"Evacuation" First Impressions
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this episode I go over my first impressions and thoughts of evacuation the 2023 Spiel release by Vladimir sui art by Michael Peele and published by delicious games this is a game for wonderful players plays in about an hour to just over an hour or two hours wait at 3.9 five out of five on the BGG complexity scale and overall right now it is ranked 1,955 at the time of recording overall rating a 7.7 out of 10 based off of just shy of 1,000 ratings so I'm not going to go over a huge overview of what this game is or how it plays but you're basically taking a world that is on the brink of Destruction and transferring over people and resources over to a new world through euro mechanisms such as action selection with cards either with the backs of these cards representing no special actions or on the front side which do have individualized unique combinations of actions selected uh you can build different buildings and uh stadiums to increase points that you get popularity Etc things like that You're Building ships as well to transfer these
people and resources and you're doing this over four rounds which can go which seems pretty quick but in the scheme of things due to the amount of thinking that is required in this game and remembering all the rules and making sure that you take enough actions it does end up being a lot longer than it sounds in addition there is obviously a solo mode to this game as it is for one to four players and there's also two major ways to play this game either the race mode or the points mode so I should say that the four rounds mode is the points mode and you add up the points at the end of the game but the race mode includes fulfilling an overall objective of raising your production on the newer world to a level of eight and having three virtual reality machines on the new planet but anyway there are two different modes to play now what makes this game good or feel unique first to me is the action cards like I mentioned before the action cards that you play to take turns during the round are individualized and have different combinations of things that you can do in general across the board and so there is a lot of potential for drawing or drafting a hand which I believe is variant of this game as well to combine certain action cards onto
your board to create you know combinations that really help you out another thing that I love about this game is the Strategic avenues that are apparent in this game I feel like there's a lot of flexibility to what you can do in order to produce a viable strategy it's not a game where I feel like everyone is trying to accomplish the same formula every time you do a bit of everything which includes building ships building you know buildings and having the infrastru infrastructure to do so dressing up the progress track so you can be able to build on different sites on the new world Etc moving over stadiums and what have you they're all present in this game and you do need to do a little bit of everything but I feel like according to the circumstances that you have such as the action cards that you have in your hand as well as the objective cards the end of round bonuses that you can get as well as the endgame objectives that you can try to fulfill that are public in nature can really skew yourself towards different uh abilities and and actions to the point where some people might be building a lot of ships early on maybe some others build them later in the game you have some people progressing through the progress track really fast with other people slowing down and making sure they get the end game objectives before uh progressing through that progress track
really fast or taking lots of actions to do so because if you take a limited number of actions you do get those bonuses and they may help you out there are a lot of different ways that this game can go and I feel like there's a lot of fluidity from game to game based off of all of these factors and so there's a lot of different avenues that I think you can pursue in each game which makes it variable and then finally the Thematic integration is really nice I feel like the fact that you're starting with a old world with a lot of different resources gives you a big bump on what you can do you have lots of options starting out which I think leads into the fact that you can go in so many different routes is the fact that you start with so many resources and so it's almost sandboxy in nature in which direction you can take yourself but then things start to get a little bit more limited in the middle of the game as you're transferring over those resources towards the new world but then you end up having that benefit of having resources again and um options to pursue different actions that you can take it kind of follows uh kind of a curve in in the sense of being able to start with a lot of abilities and actions at the beginning it tapers in the middle becomes tight and then hopefully and ultimately becomes greater at the end of the game and so that does
in my opinion mirror the Thematic goal of this game by dismantling the old world and building that up on the new new world and the small mechanisms included in the game to mirror this for example the switching of the ships going back and forth from the new world to the old world creates that uh sense of tension and evacuation as you gain some benefits by moving those people from the old world to the new but it can you know help or hinder the amount of resources and abilities to take action the energy that you need to do actions with be can become limited as you continue that that progress and so that gave me the sense of tension as I was pursuing this especially playing with the PO SM mode and having only four rounds to accomplish everything that you want to do now for game comparisons I think you naturally need to compare this game to sui's other games such as underwater cities I think I will compare it mostly to that one although there may be some similarities among the other games as well but underwater cities has the action cards that are varied in nature in the combination with those on the uh worker placement board create the potential for combinations that you can get with the advanced variant in evacuation which I think mirrors that
the public objectives are also very similar and can skew your game in one way or the other some of them are located on your Tau in underwater cities which this game evacuation is missing however uh they're you know it it takes away the Tau nature of that and creates a more Central uh interactive point to where you're building into the new world and trying to compete for potentially some spots that may be beneficial to your to your strategies and my feeling is that there is not going to be a lot of interaction and that's partially based off of the comments of other players as well but there is that potential for that there another game that came to mind from 2022 was Space Station Phoenix this game is also space themed but it also Harbors the fact that you are starting with a lot of resources on the space station and you're dismantling that for resources to create a new way to gain points or to you know explore a certain Avenue of of building an engine to get points and so there are some similarities in in the big picture in when comparing these two games and then finally I'm going to compare this game to my favorite game agrica not only because of the varied cards in this game allowing for different combinations of play very similar in evacuation to the occupations and minor improvements in agrica but
also the feeling of tension and when I say tension I mean the the decisions that you make in this game are pulling you in multiple directions at the same time you have to keep track of a few different checklists or boxes to check off as you play this game for example knowing that you need to dismantle your old world to avoid like negative penalties keeping your resources in check but also making sure you have enough food to feed your people at the beginning of each round is in evacuation just as it is in Agricola and in addition to that you're trying to keep track of all the objectives that you're trying to fulfill similar to Agricola where you're trying to obtain as many different resources as you can to avoid negative points and very much just build out your farm in a balanced way with some focuses here and there to maximize as many points as possible which is dictated mostly through the cards that you draft or are dealt with at the beginning of the game similar to evacuation where you can utilize those cards in hand to pursue a combination of different objectives throughout the game itself maximizing those points and so there's a lot of tough decisions and once again turning to the points mode of evacuation the timer of this game is is ever looming to
be able to accomplish all of those objectives or in a sense you might not OB you know obtain all the objectives that you're trying to fulfill and you have to make some sacrifices here and there making the best choice as possible for the end game as well as in the situation and the moment that you're in when you make those decisions and so I I feel like it's got the similar amount of of tension that is obtained through Agricola even in the sense of random things happening during the game to entice you in one way or the other perhaps you see a new ship that is flipped over in evacuation that is tempting and that may fill a spot in your strategy or a different uh building or INF infrastructure you name it uh the constant cycling through those plans and and cards as well as drawing new cards from the deck itself if you're playing with the advanced variant can create an opportunity for uh something that might lead you astray from your main objective or at least what you thought was your main objective at the beginning of the game which creates a interesting and enriching situation for decisions that I get the same feeling from when I play Agricola so there's that now I'm going to read some compilations of comments that were made on Board Game Geek I've summarized them through AI technology to
see what people said in general who rated this game highly versus those who rated it lowly and first for the high ratings uh is as said as follows players praise its unique gameplay Arc thematic integration and strategic depth with varying preferences for different game modes and modules emphasizing the importance of the advanced card variant for an enhanced experience some players highlight the game's challenging nature requiring multiple plays to fully grasp as an overarching um and that's the end of the quote but an overarching sense of this game requiring multiple plays I think does fall in the nature that the rule are a little bit complex which I'll talk about here in a little bit with the low ratings but the overall sense of Mastery of this game I think is appealing to many people where playing it once is not enough to gain a grasp of what you can do strategically in this game and I think in addition to just learning and understanding and internalizing the rules over a first the first couple of plays I think it would take an additional couple of plays to really understand the strategy and the adaptation that you have based on the cards and the objectives that are randomly dealt at the beginning of the game and in addition to the variety in which you can play this game with the points versus the race mode some people enjoy that the drafting as well and the
Thematic integration I think are highlights for people for this game however some people gave it the low rating and this is what they said in summary despite despite initially liking the concept players expressed disappointment with evacuation citing issues with tedious gameplay the feeling of playing a solo game poor rulebook Clarity and a lack of satisfaction in the execution of the theme with specific concerns about the quality of components colors and overall game experience race mode seemed to be a challenge was very Su endings end quote so I can't speak to the physical components of this game as I demo this game virtually however the rule book quality does concern me a little bit I did have lots of questions that I had to turn to board game geek for in order to figure out and so there were some hiccups along the way as I learned this game that I can say that I agree with some of the comments made here now the interactive versus multiplayer solitary experience where a lot of people feel like this this is a more multiplayer solitire type of game yes I can see how that is true as you are playing actions to your own Tableau you're not uh outing anyone else or blocking anyone from taking certain actions you're most likely solving a puzzle on your board and being efficient
as efficient as possible pursuing the objectives that are made available to everyone there may be some slight interaction to where can build and move people onto the new world but there are I think multiple and plenty spots for all players to choose from there may be some more competition though at higher player counts that is left unsaid on my end but I think that's where some people might have some issues there uh the complexity of the rules as well can be challenging and some people don't uh really like the race mode it seemed very rushed and abrupt with its ending and it made a hard first experience to experience this game and perhaps the points mode is a little bit quicker a little bit more standardized and it can most likely lead to a better experience firsthand but that is left to be said for me for me personally I played this with the points mode and I did have an enjoyable experience so anecdotally take that as it may in conclusion I really enjoy this game and it is something that is very appealing to me to want to play more and get better at becoming closer and closer to a lifestyle game and I think this is probably my favorite Sushi game out of all the ones that I've tried I mean I really enjoy underwater cities Woodcraft
and missing the 1347 however I think evacuation plays a lot more similarly to some of my favorite games including Agricola in the way that you are making tough decisions from turn to turn the variety that is present in this game through the medium of cards uh in your hand and that you're taking actions with as well as the interesting uh way that you're mechanically and thematically progressing through this game dismantling an engine and a resource pool that you start with that is very high at the beginning of the game and kind of tapering off and hopefully building back up again at the end of the game is an arc of gameplay that I really enjoy I love the flexibility of the strategy that you can take in this game which you can explore on your own to see what may work better or you can really try to follow those objectives and and tailor your game in a certain way that may be different from your previous experiences which is something that I enjoy in a lot of other games that I rate highly and so I think evacuation also rates highly among them and I can't wait to play this more so those are my first thoughts and impressions of evacuation and I thank you for listening or viewing this uh review until now and hope you schedule an appointment with us really soon uh to catch us on the next review take care