Libertalia: Winds of Galecrest Review
Transcript
this video is sponsored by skillshare hello hello this game should not work out too but if you do let's see why i was in very long a little longer we're talking over each other this isn't working libertarian girls of windcrest is just pure chaos it's one of those games where you play a card with no infinite certainty that you're about to do something very smart and then your friends do some absolutely nice words and then you're like why why is this my life there's plenty of games like that out there right your munchkins your kittens that explode your continuous lament that your friend decided to smoosh all of the expansions of killer bunnies together at midnight and by 4am you wish you were anywhere else but this forsaken chalet in christchurch would all times cease to exist because you're in a perpetual state of looking for cards with carrots or whatever not to win just to escape not that that ever happened to me that's just a hypothetical example anyway i bet you have two questions one what makes libertaria different and two what makes it a good two-player game when it relies so much on the chaos of your friends causing you grief as part of its entertainment let's take a look the thing i want you to know first is that despite its roots stemming from nonsense simulators libertaria is actually a very smart game and it
achieves that smartness the same way as scam bait articles with one weird trick your objective in libitalia is straightforward you're a pirate and an animal a paranormal you want gold basically so that you can sit on it and hatch more gold because i'm pretty sure that's how gold works in the real world if you're the partner with the most goal at the end of the three rounds you win no silly random changing win conditions here so how does a round play you might ask well painfully before a round begins each player will be dealt six cards out of a possible 40. these are for a lack of a better term buck wild and not just because one of them is a switch on your turn simply pick a card secretly play it face down wait for the other players to do the same and then you all reveal this is the moment that definitely makes the game the cards have so many effects and so many permutations in how they might resolve so when you're choosing a card you're trying to piece together how it will all play out but that's like trying to piece shoelaces out of a bowl of spaghetti but then you flip the card and suddenly clarity the clouds have parted with a gust of wind and now you can see that yes indeed you absolutely did do something stupid and now yep okay where's the fun in that isn't it just as real gamers would say random well sort of but libitalia does a
pretty good job of plastering over that randomness with a big dollop of cheeky mind games after you flip the cards face up they'll be arranged in numerical order at the top of the board first you'll go from left to right stopping over any card that has a d effect and resolve them then you'll go back from right to left resolving any dusk effects but this time you'll also grab a loot token along the way finally all cards go to the player's tableaus and now all cards they have with knight effects will trigger meaning these will repeat each turn here's the thing about these tokens these are generally good they give you gold or reputation unless they are bad if your card has a higher value you'll be taking a loot token first if your number is lower you might get stuck having to take a bad token which will lose you money or worse so higher value cards better generally except many of the lower value cards have been designed specifically to punish the hubris of anyone who dares play a higher value card let's say that i am holding the quartermaster existentially i'm already stumped because i have no idea what this animal is even supposed to be but mechanically the puzzle is seemingly straightforward there are three loot tokens available for this day one a treasure chest which
gives me five money and two relics each of which lose me free money because the quarter master is numbered 36 out of 40 if i play the quartermaster there's a high chance that i'll be the first to choose loot tokens meaning i can abscond with extra treasure leaving my opponent riddled with pox but what if my opponent plays the brute which is a lower number but it's they affect discards the highest played character well in that situation because the brute's effect is a day effect and would resolve first the quartermaster would walk the plank before we even landed on shore meaning no treasure chest and in fact no loot token whatsoever worse yet if i saved up my quartermaster for the last turn of the round when i would have the most loot tokens hoping to trigger its ability to get one coin for each loot token i have then the brute would negate that ability as well meaning i've just spent six times hatching a plan whereas what i've actually hatched is a sad turkey which is where you say efka that all sounds fine but there's 40 cards how is anyone supposed to predict anything well remember i mentioned that one smart mechanism that doesn't just transform this game but this genre of games as a whole anytime players draw
cards only one of the players draws cards from a randomized deck they reveal the six cards they've drawn and then the other players instead of also drawing randomly fish out the same six identical cards from their decks this is simple enough to sound daft but i can't emphasize how transformative an experienced libertarian delivers with the single change to the formula how do i know whether the other player has the brute or no well have i ever drawn one no which means they've also never drawn one does that mean that it's now safe for me to play the quartermaster on my last turn that depends let me just scan the other five cards in my hand well if i have the quarter master that means they also have the quarter master which means just like i want to play it on my last turn they also want to play it on their last turn which means they would get the same amount of gold as i did which brings my gains to a net total of zero suddenly the plan isn't to play your quartermaster it's how to stop the opponent from getting gold with their quartermaster meanwhile they are thinking the exact same thing and they know that you're thinking the exact same thing and then you're thinking that they're thinking that you're thinking about thinking then if that wasn't enough libitalia takes it a step further
by always leaving you with two cards at the end of the round meaning you can carry that quartermaster over into the next round or even the next round where there's more turns and more loot tokens suddenly the information isn't perfect anymore asking you to remember some of the more crucial cards your opponent hasn't quite spent the icing on this pirate cake is that each time you play you play with only 18 out of a possible 40 cards and each time you draw six cards libitalia creates a new little minigame with its own potential interactions intricacies and peculiarities it'll take you a few games to even know what the possibilities are but it'll take you many dozens to master how those possibilities permutate in different circumstances okay let's tackle the two-player thing because i imagine a lot of you familiar with libertarian via its previous edition are probably going wait a minute efka isn't libertalia rubbish at two there's a plethora of games out there that are intended for more players but are also great with two games like gloomhaven spirit island great western trail and so on there are also many great games that are made for just two players games like target and target with the expansion and then there are also experiences that simply don't work well with two players sidereel confluence for example is a game about
intergalactic resource trading and negotiation where you do the resource trading in real time with many different players we intuitively know that this would not work in a duet in an ideal world a board game box that's just not suited for two players would say something like three to five players but then publishers caught on then having your game support two players sells copies really well so almost every single board game is now two to four players or better yet two to five players or better yet one to six players and just for the solo players out there solo games are great but not every game can or should have a solo mode at some point it just becomes misleading advertising this is just the world we live in now if you buy your board games off the shelf as impulse purchases good luck you're taking a crapshoot in more ways than one if you want to be savvy about it however you can always consult bgg to see if your desired game is good at a certain play account let's see how that works here's gloomhaven the most popular game on bgg if we go under player account recommendations we see that most people agree that it's best at free that seems like valid information until you notice that 5.9 percent of people recommended with more than four when the game plays one to four disturbingly almost one in a hundred out of millions of bgg
users think that it's best at more than four you can't do that the game does not have enough components in the box to play with more than four this is obviously absurd but even if we look at seemingly reasonable statistics we'll discover that 38.3 percent of people think that gloomhaven is best at four whereas only 28.2 percent of people think that it's best at two suggesting that it's a poor two-player game and that's just not true if you played gloomhaven at 4 you know this it's fine it just gets too long and unwieldy gloomhaven is a great two-player game sorry that was a long diversion but i hope it illustrates the magnitude of the problem publishers will put absolutely anything they want on the box and if you ask a stranger on the internet for their opinion they will tell you what they think but what are the chances that what they think is something that actually suits you so that's what i mean when i say libertalia is a good two player game it is good for me but i'll explain why and i hope that helps you make up your mind i think what's crucial here is that libitalia gails of windcrest becomes a different game at two let's go back to the quartermaster versus brute example i can probably suss out when my opponent will play those cards especially if i know them well now
imagine six people simultaneously playing the same mind game the way i think i need to do is play the quartermaster on the penultimate turn so that i can play the gunner to get rid of him if steve's going to play the please i need to make a chair for you
i also wasn't kidding when i said libertalia plasters over the randomness because i meant that literally the randomness is still there creeping in the walls and the more people there are tearing at those walls the more the randomness seeps out it really is munchkin but with a more modern design that tricks you into thinking it's smarter than it actually is and i don't mean that as a bad thing because maybe that's exactly what you need just kick back with your friends with some silliness and fun but that's not what you get at the to play account there's one change that's introduced to the two player mode in this edition a spacer placed in number 20.5 now there are additional mind games will you play a low card or a high card because a low card means you might not even have a choice of tokens and be forced to take the pox that's all very nice and it suits the two-player mode well but ultimately what i want you to take away is that if you're playing at two it's a cat and mouse game and if you're playing at the opposite player count it's raucous chaos as long as you know what to expect i think you'll have a good time except look not to tack on a plot twist here but there's one final caveat when i say libertarian gusts of breeze crest is really good at two i do really mean it but at the same time i would never play libitalia if i was only going to play
with two players because it's just not as sharp as some of the games that are designed exclusively for that play account the reputation track particularly sticks out because low reputation means much more gold or victory points and being second in a two-player game is nowhere near as bad as being lost in a five-player game because in the latter scenario many more bad things could happen to you in between also sometimes you get into this preposterous routine of turn after turn playing literally the same character as your opponent and whilst it's cute for a while it does get rather tedious when it just keeps going on and on and on i think if what you want is specifically a great cat and mouse experience might i recommend watergate or even another game by libertaria's designer paolo mori called caesar sees rome in 20 minutes both of which we've covered in the past and of course there's targi the master of all two-player only games and when it comes to libitalia as part of entertainment for a large group of people i think you might have picked up for this video that it's not exactly my favorite genre of games i'd much rather play something like monica's in that situation but you know you do you so who is libertaria4 well there's actually a very good answer for this it's for people who like to host game nights for
people who like to invite friends over and show them board games it's versatile enough to adapt to different circumstances and i bet you can get a lot of mileage out of it if you pair it with the right situations plus these chunky azul-like pieces are fun and very pleasing to fiddle with and that's a big boost when showing people board games so that's libertalia but what about more games that are not really meant for two but were great at that play account anyway well in our next review we'll take a look at another one of those post your guesses in the comments as to what it is and i'll tell you the answer after a word from our sponsor skillshare skillshare is easily the best place on the web to just go and learn something either because you want to learn something specific or maybe frankly you're just bored and dissatisfied and decided that learning anything will make you feel just a little bit better pro tip it does if you've got a specific subject in mind skillshare has classes on a wealth of subjects like photography illustration interior design cooking and so on but what if you just want to find something well when i make these sponsored spots i like to play a little game of tyler classy featuring to the subject of the video so libertalia pirates sea shanties guitar lessons learn guitar the complete beginner's guide by mark barnacle i see what he did there will take you
from i am holding a piece of wood with thin metal strings in my hand and i don't know what to do with it to actually playing actual songs in an easy to follow structured guide that you can peruse at your own pace setting your own goals i gave it a go and look at me now huh playing what i think is a see shanty i actually knew how to play this when i was 14 and i never advanced beyond that level but that's okay that's the thing about skillshare that there's just no pressure learn what you like how you like when you like however much you like if you want to try a skillshare for yourself i've got some great news for you the first 1000 of you to click the link in the description or the comment below we'll get a one-month free trial of skillshare so you can see for yourself what it's like and if you go to skillshare and use the code nope included or one word at checkout you will also get the same offer that helps a channel out so please do that hey you're back wait a minute you didn't watch the sponsor spot you just skip right past it listen you can't do that that's cheating okay now all of us everyone watching will have to wait for you to go scroll back watch the sponsor spot meanwhile we'll just have to sit here quietly
waiting until you do that so go back now okay okay watch the sponsor spot and i'll tell you the answer
if you're playing with two you might want to use the other side of the board because there's different abilities for loop tokens here and the one with the maps in a two-player mode works better if if you're playing on the other side so that's a pro tip that they've missed out on because they have to watch the sponsors bar what's the rest of us wait
okay you're back it's ankh gods of egypt