This Board Game Review Practice Has To Stop.
Transcript
This is a full-fledged knee-jerk react to a video I just saw from a pretty big creator. I'm saying pretty big cuz I'm sort of hiding the identity because it's not about the particular YouTuber that put this video out. It's about a practice that I think is completely wrong, completely unethical, and until recently, I didn't really realize how hurtful this practice might actually be. And that practice is the practice of a of not disclosing the number of times that you've actually played a game, not giving a game it's due diligence before actually putting out a review, the BS practice of a mini review for games in which that you didn't play enough to actually necessitate a full review. The video in question attacked a game that I've loved, and um if you did enough sleuthing, you could probably figure out what it is. I'm not going to say what it is because it's not about the game per se.
It's about the people behind these games. First and foremost, recently I've realized as I'm starting to meet more and more people around the industry, especially small creators and especially small publishers and designers, these are really awesome people, first and foremost. And they're awesome people like you and I that have dreams. They have dreams of doing something really cool, and they're putting everything out there. And then there's people like myself that sit back on a high horse and flippantly, you know, throw out perspectives on their dream, on their creations, on their hundreds, if not thousands, of hours of work, and I don't think that the criticism is wrong in and of itself. I think the transparency around your criticism is completely and utterly 100% a requirement. If you are making a video and you're not disclosing how many times you've played it, and you're not thoroughly going through the different aspects of the game and explaining why exactly you don't like the game, bottom line, you have no business reviewing it. I don't care if the algorithm makes you want to put out more and more videos and you don't have time to actually play the games, just don't make it. In this mini review of this game, there was no transparency around the number of plays that had taken place. And this is a game that I really liked, and I don't care that this person doesn't like it. I care that clearly, based upon the words that were coming out of their mouth, they barely
played it. There's no way that they would have said the things they did if they played it even two times, or maybe three. And you know what? Maybe this person did play it many times, but the fact is they didn't disclose it, and they did about a 2-minute rant on a game that took somebody thousands of hours to create, and in an industry that is so incredibly small and so incredibly niche, the people at the top can swing a hammer and crush that dream. Now, I'm not letting off smaller creators like myself and smaller. We have a responsibility as well. While we don't swing the full hammer to crush the dream, we can certainly chip off of that dream. And I want criticism in the board game industry. That is definitely something I want, but I want nuance. The idea for this video actually started to crystallize a few days ago as I watched BoardGameCo's video on you need more than a rating is essentially what he said.
And that is exactly why I created Cardboard. This is not a commercial for Cardboard whatsoever. Cardboard is my thousand-hour plus creation, and that's fine if you criticize it, but the spirit in which it was created was based upon nuance and transparency and community. When you review a game on Cardboard, it goes into a database and I start to create a game personality, and I start to match you with others. So, if somebody starts to look at your profile and your reviews, they know how much how in line each of you actually are with each other and and your particular game preferences. On top of that, I have you rate whether you like, dislike, or neutral on the game aspects, the nuance of the game. So, if you don't have time to go through and and write a long dissertation, I don't blame you. That's why I added these aspects in the game so you could say what you liked and what you didn't like.
And then on top of that, I track your plays. Not only do I track your plays, I track your enjoyment on every single play. So, guess what? Somebody can look at your review where you're tearing apart a game and they see that you've played it two times, okay, whatever, not a very big deal, move on. But if you've played it 10 times and you have a high match and you're trashing the game, okay, well, maybe that's not something that deserves much more of your time. Go look at a couple other reviews from people that you have a high match score with. I want to hold up content creators as much as possible, especially the ones that are ethically reviewing games, giving them the fair shake, and transparently communicating to the audience what they did and didn't enjoy, and also how many times they did play the actual game. It is in my opinion that we put way too much faith in the hands of very few people, and there's evidence of this on BGG where one review from one of these very big people shoots a game to the very top of the list. I'm arguing for a hobby of kindness, of respect, of morality, most importantly of transparency. And there's nothing that pissed me off more than watching this little snippet, this reductive view of a game that had no nuance whatsoever, no discussion on the meta elements of the game, reduced it to one mechanism that is only one real part of the game, and most importantly, it hurt somebody that I've recently met and liked a lot. And I've played their games a lot. I understand
the nuance quite a bit, and I know for a fact that this person was wrong. This was not a matter of preference differences, cuz I am all for that. This was a matter of unethically speaking of a game that they did not have time enough to play, or maybe they made the mistake of not saying that they played it once. If you happen to believe in these same ethics, come over to Cardboard. I'm trying to create a community right this second that is based on transparency and nuance. This is based off of learning about games from everybody, not just content creators. And if you're a content creator and you agree with this, come on over to Cardboard. Start logging your plays. There's this journal that any person can go and see your full experience, comments throughout plays, all of the different ratings that you've given each play for enjoyment, even how your perspective on a game has changed over time. This is also something that Alex brought up in his video. Because you could be really hot on a game out of the gates, and then it just fall to the wayside, and vice versa. There are games that are like an onion. The more layers you peel, they the more they expose you can't possibly know what that game is after a couple of plays. If you are one of those people, come over to Cardboard.
Let's create a new community that's not based off of flippant reviews trying to get views for the sake of them. Let's connect each other based upon our own preferences. Let's quantify what that actually is. Creators, connect your accounts and let's show everyone on the platform what their match is with you, what their match is with the specific game, because I calculate all of that stuff. I've been really passive about promoting Cardboard for the most part, and it really comes from a place of wanting to stay as humble as I develop this thing, but I know that this system of nuance and transparency is better than the system of impressions and mini reviews. And if you're a publisher that's seeing this for whatever reason, let's chat. I want to hold you up. I want to interview you. I want to tell your story to everybody else out there in YouTube. That is one of my missions right now is to really just create a better community, and to disincentivize hot takes that are without nuance. Hot takes are great, impressions are fine, but bring the nuance and be transparent.
I'm putting this rant out for immediate release. This was a full knee-jerk, not at all what I was working on. I'm working on a round table review of Arcs that is full of an hour worth of nuance. So, if this hits home, go to Cardboard, subscribe here, let's create a better community, let's bring all these like-minded people together, and we can leave the ones in which that are chasing views, likes, or just want to be nasty with uninformed hot takes, we'll leave them behind. We don't need to be the biggest community. We just want to be the best community. Have a great day.