Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is Terraforming Mars: Ares Expedition Better Than The Original? - TCbH Review

Transcript 8:21

terraforming mars aries expedition is the new standalone sequel to the hit 2016 engine building game attempting to take the cold industry of the original and combining it with the now classic round resolution from san juan and race for the galaxy trying to mix it all up into a rich gooey loaf of terraforming goodness and for the most part they succeed but before we get to too many direct comparisons let's first take a look at this game on its own merits aries expedition is a competitive one to four player card game with a cooperative variant which if you look at my script card game is in quotations because the lines are getting pretty blurry on what constitutes a card game since you also have boards meters tokens and resources galore nonetheless each player represents a corporation with its own unique abilities striving for economic dominion and capitalistic prosperity through the act of privatizing the noble goal of making it possible for human habitation on mars at the start of the round all players pick one of their five phase cards from their hand simultaneously reveal and any revealed phases are resolved for all players that round here's the thing there are a few catches first off you cannot play the same phase card that you played for last round no repeat seized by the same player and second if multiple players play the same phase card for this round then it still only amounts to one resolution of that

phase for this round and third during each phase resolution if you were one of the players who played the card to create that phase in the first place then you get a little added bonus and extra little mwah just a cherry on top to make the action a little bit more powerful for you while all other players get the basic version of that phase resolution so you say jack what are the phases well i'm glad you asked development allows you to play green cards which by and large increase your production of the game's various resources as well as increase your steel and titanium which in contrast to the original are static discounts to affiliated cards rather than a resource in and of themselves which is actually pretty cool construction is where you play blue and red cards blue for ongoing inactivatable abilities and red for usually spectacular but one off abilities action is where you do the bulk of your terraforming not only can you take the actions of each of your blue activatable cards but you can also take standard projects to convert money or plant and heat resources to increase global parameters gaining terraforming rating a point value and money making metric as you go and cute little forest tokens held in your personal supply worth even more points at the end of the game which brings us to the last two phases production is where you get your fat stacks you get money for your mega credit production plus your terraforming rating you get plants and heat and you can even get card draw during production which is neat because your basic way of

getting cards is the last phase research where you get to draw several and pick cards to add to your hand what this amounts to is a game where initially it's a struggle to accomplish anything resources and cards are hard to come by and it can feel a little bit wonky as you try to decide what's the appropriate next phase card to play but as the game goes on it starts to ramp up really quickly and you catch on to the rhythm and flow and eventually you reach a level of automation where you can more reliably and more instinctively change sequences of phases together the game continues until all of the global parameters the heat oxygen and water levels in mars have reached their necessary levels for human habitation and the player with the most points from their terraforming rating their forest tokens and their point cards wins what i love about this game is that even though it's not particularly long it does feel action-packed and dense there's not even a turn order resolution amongst the players so it cuts down on down time and gets to the meat this doesn't feel like a lightweight or simplified game just polished and distilled you can lean into so many different strategies you move through so many cards you collect so many resources it doesn't feel like less of a game it just feels like it has a different structure and it's packed all that much tighter which brings me to the martian elephant in the room which is how does it compare to its older brother

it's hard to argue with some of the improvements here setup and takedown are shorter simultaneous turns make the game play out quicker the components from the card stock to the rule book to the money cubes to dropping the whole disco thanksgiving color scheme make for a massive step up in quality and it preserves the crunchy engine building core of the original the three major mechanical differences that give it a unique vibe are that the game strips away all of the area control and tile placement of the og which wasn't critical to the experience but added an extra strategic consideration and point of player interaction also the whole milestone and reward system is stripped away from this game which further erodes the already scaled back level of player interaction and lastly turn resolution in the original i could take actions at my own pace here because i don't ever want to not have a plan for going into a phase it feels like i'm so much more conscious of exactly how much of what resource i have and how i intend to spend it in some ways it feels like aries is the even crunchier game when you compare it to vanilla expansionless mars it's a faster playing and better produced game with just as much if not more satisfying engine building goodness and capacity to smog pile resources to your heart's content at the expense of multi-layered competition and player interaction so if you like those layers from the original which i do then this game is going to feel more distinct more focused but also more narrow but if your

primary reason for coming to terraforming mars is because you want to build up an engine of synergistic awesomeness where your cogs interact with the sprockets which interact with the widgets which activate the bacteria which then increases the global oxygen or heat then this does that really really well i should also note that i like the solo mode in this game slightly more solo and original already stripped away and invalidated some of the game elements more reliant on player interaction and you'd run across too many cards that made no sense within the context of solo play that's not to say that there isn't some of that here but overall everything feels better suited to handle solo in the cooperative variants and the dummy hand of phase cards is a nice way of aping the multiplayer experience and adding some slight unpredictability with only a tiny bit of overhead though speaking of cooperative it's a nice variant to have and there is some fun in trying to achieve ultimate mind-meld entering the drift phase card selection efficiency but the challenge feels kind of hollow and more of an afterthought than the great solo and competitive modes so as a die-hard terraformer even after several plays i can't really say that either of these games actually invalidates one another i mean terraforming mars remains one of my favorite games of all time and it has those layers which i still really love that i find core to that game's experience but it does strike me that

ares expedition takes the absolute best parts of the original distills them adds more mechanical and cosmetic polish slaps on a new turn structure and makes those best parts even better i have a hunch that the next time that i'm in the mood for some terraforming i'm going to leave bay on the shelf and i'm going to reach for the new and that is our review thank you so much for watching i've been jack for the cardboard herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald

Progress saved