Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tikal - First Play Review

Transcript 16:25

Hi there, I'm Jonathan with Getting Games and this is my first play review for Teall. In this video, I'll be giving you an overview of what the game is like to play while I also discuss my thoughts on this game as I played it the very first time. Now, if you have thoughts about the game, then please leave those as a comment down below. Also, click the like and subscribe buttons down there if you enjoy this video. Okay, let's talk about the game. This game came out in 1999 and it was designed by Kramer and Keysling and it won the Spielus in 1999 as well. So, it made a big splash when it first came out. I first heard about it in about 2009, which is when I started paying attention to modern board games. So, it was already 10 years old then, and now I finally played it here in 2026. I played a three-player game, and it was on Board Game Arena, and it's a pretty fascinating experience. I really enjoyed myself, but I've got a lot of things to say about it. Now, this is the first in what is called the Mask Trilogy, at least a lot of people refer to it that way, with the other games being Mexico, which I've covered in one of these, and also Java, which I played once in 2010 and hated, but I don't remember anything about it cuz that was 16 years ago. So, I kind of want to try Java again. But the thing that ties these games together is they're designed by the same uh people and they all use an action point system. Um, some other things might tie these together as well, but that's the main thing is action points or AP. So, if we look over here, let's focus in actually to this part of the board. And down at the bottom, it shows 10 different dots. And that's because on your turn, you have 10 action points that you can spend. And you can spend them in various ways based off of this menu. Uh, for example, this will

cost you two actions. This will cost you three. These will cost you five actions. Um, this one costs a variable amount of actions. And you have these 10 to piece together. But before you even get to that, the first thing that you do on your turn is place a tile that you drew. So at the beginning of the game, everybody starts in a camp over here, and this whole board is empty. You draw a tile, and then you put it down so that it is touching a previously placed tile, and it has to have a a path flowing back to the other tiles. And then you're going to start spending your action points. You keep doing that until you find volcanoes. And these are going to trigger scorings, which I'll talk about in a little bit. But yeah, this game is about putting down these tiles in a way that's going to hopefully help you. and then spending these action points. So, let's talk about the things you can do. You can spend one action point to bring a worker onto a camp. At the beginning of the game, we all have camps way in the bottom left corner of the board, but you can put more camps out to put workers there. Well, that costs five action points as you can see. So, that's the put a camp action down. You can put two new camps down. You can see I was the blue player, so I have a camp here.

I haven't put my second one down yet. The white player has put two of their camps down over here. So, you can spend action points to put these workers. You have a bunch of them. and you begin the game with none, maybe just a couple, I don't remember exactly, but you need to add these onto the board. Then you can also teleport them between camps by spending an action point. So that makes these camps really good for moving them around. And then you can move. And for this, let's focus in a little bit. So the way movement works is you're going to spend a variable amount of points depending on the the stones essentially along the path that you go. For example, let's say I have this worker right here, and I want to go over here. Now, I have to go across paths on edges that have at least one stone. So, this is not a uh valid path, but this one is. So, I could go here, and you have to spend one action point for each stone. So, that crosses one stone, so that'll cost one.

Then, I could go here, costing two, so I'm up to three. Then, this would cost another one, and then that would cost another one. So, it would take five action points to make it over here. I could do it even less efficiently if I wanted to. It costs three action points to walk up over here and then go down over there. But um as you can see, there's a wide variety of ways that you can move these around. And this is why putting the tiles down and where you put them and how you rotate them is so important because you can create some pretty wacky things like up here. I did this. Um I put my uh tent down here. Uh I place this there and I placed this up here. That is one, two, three, four, five action points to move from here to there. That is half the action points you get on an entire turn of this game to get a person over there. But of course, once they're over there, then they can start doing things and other people might not want to spend the effort to get over there, which is why I did that. Ultimately, I did move over there. And ultimately, ultimately, I did win the game. So, we could say it was a good decision in retrospect. So, speaking of that, actually, this tile right here shows three treasure on it.

And the tiles themselves just indicate the amount of treasure you stack on them when you put them down. And you can spend three of your action points to take a treasure from a spot where you have one of your people. And each person can only take one treasure per turn. So if you want to take multiple treasures, you have to have multiple people. And of course, you have to spend three action points each time you do this. Now, these treasures um are flipped face up and you put them in front of you, as you can see over here. And there are eight different types of them. And there's up to I think there's exactly three of each one of these tokens. And these score you points when the scorings happen. There's going to be multiple scorings throughout the game. I think four total, three total, something like that. One of those being at the very end. And if you have one of these, you get one point. If you have two of the same, you get three. If you have all three, you get six points. So digging up treasure can be really good.

Maybe you're able to make these sets. Maybe you're not able to make these sets. Well, with that in mind, there's this action. You could spend three action points to swap a token with an opponent. for example, well actually I don't have a good example here because it's happened already. But um if for example I only had two of these masks and uh Shinavas had three of them that I can spend three points to take that bring it over here. So I've now locked in those three and then I'd have to give him one of mine which hopefully I can give him one that doesn't actually help him out. Once you have at least two of a type, nobody can take it away from you. So they can only swap into the ones that you have just one of. So, you're essentially piecing together these sets because these could be worth a ton of victory points when the scorings happen. Now, uh another thing that you could do is you could spend a couple of action points to build up the temples on the board. And in fact, we can kind of see that out here already. This tile right here when it was placed had a two on it, but this tile right here when it was placed had a one or a two on it. I can't really tell anymore because it got upgraded essentially by stacking new tiles on top. If somebody wanted to, they could put a four on top of this three. And that's important because when the scorings happen, the player with the most workers in that area is going to score that indicated amount of points. I forget what happens if there's a tie. I don't think you get it though. I think it's just you have to have the most. So essentially, by doing this action, you are making the scoring potential of these area majorities that you're working on better and better. As you can see over here, there's a nine stack. So, that is just a really lucrative temple

over there that uh currently the red player is really trying to have a majority on. As you can see, um this big one is worth three. I think this is Anastasia. So, that's three, four, five, six. That's six majority power on this one spot. She really wants to score that one as many times as possible because she spent a bunch of her action points upgrading it. Now, at this point, we've talked about just about all the actions. The last one actually segus really well. This one costs five. And this one lets you put a guard down onto a temple. You can do this up to twice per game. And when you do this, you have to have a majority of your strength in an area compared to somebody else. And you could permanently take over that area. What ended up happening here uh as we went into a scoring, I can't remember exactly, but Anastasia moved some of her people out to score various other things. And then I was the exact next turn. And because she had weakened this, she scored it, but she'd weakened it. I zoomed in and immediately put a guard on top which meant that I locked in scoring this every other time. She scored this I think once and then I scored it every other time for the rest of the game at reasonable expense. You have to like permanently lose some workers as well but that didn't really hurt me too bad and uh she was really bummed about that.

And actually I've talked about scoring at a very high level. Let's talk about it. Uh, one very important element to it that uh, you probably wouldn't expect, and that is that when these volcanoes come out, people are going to go around the table again, not putting tiles down, and after their turn where a volcano is revealed, they are going to score for themselves. So that means, let's say I reveal the volcano, then I'm going to take my 10 action points, moving things around, trying to get into majorities, maybe trying to get treasures, and then I score everything. I get a pile of points, and then the next person goes, let's say it's Shrinavos. Shinabas could spend his action points taking over the majorities that I just scored so that he could score them. I don't really care so much anymore because I've already scored those. Of course, there will be future scorings, so I might want to v for them later on. So, what happened in this instance is Anastasia went before me in this scoring. So, she spread out to try and get a really good scoring in, but then that left her weak once it fully resolved and I was able to take it over and score it, which felt very good. So, that's probably way too much detail on how the game plays, but I felt like it was good to know the feel of this as you're putting these tiles down and all the different various actions that you could do. Um, as I proceed to talk about how it went, and you probably won't be surprised to hear that this game with 10 APS on your turn has a lot of AP in it.

Action points versus analysis paralysis. Holy cow, 10 is a lot of action points. I really liked Mexico. I talked about that a bunch again in one of these videos. And that game had six action points. And you can actually store up to two of them. So if you're like, I don't really know. I'm just going to do four actions and then store two for the future. Here you've got 10. Use them or lose them. And that is so much to think about like spawning people, moving people around. Um I have this tile that I want to put down. How am I going to orient it? How can I get over there? How can they get over there? How close are we maybe towards the next scoring? So many of these things are just crunching through my head. Uh this game ended up taking like two and a half hours for the three of us on Board Game Arena. And I had a lovely time playing it with two of my favorite people. But that's a long time. I would have definitely preferred the game to be like at least an hour shorter because of so much analysis paralysis. And I was absolutely a culprit. All three of us were. Uh I took some really long turns crunching through things and then realizing, oh no, that doesn't quite work because of this. And then you kind of go back to the drawing board as you're trying to piece all these things together. But I thought the decision space was fascinating despite the analysis paralysis. I did really enjoy playing the game as well. Uh in particular, I loved the way the map grew out. Uh it was really hard for me to not compare this to Mexico. I've already mentioned it multiple times because I played that somewhat recently. Same designers. It's also, you know, using this overall system, but they they feel quite different. Um in Mexico, you are crafting these uh majority areas depending on the various sizes and then you're taking over majorities in those spots that you can't move the majority

power out of. In this one, you're building up this board, essentially doing route building. I guess you kind of have routes with the canals in Mexico, but this one, it really felt like you could do some creative stuff with the route building. And for example, for me, I essentially built an area over here that was really hard for other people to get to. My tent was right here, so I got there relatively easier than they did. And I was able to somewhat easily score a pile of points because my opponents were struggling with getting over there. Ultimately, one of them was able to get a tile down, and they got a camp down to invade. And here's the thing, they easily could have stopped me, but it was our first play. You know, we've only played this a one time, and in retrospect, we were all, you know, talking about it once the game was over. Uh, and, uh, it was like, oh, we we totally could have invaded. Like, it's very easy to make paths go. Like, this might look like it's really hard to get to right now because there's only stones right here, but if you put something here that has stone on this side pointing that direction, suddenly that's a path. It's very easy to carve paths through the forest. and they essentially let me make a really hard to get to area and before they realized what I had done um I was able to like secure it and lock it down essentially and I think I won the game because of how I laid the tiles and because of how they weren't necessarily noticing that.

So yeah, it's a fascinating game. I I shudder to see what a four-player game of this would be like, but I really have a hard time thinking about playing this game over Mexico. Like if I owned both of them, currently I own neither, but if I owned both of them, I think I would probably always be reaching for Mexico. And a big part of that is the randomness. Like I don't mind randomness in my strategy games, but especially in a game that's this long, it was very impactful. Like there were some big point swings based on when the volcano came out. And I don't just mean like, oh, like this round versus next round. I mean like between Anastasia's turn and my turn. For example, that um thing I said earlier, Anastasia spread out really wide and then I was able to take over that spot and Trinas was like, "Dang it, I really wanted to do that, but he couldn't because of turn order because of where the volcano came out to trigger this thing." If the volcano had been one tile lower, then I would have been the one to pull out the volcano. I wouldn't have been able to do that at all. Maybe I would have spread myself thin. Anastasia would not have lost this maybe for the entire game. But she did.

I mean, partly because of her decisions, but also partly because of how that volcano came out. Also, just like the not just the volcano, the other tiles that you're getting frequently you could be like really wanting one thing and not getting it. And obviously you try to play towards whatever you get. Like obviously you have to be tactical in that way. But then comparing it to Mexico that is 100% open information, zero randomness. I I think I prefer that uh just because it like you don't have the outlet of like oh well if only the tile had gone differently. It's like oh no, everything is player decisions. Everything is my decisions. and what other people did. You could say, "Ah, if only you hadn't done this or that." Is a little bit different from being like, "I cannot draw a tile that lets me put a camp down over here to save my life." Which seemed like it happened a couple of times. And again, we are super noobs at this game.

It was the first time any of us had played it before. And I could absolutely see how playing this game multiple times, you could really get into it. You could um not let people sequester a bunch of points that are easy to get uh for themselves off to the side of the board. And I'm sure it'll get faster as you've internalized the system and you can see the stuff a little bit better. I'm sure that will help. I really like the fact that when you score, you just score at the end of your turn. So, you're not like setting things up and like, oh, I hope it's going to go around. No, it's just like spread, spread, spread, spread, spread, get as many points as I can, while hypothetically not leaving myself too vulnerable to other people taking away those really good uh point scoring spots as well. So, there's a ton of awesome stuff going on here. A lot of fun was had, but with a discreet amount of time to play board games, I think I'm gonna be getting Mexico. A reprint just got announced and it looks great and I think I'm gonna be going for that one. And I could see myself playing Take Call again in the future if somebody really wanted to, but I don't think I'd want to play it at four just because I think that'd be so long. And B, I I think I'd probably just rather play Mexico. I've got to try Java and see where I land on that one. I think Java has the same amount of action points as Mexico, so maybe that'll be a tossup. Uh, again, I don't remember why I dislike that one so much. Um, back in 2010 when I played it beyond, I think it just had a lot of analysis paralysis, which these um action point allowance games do tend to have. Um, I guess speaking of randomness, there is also the treasure.

Since we, it was our first play, we had no idea what was good, what was bad, and early on, one person uh tried to go really hard on treasure. I think Trinas went really hard on treasure and proceeded to realize that he didn't really have people out on the board because he's spending so many action points digging up treasure. it takes three of them out of your 10 on a turn. And so he did very poorly in the first scoring and proceeded to not do terribly well throughout the whole game. And maybe it was because of the treasures, maybe not. It definitely had the feeling of okay, maybe don't go all in on the treasure. It felt like, oh, I should really try to do that. But um it seems like maybe something you should do as you're also working towards these majorities because there's just a lot more points to be found. It seems like in those other different areas. And of course, drawing treasure is random as well. You could draw one treasure and draw the next one and it could be an exact match. Congrats, nobody can take that away from you. That is some free easy points that are locked in for the rest of the game. Or you could never draw a duplicate to save your life. And sure, you could spend three action points to swap. But three is a lot. Like that you have to work that in and consider everything else you could do.

Like that could be three movement points to move this person over there. And you know, if only you drawn the actual right tile, then you wouldn't have to spend these three points on doing that. That's just one of the things you have to consider. And so if you go into the game knowing there's a moderate amount of randomness with those treasure draws and that the tiles can be um sometimes not go the way that you want them to, then I think you're going to be in for a really good thinky time. Uh maybe just don't play with uh your friends that are excruciatingly bad at analysis paralysis because that would probably turn this two and a half hour game into an even longer one depending on who I played it with.

Progress saved