Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 22:47

welcome to John GS games today I'll be reviewing arborita this is a deceptively simple and somewhat intense card game about planting beautiful trees into paths and then Defending Your Right to score them first we'll go over the rules and then I'll jump into my review barbarum consists of a big deck of cards with 10 different suits inside each ranging from one to eight in value setting up the game is quite easy if it's a two-player game you remove four suits from the deck it doesn't matter which ones if you're playing a three-player game you only remove two suits from the deck and if it's a four-player game you just play with every single card in the game and now you deal out seven cards to every player and you flip up one face up discard pile per player so this right here would be a setup for a two-player game the first thing you do on a turn is you draw two cards now you either draw these from the face down draw deck or from any face up discard piles you can draw from your own discard pile and you can draw from the same discard pile multiple times in this instance I'd probably draw this eight because I started off with the 1 four and five and then I only have one of these Royal Point SAS so I'll probably grab a random one from the top of the deck and oh I got another one once you've drawn two cards you will always have nine cards in your hand at this point you need to play one of these cards face up in front of you into your Arboretum for instance I might take this one here put it right here in the middle and this has begun what will end up being a very large arum the last thing you do on every turn is discard one of your cards face up into your own personal discard Pile in this instance I might go ahead and look at my hand and say at this point this Oak isn't doing doing much for me so I discard it down

here I'm once again down to seven cards and now it's the player to my left's turn one thing I'd like to note about discarding is that the rules just say you discard a card onto the top of your discard pile what we have adopted doing is discarding cards in a spayed order so that you can always see every card that was underneath it now I don't think that this is necessarily the way the game was supposed to be played but we enjoy it because it takes out the memory aspect of what cards have been discarded into piles before and we get to kind of math things out but that's not necessarily how the game is hypothetically supposed to be played I can't be sure about that players will keep taking turns until the entire draw deck runs out once the final card is drawn that player will evaluate their full turn and then the game will be over now I'm going to jump into an extended look at how we actually build our Arboretum and the reasons we build it in that way now let's talk about this Arboretum because it really is the meat of the game you start the game by placing any card in the central area right in front of you it can be any card in the deck I happen to have picked this one of Magnolia here future cards must be played orthogonally adjacent to any of the cards that have already been played inside of your Arboretum however there are no actual placement rules in the game any card can be placed next to any other card in your Arboretum the only thing that's going to modify how you're going to want to do this is the endgame scoring which I'll get into now at the end of the game you may have an arboretum that looks something like this of course it could look completely different it all depends on how you decided to play your cards throughout the game it could be a big line or a zigzag or just a big old grid but let's go ahead and use this as our example

what we're looking for are Paths of trees and simply Define this is a set of cards that are all orthogonally adjacent to each other that Ascend in numerical value and begin and end with the same type of tree for instance we have a jackarunda path here we start with a one then we go three four five seven and eight so this is legal we have ascending numerical value going through the whole path we begin and end with the same type of tree it doesn't actually matter what the tree colors are in between you're not allowed to have duplicate numbers in a path however so we do not have a willow path over here because it goes three 3 four so this is not a path at all and obviously if you only have a single card of a tree there's no way to make a path with that card so you'll be doing no scoring for that specific type of tree so now let's see how we score a path you get one point per card in a path so we would get one two three four five six points for this Jack run a path however if you have a one in a path then you get a bonus of one point and if you have an eight in a path you also get a bonus of two points that means this is 6 + 1 plus two or a 9-point path likewise with this Dogwood path we see that there aren't any trees in between these two cards but that's fine this is a two card path and since we have an eight card in it that's a bonus of two points so that's 2 plus two or fourpoint path for Dogwood now you are allowed to make paths that are all the same type of tree in fact you get a bonus if the path is at least four long and they're all the same suit in this case you get two points per tree instead of the usual one so for instance this would be 2 4 6

eight points plus a single bonus point because you have a one in the path so this is also a nine-point path and lastly we see this Royal Point Sienna path is 3457 that's fine you can reuse cards when you're scoring different paths so even though these cards are used in the jackarunda path they could be used again for this Royal Point SI path not everybody gets to score every one of their paths in their Arbor rum however let's talk about how we get the privilege of scoring these specific paths for these different trees at the end of every single turn and the end of the game you will always have seven cards in your hand and these are going to be the key to scoring the different paths in your area at the end of the game we will go through every single type of tree and see who has the majority of points in their hand for that specific type what I mean is if we were to call out jackarunda every single player would take all of the jackarunda cards out of their hand and put them face up on the table you add up the value of all the cards that you played face up so in this case that'd be eight and the player who has the highest value for that specific suit is going to be the only person who gets to score a jackarunda path ties are friendly however so multiple people may be able to score a specific type of tree so in this instance I have eight power going towards jackarunda an opponent could play a single card like this and that's seven power however 8 be seven and now I'm going to be able to score my ninepoint Jacka path and I'm going to log that down next up if we were to call Oak I would pull all the oak cards out in my hand which would be there this one and let's say an opponent pulled these two out here well my eight still beats their seven and even though I don't actually have a legal Oak Path I just

have this single card that's fine I've stopped anybody else from scoring their Oak paths in their arboretums so in this case everybody would get zero and I'd be pretty happy about that the last thing to note is what happens when a one and an eight are both revealed when you're looking at the power of different suits so in this case if we called royal Point Sienna I would have this one and six which would be seven if an opponent played this eight it looks like I'm in trouble eight beats seven and I really want to score this path however if they one and the eight both come out in the same reveal session to see who wins the one Will trump the eight and knock it out of the game entirely this case I'm going to win with seven that eight did nothing and I'm pretty happy about it so obviously this is one big reason that you want to keep ones in your hand the game comes with a nice big Score Pad which helps you out by letting you log all the different types of trees write your scores down you add them all up and whoever has the most points is the winner if the game ends in a tie then the person who has the most different colored trees present in the Arboretum is going to win that tie and if there is still a tie then the rules say that both players must go out and plant a tree after 5 years whoever's tree is higher is going to be the ultimate winner of that particular game of arum for my review of arbm I'm going to touch on each item of this list starting at the top and working my way down to the bottom so let's begin with those positives and the first of these has to do with building that arom in front of you you need to think about what card are you playing as well as where do you play it and when do you decide to play it these are all very important aspects that go into building that little Tableau in front of you now there's

almost a feeling of push your luck because you only ever have nine cards in your hand when you're going to be playing these cards down you of course go back down to seven at the end of your turn so you have a very small amount of information especially early game with which to decide well I have three Magnolia I'm going to start putting Magnolia down try to make a path and then keep one of these cards in my hand to try and be strong in Magnolia at the end of the game but the end of the game is way off so in the meantime I'm hoping to maybe pick up a couple mag cards that people might discard uh thinking that maybe you don't have necessarily a big thing going on just yet or you just draw from the top of the deck and really hope to grab those good Magnolia cards of course you could get lucky and start off with like five Magnolia cards in your hand and that means you're going to be strong on that path but that means you have very little information and uh strength in any of the other types of trees and I've never seen anybody win this game with only a single big scoring path you need at least two paths to score if one of those is big then you can win with two usually people win by getting three different paths scored into their arboro in addition to that push your luck idea where you're hoping that things are going to work out in the future there's also just the puzzle of how you place your cards that you can get multi-use through them you know maybe you run the two three four and then you run something else back through that three again to try and get multiple scoring potential possibilities through single cards you don't necessarily want to just build rows of cards that are each only giving you one opportunity to score you really want to synergize this stuff as much as you can given the small amount of information that you have in your hand and what you can see out in

front of you when you add these two things together it just makes for a wonderful decision every single turn how are you going to place that one card into your area and all the ramifications that are involved I haven't found that analysis paralysis is too bad with this there is a possibility to really lock down on that a bit but you can think about it when it's not your turn you can see the cards that other people are playing and discarding so in general it has not been too much of a problem as far as downtime concern it's just a really tasty decision positive number two has to do with how difficult and layered the decision to discard a single card from your hand can be usually as you're playing the game the first thing you're constantly thinking about is I don't want to get rid of any of these cards you usually find yourself in a situation where you like everything in your hand for various reasons either you want to play it out in front of you to make a stronger path or you want to keep it in your hand so that you have a much better chance of scoring that path at the end of the game or maybe you just have one or two really strong cards of a different color that you already see an opponent going big on and you want to keep those in your hand to potentially play them at the very end of the game to stop them from scoring anything uh on top of that you really don't want to discard those cards because they're very good for your opponents but at the end of the day you have to discard a card from your hand you're going to eliminate every single card from your hand as a potential to discard and then realize well let's relook at this again and decide what I'm actually going to get rid of now every now and then there is an easy discard but I would say that's one out of every 10 hands is a simple decision those other nine are really

great things that you have to think about all the different ramifications you might discard a card that's really good for the person directly to your right and you just hope that the other players before you might pull it back into their hand because they see how good it is for them I've had situations where I do that somebody pulls it up into their hand and then they start going big on that color as well and so I thought I was helping this person and in actuality I was helping that person at the end of the day what ever you discard is probably going to help somebody and that just makes it a great decision wrapped up into just this tiny little Act of discarding a single card positive number three is specifically the hand majority mechanism at the very end of the game now I already touched on this a little bit with discarding because it comes into play with what you want to discard but just when you really think about how you're going to plan building your Arboretum based on the cards in your hand and the strength that you need to keep in your hand to just stay just above the threshold over every body else and still get the most points out of that specific suit is really interesting I like how you can have the ability to really count the cards there's only eight in each suit so it's not too drastically hard to maybe see what other people have played see a couple things in the discard pile and based off your hand and sometimes you can solve it and realize I am actually totally good I'll play this card or this card and no matter what I will be safe now I think part of that is because we splay our discards out so that you can see every single card underneath it and like I said in the rules overview that's not something that's strictly forbidden by the rules but it's not something that's ever mentioned in the rules so it's a slight maybe variant on how the game is

hypothetically supposed to be played but it's a way that we really enjoy playing it so that there is no memory element because I really don't like it when memory is a big deal in a game and based off of the cards that are discarded memory would be quite a big deal to figure out the kind of strengths that you have in your hand based off of other people and now other people are going to like that memory aspect but we don't so we get rid of that with SP those cards and it adds in to that great uh Zero Sum nature where you can really figure out how you're going to keep the cards in your hand to best score the paths in your arinum and positive number four is simple the cards are beautiful the artwork of each of these different trees is so intricate and it just pops off the table every time this game is played people come by and talk about how gorgeous it looks on the table and they want to know more about how this weird tree game plays in addition to that just the linen of the cards they feel really good in your hand they have this foil kind of gold look to the back of the cards it's just a really good combination of component quality uh on top of all that you have this big pad for scoring and normally I don't like scoring pads I kind of avoid them but I've actually enjoyed it in this game riding down all the different scores for the different trees and now I have a log of how we've done in all previous games and I think I'm going to continue using that pad and just keeping in the Box because it's kind of neat to see how things went in the past someone can say well how often is Three Trees w versus two when you're scoring in the end and I can just flip through the score pad and look at it I don't know it's just neat I think it's amazing package for the money that you're going to pay to get this

game and now let's shift into the neutral points the first of these has to do with the special scoring conditions for the one and the eight not only on the table but when they're coming from your hand at the end when you're trying to figure out majorities now I think that these mechanics are important to the game I think they add a lot to the game but they also feel kind of inelegant like just having the one are arbitarily be a bonus point when it's in your Arboretum on a path and the eight gives two points well I understand why that is because you're going to want to keep eights in your hand to have a really good buying power situation for winning to score a path so if you put it in your path you're sacrificing that uh potential and so you should get paid out because of that but it just it's not on the card anywhere on the one or the eight there's no little iconography to kind of hammer that point home and it just kind of feels it's a little awkward every time I've taught it and people have understood it I haven't had too much of an issue with it but every time I teach it it's kind of a stumbling point where I have to kind of go over it twice uh not only that but also the thing at the end where if somebody reveals the one and somebody else reveals the eight the one kills the eight again I totally understand that it makes the one a more interesting card to keep in your hand and it makes the eight more of a risky thing to keep in your hand if you haven't seen the one yet I like all of that but ultimately these things come together to feel a little bit inelegant especially when compared to the pure Elegance of the other mechanics that make this game up with the drawing placing scoring rules it works but it feels a little awkward and neutral number two has to do with

expectations when you first pick up this box and look at it it's got this gorgeous filigree art it's called arbura that's about having a forest of trees you look and you see this deck it's full of gorgeously made tree cards you think this is going to be a pleasant game we're going to be playing these cards down it's going to make pretty little paths but in actuality it's a pretty brutal game where you are making all these painful arduous decisions I've joked that the the tagline for the game should be painful decisions and regret because that discard is so hard and four turns L into the game you're already going to be regretting how you put these cards into your Arboretum it is nowhere near as peaceful and Serene as a game called Arbor might first lend you to believe and I don't think that's a problem but I think it can catch people off guard they get like four turns in and they're like wow this is actually intense like this is not an easy stroll through the Arboretum kind of game this is a crunchy really think about every single decision because every single one of them is really important kind of game and I don't think that the theme in the box art necessarily conveys that and this is the point where I would normally discuss at least one negative point for the game but for the first time in making reviews for my channel I cannot come up with a single negative attribute for this game even those neutral things they're just neutral they are little skipping points a little bit of awkwardness they don't detract anything from the game in my personal opinion and I thought about putting this review off for a while until I played it more times to try to find a bad part of the game but I played it six times now and I

think ultimately I'm not going to find an issue that really brings this game down for me so unfortunately I have no negative points so let's move on to the next section and that's going to be replayability obviously with this game there is very little variance between one play to the next every single card in the deck is going to be there every time we play sure in two to three player games you pull a couple suits out but that's just a thematic glossy difference all the suits play the same so you're going to be doing the same thing every time you play you always draw two cards you always play a card you always discard a card throughout the entire game but that has not detracted from a replayability perspective I've played the game six times so far and I'm really looking forward to playing it many many more times and I think that's just because the mechanisms work so well it's so thinky it's so interesting but it also plays usually in about 20 to 40 minutes depending on your player count and I think that makes it this awesome super filler that you can play at the beginning and middle of your game night at any point to really have a very fascinating interesting game to think about I see this game being played 20 times 30 times by me going well into the future and it's not because each game is going to bring a new uh aspect like some games you bring things in bring things out and you leave some stuff in the Box this game doesn't have that it has a classic card feel it really feels like a game that could be 40 years old and I really like that I think it just keeps you wanting to come back for more because the decisions themselves are so pure and so interesting and also the

fact that you don't build your arom the exact same way every game lends itself to a very long amount of replayability I think if you like the game the first time you play it you're going to be still really enjoying it on the 20th game and now let's discuss player count arbm plays two to four players and I've played all of those different types of the game and I'd say the biggest dividing line comes between the two and three player game as far as how the game plays and differently so the three to four player game the biggest difference is that you have multiple people that you can help out as you're playing the game obviously you don't want to help anybody out but as you're discarding Cards into your discard pile you are going to inevitably be getting rid of good stuff for other players and in three to four player games you can give good stuff to various different people you kind of spread out the love so you're not helping one particular person too much or you might look over and see the person who you think is the weakest and help them because they are not your biggest threat versus the two-player game you only have your opponent so every time you play a card that will help your opponent it always helps your only opponent and it makes it much much more difficult of course you also have the thing to think about in the two-player game of the Zero Sum aspect where they're the only person who's going to have cards that could stop you from scoring a big uh path inside your area versus in a three to four player game there are multiple people who could potentially come in and try and mess you over with that ultimately I think two-player is brilliant I love how back and forth it is it's very quick to go it's like a 20-minute game when you only play a two-player game but it's intense you only have that one other person and it really makes those discarding actions

the hardest that this game really gives you in the three to four player game I think they both play really well as well they're just a little bit nicer and I don't know it's fun to see all these different arbm that happen around the table if I was to pick a favorite I would say that three is probably a touch better than four just because it's a slightly shorter game and if you have anybody who is prone to analysis paralysis they might take a little bit longer on their turns and it takes a little bit longer to get around the table back to you but I would say that two player and three player are different enough to be equally best in my book but I will never say no to playing this game four players in conclusion arum is one of the best card games that I've played in years and it swiftly jumped up to become one of my favorite games in general and it really all comes down to how interesting important and often times arduous every decision is that you make in the game when you think about it you're going to make four decisions a turn you're drawing a card then you're drawing another card playing a card and discarding and now usually drawing a card is not arduous but it's certainly important because you can push your luck and go for random cards from the top of the deck or you could give your opponent's information and draw known cards from discard piles around you it might be a no-brainer maybe it's a really good card that opponent gave up in an arduous Manner and you take it because you know it's going to be good for you but maybe you're taking a different color card that people weren't expecting and now they saw you take that card and now they're going to play around the fact that they know that you have that card in your hand then you add on to that the playing card phase where you're really trying to puzzle together how all these trees and paths are going to work their way out and also thinking

about waiting the strength of that suit in your hand versus the strength of it in your arbu for scoring points and finally discarding a card is so painful but it's that really great interesting kind of painful decision where you don't want to get rid of anything but you need to figure out the least good card in your hand and get rid of it and hope that it doesn't help an opponent too much and then you add on to all of that the fact that this game plays great with two three and four players as well as being a small 80c card deck it makes this game highly portable and kind of an anytime anywhere sort of experience now I will admit that it is a pretty intense game if you're looking for a laidback like throw cards on the table not really think about it too much sort of game this is not going to be that but what it will be is an enriching in-depth wonderful game that you'll be playing in only about 30 minutes and I think that fits in great Niche and I see myself keeping this one around for a very long time it's relatively easy to teach to new players I will agree that there is a little bit of inelegant side rules that come in with the one and the eight but I've never seen anybody struggle with that past certainly the first game and usually people maybe ask once in the middle of the game and then nobody has questions by the time we actually start to score so ultimately this is a very strong endorsement for the game if any of this has sounded interesting at all to you I I highly recommend that you seek it out pick up a copy I really don't think that you're going to be disappointed I hope you've enjoyed this video if you'd like to see more reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs blogs and all the various other kind of videos I do please consider subscribing to my YouTube

channel thanks for watching

Progress saved