Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 31:58

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for vignos the deluxe edition specifically the 2016 edition because we have not played the 2010 so there will be no comparisons there but if i had to guess uh based off the ranking and everything of a board game geek 2016 is the way to go slightly better uh slightly better people that you seem to think yeah so uh all right so this is your first villa lasarda game this is your fourth technically because we've played escape plan on mars and co2 um i have played all of those and i love all of his but i'm more interested to hear your guys's thoughts so we will start with brett this is certainly a more complex and more layered game than i am used to than i have typically enjoyed however and this is my second time playing second time is absolutely better but i still am forgetting key things i still you know have so much stuff to keep track of losing track of them and those kinds of things because then i look back at a turn later and i go crap and it's too late yeah and i totally understand and i totally get it it's just my mind doesn't like to work that way as i'm playing games now that's my opinion as a review of the game itself uh it's it's it's very good and it's not as bizarrely complicated as as other ones that i have played and have

not enjoyed um it it certainly gets easier after considering consider first playthrough being learning how to play right not even thinking about strategies much and seeing what works out this time i actually tried to develop a strategy and i didn't do badly no i didn't do badly uh at all the point spread was actually it seemed almost equal me to you and you the cat and i think this was roughly the score last time we played i think i think each i think you got a little bit higher i did a little bit less and then i accidentally uh miscalculated cats points the last time i gave her an extra 10 but she i think without that i think she did about the same i think maybe last time you did a little bit better but i don't exactly remember um but it's consistent well it basically i did because i think you got a point for each like person you had and i like doubled that amount of points because you were supposed to get like 10 and i gave you 20.

um but still what's amazing about that is the fact of how balanced it is because we did not play it the same way and the points for this strategy was roughly equal to the same amount of points of the last strategy that we all tried um so in terms of this game and we'll get we'll jump to cat real quick and i'll talk about specifics of the game um what do you think this game is thematic this is actually more of an open-ended question for being a wine mogul yeah a winemaker i mean you're not you're not a grape stomper true but you're definitely the person who's behind the scenes of like i wanted to start this to make money like i am too i am making money more than i am making memories uh being that chick off of fox news that whenever she's stomping the cranberries and she falls it was on i don't know if it was fox news it was on the news so yeah because she tried to go fast and then she like fell out and just ate it oh yeah she just was milking it um it probably [ __ ] hurt yeah i think overall in theme uh i think it does a a pretty good job for this kind of heavy euro game because normally all euro games are kind of like oh there's no theme which has drastically changed over the years but his games are always every action you do and everything you're doing has some ambulance of oh that makes sense yeah that's that was one of the things i i absolutely appreciate is literally every i cannot think of a

single rule or a single mechanic that doesn't play into the theme in a logical way which makes it easier to remember all of these rules yeah they're not abstract they're like you know so renown makes sense it builds up as the place gets more valuable and then you utilize it when you sell or export yep and then you're like oh hey this is from from uh this is the porto wine or this is uh from ribatejo and they're like oh wow okay and then they offer you more points for it but then the market gets flooded and the renown goes down exactly and so exactly it's it's really cool because that was the first uh instance where i was like that doesn't make sense because we both were in dow the first time we played and then you sold twice and used them all there were like four renown there and i'm like well that sucks because i don't get to and then as we started playing i'm like no that does make sense because you were the first one to tap into the market and i technically would follow and they're like who gives a [ __ ] about your wine we got this guys it's not special now yeah uh which i love that's what i love about his games is you have to understand the rules very much but then once you start playing you're like oh i can do this because this i because this makes thematic sense so it i wouldn't say i don't know if it makes it easier to teach but it's easier to retain which helps because yeah you are absolutely right this game i don't think i think there was one hiccup with understanding wine quality and wine value which is easily the hardest thing to understand about this game um

because they're they they are very much hand in hand oh yeah but so it's like oh well what they're following separately and they're in here separately yeah but once you figure that out then it makes sense because then it's like you look at the number and you're like oh well i should that should be what it sells for but do my knowledges help no they did yeah they helped when their production happened now it's already there it's already in the casket so now it's just being sold you know and along with um thematic the iconography again somewhat complex but once you get it you get it yeah because everything that appreciates quality is in a barrel and everything that appreciates value is in a circle it is in that circle it only matters when you sell or export or or present yeah and and i i really like that because the only the there there are a few negatives i have about the game and one of them is the iconography it's not that it's hard to remember it's the fact that there's five different books that's talked about uh i really really hate how it was presented because it's like it's like you have a 2010 reserve book you have a 2016 book you have the the rule reference and it's just like and it's like but the rule reference is literally only it has set up why is the setup not in the rulebook for that version the reference book should have literally been exactly that oh i need to find what the icons mean um and what what the magnet tiles do which book says look in that book yes yeah yeah and that's exactly kind of what they are and it's just it's very fiddly when you're looking

because there were times where i was looking for uh what something was doing or uh and it was i was like what this doesn't make any sense and it's like oh nope i was looking through the 2010 rule book uh which is just it it's very very annoying these are absolutely useless these player these playwrights they tell you they're the only thing that's useful here is the production the wine production thing on it because you know what to add i thought the inside was more helpful than anything i always told you what the actions did right they're useless um i i i just i wish that this would have been they could have put the icons in here very so so there's not one person oh oh you want to know what that does okay well let me oh no that's the wrong book sorry that's the wrong book here's the right book for you to look up just one more why they included stuff from the 2010 well probably because people preferred that maybe people prefer the 2010.

and it's cool you get two slightly different games yeah without having to buy a whole different set or an expansion yeah so it is all condensed and i like that but it should have been one uh like condensed rulebook for it all um but cat after playing on mars co2 escape line and this one what do you think of this one i like it vastly better than all of them yes cool how come um it's uh one a theme that i enjoy a lot um you don't like terraforming mars or worlds games actually i want to be real honest or world pollution world pollution that's just more depressing it very much is um as it goes yeah co2 um we just really didn't we being me and crystal just didn't play because it's just you guys were you and steven were just getting so into it that it's like we might as well just let them have their fun and we did we forgot you guys were we existed we just didn't even tell you we were leaving we just left yeah and we were just like oh after we were done we're like where'd they go yeah um and then on mars um i talked to people about it i was actually just talking about it the other day with one of my co-workers and uh it's just i think the mars theme is tired and overdone and it's just everywhere and then um what was the other one escape plan escape plan it was it was the game set you didn't do the heist it was you trying to get out of the city after a

heist yeah in in that one just i remember playing it the first couple of times and it just didn't really hold like my attention oh you've actually played five now you gallerist oh yeah see and with that one we just don't even remember i still have it because i want to give it another shot but yeah that one didn't quite click for us yeah that one didn't really click either um so i would probably put that in the um escape plan kind of in the same vein of just like this didn't really hold my attention okay this one though i like the theme i love the art um it's graspable graspable um the playthrough video that we watched really helped paul grove and gaming rules playing it once and then going over the rules again was enough honestly like like a kind of like a trial play through was easy just to like okay well this is what we're actually getting um it just it works it works really well it's not that com complex for a beautiful starter game this is this is yeah yeah this one is is uh incredibly good especially uh multiple playthroughs because you it the the pacing is just so well done um because in the first i mean they're each individual years um but you essentially the first row before the first fair you have three production and i like that because you have multiple attempts you essentially have six actions before the fair to build up your um your estate

your production yeah your engine essentially and then the second before the second part you only have four and it's like oh [ __ ] i have less to do but you should have already you become more efficient you don't do as much it's like okay well now i can hire farmers i can hire enologists i can go with sellers now and constantly increase so then each ferry you should be giving out more higher quality wine it's almost a little bit like great western trail each trick trip trip around up to kennedy you should have better cows to sell you should have better wine to sell um and then by the final end you're doing your basically your one last hurrah but really what's fantastic about the pacing is all that leads up to the fact that you get rid of some wine some shitty wine to get these green magnates for free actions as well as by the end of it then you're really trying to get the barrels for the end game which i i love i always love end game scoring uh and and unique tiles there's so many tiles that can come out uh and there's strategy around that that's why i went first because there were tiles out there that i wanted over uh someone else getting so i was like [ __ ] okay well i don't need another person so i'll go first but at any time you can call a press release and then just oh i have a level you know i have a 10 it makes it the 15 and jump ahead and really get the crunch of more fair points or more money which is what i usually was doing i'm like i need money i'm always poor it's the second time i

had no money by the end of the game um but it's just incredibly well balanced without feeling like you're just like mentally exhausted by the end of the game yeah um there are a bunch of different ways to score points there's a bunch of different ways to build an engine and all of them work yeah you know you focused on two regions and that's all you did one day i spread out over four last time i had five oh yeah you had all five estates last game oh [ __ ] i didn't know that yeah and and each of them were producing lower quality wines yeah but i had a lot more i could do with when spending them exporting um selling buying magnates yeah um this time i kind of went in the middle and i got more workers because you showed the value of that before yeah my seriously get a single visitor or a tourist you did not get a tourist uh i didn't even think about it what's cool is that the mini expansions are they're so they add just a little bit and it's not like oh god what does this whole thing do yeah like the only thing probably is the expert pack just because you have to look at the icons but yeah the the tourists are just oh hey they just had one value yeah which is great for exporting or selling or the fare just a little boost yeah when you said that we were going to be playing with with an expansion i was like and they have sort of an expansion yeah exactly and they have two more one is an island which adds a new region and the other one uh was i think it was like combined estates like like combined like

buildings um i i don't know exactly what that one does uh but what if because mine it mine on the surface doesn't look like it has and has an idea can you guys guess what my strategy was this game now my strategy was to have high amount of fair points the entire game i wanted to win the fair each time and at the very beginning that's why i went for the porto region so i can immediately because it was a plus two that at straight out the gate i'm gonna go do a press release together get up twelve or fifteen i think that's what it was um and then just sold it and then i just maintained that lead and that because that nets out to be 27 36 points if you're in first the whole time yep that's interesting my strategy was to just have one a good one have a good winery yeah um but i will say that that was actually it wasn't hard to maintain the fair points it was hard to do everything else because i was so strapped for cash like there was a time where i literally had one wine tile and you had a bunch cat had a bunch and i'm sitting there and i'm like i can't export i can't sell uh all right uh i guess i'll just wait till the next year to where i can do something um but i wanted to maintain that lead the entire time and i also wanted to try and show uh these people i wanted to be like are these valuable to have and yes they are incredibly valuable in the 2010 version you can use as many of

these as you want on your turn in 2016 you can only use one uh which i don't really care for that i wish you can use multiple because using multiple means you can't use them in the fair true and since you can have an unlimited number of them yeah that seems like an abstract yeah uh so i didn't quite care one rule that doesn't seem to fit the theme yes because you have all of them but it's it's like because i i usually bribe one of them at a time huh i guess so you hire them because i get the magnate because that would be kind of too busted yeah um these can well i don't know some of them are just a little bit i mean i certainly can't reuse them yeah but i can see limiting maybe two at a time yeah well because a lot of them seem to be like based off of helping out on actions or do well especially and i'm focused on the green ones because that's what i have the most yes yeah like so it's like okay well this one is i can buy i can buy an estate for two right now and then if i need to buy like because i could technically find the money which i never did is buy three estates now states three wineries i guess the i guess the real power is that these let you do an action without going to this exactly so yeah i can see doing two or three or four different actions on one turn that would be busted uh but so basically everybody can yeah but that would just be i wouldn't like it too much too much to keep yeah i think i think having these because they don't they are not actions they are just oh we're down there let you use someone else's person peek at the next year stuff like that that that is fine um if

you're giving up fair points or influence for them exactly and we're here yeah and giving up yeah getting getting boosted on fair points the the cool thing about having the green magnet tiles and a bunch of them like you did and and i did is it give you it gives you options oh i'm all the way up here and like for example if i had the sell one i could have been like oh i'll use that because i don't have any money to go down there boom i can still sell or the export one that i could have i was gonna actually put it out there uh so it just gives you variety in case someone happens to get in your way the other thing i love about this game is the player conflict is minimal and non-aggressive yeah it's you go somewhere i only have to pay you one baggage but because money's so tight for me because of the way you were managing the way i was yes most of the time i had plenty of money yeah um and i still have plenty of money didn't add up to a winning strategy but it wasn't a bad one either right i mean still you were only uh 15 points away from um it got down to two maybe one at one point but i never ran out yeah yeah i ran out multiple times and haven't having to go there so money is so tight that going to a place it's like oh i know he's probably going to want to sell yeah i'll go there because it doesn't hurt for me to sell and now he can't go there and it's like oh that sucks yeah um but yeah i i like that using the renowned cubes

it's something that you can visually see you you like games where you can see what everyone is doing this is a game that you can and and and i did that many times it's like i can sell this one do they have a renown well let me try this one yeah because it wasn't yeah that's actually why these are here so you can see how many wineries other people have uh but you can also count these because these are limited as well you can try and flood the like hire all the farmers so people can't get farmers yeah i mean we've never run out of those resources but it does feel like almost every resource is scarce you know like barrels you know because i wasn't focused on acquiring them last time i was running out this time i knew to get them so yeah so i had plenty yes now or later yep to get to get the magnets at the end or or export yeah but we never you know accept money i don't think we've ever regularly run out of any resources no i think it's one of these where it's like everyone can have a little bit of everything or two people can have all of them yeah uh because for example well you did totally monopolize one region yeah yes you yeah and you scr uh you didn't screw me but we we stopped each other because we both started with uh liz boa yeah and so i took a red then you took a red so then i couldn't have another vineyard in that spot and it's little things like that where it's like oh but it's not like [ __ ] you you know it's it's never personal it's just like oh man okay i'll try and work around that that's why i abandoned liz boa i'm like i could have bought it put another um uh estate there to help but yeah i

i didn't have enologist this whole time um i focused on the two things that increased quality for the the uh uh duro region which would sell for higher fair points and then the uh tres montes region would give you extra fare points so i was like oh let's try something different this time and they have two other regions yes and uh you can actually this is the setup that they recommend for a three-player game you don't have region seven um you can actually mix and match and you take you always have seven regions no one two three four five six you have eight regions in a three player game and you can take one of them out it doesn't have to be seven it could be oh this time dao is not here um so you have variety in the game but yeah this one if i had to rank all the vital games right now galarus is on the bottom um because that one i think the problem with the gallerist is we expected it to be very complicated like on mars and then we're like is that it uh i wanted to sold it to ourselves right i want to try that one they should probably try that one it i'm sure it's good uh but we need to give it another shot but it's that one and for the record i have not played kanban or liz boa but they are right over there i think kanban will be pretty cool but yeah so gallerist then escape plan

on mars on mars is really good um it's just extremely complicated this one and then co2 uh so i mean other than that like i mean it's weird because i feel like there should be more we can talk about but there's really not without getting like extremely nitty-gritty you guys have any negatives about the game i personally do not you do not just and against personal preference um complexity and so many different avenues to score points it's hard for me to tell like you know i completely gave up on trying to get any fair points yeah i wound up actually doing okay yeah there was actually multiple times you probably could have just gotten rid of one of your uh yellows and jump up or pay the second place and got more points for it yeah but it seemed hopeless so i gave up yeah and then suddenly i'm jumping forward 12. funny enough it actually that wasn't a part of my strategy but it actually ended up working subconsciously because i jumped up so high so quick that it's like well i'm never going to catch up but it's like why there's nothing no reason why no one else can also sell up proved that that was not not correct right it just because that was only four points behind me yeah it felt that way at the time yeah but you know even with me not focusing on that yeah still did okay 29 points i do like that i like how it doesn't reset every fair so it's it's a it's a struggle we're not struggling it's competition fair like fair competition to try and get past each other uh to try and get the the increasing points over the course of this like oh

these people come to the fair every year they're really good we're only getting better each year yeah we've kind of built like a um reputation yeah i was trying to say a rapport that would also work too yeah i will also say um negatives um minor but worth mentioning for me the grid quadrile okay that does double duty as different actions and as different places to move i feel it's an unnecessary complication that doesn't enhance or change much okay all it does is give you a penalty for going to a place if the turn marker happens to be on it and oh yeah and the taxation marker yeah it just feels like you're messing with the two things that don't make any sense to go together that's all yeah i can't think of another way it's very minor yeah but i like it uh because i've played as other games and how term structure works and how actions work and this one it you don't have much to think about you can go anywhere if you and maybe there's a small penalty if you go too far uh and you have to pay an extra money yeah or you can potentially pay in a three-player game one for going too far two three four if the markets are so you can get really hosed if everyone happens to be in the same spot and the turn markers there and it's far away but but that penalty never never really came up especially in this one

not as a penalty just as it's unnecessary to match up those two concepts on one board okay and and i don't see any benefits there's a tiny penalty for it but it's fairly random yeah so i just don't see a point in complicating it on the other hand it does save production costs yeah rather than having a separate tracking mechanism uh so it is a very minor nitpick right for me it just confuses things slightly in a way that isn't necessary okay yeah i think uh on my side i think the it's it's so inconsequential that it doesn't i i don't even think about it but okay cool fair fair fair one actually thing that is important what do you guys think of the weather gear tiles do you guys like that mechanism um i think it gives it an extra challenge um and something to kind of shake it up a little bit it's also realistic because weather does affect you know how yeah and how this is supposed to be each each square is a year so it's they get reset so it's like it's not that the weather was rainy all year it's that when we during um production season for x1 productions yeah yeah and the fact that at least bruno plays into that yeah other than that again this is two concepts that don't have anything to do with each other except that you know bad weather he has lower expectations oh yeah for true value yeah i i really like that i think yeah they don't relate but it's just yeah like it would be annoying to have another set of tile you have to flip so

that's the they they come up at the same time well in the same concept so they're easy to keep separate right and once again it's never you you know that you know the threshold it's going to be negative 2 up to positive 2. you don't know the order but you can plan for that and there's business people are here that you can have oh i'm going to see what the next tile is so you can plan ahead yeah i don't know if i'd ever use that it's it but i get the reason why someone would i probably wouldn't either but yeah it is there so people aren't pissed off by well i great i didn't have any of those regions like oh well okay well there's a person who can help you plan ahead if you want to get a new estate build or plan ahead for the weather yeah oh yeah i'm planning ahead for the what with the weather so i i do enjoy that i think it does have add theme um all right do you guys have anything else i i yeah i mean everything this game is just incredibly well balanced uh that i thoroughly thoroughly enjoy it so on a scale of oh actually sorry with the expansions i'm not really gonna talk about the experts pack they're there um i actually enjoy the experts we didn't touch them at all last time we played um i like they they do add quite a bit gives you more variety just like the magnates what do you guys think of the tourists they're just they're little helpers yeah i'm glad it didn't add you know a whole new set of rules it was just something to give you a little boost yeah yeah and you used it multiple times and there were multiple times where it's like oh man because with your with your two people that's how you were able to get

those points otherwise you wouldn't have been able to block um block him or go here right so they actually do come in handy because it's a game where it's like you were talking about how the starting setup won bago one money doesn't make a difference for you going last and but i i would i would argue the entire game one thing does make a difference yeah like one down that's just one yeah so that just shows how well balanced the and designed the game is yeah um so with that being said on a scale of one to ten what would you guys give it brett i am interested especially because we literally played like two days ago yeah and this is um probably actually i would now probably say at this point anachrony had to be more complex and of course i wasn't playing it fully because i wasn't remembering all the tutorials and mechanics so um so um again i'm not going to rate this for me i'm going to rate this what would you rate it i always rate it for me yeah that side your rating well i understand you can give two i guess but i i would say that of this level of game um i would probably say a seven overall um for me personally five okay um again just two more to keep track of sure but for people who enjoy that level of complexity really good and again the theme makes it easier to remember all the rules okay even for someone who doesn't want to true yeah yeah yeah so i mean because some people are like well this game isn't for me so it's a two it's just like that doesn't okay

exactly yeah you know i'm trying to take my personal opinion out of it but i'm explaining what my influencing factor is i would i would put it in seven okay on on a regular scale awesome all right cat gonna give it that dang old nine nine awesome really truly liked it very surprised for reveal to start against because i just yeah that's not my cup of tea yeah i man here's the thing uh whenever i i like i mentioned earlier before we started recording i always stayed away specifically from this one because i had viticulture and i was like why would i have two games about wine making well vinnie culture is actually about wine making yes uh you you are kind of running the things the machines there is the love of the craft and then this is the i need a profit margin this is the business side so i can i can say if there are people are asking will i own one should i get the other absolutely yeah um do i like i i still prefer vadi culture over this one um but that's because it has a plethora of expansions and it's a work replacement game um and so it's still really good but they are both fantastic i was initially feeling an eight when i was uh whenever i was gonna rank it but as we talked about it more and more my only nitpicks are are this thing which i mean if i'm only gonna play one version then fine that here's the rule book in the reference but the other one in the box but the other one in the box so that's fine i can overlook it but yeah everything is so

well balanced so tight-knit you don't feel punished for making decisions you have ways to work around if someone happens to get in your way i'm gonna agree with you cat i think i'm gonna give this a nine as well um it it's it's really good and if you wanna add more complexity then you just there's two more little mini expansions if you want so that is that that is our thoughts on vinos uh the 2016 edition let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever come up today it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved