Skip to main content
Loading video...

Barrage Digital Review: Great Implementation, But Quite Limited

Transcript 7:35

Hello and welcome to Borovit. Today we're doing something a little bit different and we're going to review Barrage Digital. Now, you may know if you're a fan of the channel that Barrage is one of our all-time favorite games and we jumped at the chance when the publisher sent us uh or offered us a review code. And please note that Barrage Digital is currently only available on Steam. So if you don't know what barrage is, it is a heavy euro for one to four players with a theme of building hydroelect electric dams in the Alps. Now it's full of complexity, hard decisions, brutality between players, and you know that because of all those things, we love it. We love the tight resources, the tough decisions, the meanness. It's terrific.

But we're not going to be talking about the game itself in this review, just the app. So if you want to know more about Barrage, please check out our review which we will link in the description below. Firstly, let's tackle the app itself. So in terms of being a digital implementation approach, I think it ticks all the right boxes. Now starting to play, I was able to just jump straight into a game with AI opponents and go because everything was intuitive and I will admit I am intimately familiar with barrage. But it was nice that I didn't really need to spend time learning how the interface worked. It just came naturally. There is a tutorial if you don't know how to play Barrage or you just would like a refresher. And I didn't use it, but the friend who I played with said that he used it and it was very good at explaining barrage, but he did lament the fact there was no way to go backwards to previous instructions and information. Now, in terms of implementing BR, I think that there's a lot of fun theming. You have some great background music, nice sound effects.

The display works really well. You know, you can hover over things and it gives you all the extra information such as faction powers or scoring conditions. So, in terms of it being a vehicle to play Barrage, I am quite impressed. The one negative I have about actually playing barrage in this format is the lack of ability to undo your actions. So when you play against AI opponents, I found it to be quite generous in that regard, but when you play against human opponents, it seems much more restricted and it's a little bit frustrating because you have to click end turn to end your turn. So there is a clear point before which you should be able to undo your actions. Now it's not that safe. If you click on one thing, you you are stuck with that. You can always X out of that. But for example, I had the issue where when I had done an energize action, I had accidentally not selected a contract and then after the energized action was complete, I couldn't undo that in a game with human opponents. And this obviously can have a big impact on scoring and and you kind of bonuses if you're not getting the items from a contract or the points from a contract.

And this is also something that would never happen in a reall life game on the table where the issues with barrage digital arise are all to do with outside of actually playing Barrage. For example, it's a $15 buyin, but all you get is the base game of Barrage despite there being a wealth of expansion content out there for the game. And I was told that they are working on bringing in uh expansion content and maps and they will be offered at a very low price considering the initial buyin price. But for me, I feel like it was very much a missed opportunity to include the Lee Water project from the start, especially considering it was a day one expansion for Barrage. personal opinion of course, but for us, the Lee Water expansion allows you to have options that are kind of lateral to problem solve and it makes the game more robust. And I always have felt that when that expansion is taken out, it is a a lesser, more restrictive game. And I think it come it comes across as one of those occasions where initially was part of the game and then they stripped it out for the Kickstarter to offer us extra content and also to to simplify the main game to get a wider audience.

So that would have been great to have been in there from the start. Then I'm rather disappointed in the options to play barrage. When you take the AI opponents, every time I've played against them, I've wiped the floor with them. I found them very easy to compete against and there is no difficulty options. Now these are supposed to be added at some point but currently they're not there. Then with online matchmaking there is no way to find your friends and there is no way uh no intention to implement that for now. So, you have to basically either host a match and hope they find you or kind of just look at the batches available and and join one and hope it's your friends, which is quite frustrating if you're trying to play with friends. Although, not so much a problem at the moment because I've never seen more than one game being hosted at a time in the online servers. But then that flips to another problem that is there a lot of human players around who you can actually play with even if you're not looking to play with friends cuz often there are no matches being held and I guess time will tell with that. So, in summary, if you're looking for just the opportunity to to play barrage against AI opponents and just kind of play it digitally, then I definitely recommend this as a great implementation of barrage and the best looking implementation of barrage digitally. Uh, especially as the AI difficulties are supposed to be

coming. However, if you're looking for something more, eg you want the expansion content available, you want to try out different barrage maps, you want to play online with your friends, then we can't recommend this because it's just not the there yet or you'll have to pay extra for what you want or it might never happen. As a final thought, the hardest thing to reconcile with Barrage Digital is the price verse the lack of options. You know, you can only play it on Steam. If you want to play with friends, everyone needs their own copy. And it's even weirder when you consider that Barrage is available on Board Game Arena. And I think I would personally rather pay the extra for the subscription to Board Game Arena uh Premium to then get access to the 100 other games on there. And and if you're going to play with friends, only one of you needs premium, so you can just split that cost. Uh it's just a very strange proposition I think uh in terms of this implementation but it's also worth noting that I and we we're not people who play digitally very often. We have experience with it on board game arena and tabletop simulator but we're not someone who goes out looking for digital implementations. So what we're saying and what we are looking for might not reflect what people who play a lot of digital digital implementations are looking for. Just keep that in mind. But that is our

review of Barrage Digital. Hope it was helpful. If it was, please consider subscribing and we will see you next time. Thanks for watching.

Progress saved