-to online retailer in the uk we can get some great games at some great prices but let's get started on a feast for odin okay so a feast for odin is a worker placement and title placement style game with a hell of a lot going on here and a hell of a lot of table presents so let's just talk about all the different things you'll see throughout the video so you've got your individual player board here which is kind of unique to you as a specific player which holds all your different workers on them and it holds your little banquet table here which is going to be used to feed workers throughout the game and because the more people you have put on the board the more people you're going to have to feed so it has this nagging tension we have to fill up these spots with different food you've got your main kind of play area here as well which you're going to use to place tiles on um not only to gain more income because if you build these towers in a certain direction if you expose a certain amount of income then you can get that much money you've also got resources on here as well if you cover these perfectly or surround them then you get that income in terms of rewards or resources and you've also got all these spots here with minus one on them as you can see
which means that if those aren't covered at the end of the game then for each of those exposed you're going to suffer a negative point which is obviously not a good thing you've got some space here to put boats on you've got some space here to put your live stock on each player is going to have a bunch of weapons as well that you can acquire throughout the game and these bonus cards as well and you've got the main worker placement board here which has a ton of different spots on here so as you can see it's quite overwhelming um a lot of different symbology different things but i will say um as it's broken down it's not as bad as it initially looks but we'll talk about that in just a second and you've got your resources here so you've got your word your stone your your metal and your coins you've got these resource strips which is going to be used to acquire these resources where you can only take them from left to right but they do get kind of um depleted as the game goes on and more of these strips come out and we've got kind of a boat market here where you can choose to buy boats if you don't want to build them by using worker placement spots and you've got these additional tiles as well these different um islands that you can acquire which will again give you more potential to get more income and more resources and more points and you've got a ton of different resources here that come in these um trays actually come in the base box so um they're kind of broken into different tiers you've got your um in fact i've got these upside down so if you have a look here you've got your real basic kind of food resources here with these orange tokens and then the next one up you've got the red tokens then you've got the green tokens and ultimately the blue tokens and they are double-sided so and they kind of show the different rareness of the different items and that not only goes upwards in
the tears but also goes from left to right in their size and of course bigger is generally better because you can fill up your boards i'm a lot quicker and try to cover up all those negative points and you've also got a deck of weapon cards which you can acquire each round and you've got these different cards that you can acquire as well to give you bonuses you've got a pair of dice here as well um you've got i think it's a d8 and a d12 i've got this little kind of blacksmith board here which you can get these weird and wonderful different tiles to cover things up in weird shapes and you've also got these additional buildings and farms that you can give you different points in different ways so that pretty much covers all the different components let's talk about the actual gameplay and so the game is going to be broken into 12 phases and a number of rounds depending on the mode you've pl you've chosen so this one here shows the short game which only plays over six rounds or you can play the um the more advanced version or the full game which plays over seven rounds but the only thing is it's a bit quicker um so the first thing you're gonna do is you're gonna take take a new viking and add it to your pool of vikings to use this turn so like that for example and this is gonna show or expose a new block here which can be a bit of a problem because it means that you need more food to fill up your banquet table and then you're going to do a harvest which means that you can take a number of different tiles um depending on the round it's on so in the early rounds you're only going to take number one harvest tiles and then as a game goes on you can potentially get the ones up to threes which will give you more to play with me meaning that you have to spend fewer workers in order to acquire the food to feed your vikings and you've got the um
expedition boards here um which will get refreshed every few rounds and they do actually acquire these um this money on them meaning they're not the longer that they are neglected and they're going to start building income on them which means when people take them they also get the money on them um you've got the draw a new weapon phase which is simple as it sounds you just draw a weapon from the top of the deck here and you've got different types of weapons you've got bows and arrows and you've got spears you've got um swords as well and you've also got traps um you've got then you've got the main action face which you're going to be using to deploy your workers on the board which i'll talk about in a little bit and you've got the determined start player and then you've got income and you've got the animal breeding because some of these spots allow you to take sheep and cows when you take your sheep and cows you're going to end up putting them in your little pen here on your player board so let's just say i had these two sheep here like this when it comes to a breeding phase because i've got two non-pregnant sheep they will actually give birth to um first off so they become pregnant like so and when it comes to the next round and the pregnant sheep will actually give birth to another sheep so these do actually multiply on each other naturally as time progresses and the same applies to the cows and they'll give you points accordingly and then you've got the feast which is when you're going to need to fill this banquet table up of the different of the different foods so i could like do this for example put the fish on there and then i could maybe fill it up with some peas like so all trying to fill up these gaps
here however you can only ever put one um one vertically of each color so you don't want to maybe waste the fish by going up like this because it's not going to be as efficient and as you can see here all these different kind of grids have different restrictions on them so this one shows that i can put orange and red tiles on them and look and also put coal on them so the coins on them as well however the oranges can't touch oranges and reds can't touch reds and just like on this one here i can put on the greens and the blues blues can touch each other the greens can touch corner to corner but can't can't touch flush um you can cover things up with coins and so on so again all these different things have different restrictions which you need to abide by and then you're going to take your bonuses which means that you are going to get any resources depending on what you've covered so again if i've surrounded this block here then i'll get one of these as a free income and then you're going to update and add new mountain strips which means that basically all the left side resource is going to get taken off these boards here and then a new board is going to come on with filled up with resources so that you've got different selection because when you take resources you can only take from left to right and you can't go straight in to the money for example and then finally you're going to remove all your workers and get ready for the new round but i suppose the main bulk of the game is going to be the action phase which correlates to this bit here so let's talk about all the different workers worker placement actions so obviously i'm not going to go into every single spot individually i'll just
give a general overview consensus so basically these are divided into four different columns you've got the one worker column here two workers three workers and four workers so in order to go to these more powerful spots on the right hand side i'm gonna have to spend a massive four workers to do so which is obviously quite a big portion of my workforce however when you do these further um two right actions here so you've got the three or the four workers you're either going to draw one of the bonus cards or actually get to play a bonus card and they're gonna let you do lots of different things give you instant rewards give you different things you can do throughout the game like for example my starting card here means that and when it comes to the income phase i can choose to spend one of these if i have one of these tiles and if i do so i'll get a coin for doing so and there is a hell of a lot of different cards in this game this is not even half of them as you can probably imagine there is a ton of variety there so going through them is just not going to be an option for a video like this but but let's talk about all the different actual events all the different spots themselves so you've got the ones here that let you spend resources to get these new tiles and which again will give you victory points and hopefully you can cover up those negative spots to kind of bypass any forfeits you have to do you've got ones here that let you build boats so either one boat so one of the little boats here for one word or maybe the bigger boats for for more workers and two would and you can do ones like this as well which let you you know build all the different things as well you've got the hunting spots here which is kind of a big part of the game which uses the weapons and the dice so again you can use one two three or four workers for doing so which let you get
all these kind of different whale meat or you can get the um you know all the different kind of pelts as well which you can put on your play boards cover things up and the way the combat works is basically used on die rolls so you're going to try and get to or in this particular spot you're going to try to get to zero and by doing that you're going to roll the relative die so you can either roll the d12 or the d8 when you roll it and you're going to have the opportunity to roll up to three times trying to get as low as you can however you can mitigate things further by spending additional weapons or or resources so if i wanted to use this hunting one here and i rolled a two if i got rid of two bow and arrows i'll say a bow an hour and a wood i could actually take that down to a zero and make that a successful hunt and get the corresponding resources which of course could be used to fill up my board or even feed my banquet table i'm however if i do fail a hunt i actually get these as compensation so i get a um an arrow or a wood or in fact both of those as compensation and even when you get to the more bigger spots here you can actually take more workers back um back to use again so that you aren't suffering such a penalty for not having a successful role so despite being quite a significant luck factor in terms of you know just die rolling and i'm top decking cards off the off the top of the deck and you do actually get compensated to build towards your next hunt if it doesn't go so well and you've got the livestock ones here which will let you again kind of buy sheep and cows um with ones that will let you buy fish by spending money or dip buy different meats um once here they let you buy one
of each and you've got the market here which actually buy just like produce and stuff so you can feed your vikings um you've got the ones here that let you milk your cows um ones that get you you get um get wool from your sheep um and so once you've got ones here that you convert goods into other goods and maybe you can convert like uh fabrics into clothing which again will give you a lot more coverage of your player boards you've got the ones here that let you convert this metal into building these specific items as well so if you take this particular action then you can get one of these and add it to your player board which will be a lot more kind of specific on where you can fit them and what shapes you can cover et cetera um so they're a lot more kind of flexible than what you can do um you've got uh ones here again that convert kind of fabrics into cloth or kind of smaller bits of metal into bigger more elaborate pieces you've got straight up taking resources where you can take resources from the from the action scripts here always abiding to that left to right method and you've got upgrading um spots which when you get these upward arrows you are essentially choosing to upgrade resources so i could say i had one of these tiles here i could upgrade that to the one above it and take one of the fish instead and to replace it with so these are really good for kind of cycling through the different goods and getting better and better upgrades or you can even do ones like this will let you upgrade the same thing twice to um to really kind of um up its value and you've got ones here the raiding so the raiding and pillaging
basically work very similar to the hunting except you're trying to get as high number as you can again by rolling the dice and boosting it with swords or stones and other other things when you do that you are looking at the value here and trying and you know if you reach or exceed that value then you can add that particular token to your player board to fill things up um and then you've got the um once that you buy the buildings um all the different islands here i'm going to give you more opportunity to place things and fill things up and you've got ones here that you draw cards and play cards and things like that so as you can see you've got a lot of different options there on the work placement board okay so i don't want to go too much further on the rules themselves and want to get into the actual review and my thoughts on the game because i suppose that's what you're here for um so first off as you can tell this game is incredibly wide there is a ton you can do and this was one of the things that i was the most apprehensive about because normally with worker placement games and there are a few exceptions um i like games to be relatively tight so that if people go to a certain spot then the tension and the the kind of race aspect to get to that spot is a lot stronger whereas in this one if somebody takes a certain spot then the chances are that you can go pretty much anywhere else and still have good options to uh to fight for so again that's a double-edged sword here because it does give you a plethora of different paths to victory and different things to try um however some of the tension is certainly taken out in my perspective um because again the game is so loose and it is so wide um i will
say that i do like some of the gameplay elements in terms of um the guitar placement because um this is the i think actually i think this is a really good part of the design is that you can actually choose to uh kind of manipulate and move your tiles whenever you like i'm obviously not one of the place on the board locked in but um you're not kind of constrained to a particular round or phase or an action spot in order to place things onto your player board you can do that whenever you like which keeps the game moving along a lot nicer pace and makes it feel a bit freer and i think that certainly does help the game rather than feeling so rigid and having to go to a particular spot to do that so i do think that's pretty well done um there are some things here that i do think are quite unnecessary though so for example i'm not quite sure why the resource market has to be like this in terms of taking resources from the left to right i understand that the rare resources are to you know are to the right here and you might have to wait a bit longer to get to them um however because the game is so wide and there's so much going on that i'm not sure if things like this really help the game at all some disconnect in terms of it being such a heavy involved and um meaty game that a lot of things do come down to top decking you know you do um basically just draw a card of the weapon deck every round and if it's not the weapon you want then you know that's not the best thing you might have to waste some workers and knowing that you're going to lose one of these hunts to get the compensation reward which sometimes feels feels a little bit um unsatisfying and also i think that some of the cards are you know there's such a wide diverse amount of cards here there's absolutely
hundreds of them sometimes they're going to work for you sometimes they're not going to work for you and it all comes back to top decking off that card when you take a particular action so again there's a little bit of a disconnect at times for me when it when some of the randomness is used and i do understand that the designer wants to add that that sense of adventure into the game and that little bit of excitement but for me it just has again that little bit of a disconnect i do think some game things in this game are done really well particularly i like the the animal breeding i think this is quite a cool strategy to go for and i like the way that as time progresses if you have non-pregnant animals they're going to keep breeding and breeding and breeding and that can be a nice kind of place to go to and of course it's going to be correlating actions on the board in order to again to use those to advantage by getting milk or bugging wool etcetera and this is kind of one of the things here there are so many different paths of victory so many different things to try and it almost feels like there's more games or kind of like several games here almost sewn together rather than being so harmoniously intertwined because again i'm obviously this is a massively wide game but i'm not sure that the depth to width ratio is quite there um you know you you do have to pick and choose what you're going to do from round to round and that kind of ties back to this sandbox nature of the game and this sandbox nature is one of the most polarizing things about me for this game because i know a lot of people will love it because again there are so many different things to try each time you play the game you can try something different and go for a completely different strategy however for me it leaves me feeling a
bit kind of aimless and a bit goalless and i it doesn't just quite connect right when i'm when i'm kind of neglecting a whole portion of the game in order to do what i'm doing and it just feels a bit weird for me and most of the games i play don't have that element to them so i'm not saying it's a bad thing i'm just thinking it's just very different to what i'm used to playing and without having at least a little bit of guidance and something to fight for um then i i do feel a little bit lost at times and certainly the first time i played this one i did feel like you know where the hell do i start here what do i do where do i start you know what am i building towards and um it's going to take a few plays to get your head around that in order to understand how everything kind of works together and what the kind of end game payoff is going to be now obviously despite being so massive in scope and things to try i will say that once you do get the rules down and have it explained to you or do the explaining yourself the gameplay does work surprisingly smoothly or it's not actually too complicated in its actual gameplay uh yeah there are a lot of different phases here but most of them are very relatively simple you know just take a new viking i'm going to take your resources for the round so they are actually pretty simple and the actual gameplay and flow doesn't have too much rules minutiae and too much fiddliness um because again everything in their own right is relatively simple but it's just that width and kind of um you know that initial that initial kind of uh rules haul can be a bit a bit much and it's going to be a long teach and you know if you haven't played it before and you're teaching it to all new people then it's going to be you know pretty good half an hour teach but
once you have got the rules down it does actually work surprisingly smoothly and it certainly isn't too fiddly i do think there's a good forward momentum in the game where each round you get a new viking and add it to your to your pool to use but that is kind of a double-edged sword because as you place more workers down you're going to create more gaps and of course these are going to get wiped and you're going to have to feed all your workers again each round which to be honest is something i'm not too keen on i generally um don't mind these kind of pressures in these type of games where you have to feed your workforce but in this one i don't really feel like it added much at all something i will say that i did like was the fact that some work replacement spots would allow you to convert boats into these um these tokens here like so which will not only give you victory points but mean that you don't have to feed those vikings anymore so i did like that touch and i thought that was quite a cool um a cool element to the game but yeah that was kind of another wrinkle to the game that i thought would could have been taken out and i didn't really add much to the fun or to the ultimate experience so i'll just quickly go through some of the talking points of my review so um meaningful decision-wise there is a ton to do here and everything is going to kind of mean something and going to contribute to you know you being good at this game or not so um i do like the way that you have to weigh up how you're going to use the polymer tiles you know are you going to take the income are you going to take the resources are you going to actually bite off more you can chew by taking more and more spots here and hopefully you can cover them up um are you gonna try and just completely clear up all these negative spots straight up so yeah there's a lot you can do here and it adds a hell of a lot of depth to a
a lot of kind of meat around a very simple polyamino style game and the fact that this is so meaty and it has so much going on but the actual one of the crux of the um you know of the game is polyominos is quite different and there certainly is a change of pace so yeah meaningful decision-wise there's a hell of a lot to do tons of different paths of victory and um it certainly is on the heavier end of the spectrum not only in terms of rules but in terms of decisions as well um the balance um despite the things being so well um you know diversified lots of different things to try i think the game is really well balanced i couldn't really see a particularly strong or you know um overpowered path to victory it seemed like everything you got to you got a fair shot of um of winning you know depending on which route you take um so yeah i've got no real issues with the balancing the game or anything like that you know i haven't played this a ton of times and this is kind of more of an initial impressions review but yeah so you know i don't have an issue with the balancing or anything like that um time investment i do think the game goes on a bit too long um i have played this solo and it still does seats you know it does feel like it takes too long even for that play account um i don't really find myself being gripped um particularly that goes for that kind of mid-game lull um i i wasn't really overly um enthused by how long the game takes you like i said the game box does say it takes up to two hours i think that might be a little bit generous and um it'll probably take a bit longer than that if you're looking at a three or four play account particularly if you're playing with people who haven't played the game um before uptime is generally okay because you can
do a lot of this stuff in the admin when it is another player's turn and i will say that i do um you know despite having a ton of workers at times you can feel like you've got a hell of a lot of workers to get through bear in mind that some of these spots do actually require four vikings so you can't get through that workforce pretty quickly and um you don't have as many options as you might think and when you do have a whole army of vikings at your disposal at the start of the round um replayability yeah there's a ton to do here um again so many different strategies you're not even going to scratch the surface in your first couple of plays however i will say that for me um once that sense of discovery was done like to see what all the different work replacement spots do and how they link together then i will say that the enjoyment factor does start to diminish quite quickly so for me a lot of part of the game like this and the fun to be had for a game like this lies in that sense of discovery on what you can do and trying things out where i think once that's done and out of my system i don't really have a massive urge to go back to it and explore much further um interaction yeah it's kind of again a double-edged sword because despite having a ton of workers um relating to a huge worker placement board it does feel like it is a bit too loose and you don't really think you know if people grab a spot you're not devastated and um you know taking first player and being first player isn't as big of a factor as there as it is with a lot of other work replacement games you have got a a good spot that you can go to as a kind of backup and you've got lots
of plan b's you can go for if your planner it goes off the rails so again i think a lot of the tension and the player interaction is um is taken out of the game because it is so wide with so many options um aesthetically i think the game looks fine i've got no issue at all with the production or anything like that all the resources are good quality and all the iconography is generally good considering how much of it there is um so yeah i've got no real issue with the production i think the fact that the game comes with these um trays to aid with the setup et cetera is um it's a really good bonus so i've got no criticisms there with the production or artwork i'm generally happy with the way everything is put together from a physical um perspective and the setup and teardown time um just again despite being so huge it's not actually that bad um because again you do have these trays and stuff um yeah it's going to be longer than average which you'd expect with a game of this magnitude um so yeah it's not the best nintendo set up but it's not probably not as bad as it initially looks either so final thoughts on a feast for odin so this is a really strange game to review because while i can completely appreciate its design um it's scope it's kind of um just ambition and what it does um i will say that i don't think the game is for me personally um because again i like the tension of a worker placement game to be a bit tighter um i think there's there's a bit too much going on for me and while i again i do like the way that some of these things intermesh with each other i do think it's a lot wider than it is deep and i'm not sure that that actually
helps the game as much as i would have liked it to and i do think a good kind of 30 of this game could have been shaved off and you could probably still have pretty much the exact same experience i'm coming off the back of it and now i know that's going to be somewhat of a controversial thing to say because i know this is an immensely popular game and i i certainly don't want this to sound like a negative review because i did enjoy my games of east road i think it's a really solid work replacement game some good uh interesting ideas here however is it going to be for me um i again i don't think so because i do tend to like games being a bit more self-contained being a bit quicker um being a bit easier to explain and less kind of front heavy in terms of explaining this to somebody who hasn't played it before i think it's just a bit too big and a bit too much going on for my personal tastes i've actually yet to play an uv rosenberg that i've fallen in love with and i was actually quite optimistic that i was going to this well this might have been the one because not only because it was probably the most critically acclaimed um because i thought you know reading the rules i thought you know this sounds really awesome i love the different things you can try and it's in practice yeah it was good but it just didn't have that special bit of magic that tends to hook me and keep me coming back and as i said earlier and for me a lot of the enjoyment i got from a feast for odin was in the discovery trying things out just seeing how things worked and now i've tried it all um i can't really see myself coming back to it so yeah unfortunately um this one hasn't really changed the tide in my uv rosenberg appreciation
well again well i still do like the game i think it's a good design and certainly nothing wrong with it um but it's just one of these games it's not for me because there again there's just too much going on and i can't really see myself pulling this one off the shelf on top of other games i just think a bit more concise and a bit more streamlined and just ultimately a bit more fun for me so yeah unfortunately again not going to be a recommendation for me but again i don't want to make that sound overly negative um because there's a lot of great games out there that aren't for me either so yeah unfortunately not going to be not going to be a massive recommendation for me but hey i'm still really appreciative that i've got to play this one and it's certainly another game off my bucket list that i wanted to try so that's my final thoughts on a feast for odin thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation and i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time