Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 27:05

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to board games unlocked and Dev and I are doing a discussion for eldrich horror this game God how old is this game now like so this one of your first like my first game uh I mean in the grand scheme of things yes I had everything for Arkham horor second edition and then then this one obviously came out had and they were it came out what's funny because Arkham hor second edition just got so crazy with content you think this has a lot yeah aramore second edition had even more damn um and this was meant was designed to refine it and they were like don't worry we're not going to bloat it out bloats it out really yeah uh but still somehow keep keeping it relatively refined like cuz second edition for Arkham horr was just still kind of all over the place um but this game came out in if I knew how to spell El eldrich if I knew how to spell eldrich whor in 2013 damn this game is 10 years old at this point which is crazy to think about cuz I got it at that time too so just how long I've actually been in the hobby um yeah and as time has gone on I no longer owne Arkham hor second edition uh

Arkham hor Third Edition came out and it just was not was not good and it's not even getting supported anymore by Fantasy Flight because they put all their resources into the card game so the Arkham Horror card game I actually do like more than this one because I feel like the writing's better the campaigns are better the story it's it's more of like a story driven thing um that it's just a little bit more up my alley but if you're really just talking about a game that has if you love cthulu or if you love Lovecraft you can't really find a game that that beats this one out MH and my opinion uh so I've done a discussion for this game before this it's been years and years so I wanted to kind of redo it to mesh with the format of my channel now and we included a lot of expansions uh the Himalayan one and a lot of the small ones so Devon what do you think of eldrich Horror oh eldrich horror it is nice I enjoyed the game it's fun mhm um I you know it kind of brought me back it's been a while since I've done a nice scenario kind of game you know where you read cards and like oh we resolved this little Standalone scenario which was fun um I enjoyed that yeah yeah um let's see here gameplay wise uh you know definitely let's see here dice heavy yeah heavy sign which it's like I don't mind don't mind hey

I'm used to bad luck it's okay mhm let's see let's see yeah I mean it's it's it's a fun game I enjoyed myself um I'm struggling to think of like H I guess I'm I'm more used to we've been doing Campaign games for a while I'm like okay how do I describe this kind of game anymore I know I know you're you're expecting it to like lead into a bunch of other stuff it does have a campaign to it but I don't know a single person who's ever done that um I mean certain I I don't begin I I'm sure this is a slew of uh add-ons you put in yeah I mean so the reason why I still love this game because it's funny you the the luck aspect of this game it doesn't affect me as much as other games because I think this is probably just because I am well aware what kind of game this is M uh and I get way more engrossed into the theme this kind of to me is like this lovecraftian epic that you can really ham up and you kind of take the die rolls for Better or For Worse and make it funny MH uh when bad things happen to you it's it's more hilarious because it just doesn't have that s same impact like a campaign game does if you fail then it's kind of like to we redo it we just keep getting worse in this it's like oh we lost okay well that was still 2 and a half hours of a fun time right uh but there's just so much content to this game that you're just never going to see I mean look at this item deck dude

every single one of them is different exactly it's pretty [ __ ] Bonkers it's so wild you get so many just different gear we we didn't even get the the god killing shotgun I know really that's really why we lost God killer but I need to get one one is this gone killer on side I mean but the one amazing thing that I always loved about this game was the fact that every location like like this green deck we went through three cards mhm and that's just three different options that have Arkham San Francisco and buen o Aries on it so you're just going to have the amount of riding in this game especially back then is insanity the amount of methos cards the amount of spe you know ancient one specific research cards and every single one of them has like flavor text on them exactly and you just really that while the writing it it's it's snippet form it still evokes a picture especially if you know any of like the lore then you can from actual Lovecraft you can Envision what's going on um and the reason I used to think Arkham hor second edition because it was in the city of Arkham uh so it was a lot more condensed and I I used to think that that was a lot better because I felt more homelier you know but this one because you're traveling all over the world having different Encounters in different cities and in Wilderness areas and going into uh other

worlds like it's it's just it's awesome MH uh and so whenever the dice are are there and it's like yeah fours and or fives and sixes are your only chances of success uh yeah yeah it's just kind of like that's what a merit trash was 10 years ago that does not exist now and if it does it does not do well mhm I mean as dripping as it is in the flavor text and whatnot um it certainly yeah it feels a little dated but it was fun it was enjoyable cuz there reminds me of a lot of the games we played when we first started hanging out exactly and that's kind of thinned out over time I've seen so many of those yeah exactly no you're right yeah I mean this game is for sure dated like just a simple thing of like okay test will all right I got a success I got a six okay what happens pass fail M uh and you just kind of run with it and I mean there's always the inevitable character that just gets super busted for no Rhyme or Reason they just happen to have I succeed okay gain an ancient artifact oh it's a cursed sphere that adds two the all kills yeah would you say like it's like skill build is like is like a progenitor to several other games or was this like based off or did this also take influence from games before it uh you had skills whenever so in Arkham hor second edition your characters actually had sliders

that if you were good in one thing you were bad in another so like if you chose to increase your skill in lore that meant you were going you were really bad at strength or something so you made those decisions um um I can't really think of any game that kind of took this and and like ran with it and like improved upon it like like other games especially with skills mhm uh it's like having the skill check and then would give you many dies I was just curious yeah reminded you of anything no that's that's a good question but I can't really think of anything that that we've played on I mean cuz like Arkham Horror the card game has your skills but that's based off your deck and you play cards and then you draw the modifier bag mhm so that was whether you succeeded or failed which was that's obviously way better than just rolling four or five dice and just hoping you get a five or six well I thinking like with the the cards and the you know what was it the um what was that like above and below the near and far they use that kind of system the encounter and then a check and then right and then whether you pass or fail is kind of way you get yeah I mean other several other games I could begin to name I know yeah there probably is it's just kind of like Loosely influence but I can't think of anything off the top of my head that it's purely like read a story and then make a check and pass was one of the F early ones that did that and brought

that into prevalence but anyway so the question um no I mean it's a good question because if this game is 10 years old like as games have evolved since then you would think I mean there's a lot of things that's like more recent where you think seventh continent for example introduced that map exploration and then it's like okay well stars of acaros Tainted Grail uh a on trespass all do that same thing but in a potentially better way depending on how much you love so it's like yeah did anything take what eldr hor did and improve upon it probably not I mean because there are the cthulu Mythos and the theme is in so many games cuz it's open source speak uh but nothing in such a way that's like so snippet story driven MH uh cuz most people don't they they want the the story to connect like nothing connects in this game you just have Random Encounters MH oh yes but it builds the story of your character and that's what's fun right yeah exactly and sometimes that's needed versus this whole epic where it's like all right guys we have to do another campaign it's like this feels like we did like a story of a campaign yeah but we're done we lost uh horribly uh to hter again he keeps kicking our ass he sucks I mean because

of the fact that he just dots you for sanity MH um but then there's just like okay well we we we have the miskatonic or the the mountains over there we could have done the dream world the dream world is whenever you rest you can actually portal into the dream world oh nice and deal with like hypnos and it's really funny though because so many Kickstarter Games come out and this obviously wasn't Kickstarter so many kickstarters come out with so much bloat to it and don't Rong this game is the epitome of bloat but whenever we were setting up again because it's been years since I played this and there were only like 16 ancient ones mhm I was like only 16 it it was just so weird to be like oh there's not 70 uh there's a million cards uh the Fantasy Flight little cards uh these insane I have 15 decks over here we didn't even touch uh Jesus like we didn't even touch the cards that destroy cities um we barely touched spells no one really was a spellcaster uh we had one an two ancient artifacts come out um like it it just still blows my mind and I just was reminded again in how much fun this is uh but yeah there's just like oh let's do Haster but really there's only 16 huh but then I forgot that every single ancient one has their own research deck and have has their own special encounters deck the Mythos cards

are not tied to them that's just there's decks of that thick of blue yellow and green okay decks and those are all just random and then you you you make the methos deck based off of the oh okay gotta the so you know if you're fighting Haster you're G to have two rumors come out before you start getting into more green and yellows Goa but other than that yeah it's like eventually you will start dealing with the Unspeakable one deck but that's what because he awakened that's the the deck we had to deal with there's another king and yellow deck that is purely based off the mystery that comes out oh okay and I feel like a lot of games miss out on that I think so many many games like you were mentioning did anything kind of take from this but what nothing what no one took that I think this game does super well is every game wants to include everything that it gives you and something that I find fascinating about this one is there's a bunch of stuff that you just will never touch um just because a certain card didn't come out and tell you to deal with it and I think that that's exciting because whenever you play a game especially and you you see everything M like I know people who would read like event cards before a game just to know them and I'm like I feel like you miss out a lot I like the fact that it's like oh we didn't even see those yeah that's replayability no I agree I was watching a uh uh let's player he was talking about lies of PE because I was watching him play it and so many people were telling him he was missing stuff and

he's like guys this isn't 100% playthrough like missing stuff is a good thing cuz that adds for replayability like you don't want to see everything you don't want to go through every single mystery card you don't want to go through every single other world event thing because then when you replay it it's like oh I've seen that right I like not having having seen everything so every time I play it it feels fresh and out of all the games over the past 10 years this game feels fresh but still dated at the same time it's it's mechanisms are 100% dated uh but still work MH I don't know I I'm not as like we play Madara with dice and it's like uh when like after a while I'm like I'm [ __ ] over these dice but in here it's just kind of like oh oh let's see what I got okay well I didn't get a success all right here's my horrible you know dark packed condition that will just kill me and maybe that's just because I'm not playing it no I'm not playing like right now um I mean it's hard to kind of discuss these games because of just how old they are mhm um I mean I I mean you've played a ton of these youve played Legend of Legend of five rings what yeah I played that you have played that I mean this this style of game is definitely yeah my

style I really enjoy these really yeah the snippet ones oh yeah big time I I love narrating it's fun it is it is a lot of fun I mean and yeah you could just kind of ham it up and have have a good time um I'm actually glad we picked the Antarctica one because it's like it's ELD horror so Halloween just ended but we're coming up on Christmas so it's like ooh the snow snow but even then like what you can do and you can do this with Talisman as well which is another super old game but I didn't filter out the decks like cuz what I could have done was I could have looked through here and been like okay we don't have the um we don't have The Masks of expansion so let me take out all those cards I just because I didn't want to seed through them all right but if you really want to hyper fixate on a very specific expansion like you would with Talisman is you take out all the stuff you're not using and so you only keep you know I only keep the small um you know the small expansions in here and then only keep the that uh the uh mountains of Madness yeah the mountains of mad expansion so a lot of the story is still is more themed to that yeah instead of being like Oh you come across an ancient Relic and the pyramids it's like well the pyramids are a location so it doesn't feel completely out out of it but yeah we would get a lot more stuff that deals with thatly the okay yeah Antarctica uh yeah with Antarctica uh in this game it was like

we did go over there and it was funny I mean cuz even still through the story stuff it was put in we had Jim go through it get all warmed up and get the the guide get the the what it Sherpa and the Snow Dogs and he's going through there and he goes through an ice Maze and he appears out he's like where the [ __ ] am I and then Ran's like oh God right they passed by each other and they're like but and those are the stories that you create that players are telling based off events that have happened instead of just having it all told to you right um and I do feel like that's missed a little bit um it is just a a nice breath of fresh air to just be like we're done like there's not another session of this and it is good also for me who who's I mean I just looked at my ranking of it's an 8.5 on board game Beek who talks about this game in his top 100 all the time kind of looking at it through a little bit of nostalgia whenever I am talking about it's like I haven't played this game in [ __ ] two years uh but I'm still saying it's on my top 100 and it's nice to go back to a game and be like thank God I still like it cuz there are times where it's like oh damn it like it sucks now like I didn't have a good time uh so I don't know I don't know it it's still just it still works for me yeah

I'm glad I didn't come in here and read a bunch of Lovecraft stuff and be like oh [ __ ] I feel weird about it and now I have this tattoo oh no uh I still love his writing it's it's just so so cool um I mean yeah overall like like I'm trying to I'm I'm just trying to to think of other additional additional things to say but it's 10 years old yeah it's it's 10 years old you think it still holds up yeah I had a good time yeah no for sure um I mean it's really not that hard to learn frankly not really yeah I mean the setup's not too bad um well I mean setup is a little bad um given all those decks A lot's a lot of deck deck shuffling there um but just the mechanics within the game I mean I have to say they they keep them pretty similar from game to game is like you know you get your standard you get two actions picked from this list of actions can do yeah um like yeah Mansions of Madness does that too mhm yeah that's probably the one thing that I don't like is the fact that you can only do you get two actions that's fine but you can't do the same action mhm so it's like it I mean it does keep the game kind of going so it's not like you can't really do a lot of combos right but it is like okay we need to get over to the Himalayas we can only travel

once so we can only move one space unless we prepare for travel then we can move further but if you really get into the theme it makes sense it's like we need to get to the Himalayas well that's not going to be a [ __ ] day trip it's the Himalayas we need to get all the way to Antarctica but I'm in London you got a while you got especially not in this is set in like the 20s you're taking a ship dude [ __ ] that yeah no right this is over months so if you take the actions kind of as they are thematically it's not that big of a deal but also it it it's quick your turns are boom boom boom all right everyone deal with with encounters and this is also a game where I'm invested in what happening is happening to the other players M I'm excited to read a story um and and they also did something really cool is when your characters go down you actually can go have an interaction with them and get like a send off to try and get their stuff and see what happened to them when they went insane or they went down do the health right that's really cool uh another thing this game did to try and streamline it which just wasn't happening was um the Prelude cards which we didn't do I we just handpicked what we wanted to play but the Prelude cards is a massive deck you just Shuffle and some of them will tell you to throw in the you know the Mystic deck some will tell you to put in

the uh Egypt sideboard uh some will tell you to put in uh side Adventures that you can go on okay um that and I always thought that that was cool that again it's another thing where you're not going to see everything most of them are just like I think one I think the one I did draw for us to initially use was it allowed us to like look through and take tasks from this from this deck like we would have all started with like certain tasks oh okay on our thing but even the Prelude cards have flavor text yeah to even just kind of somewhat seed the setup there's a lot of still really good ideas that I think a lot of games can still benefit from uh but they got to make them all campaigns uh yeah I think still .5 huh still an 8.5 yeah yeah I was going to I was thinking about bump get up to a N9 but I think I am I'm I'm more comfortable keeping it at an 8.5 uh setup is still a bear M um yeah for sure but I will say like even after all these years it was funny CU I was like okay let's do a refresher on the rules and I was able to just still tell you how to play the game right and I was like man I'm amazed I'm actually remembering this I can't even remember games we just played the other day uh

but this one is just stuck stuck in my head keep it an 8.5 because of nostalgia um like I just remember playing this like on the floor like we used to play games on the floor uh when we then have a table big enough to I know it's like off my back God Christ uh yeah I'm not going to play this game all the time because it's long um but one of these days I do because it it can play up to eight nice um I think yeah like uh I if I I will say if I didn't have the um crate this game would never get [ __ ] touched oh yeah if I just said baggies of stuff oh [ __ ] that of all the different cards yeah the crate is is wonderful uh yes it plays up to eight players damn and every gate spawn is two gates you spawn four Clues whenever the icon shows up and every and then monster surges three I don't even know how I'd get eight people I think the max I've ever had for this is six be cool though be fun it would be it would be like yeah I'd be down for an eight-man Talisman uh that plays God how much does that play up to I think it's six remember we did that at Gen Con we had like six or seven it took us like all night we had to go to another event because that guy didn't even know how to play his own game uh well four people were like new that's true it plays up to six yeah we had six

people yeah and it was like four of them were new and it was me and you and I was like dude I'm like dude no um Talisman is another one will'll redo uh I was almost going to do both of them today but I want I want more people for Talisman because it's competitive this was easy to do uh I mean theoretically there's nothing stopping uh like you from running having playing two people and running four characters this game is so easy to manage multiple players or multiple investigators which is nice um on scale 1 to 10 what are you giving it uh I will give it you would saw it eight eight it's a fun game yeah um yeah enjoy it unique assets um definitely probably one of the better iterations of this of you know fantasy flights take on the lovecraftian board game uh yeah definitely a good one enjoy I'd replay it had a good time with it yeah love the the small form story mhm yeah eight solid eight nice yeah there's in terms of Lovecraft games there's this one Arkham over the card game and cthulu death may die are the three oh that was that battle heavy one wasn't it that yeah that's the one where it's kind of like you Shuffle to you Shuffle like an ancient one and then a story box uh we played it at that bar at Gen Con yeah I remember where what you can play as Rasputin yeah um that one is

also fantastic and that one was all is is kind of like a different style of Lovecraft which is still done really really well um in fact uh shortly probably next year I'll be getting a cthulu sized one that's basically like that galacti this oh that' be cool uh so very excited for that but yeah those are basically my three Lovecraft games and I'm very excited that this game still holds up for me nice all right well that is it everyone that's our thoughts on alrich horror let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved