Viticulture Bordeaux Review: Your game was an Elderberry
Transcript
Ah. Hello there. That's right, we're back in the kitchen doing videos like I used to do, like I used to love it. See the reflection? Because today we're kicking it old school. We're taking a look at Viticulture Bordeaux. Now, one of the first videos I ever did was like 10 years ago about Viticulture in general. Loved it. It's one of my favorite video intros I ever did, right? Um the whole watching Go watch it. It's fun. But Viticulture Bordeaux purports to bring a new board and a new feel ala Tuscany to the Viticulture world. Not Viticulture world with the capital W trademark like the expansion game. But Viticulture the world the game. The movie. So, let's take a look at how it plays. We'll come back up talk final thoughts right now.
All right, this is Viticulture Bordeaux. Now, this will not be an entire teach of Viticulture. You can look back at my original Viticulture review from like 10 years ago. And if you want to learn the game or if there's other videos on how to play the game and learn the game. But this one is mostly focusing on the stated goals of Bordeaux. Now, the design goals are right here. We're going to go through this really quick. Getting a faster start and shorter games. Did not find that to be possible. Um the faster start, yeah, you get a couple wine and get a couple or you get a wine and a grape and some more coins. Better options at two players, yes, cuz the bonuses are better. More agency specifically for card draw, yes, that's in the board. Um providing greater incentive to use the wine making process. Well, mostly because they removed from Tuscany the worker or the area control area to get more points. So, really the most the only way you can really get points now is the wine making process but from selling wine or filling orders. So, that makes sense.
Um increase the impact of coins for engine building and victory. Uh yeah, I guess. Uh that doesn't really change much. Decrease the viability of repetitive non-wine making strategies. Sure. Because you're mostly now filling wine cards. Um Adding and compelling alternate path to gain more workers. I can't find that anywhere except for take any action because currently you can get a worker back from the fall. You can still get the one from taking the bottom row. Or you can train a new worker. So, I guess technically you could train two workers in one turn if you do take any action and train a worker. So, you'd have two workers coming back in one turn. Um adding opportunities for positive player action. That's true. There are some things that affect everybody in positive ways. Providing players with an end game reward for excess coins, grapes, and wines. I do like that. And then making more actions relevant later in the game. Uh sure. Yeah, I mean kind of everything is still relevant considering you're limiting what you can do. Now, the main change are these expert options.
You'll notice the little cubes under every action. These are spaces where you have access to four of these. Now, in a four-player game, all of these potentially could be filled. In a five-player game, that means if everybody was to do this and to their full capacity, someone's not going to fill their full experts. Which you notice not everybody filled their experts in this four-player game here. Now, what they do is you can take the hire an expert action over in the spring in order to put one of your cubes on one of the actions, essentially giving you a bonus to that action. It's cool in concept. I don't know that any of them are that super powerful because again, even though money does matter at the end of the game now because it's points, so getting your residuals high matters, too. But, you're going to spend money on certain things, too. Like, it's still like I I still don't see the benefit of the tasting room and the windmill now. I feel like those are kind of relics of the original game that don't make a ton of sense.
Um maybe I'm wrong on that. Visitors cards are still always kind of a great very Agricola-y feel where it's like, man, I have great cards or I have terrible cards. Um but the the experts is a pretty cool addition. I don't know that it changes it enough to where I'm like, man, I'm going to play Bordo over Tuscany. I still think Tuscany is the essential version, ironically, even though the original essential edition is called essential edition. I think Tuscany is still the better game. This is second to Tuscany. It still leaps and bounds against World. And I don't know that I'm going to play this though over Tuscany. I think I still like Tuscany better. However, I do like this tweak. I do think it muddies the board a little bit, right? Having those um spaces below each action with the cube. I think it kind of makes the board look a little less pretty because you just have text all over the board now.
But I don't know. This is This one I'm torn on, and I'm going to talk about this in the final thoughts, but that is the major changes of Bordo. Uh there's autumn, of course. But the only other major change besides the beginning is you only start with your six field open, which, ironically, if you're talking about speeding up things, yeah,
[clears throat]
it kind of forces you to plant there, but still one thing I find is that you still have a hard time planting grapes early on in the game. Now, once you get that going, much like any time you play Viticulture, the first three rounds are like one or two points, maybe, and then all of a sudden people start getting eight, nine, 10 points in a round. So, it's like if the graph was going, it would be like speed, speed, speed, speed, speed, speed, speed, like that. So, that is Bordo, though.
Well, that's Viticulture World. Couple things to talk about. As [clears throat] you know, I always love the art of Viticulture. I love the components of Viticulture. I love old school meeples even though these have hats and baskets, which is really cool. I love that mid-2010s Euro feel that Viticulture really has. Now, let's talk about good things first. This one tries to do some things that are interesting by adding the experts. Now, I don't think it hits the mark completely. I think one, it muddies up the board. You know, Viticulture has always been a very pretty board, and having text under every single action actually kind of makes the board look a little muddy. However, the expert actions are pretty cool, but almost analysis paralysis kicks in. If there's 16 to choose, I can only choose four. That one's blocked, and most of them I don't want anymore. So, you run into that problem. What I would like to see, if we're going to go this route, is little um tabs that you can put over each of those and change up the experts to where the experts can be different actions on attached to different actions or different experts. You know, you shuffle up 16 of 32 or whatever. And you put them out on the board, and now you have a variable set of experts.
As far as everything else, I don't quite get the notion of it saying it speeds up the game. It certainly didn't feel like it for me. Um you definitely are concerned with wine making. It almost feels like a step back. It's kind of feels like the Finn Spahn version of Tuscany because it takes away the board with the um area control, right? Because you could win with the area control from that, and so you wouldn't be all about wine making. It gives more points and it kind of pushes you towards selling fulfilling order cards. In fact, what I do really like though, and this may have been what I can't quite remember, taking action from anywhere on the board. I think that's a cool one, and I think the wake-up chart where you can retrieve a worker from fall is a good one. And then also, you know, if you did that take any action with your regular worker, or your grande worker and then do the fill order card, you could potentially fill I think up to three or four order cards depending on how the rules work on that in one round.
And I think that's pretty good. It's easier to age your stuff because you're always going to age it at the end of the round, but you also have the wake up chart will let you age it. Plus I like the fact that if someone takes the extra worker, then everybody gets the benefit the next round. So a lot of good things going for it. I don't think I'm going to play this over Tuscany. I think I still like Tuscany the best. It just has such a classic feel to me where ironically, even though it's Viticulture Essential Edition is called the Essential Edition, I think the Essential Edition of this game is Tuscany. I think this one is more like, "Hey, we want to do something a little different." Or we want to ease players in, but we don't want to do the very intro just spring summer or whatever spring fall version of the game. We want to play a little more heavy than that. I think this is kind of right there below that. It's not quite Finn span at too easy, but it's not quite worm span either of like, "Wow, this is ridiculous." and sometimes it's kind of right in the middle. I'm still going to play Tuscany over this, but I do like the thought and idea of the experts. I just wish there was a little more variability and I wish some of them were better than the other ones.
So if you get stuck, you pretty much have to take that action early. The only other thing that I wish was thought about a little bit more was more ways to get any type of card because if you really want the structure cards and you're playing with the structure map, you've got to be a little more meticulous about how you get those cards. But all in all, it's a good expansion. I'm going to keep it in the collection. We're going to play it more, um but we're going to play Tuscany more than it. So that is Viticulture Bordeaux. I'm Brian Train here on the Dice Tower.
Mhm.