Stonemaier Games' Greatest Hits: Rolling Realms
Transcript
i received a complimentary review copy of rolling realms from the publisher in exchange for an honest review so thank you to stonemart games i'm going to open the review with the hook the thing about the game which is going to draw players in so it's a roll and right game and we've seen many of those before but this one has modular scoring just like that seen in cartographers it has a modular player interface like that seen in silver and gold but it's rare to see these two things pulled together into one game so i guess that's the hook a bit weak okay well let's try again so it's a roll and right game with different modules inspired by each of stone meyer's greatest hits yes i think that's probably the real hook i'm adam porter i design games and this is a different sort of review because we're going to be taking a look at a tabletop game but analyzing it primarily as a product over recent months i've been making regular videos covering all aspects of product design and in this series of reviews i'll be applying all the things we've discussed we'll talk about the gameplay too so you should get an idea of whether the game might be fun for you rolling realms is a 2021 release from designer jamie stegmeier from stonemaier games with a great little backstory so early in the covert 19 pandemic jaime set about creating a free print and play game which could be played via facebook live the game was a simple role and right game and it evolved and grew as the pandemic dragged on stonemeyer
already have a strong community but this game brought together many fans of the company who play-tested the game via their home printed copies and fed back constantly to the company there was never any intent of formally publishing this game but by mid-2021 the demand was apparent and stonemeyer decided to make a full production version available to purchase rolling realms is a game for one to six players at the start of each round three cards are chosen which will set the scoring criteria for the round each card represents a realm which takes its inspiration from a past stonemire game each player gets a copy of each of these cards to work with and each round lasts nine turns at the start of a turn two dice are rolled all players then use these dice results to fill in sections of their cards for example a die showing a 4 might allow you to cross off the 4 result on one of your realms each die can only be used once and you can only fill in one value on each of the realms per turn so essentially you have to allocate one dice result to one of your realms and then the other dice result to a different realm often filling in the realms generates you resources which are marked onto a separate card by circling them and later in the game you can cross off resources in order to use them to manipulate dice results each of the realms works differently generating new resources in different ways and ultimately scoring you stars which are marked along the bottom of the realm card after nine turns the round ends and players total up their stars for the round adding additional points for
leftover resources two more rounds are played using different realms and scores are totaled to determine the winner the introductory blurb from the rulebook describes the game as an infinitely scaling roll and right game which is a little bit odd because the game is actually limited to a maximum of six players because there are only six sets of cards included sure you could buy more copies to play the game with larger numbers as the back of the box suggests but it seems like a bit of an odd selling point to advertise when the vast majority of role and writes are genuinely infinitely scalable because each player only needs a single sheet of paper torn off of a pad and this is one of the few games in the genre where player count is actually limited i want to try and describe my experience with the game from the very start to form a customer journey map the start of that journey is a little bit fuzzy for me though because i didn't have the genuine customer experience of picking up the game from the store shelf considering my purchase and handing over cash for it the game was generously provided to me by the publisher so i'll have to start with my initial contact with the game upon opening the package which arrived in the post the first thing that struck me was the size of the box the game is small by stonemeyer standards but it's large in comparison to others in the genre it's considerably bigger than quix and quinto the microscopic first wave of the current roll and right trend it considerably outsizes silver and gold and ganshon clever and the myriad of schmitchbuilder roland rights the box is a similar
surface dimension to welcome too but it's considerably deeper i tend to think of roland rites as small box experiences the sort of things you'd tuck into a backpack and take on a holiday maybe playing a game or two in a cafe or at the airport or on a train rolling realms is a little bit unwieldy for that now i understand that the intention is for the game to be expandable with space for additional materials within the base game box and that makes sense recently this kickstarter behemoth arrived in the post cartographers has gone from this to this and the later box is packed with expansion content suddenly rolling realms seems positively unassuming and honestly unassuming is the word i'd use for the cover art here too we've got none of the lavish illustrations that adorn the boxes of scythe or wingspan none of the bright colors splashed over the covers of euphoria or red rising instead we've got a simple bit of graphic design with a charming illustration that's a little bit hard to make out the composition has an air of school textbook about it i'm a big fan of game boxes which give an accurate depiction of what you're going to be doing in the game or even better how you're going to feel so welcome 2 has a town planner laden with papers and indeed you do feel a bit like you're laying out a neighborhood on the page well sort of the cartographer's cover has a wise looking elf and an imp
plotting landscapes on a scroll of paper and indeed you do feel like you're creating maps as you play well sort of gansstone clever and quicks lean right into their total lack of theming and feature dynamic images of colored dyson spreadsheets to be honest those two covers are virtually indistinguishable rolling realms falls somewhat awkwardly between two stools it's an entirely abstract game there's no attempt to define what the players are doing or why the most intriguing selling point of the game is the various realms inspired by different popular stonemaier products yet you really have to squint to find the references on the cover the most iconic stonemire games scythe wingspan and viticulture all feature but you'd have to really know what you're looking for no casual wingspan fan is going to pick this game up off the game store shelf and immediately make the connection my initial responses to rolling realms weren't all that enthusiastic i wanted to give it a try but i wasn't really excited of course the next part of the journey is learning the rules and as with most stonemeyer products the rulebook is pretty good it has a weird page order though we very quickly get into a very detailed example of play before we've learned all the rules the wide variety of different cards are explained before the resources which are going to feature in every round of every game i found myself flipping back and forth more than i would have liked and one fundamental rule is totally left out unless i've
missed it the rules ask players to mark various boxes and icons on the individual realms but they don't mention that these boxes and icons can't be marked again it's easy to extrapolate that information because i've played many roland rights and worker placement games and i know how these sort of things work but even for a veteran gamer like myself i did end up watching rodney smith's watch it played video just to check and understood it all properly i'd highly recommend doing the same by the way these instructional videos are very much appreciated and rodney is the best in the business all of this is not to say that stone meyer have done a bad job with the onboarding process quite the opposite they may not have made the game as appealing as it could have been for the casual shopper but jamie stegmeier has masterfully created a community of players who will buy the game regardless of outward appearances by the time the game was released there was already a community of fans playing the game discussing it online and sharing information through his various social media channels as usual stegmeier has created a little army of brand advocates the company is transparent and open it responds to customer queries they are industry leaders in that regard setting up the game is a breeze but teaching it is a little bit trickier every round means teaching three new rules none of them are complex but it isn't as simple as teaching everything up front and then rinsing and repeating one player needs to be on the ball to keep the game running smoothly
now you'll notice on my customer journey map that interaction is a low point in the game like many role rights your actions will have precisely zero impact on the other players a player will win or lose and they'll have no idea until those end scores are revealed this is an intentional design choice of course it allows the game to scale to large numbers of players but if you're looking for an interactive experience well this isn't it the main draw to return to the game for subsequent plays is to experience the many different card combinations by mixing and matching three cards from 11 you've got 165 different combinations only three of which will be used in any given game alternatively you might like to play through the solitaire mini golf format where you're faced with 18 defined card combinations and specific objectives for each round some of these challenges really shake up the way you play the game and add even greater variety to the package at one point i was feeling like this is jamie stegmeier's version of freedom and freezes 504.
if we plot pain points onto the customer map there aren't really any major problems the rules could be better but they're fine there's no interaction but has a feature rather than a flaw and i'm not desperate to tell everyone about the game and persuade people to play it with me but i would always be up for playing if somebody else wanted to in my video about engaging players i described the five key facets of a board game which tend to hook me so these are thematic immersion meaningful interactions challenge and stress feedback and meaningful choices a game doesn't need to excel in all of these categories to keep me engaged but featuring a number of these elements in any combination is likely to pull me in if we allocate 0 to 3 points to each of these categories we end up with a score out of 15 and a game which scores 10 or above is likely to be a real favorite with me but rolling realm struggles a little bit the lack of interaction and the lack of theme severely dense its chances of reaching the top of the ladder it doesn't provide much in the way of invigorating aha moments there's no real feedback aside from crossing off boxes and counting points not much in the way of a dopamine hit playing rolling realms but i do appreciate the puzzle it's challenging and there are some neat decisions to be made especially in that solitaire mini golf format perhaps this relatively low overall score explains why i don't really feel excited about the game i think it will settle into my rotation of role rights alongside quicks
and cartographers and ganshon clever and welcome to but i don't think it will always be the first of them that i reach for moving on to my product design checklist is the game innovative no i don't think so the the use of dry erase cards is fun and it hasn't been used often before but here the cards are never held in hand they're never piled up in a discard pile or drafted mid-round rolling realms just isn't as dynamic as silver and gold which is the game that inspired it the mechanism of incorporating a modular rule and a modular playing surface into a single card is a nice twist and it's a fun iteration on other games in the genre number two does it solve a need well right now not really i mean there are plenty of other role roland rights which offer up a similar experience that said it did solve a need in the early days of covid19 providing a print and play prototype which you could playtest across the globe with a world famous game designer was a unique prospect and exactly the sort of distraction that gamers needed in a global pandemic i'm not surprised that anybody involved in that process is keen to have a memento of the experience in the form of a boxed version of the game that they helped to create number three a great product grows with its user the experience gets richer and deeper as they explore all the different features rolling realms offers up variety with its multitude of card combinations but i'm not sure that i'd call it a deep experience it's not really a game that you can master
jamie stegemeier has indicated that there will be mini expansion packs similarly sized to a magic the gathering booster inspired by each new game released by stonemaier so each additional card will massively increase the number of possible card combinations and is going to increase the replayability of the game accordingly it's a really clever design choice enhancing the gameplay providing an affordable purchase for fans of the game and promoting stonemire products along the way the size of the rolling realms game box suddenly makes a lot more sense when you hear about these future expansions they have planned number four branding i think the game is a fascinating experiment with branding each card is named after an earlier game and the nature of the card relates to the mechanisms in the game to which it relates for example on the between two cities realm you score points equal to the lowest score of the two other realms used that round just as you would score points for adjacent cities in the original game now i'm a casual player of stonemeyer games wingspan aside i've played most of the games only a handful of times if at all and i can't immediately connect the mechanisms on the realms to their big box counterparts in the absence of any artwork to aid players in making the connection i'm not sure how successful this approach will be but i'm fascinated to monitor the development of the game and find out i do wonder whether the lack of brand assets is a missed opportunity a few distinctive bits of artwork from those famous games would really lift the
experience so let's return to that initial hook a modular scoring system combined with a modular player interface how strong an idea is that well it's interesting but i think it's really hard to communicate that to players and as a result i don't think it's a strong hook so we're going to consider the more thematic hook a roll and right game inspired by stonemeyer's greatest hits yeah i think that's a pretty cool idea so in terms of execution well i think the game's a bit less successful the onboarding process was impressive it was organic it was never forced but the aesthetics in the game are a little bit dull and the branding is a little bit confused the expansion potential does lift the product but ultimately the game sits in the darker green area of my grid i don't see this game rising above the front runners in the roll and right category that said it is a really solid entry in the genre and it does have some fun and surprising twists it's got a great backstory and it's got loads of potential to grow if you feel like it might suit you i don't think you're going to be disappointed if you'd like to see more videos like this please hit like subscribe to the channel and i'll see you next time