Skip to main content
Loading video...

Expedition to Newdale Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 22:31

hi everyone today i'm talking about expedition to new dell by lookout games and by designer alexander fister this is a one to four player i suppose resource management game uh that was released in 2019 now the game was or is based on one of alexander vista's famous small card games called oh my goods now i will say i've never played oh my goods so i can't um i can't compare the two and i know a lot of people will be doing that so i suppose in a good way i can look at this game in its own respect really and um not have that in the back of my mind so i'm going to be very careful with this one because it is a i suppose a campaign-driven game there are eight different scenarios which kind of mess with the rules and add different things into the game but i wanted to do this just to show how the game plays and there's core mechanisms and so on without giving anything away so i'm going to be quite wary of that so yeah very very basic mechanical overview here so the you're gonna get given a lot of game boards for this game i think there's four different types they're all double sided this one is the basic one and you've also got this other board here which shows your score track um add some different abilities you've got here and you've got your own little player board your play board looks like this and it talks through all the different phases in the game and offers you different spots to put buildings you're going to start with a coal mine i have a couple of these different uh little things here you can unlock and you're gonna start with a bunch of cards because this is very much a card driven

game you've got this huge stack of buildings that you can play through you've got loads of other buildings that are gonna be unlocked as the story goes on um these just depict your different resources and each one is gonna have a kind of scenario or each mission that is gonna have a scenario and it's gonna have an events deck now the scenarios start off very simple but they do as i mentioned become quite more involved and more mechanisms come into the fold and so on so again take this as a very introductory version of the game um at start the game you're gonna get given eight cards and you're gonna have to choose to shed these down to five cars to form your starting hand so again this is this is the starting mission so i'm not going to give anything away here um is to so the the objective here is to collect food to accumulate up to 30 coins so you've got your corn you've got your bread and you've got your meat and um i should say very clearly this is the solo mode of the game um the multiplayer versions have slightly different criteria so yeah in this solo version i've gotta have 30 coins worth of these goods i've got to have 38 points and i've got to have two military strength and you've got this events deck here which is going to reveal itself as the game goes on and kind of add new buildings into the picture and so on and i said you've got this massive stack of building cards so considering the um the objective of the game here let's say i can get rid of a couple here that which won't really um do me much good so let's say i get rid of this one uh

this one and this one i'm not going to think about this too much start going to the discard pile and let's talk about how the game actually plays out so first off you're going to draw an event from the events deck so what i'll do is from the stack here i'd reveal the event and this is going to show some important information so for example here it will say put this building into the display which is the number 200 building um and it will say um you know when i can build i can choose to build from that from that display other than just my hand and you've got a bit of flavor text here as well and these different symbols on the side of the cards here are going to be quite important because that's going to play a big factor on what i can and can't produce during the turn so after you've revealed the event you are going to i suppose it's worker placement pretty clearly worker placement you're going to start with two of these tokens and you're going to deploy them on two different spots and you can either deploy them onto spots onto your board here where you've got buildings or you can use these um these i suppose common places that are on the uh on the main board here so the building spaces are quite interesting and i suppose i should show the anatomy of these cards so this just shows it's a starting building some of the other ones will have costs on for example which costs to build it so for example this one would cost 10 to build um and points that you're going to get at the end of the game and also what the goods produce so what this coal mine says is that i need two yellow workers i need one of these red workers um in order to produce a

coal and that coal was going to be worth one coin um and something i should have done during setup is that you start with a number of goods already on your building like such so what's that what this is showing is that i've got five coal because they're on the coal mine card and each one of these cubes is going to be worth a coin so when you produce when you choose to allocate onto these buildings you can either put your work or your little token on any of these spots and what this means is that i believe if i put on this one here it means that i'm going to have one of these workers fewer than the criteria depicted on the card so you've got your four different types of workers you've got your yellow ones your green ones your red ones and your blue ones and you will have different rarities so you can see the yellow ones are more popular with six being available in this bag here and you've got your rarer ones here which have the blue ones where there's only three so in order for me to trigger this i'm going to need two yellows and a red and the yards on that are pretty good considering uh this card has already got a kind of a a starting point so i've already got one yellow into the picture and i've also got two reds so i actually only need one more yellow to get the standard um ability and um you know the yellow is being more common the chances are that's going to be drawn from the bag so let's say for example i put it on on here like this so what this symbol says mean means that i'm going to i believe that i'm going to have one more of the depicted workers than um that need that that is needed and to do that i'm going to produce if i if i meet that criteria that is i'm

going to produce four cubes i can be really ambitious and say i'm going to produce two more or have two more workers than i need where i get four cubes but i'm not going to be that brave but you know if i really felt a bit cautious i could say i'm going to get one fewer and say that i'm not going to draw any yellow workers from the bag and only produce two cubes and you've got all these different spots you can put new buildings in and those buildings have different kind of production values as you can see you can do one more or two more here or have kind of all different setups you've also got these common buildings here such as this spot which lets you build another building you've got this one here where you can spend four coins to upgrade one of your player boards here which i'll explain what they do a bit later you've got this one here that that lets you keep a card from your hand kind of reshuffle the rest into the deck and then draw three additional cards so this one's a good way to um get more cards into your hand this one here let you trading two cards to get more resources so you can get four coal and then you can put any resource on another building that you've built and this one here lets you spend seven to unlock your third worker or 13 to unlock your fourth worker which also gets you an additional three points so as you can see the worker placements are pretty straightforward and yeah pretty simple to understand what they do so once you've committed to what these different workers do so let's see for example i did that they are then going to go to the bag here and you're going to draw out four of these different um different workers blindly so let's do this one hand oh that was a

quite strange look there so i've got four additional yellow workers so what this essentially means is that from this event or this round i'm gonna have basically five yellow workers in the picture two reds two greens and a blue and as you can see that more than um adequately reaches the criteria here and i could have actually gone for the extra um the extra criteria and gotten myself an additional cube so then they're going to get resolved in order these disks that is and i'm going to place the resources onto that onto that card so i would place three of these cubes onto the card which means i now have this many coal to spend and then i'd go to my second one here which would let me build a building and to do that i would be able to spend the money i have available here or available from my resources bear in mind these these are worth one each at the moment to build a new building and these do lots of cool things you know such as um you know being able to produce bread or being able to produce meat and so on which are worth different value so every cube on these cards are going to be worth five each or four each you can also do these here which will um basically give you more military strength which is if you remember is important for the mission because i need two military strengths to win it um you've got these ones here as well which the post offices they basically give you a permanent passive worker to to be used and on top of all that when you build a building by paying the fee you are going to actually use the main board here to deploy one of your houses so you're going to start here in this

city and if you go to an adjacent city uh like this for example you can choose to take one of the um adjacent tiles here these towers that you do lots of cool things such as you know when you build a building you can build one for four for money fewer you know you can trade in two cars to get a point for every yellow worker in the pool and so on but you can additionally if you don't want to go to the the next town you can go to an additional town a further town a one step away i should say but you don't get one of these tiles but the reason you might want to do that is because as you see from some of these cards like this one if you build on a certain building a certain spot for example this one here with the tower so if i built here for example i would get an additional discount of three coins and some some of them buildings also give you uh additional bonuses or instant bonuses so you've got to bear that in mind as well something i should have done during setup as well is that everyone gets a mission card a secret mission card which gets you points depending on if you deploy in certain spots on the board you know with certain certain flags on or these symbols on and so on so there are some more some more um points you can go for there so let's talk about what these um different buildings um do so this one's here basically means that when you when you build a building as i said you can normally only ever could take the token if you build one away from you rather than the two but this one increases that range so if you produce two or if you if you move two steps away from you you can

still take the token but you can potentially move another one and not get the token so that one just increases your range and flexibility to travel around the map and this one here normally you would have to spend three workers in or sorry three cards in order to substitute for one of these workers you're missing but if you get that upgrade then you only have to pay two and um i said you would remove these tokens if you do choose to invest in those so that's going to be basically how the game's going to work you're going to be trying to work towards these objectives you know in this case trying to get produce as many food as you can in order to meet that 30 threshold and also to get that many points by doing you know by building buildings by getting your secret objective missions and by producing points um because some some of these tokens and things let you get points for example you know trading in uh let's see what we've got here you know trading in two of these yarns in order to get a point for each uh each red work you've got out there and so on so yeah you're trying to get points in all different ways and trying to ultimately fulfill that objective um the multiplayer game works a bit differently in terms of the military strength because whoever's got the most is going to get some additional points and um and so on and then from then on you know when you complete the mission or you don't complete the mission um you are going to go on to the next story which will progress so yeah it's pretty simple mechanically the hand management is quite tight because you often have to spend cars in order to do other things so you do want to have a constant influx of cars going through your system

and not only that not only for that reason to give you flexibility on what you want to build but also because when you choose to produce these buildings you can choose to cash in cards for the matching symbols so say for example if i had that symbol there that this card shows for each one you get rid of when you produce you can add another cube to that supply so again you want to be constantly getting as many much resources as you can but bearing in mind which cards you're going to have to get rid of in order to do that so there is that decision there and i do like that multiple use cards method which alexander fister is very famous for um as i mentioned time and time again this is a very introduction verge introductory version of the game um loads more builders will be coming into the fold which do lots of different cool things the event cards add a lot of flavor to the game it said there's lots of different boards here which uh are much more interesting these these boards are double-sided but i won't show you what the other side does because again it adds another cool wrinkle to the game there are character cars you can add in which give you powers lots of different things you can do and so this is a very stripped back version of the game which will hopefully give you impression about the core fundamentals of the game so let's talk about what i think about it so first of all um as i touched on i do like the card management system um yes there are ways that you can completely flood your hand of cards you know by using these abilities for example but if you don't play these cards sensibly then you will quickly find yourself running out especially if you keep burning them off in order to you know in order to get the extra resources

so the balancing the resources you have available to you and the cards in your hand is is important you know you want to decide on what you want to invest in because you want to get these upgrades in order to make things more efficient and additionally you want to upgrade or invest in getting more workers so you can do more per turn um i really like this mechanism here where you can basically gamble about how much you're going to produce you can be really optimistic and go for those higher values but if you don't meet that threshold then you are actually going to leave with nothing so having cards in your hand to compensate for those missing workers is going to be important but you can mitigate that luck a bit more by making these post offices and giving yourself permanent workers to play with so i do like that it has a cool um it has a cool idea of a small pushy luck mechanism in a more involved game which is quite interesting um i like the different abilities you can get as well from traveling around these this map here um and you know there are quite a few variabilities here as well because there um all these tokens aren't used per game you know there's a big um a big bag of these tiles like that for example and um so each game is going to look different from time to time some of them are more available than others because if you ever you basically fulfill filling this board up one spot at a time and if you ever draw a duplicate tile out then that actually has an additional spot on which can potentially benefit you um more than once whereas if it's just the ones drawn you can only

use it once so bear that in mind as well um so yeah there are some interesting decisions here the the objectives are varied there's a nice narrative thread throughout which you know it's not it's not the most amazing story in the world but however it it does add that extra flavor that might keep you coming back to it eight very distinct scenarios um adding different things in um and which which can really um you know keep that hook and keep you coming back to it so you know eight games is quite a lot for um or at least for me i don't tend to play many games eight times so the idea of giving you that extra incentive to come back to it and see where the story progresses is nice which i think alexander fister does um does does well the the balance of the game is is decent i mean i said i like the weighing up of the buildings and more powerful buildings they are the more powerful abilities they're going to give you more points they're going to give you etc so yeah there's some nice balance there and the the events deck because the events decks are tailor-made to the current scenario um they do a great job of adding again more flavor to the scenario and giving you that extra boost or extra setback that you that that makes the game more interesting from game to game um the time investment is good especially at a solo mode i i highly recommend this as a solo game actually because you can actually get every game done in about half an hour whereas in a multiplayer game it leads more towards that 75 to 90 minute mark

you know probably more around that 90 minute mark for the three or four player game which you know is it's not the most involved game for to take that timestamp which is why i like the solo mode because it is so so quick um again with with that time as well that the analysis paralysis is when i first read the rules for this i was quite thinking that this game is going to be pretty straightforward especially you know deploying the workers it's not going to be that important the order which you do things but the order in which you do things is actually extremely important because you might need the prior abilities because they're resolved in order to fulfill the later ones you know for example i might have my um building action becoming after my resource gaining action um which i might rely on getting my resources in order to build the building in the first place so the order in which you do things is quite important which can add that extra wrinkle of um of of meaningful decisions but also potentially add a bit more analysis paralysis into the game as well so so yeah bear that in mind but um it's simple mechanically but um not not certainly not brainless because you know the order in which you do things are important and also what you're going for in the first place uh is important um replayability as i mentioned it's story driven so it gives that it gives that reason for you to even if you just want to play through the scenario once that's still eight games you're gonna get and i don't think many games nowadays hold up to that many plays and this one does that you've got different balls to play

through loads of different buildings to add into the add into the shuffle um you know dual player boards here you've got lots of different levels of story and different twists on the core mechanisms that just keep you hooked really so i do like the extra efforts that have been made in order to make you go back to this game aesthetically i like the nice bright colors the white bright board i think it looks very nice um the you know it's all pretty basic stuff but it works well and it's certainly not overdone it's not pretentious in any way and i just think it's it's well produced if you're familiar with vista games then you know the card kind of anatomy here is going to be familiar um which is nice you know it's very simple to digest and understand you know how many points you get how much it costs the additional resource that you can cash in in order to get the extra bonuses and the actual bonus it gives you so i do like the anatomy of the cards um the uh the component quality is good as well you know not only looks but all the components are good quality and progression is is decent because you want to spread out and get all your secret objectives you're producing more and more buildings which means you're producing more goods you're unlocking more workers you've also got the additional bonus of you know always drawing more cards and making another building um as you build up your engine you get more black cars and black cars trigger at the end of each at the end of each round which is good and they can do lots of cool things as well so there is a good sense of progression and the game does have a ramping up effect which is nice scalability as i mentioned i would

highly recommend this at a solo mode i think i prefer it much more solo than i do in um in a multiplayer game because there isn't that much interaction the only interaction really is trying to grab these different tiles um and obviously as some some buildings become available in a public forum which can be snapped up by other players if even if you wanted them so there's a little bit of tension there but not much to be honest and you know comparison-wise i've had multiple times this one being very similar to the actual card game omo goods but um i can't personally compare them so um i can't really think of any direct comparisons other than that really but overall yeah i enjoyed this game it certainly um you know has that fista flavor to it it's got some very simple mechanisms a nice simple flow from start you know from from phase one to phase um to phase six very simple broken down um you know rounds in the game um the hand management is good it's you know it's enjoyable the resource management is good you want to produce things in order to meet these objectives always bearing in mind the military strength as well we're trying to get your points um i particularly like that pushy like element of actual manufacturing the goods in the first place so do you want to take that extra um you know do do you really believe that you're going to draw the workers that you need to get those extra resources which can give you that extra kick but potentially leave you getting nothing or having to at least discard cards in order to get that extra resource so yeah overall i liked it i like this game i think it's pleasant

it's fun um yeah it's snappy and it's got some good hand management in it uh loads of variability in the buildings loads of um i said extra wrinkles in terms of the um where the story goes and the events decks and things um certainly not one of my favorite vista games it doesn't have that huge level of um you know scope that his bigger games do but um nonetheless it's still a very tight design it's fun it's um yeah it's not brainless i like the way you have to plan your workers in different yeah in order so they are resolved in order and you can't just choose which ones you want to resolve first and that can play quite a big part in your decision making and so on so yeah so again a pleasant game one that i enjoyed um i don't think it's going to stay around long term because it just didn't quite have that hook to um really stand amongst the best of the best but nonetheless fister games are always solid and this is another example of that i'm getting eight chapters all different lots of different wrinkles to the game which is um which is a good thing so that concludes my thoughts on expedition to noodle if it does appeal to you go check it out because um it's certainly a solid game if you have enjoyed the video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved