Peacemakers: Horrors of War - Review
Transcript
Welcome to Allies Arene Enemies. I'm Jess. And I am Sean. And today we are talking about Peacemakers: Horrors of War. And our copy was provided for review, but the thoughts in this video are all our own. Peacemakers is a one to four player game designed by Samuel Laxo and Vill Rhinoan. and it is a cooperative game where you're trying to mediate peace between waring factions and there's a bunch of scenarios to play through. It takes place in the same world as the lands of Galier. So all the different characters and factions are anthropomorphic animals. Let's take a look at how it plays. To start the game, you first pick one of the six scenarios and lay out both halves of the map, as well as the cards and various figures for that scenario. Then all players choose an adventurer and divide four resource cards among them, and you're ready to play. Your goal is to bring peace to the waring factions, mostly by playing cards, which players can play in any order. And these let you move, look at army orders, fortify defenses, delegate cards to other players, or scheme by resolving the cards special written effect. After players have played their cards, the armies resolve their order cards and resume their battle. Anytime
an army unit dies in battle, it decreases its side's motivation, but it also adds a horror card to your deck, which will negatively impact you every time it comes up. You win if both sides motivations are in the green zone at the same time. And you lose if either side's motivation falls to zero or if their leader is killed, at which point you set it all back up and try again. The theme of this is really interesting because usually when you see a lot of characters on a board and there is a war happening, usually you are part of that and you're trying to destroy different like factions or each other. But in this case, you're just like this solo person trying to talk to the different groups and broker a peace still. It's a really like interesting premise. It is. I don't I can't think of any other game that's anything like this. It is really interesting because Yeah, totally. you you see the box, you like see what's inside the box, you think, "Oh, yeah, we're going to fight." And you absolutely are not. You're trying to stop fighting as much as you can, which is such an interesting puzzle. And especially for a co-op game as well, because I kind of I was in I was chatting with someone recently about how there seems to be so few kinds of co-op games. And like 80% of co-op games feel like they're kind of pandemic. They're kind of, you know, you're putting out a bunch of fires together and you've got those happening at different places.
This is something that's actually different where you are these mediators mediating peace and it's just interesting that it is so different. Yeah, this game feels really different. And how you're trying to mediate peace is through a lot of card manipulation. You're trying to reveal the cards of what the different factions will do. And a key part is really about timing because you'll want certain things to happen at certain times. So, you really have to be patient. And it's interesting because you sometimes do want them to attack each other, which I wouldn't have expected once I knew the premise. Yeah. And it is, you're right about the patience because so much of it really is patience because I think our first games were like, "Okay, well, when they die, they like move one closer to peace because they like they run out of steam or they lose morale." Um, but if they every time they die, you get a horror card added to the deck. And those are really trouble. Those are like a major problem each time that they come up because sometimes it's an ongoing problem, sometimes it's an immediate problem. So, you really do want to find ways that you can like move that thing just like little by little, moving their bead down to piece instead of killing them. But you do want to like rush and kill them. But it's it's generally a mistake. Yeah. And you really have to manage that because usually the amount that each faction has to decrease is different because they'll be starting on different amounts or their target is
different amounts as well. And it is really challenging to get that track in the right window. It It can be so difficult cuz you can often push the track too far or the other team just gives up. Yeah. Yeah. Cuz you don't want anyone to ever get down to zero. And we really you really can be like, "Oh, great. We can do like a big push and look at what a great turn. They just drop like four morale." And then all of a sudden they're dead and the other one hasn't moved down at all. So you have to be so careful with that balance. And that really is like an interesting and difficult puzzle. And this game is very difficult. We've played I don't know five, six times so far. And I think we've won once. And we cheated when we won that once because there's one of the rules we didn't get that made our life a lot easier. So with the correct rules, uh we haven't won it yet, but we are always really close. And I think that's the that is kind of what you want in a co-op game. Yeah. And I think you definitely get better the more you play because you have a better sense of the pacing and also you're more familiar with the faction cards, particularly if you're replaying scenarios because when you first play through, you don't really have a sense of what cards are included in each faction deck. But the more familiar you are with those cards, the easier it is to try and like manage them and set yourself up. Yeah, you definitely you're you're almost certainly going to lose each scenario the first time you play it. And so you're just kind of watching for like how how am I going to manage this once I
actually know what's going on and I've got a better shot at this scenario. I think the biggest point of replayability is that it comes with six scenarios and you don't have to progress through. They're all independent scenarios, so you can play them in in any order. And as a result, each one is such a different puzzle. There's like different factions that you're working with. There's also different rules or scenarios that apply to the specific map, too. Yeah, there are. Yeah, the different factions, first of all, are interesting. Just because they're in like they just look cool. They look different. You've got even different figures within that. So, like just because you're using the bears maybe in two or three scenarios doesn't mean you're necessarily using the same bears.
And there's there's just weird little wrenches that they throw in as well. So there's one where there's like a touittara pirate, I think, who's like shooting cannonballs at folks. There's one where there's ocelots who kind of switch back and forth. The ocelots oscillate. I just realized that. But they switch back and forth between the two factions. I just want to do this now for oscillating ocelots. And there's like each one has something like that where there's just something that's like a little bit weird, a little bit different and that does make them play, you know, quite different. Yeah. And the different scenarios have different maps that definitely change things up. There's a map where one of the factions has to like go up this hill and boulders keep coming down and might hit them.
other ones where like rules have been introduced like you can't see what some of the upcoming cards are and so that makes it more challenging. Yeah. And and they just look cool and different and I like the like the book that they use for that too. The another point of variability in this as well there's a few really but there's the four different um adventurers who are like the peacemakers that you can use. So, the four different player figures and each of them has their own kind of spe it's not really special cards because you can all use the same cards, but they get a bonus with a quarter of the cards and they all get slightly different bonuses where like one of them might look at cards a little bit more. One of them might be able to move the factions around a little bit more and so that does make a difference too. The other thing that will change things up is the horror cards. And there is a whole stack. And these give different penalties, but some of them are a one-off penalty, some of them are ongoing penalties, and you're definitely going to be getting the horror cards.
And then so that will impact the scenario is which ones you get and when you get them. So the components are really solid across the board. In particular, I really love the figures of the different animals. They look really great. They're distinctive between the factions. And you get those individual differences when you have differences within the factions, too. And the screen printing looks really good. Yeah, they do. At first, I wasn't cuz like the adventures, the screen printing's like a little weird. It's the same thing with Lands of Gals as well. And I know a lot of people really like it, but it just it's it's like a distinctive art style, I guess. But with the animals in this one, I really like all of the animals. And some of them more than others. I really like the Tuittara pirate. I think he's great.
But there are most of them I I really enjoy. And yeah, it's not too hard to tell them apart. They also have these great bases that they stick into, which is important for the gameplay because a lot of the cards will affect one kind. They'll affect like the circle ones or the gear ones or the star ones. I think that's the three. And that works really well. I wasn't sure how well that would work, but they go in just kind of perfectly snugly, but they come right out of it. And so I was I was really happy with with how that part of it worked. Yeah. And the different scenarios all use different maps and those are all presented using these two different books. And I think that works really well because you don't need a thick board. So you're able to get six different scenarios and six different maps and all of the specific information that you need for those maps printed right on the maps. It's cool, too, because that also does a good job of breaking up where those two different factions are as well, because you've got one on the left, one on the right, and you've got the places to put their cards. And so, all of that makes the game just really clear that you've got like this is exactly where the cards go.
This is where the factions go. This is where like the dead ones go and and this is like the beads that slide down along the track. So, all of that just makes things pretty easy. And everything that's labeled on the map as well. There are a couple times maybe when we missed like oh there's like a little icon here that shows that someone's hidden there or there's like a little icon that shows that they've got a little bit morale as long as they've got something here that very occasionally that will get hidden because you like stand a figure on top of that. Even with that like that has been pretty few and far between and it's probably the only problem I can think of. The insert's great too. Yeah, it has a great insert and the labeling is topnotch. I will say one of the potential other trickies is when somebody gets injured, there's these little discs that you put next to them.
And for the most part, that does work fine, but it does mean you have to like move the discs with the characters. So, if the two characters are close together, you just have to keep an eye on making sure those discs don't get mixed up. The other thing as well is that they do look a little bit like Tums. So, if you're eating a lot of Tums, just don't get confused. But they they actually really do. But there and there's also the uh the square cubes that go on, but those are less of a problem because you don't actually move those. Those stick to spaces. But other than those couple problems, there really isn't a lot here to poke holes in. This is a pretty solid production. So, let's talk about player count. And mechanically, not a lot really changes between one and four players. You're always going to have four cards, but it is going to change who's got those cards. So, if you're one player, you're going to have all four cards. If you're four players, you're going to have one card each. If you're two players, it's going to be half and half. If it's three players, one person gets two cards. And that is actually kind of an interesting decision. But the more important thing is how many adventurers are on the map because you each have an adventurer. And that does make a big difference because you need to be where people are in order to affect them. All the cards say nearby adventure and that means like within your hex on the map. And so usually what happens in a two-player game is one of us is kind of whispering in the ear of the one army, the other one is talking to the other army. And that I think works really well. But if you're playing with one player, you're going to be using some of those cards to really move
back and forth. Or what I would suggest is just play with two characters because I do think the game just kind of works a little bit better. And even like thematically, like I like the story of, you know, one of you is in Rohan and one of you is in Gondor and you're whispering to the two kings. That just makes sense to me. Yeah, thematically it it does make sense. I think it would be trickier at three and four cuz I don't know if it necessarily offers up much of an advantage and you're having fewer cards per player. So that could be really tricky because you may not be in the right spot for that card, too. So I would imagine at four players you would probably like team up where two of you go to one army, two of you go to the other army. Maybe you even stick like in the same space so that you can share cards a bit better, but then you can take advantage of having more player powers to use. Yeah, that is one of the trickies for sure is that in order to share cards, you have to be in the same place. And if you're like even three spaces apart, that's a long way to go because each hex is like a fairly big chunk of the battlefield. And a lot of the cards only let you move one or two spaces. So you and you don't have that many cards. You do not want to burn cards in this game. You you really need every card to count. So yeah, I think four players would be it would feel a little weird. It just it feels like a two-player game to me. I think BGG does suggest two players and that makes perfect sense to me. Yeah, we really enjoyed it as a two-player game because it worked well and like you say thematically it makes sense
too. So, moving on to final thoughts. And I think there is an audience for this game, but I think it's important to know if you're part of that audience cuz I think there's going to be some people where this is not the game for them. And I think part of that is it has a lot of figures on the board. It looks like it's going to be a war game and it is not. You're not rolling dice. It is very like strategic. It's very patient. You really have to manage your cards and how you're manipulating the different faction cards. Yeah. And I think that is one of the biggest things is that you really have to have patience to win this game cuz this is it's a hard game. You're going to lose a lot more than you're going to win. And you're almost guaranteed going to lose every scenario the first time you play it. So, you're going to have to be a player who's okay with, you know, I'm going to lose it.
I'm going to learn and then I'm going to play again and I'm going to like use the things that I learned the next time. But even within the game too, you really have to be patient. This is like it really is a slowpaced game where you are understanding the cards. You're flipping them at the right moments. You're like just knocking them down kind of one at a time and really trying to get them down to the right amount without them dying hopefully too much. And so this is it's just not going to be a game for everybody because it's not always going to be big excitement and the theme is just it's kind of like even though it's so cute and pretty and everything, it's also kind of harrowing a bit. Yeah. Cuz like some of them do die and it is war. You are trying to stop it. So you're at least on the good side of it, but it is a bit of a dark theme. And I think if you like the sounds of really kind of paying attention to the different cards the different factions have and being able to try and set those up for just the right turn and being able to have some turns where maybe you're not playing any cards because it would be best just to hang on to those for later.
It is really about the long game. Yeah, this is really a game for people who who like a a difficult puzzle, but also where you're not necessarily kind of the main character in the story, too. And I think that's an interesting thing in this game that is really going to appeal to some folks and really isn't going to appeal to other folks because you've got these big armies and you're not those armies. You're not the big exciting bear with the sword. You're you're the little guy talking to the big exciting bear with the sword trying to get him to not use that sword. And it's it's just so different than so many other games. And I think some folks are really going to enjoy that difference and think, "Oh, this is like what a cool totally different thing than anything else on my shelf." And other folks are going to think, you know what, I kind I kind of wish that I was just the bears fighting against the ocelots. I kind of just want to do that. And so you'll have a sense of kind of which side of that fence you fall on. Yeah. And if you fall in the sense where you think this is a game for you, it is nice that it comes with six different scenarios that do feel quite different and are quite challenging because also each scenario has three different levels of difficulty. So if you really want to try and master it, you can take the time to get better and better by increasing the difficulty. And the like factions look cool. It is like a nice looking game as well. I I would be very impressed by the person who can beat like the sixth scenario with the extra challenge things. Gee whiz, it's already so hard already. Sorry for my
language, but gee whiz. Yeah. No, it is quite a challenge. But I also do like that you don't have to do the scenarios in order. So if there are particular animal factions that you're interested in or particular maps, I mean, you can just jump around. So it isn't a campaign game, but there are a lot of like different ways that you can play it. And that is it. Have you played Peacemakers? What did you think? And are there other co-op games that do something a little bit different that you might like to recommend? We'd love to see those recommendations. Thank you so much for watching. As usual, please like, subscribe, and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game.