Skip to main content
Loading video...

Vantage - Stonemaier's new cooperative sci-fi sandbox - TCbH Review

Transcript 7:43

In the late as an an era of questionably pairing blue jeans and blazers at mega press conferences for the 360 generation of video games, a common enough declaration to the point of being parody was, "See that mountain in the distance? If you see it, you can go there." Opening up a new world of expectation for exploration. And you may be like, "Jack, what the hell does any of this have to do with my board game review?" That spirit, the openw world exploration based off of perspective, wonder, and gumption, is exactly what Stonemire Games is trying to tap into with their first fully cooperative release, expansions aside, Vantage. You and fellow players are space fairers for a corporation or something, Zeno Explorers. But after choosing characters, every game starts with a stellar mishap and evacuation from your ship, determining your starting point, randomized through rolling some dice, and the rest is really up to you. Each player has their own location card, their vantage, a beautifully illustrated, if often ambiguous and somewhat limited, panorama with a compass that allows you to navigate to other cards, or contextsensitive actions that can be taken based on one of the color-coded skills. Though these are generally vague, if not obfiscating descriptions of what you can do, and it's most often not until you initiate the action that you find out what drink

or chase or whatever other action means by way of following the accompanying narrative in the skill specific book. So on your turn, you choose one of these actions, whether it's one listed on your current vantage or on another card you own. Spend some skill tokens to reduce the challenge level. Roll some dice, which can be cashed on open spaces relating to this type of action on yours or other players cards to avoid some penalties. Then proceed with whatever the results tell you to do. You pretty much always succeed in an action. It's just more so you have the opportunity to get some penalties from rolling the dice that are going to reduce some of your stats, but otherwise you move to the next player's turn and repeat. But why why are you doing this? Well, it's important to know that every session of Vantage is a standalone adventure. This is not a campaign game, and your objective, while you're given one of several missions at the very beginning, is largely to explore. You can find new missions or destinies, or even by the rules of the game, choose to end when players feel satisfied. Even defeat by way of a character losing all of one of their three stats, health, time, and morale allows for a sort of, well, let's hang in a bit longer if players choose to do so. This sort of open-ended go forth and find your fun is going to really make or break your time with Vantage. See, for me, I normally come to board games for stakes. Competitive

games are, well, competitive. And when I play cooperative games, I'm really looking to have stakes by means of trying to overcome the system, to see plot threads to their conclusion or to really constructively and creatively collaborate with other players at the table. While there are victory and defeat conditions in Vantage, they're kind of on the periphery, cutting through the tension. though on the flip side enhancing that sense of endless exploration which in that regard there is so much to do. Vantage is a chonker. Thousands of cards, a bevy of spiralbound notebooks, and an honest to goodness butt ton of surprising systems that aren't even hinted at, just waiting to be discovered, giving fornowledge of ways to approach future games. This is Vantage's strength. There is so much in this alien planet beautifully illustrated and weirdly described where each game I've brushed up against something that felt at odds with my current direction, but nonetheless I cashed the knowledge for pursuit in another adventure. Whether it's the physical geography of the world, ways to win over sentient races, certain hidden iconography to spy on cards, or just how to start by leveling up your skills by taking the damn actions listed on your character cards. It makes me want to see more. But if the world is dense, it shows a hollow structure and relief.

Vantage is nominally a cooperative game, but there's very little to do with collaboration. Sure, your group might have an overall mission, but the only interaction you really have is reading one another's story prompts and skill tests or offering relief in said tests by spending some of your own skill tokens or cashing some dice for other players taking their turn. You might never be even remotely close in proximity to other players in the game. And honestly, it doesn't really matter. There's a sense of isolation, too. Your vantage is yours, not to be shared with other players. You can describe it, but you can't show it. So, largely, you are just doing your portion of the adventure, and everyone else is doing theirs. Hopefully, in some way that might contribute to the overall goal or reveal a new goal easier or more interesting to accomplish. Unlike some other recent openw world co-ops from sleeping gods to earthborne rangers, Vantage doesn't trade in keywords to make contextsensitive story moments, which feels like a disservice to the world. There's less of a sense of interconnectivity and progression, though that might be a trade-off of making each session one and done. Sure, I developed a relationship with flying moth bug people, which now I have some cards in my inventory that help with future flying moth bug people stuff, but happening to run into a flying moth bug person in the area. They don't have some story moment trigger where they go, "Oh my god, you've mastered our dance and

been bestowed with the emblem of our mighty queen. That's amazing." At least in my experience with a few plays, that same action on that same card is going to be the same no matter what I've done before or since. Ultimately, as someone who's really driven by stakes and tension and strategy, which yes, can come from interconnective story, this game doesn't really offer enough of that for me. But I don't want to make it sound like I hate it either. My dedicated campaign group, who has played through everything from frost Haven and Sleeping Gods to Adventure Tactics, several Crossroad games, and more, have been playing this, and we intend to play a couple more times just to discover more of the kind of insane amount of content in the box. But for every hit of really cool stuff, there's also this sense of frustration that we're just living our own disconnected stories, stumbling through vantages, doing actions that might or might not be helpful in the end, hoping with marginal success rate that we'll feel satisfied at the conclusion. And that's our review. But let me know, what do you think about this game? What are some of your favorite narrative exploratory games? And what would you like to see in the future out of Stonemire and cooperative gaming? Put it in the comments below. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for being an awesome community.

You know that I've been Jack for the Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved