Clans of Caledonia: Industria - Derailed or On Track?
Transcript
Hello and welcome back out to the Dice Tower. I'm Wendy Ye.
And I'm Chris Ye.
And today we're going to be reviewing Clans of Calonia Industria.
What we have here, this is the big box, but we're going to be focusing the review on the expansion, the Industria part of it,
that extra content. Yeah.
Yeah. Because we re we both really like the base game a ton.
Yeah. This one or the base game is like a nine for me. So, I absolutely adore it.
I'm right there with you. Tom reviewed it originally on the channel years before we worked here and he gave it a seal of excellence as well. Uh, so yeah, we both really like Clans of Cal Calonia. Review done, but we got the expansion to talk about as well.
Yeah. So, Chris will show you briefly how all that is included and then we'll come back with our thoughts.
I'm going to go through a lot of different shots explaining the different things that come in the expansion, but it's just a kind of a quick recap on the Clans of Calonia. Uh, the game has a map over here. Every player has their own player board, and you're spending money to build out these factories onto different parts of the map, completing different end of round goals, but also as you move things off the board, you're going to get more and more uh income and production. So, being able to get different types of goods and be able to get money the more that you build out on the map. So, the map matters a lot. And the basic game came with a double-sided map that you could play on. The Industria expansion comes with four new map tiles, which are also double-sided. And here's the back side of the map. So, you can see that on both A and B side of the new four map tiles, you're going to see there's a lot more of these small lock spaces so that you can sail across as compared to the original game, this side has more of the little ones, but on the front side had more just big clumps.
So, the maps are going to uh interact differently with the players. In addition to four modules which change up the gameplay, the industry expansion also comes with just more of the same stuff you've already seen. So more port city tiles. It comes with these half hexes because whether you're playing with the train module or not, you can turn on one half or the other half of that particular tile. Here there are more end of round bonus scorings. So based on whether you have animals built next to each other or types of industries built next to each other, production chains building next to lock spaces or not or having larger groups. There's also nine new clans here and these lean into different mechanisms of the game, focusing a little bit on trying to build certain types adjacent to each other, production chains and such. There are ones that allow you to do some of the new stuff in the expansion like build multiple pieces in the same space. So having multiple animals in the same area. There are other ones that limit your ability to move across lakes, but instead you pay to move two spaces away, and those are counted as connected for the end of the game. There's one that creates a special type of resource called kilts, where you turn wool into kilts, giving wool a production chain. So there are nine of these. They're all explained very well in the back of the rule book. There's also starting tiles over here as well as the new scoring pad which is going to factor in scoring for the uh two or three of the other modules here. So, let's talk about what those modules introduce. Starting with the smallest module, you'll place out one of these
endgame bonus scoring tiles. You'll just simply place one by the end of the game. Uh and you will earn bonus points, 12 for first place and six points for second place of whatever the randomized category chosen is. So having the most points earned during the game or most leftover coins or leftover resources, building adjacent to locks for having the most of of the single type of resource imported. And all of these are also double-sided for a two-player game where the players earn eight and then zero points. So that's the smallest of all the modules. The next module here is this contract board. This is just a preview of the contracts that are available for grabs right now. When these have to be refilled at the end of a round, you will refill any empty spaces from the front of the board here and move these along and then refill tiles from the back. The other thing you'll notice is that when players earn one of these symbols here, this reward that says uh normally in the basic game, grab three tiles and then choose to keep one if you would like, you instead get to see this preview of the three in the front and choose from amongst those.
Clan Buchanan gets to pick from this wider swath over here. The third module of the expansion are the farmers market tiles. Players are going to take turns setting these out at start of setup of the game and you are going to have them equal to the number of players on the board. What you will do is during game play as you expand adjacent to a farmers market. You can immediately perform a sell action of the two types of goods indicated on that tile. You can sell up to four of them as it shows here on the back of any of these tiles as a reference. And you can sell for additional pounds. So right now, this player red could sell up to four cheese. And because it is a processed good, each one of these is going to be worth three additional pounds on top of the current market price of 13. You take one of the resources that you sold and you place it on top of that farmers market tile to show that that part has been fulfilled.
Once both parts of the farmer market have been used, this tile is removed from the map and this is now a normal usable space while farmers market tiles are out there. You cannot expand into them. However, because of this extra influx of money, players are to put this tile out during setup, which is going to reduce the amount of money earned when passing uh for just the basic income over there. The last and largest module here is the train board module which comes with a secondary player aid card as it comes with two extra actions that you can take. You can move your train to make a delivery and then you can also place out a milestone. So let's talk about those. Now on your turn, one of the actions that you can do is you can choose to move your train up to two steps. If you pass into or through a space with an opponent's piece, you have to pay them three coins. However, when you land in a spot, you must be able to pay the cost shown on this tile here. As you do so, you'll knock your train over to show that it's been done for the round because you can only do this one time each round. You pay for the delivery, and then you gain the benefits shown on the tile here. You'll then also claim one of your milestone markers, which looks like a little bit like a gravestone marker, and you're going to place it into your supply. A later action that you can do is the milestone action wherein if you meet the conditions of one of these four milestones shown on the board. For example, I have two contracts that award at least three hops. I can for an action place this milestone marker from my
supply onto the largest available victory point spot here and that will be tallied up at the end of the game. Each of these milestones also unlocks a part of the board. So Edinburgh over here is not accessible. that's locked until you place your milestone marker. Then in a future movement, you can go into Edinburghough and make this trade here. As you do so in either Edinburgh or Glasgow, you'll get two points. Now, the other two over here are tunnels that you're allowed to move through. So, if you unlock this, then you can move through this tunnel here. You'll come out the other side and then you'll get a bonus action. So on top of moving your train, doing the trade in and getting the benefits, you'll get to take another action right away and you have further access to the different parts of the board. So that is the last module. Oh, I should also note by the way that if you are playing with two players as a backside to the board and you also put out these miniature trains and the mini trains uh when you move, you have to also move your mini train and it exists simply as a foil so that if your opponent moves through uh either one of your trains, they have to pay you £3.
So, that's the last expansion module there. That's the train board. Now, let's get back up and let's see what we think about it. All right, so starting off as a package, if you do end up enjoying the expansion, it is nice that it all comes together. I feel like it's very clearly laid out and labeled within the rule book and everything. Like, it's pretty clear.
Yeah, the big box has uh it's it's funny. This big box is like twice as thick as the original box was. One of my favorite parts about Clans of Calonia is that there's this big heavy euro that came in this like teeny tiny box, you know, but uh it also has better storage solutions and stuff like that. Trays that actually have lids and work and all that stuff.
And they hold Yeah. the contracts, they hold the player pieces.
Yeah,
I think that's that's nifty.
I believe that there is a box that is just the expansion if you already own the original game. Uh but we can't speak to that because we were sent the or got the big box for the review.
Yeah, that we did. Uh so talking about some of the the modules and stuff that's included. Um I think my favorite module of them all is just adding in the extra player powers like getting new powers that to me it feels like the original game. You just add in some cool new effects.
There are a couple of features in this expansion. uh when you open up the front rule book, it says, "Hey, here's a couple of like key things that we've added in." One of my favorites is that those clans lead to little things, little effects where you can build multiple of your pieces in the same space. Uh and that leads to some interesting decisions because as you fulfill contracts that require meat in this game, you have to take one of your sheep or your cows from the board, slaughter it,
uh and return it to your board. And now you can double up on a space occasionally, right, with like a special power or special option. And so you don't have to sacrifice the connections or you can still leave those those gaps on purpose to create like the the disconnected u but or like the separate but connected clusters together.
Yeah. And sometimes you don't have to pay that extra land cost again if you've already paid the land cost. So, it's kind of like a free spot to build candles. I think it's cool. It adds in some of those cool like mechanical elements to that base game that I think Yeah, like they just feel like a little bit more. I appreciate the clans make it feel like you're working towards something a little bit different in the game.
Yeah.
Uh the next module I want to talk about is the farmers markets. And those I could take them or leave them honestly.
100%. Yeah.
You get a little less income and you get what a couple tradein options if you build around it. I I honestly just felt like they were kind of meh.
I agree. They were they were they required you to think more about when you could expand into certain areas
and the game already has the basic game of of classic Calonia already has this great mechanism where as you build adjacent to other players, you can purchase things at a discount. And so this is like selling for an extra boost of like two or three pounds. And I I didn't feel like it was worth the extra thinking of like, okay, I can't build there yet because I don't have enough cheese. No, I just kind of want to be able to expand how I want. So this
Yeah,
it it's take it or leave it honestly on the negative side for me.
And I didn't feel like the benefit of what you got financially was that much more
and you have to sacrifice. You put that overlay on the end of round passing income and you feel that difference of like three or four pounds each round that you pass. Like ah that doesn't doesn't feel great.
Yeah. All right. And on to the train tracks.
Uh, well, let's talk about some of the other things. So, there another one.
Yeah. Well, there's there's there's the end of round, end of game bonus.
That's right. Yes.
The 16 points and the
I actually really liked that part.
You did?
Yeah.
Yeah. I thought it was gives you another endgame thing to work towards.
Mhm. I forgot about it half the time. And if you if you do end up building towards it, you're like, "Oh, cool. Hey, points at the end.
Points." In a two-player game, it's binary eight or nothing. in a in a higher player count game, it's first and second place. It fits right in with everything else that the basic game does already. So, yeah, I think that one's a good little module.
I don't think it's necessary, though.
No, exactly.
I think it's just useful.
The next module is the display board of the contracts.
And
that's nice.
It's
It's nice to look ahead a little bit.
Yeah. Yep. You It kind of gives you more to plan them. I think that's a recurring theme of this expansion. It gives you more control and more more ability to balance plates that are spinning because you no longer uh you at certain moments grab three random contracts and choose one to keep. You see what that display is ahead of time. You know what contracts are coming. You know what are the three that you can look at and take one from. I don't know if it's worth the extra headache though of knowing I have that extra plate to keep spinning. But it is better. But it's more work.
But it's also more painful when someone else grabs it first if they have access to that area before you. Yes.
And you're like, "No,
I've been waiting for it to get into that spot."
Yeah. So, it's a mixed bag. This I think it's probably good. And I think most players who like taking games a little heady, a little seriously are going to love that because there's a bit more control.
Take it or leave it for me. I think it's all right.
Yeah. Now, the biggest of the modules here is the train map, the extra whole actions, the extra board, the extra iconography, everything that goes along with that.
It literally doubles the size of of the game. Like, it is the size of the game board again. And so, it is big.
It's big. It's a little hard to like read and everything. And you have and you have to position the stuff so that like something is going to be far from someone which I thought part of the appeal of Clans of Calonia is that it is
small size. Yeah.
Yeah. It's a little bit more compact of a bigger thinkier Euro game like of this weight. It it like punches into a higher weight class than it is and then it looks like and everything. And this module and this whole expansion box in general just puts more weight into the game. I think for me the iconography was such a problem. It was such a struggle with this industria map. So you have the the delivery bonus tiles, right? Um and some of them are large big pictures and some of them they had to squeeze a bunch of icons into a tiny little space and so from a distance like I can't see the what it is. Like even if I understood what the icons were, I can't see them. But then they just I feel like the icons are just over the top, right? everything in the base game. I had to look up what the ports maybe.
You look up the ports, you have to look up and clarify what every player's clan does.
Yeah, but once you've got that, maybe the end round bonuses. Once you've got that, you're like, "Okay, I'm good. That's like a handful of things I have to look up." But this is just like a sprawling map of stuff that I have to look up. And then the it's just so busy. The train tracks everywhere and you're like, "Okay, I can take this train track, but I can't take this one because it's locked." but it looks very similar to the one that's unlocked that it's just busy visually. And so it was a lot to a lot to like parse and a lot to comprehend and understand just visually.
When you move and you get to a a city or a town or whatever, you have to pay that delivery tile shown in the middle, the the delivery cost. And it's so expensive.
Oh my gosh,
it is sometimes as expensive as fulfilling a contract. maybe like a slightly lower cost contract, but it is about you're sacrificing as many resources just to go to a city to get a bonus that you have to look up and you have to ask, "Hey, can you hand me the rule book? What is that uh there?" Yeah.
So, you're giving up a lot to get something that hopefully is worth it and then you're unlocking some points as you remove those milestone markers each round that you make a delivery. You get two points, then four points, you know, at the end of the game. You can get up to 20 points, but you have to make a delivery every single round of the game
to make it to the 20 points. Yes.
To make it to the 20 points, that's really costly. And I I made I mentioned earlier the idea of spinning plates. This board to me is a lot of plates to spin at once. If the display of of contracts ahead of time is like one extra plate that you're like, "Oo, is it worth this extra work for this fun?" This one is like adding five spinning plates to a game where you're already spinning multiple. I don't think at that point it is worth the effort for the amount of fun and the payout that you get.
And I think that each individual space, if you take it at its cost for the goods that you have to pay, which by the way change if someone else has paid that and gone there the the round before you, right?
Yes.
Uh so that changes entirely, which is ridiculous. Um, but on top of that, the actions themselves sometimes have big costs. You know, you're like, "Oh, cool. I can sell a cow for $25." Well, that is now a cow I don't have. So, not only did I get rid of a beer, a milk, and a
whiskey.
Oh, whatever. A whiskey, a beer, and wool.
But on top of that, I also have to get rid of a cow.
All for $25 and two or three points from that little the little piece that comes off. It just doesn't feel worth it. And I know that it might it does at the end of the day like it is worth more. If you calculate all that stuff, would it be worth $25 plus the points? It's probably worth more. But it doesn't feel that for all the work that you have to put in to get the exact things that you need and also not have it mess up. Like like you mentioned, I could have fulfilled a contract for that and that contract might have been 20 points. And so it's like is that is that worth it? It might have. Yeah. Be between like the import goods and the other stuff and then the upgrade or if you get 10 pounds out of doing that contract.
So that's the problems. I feel like the built-in systems of the basic game are more elegant and they're cleaner and you don't have to look up as much iconography and all of this extra stuff is work and you can you can work so hard to come out and be ahead five more points than you would have been if you had ignored that part.
Yeah. But it doesn't feel good and and more than five points because you also unlock milestone markers and then right hopefully you have played a game in such a way that you qualify for milestones earlier than other people have so you can get the eight points but you might only get four or you might only get two points for completing that milestone because other people did it earlier than you.
Sure. I think about like the last game that we played, right? I think I got 17 points total from that board. I dabbled in it a little bit, but I did get two out of the four milestones, like the the higher point ones, right? Yeah. Which is huge.
And I'm still like I got like 17 points from it.
That's still potentially less than one contract when you get all the endgame multipliers and stuff.
Yeah.
It's just And I think the thing is is it doesn't add fun. None of there was never a point that I was like, "Oo, I'm so excited to move my train. Oh, I'm so excited to block your train for $3. Also, that's annoying. Um, it just is. Um, but yeah, it didn't ever add anything that was thrilling or exciting or I feel like I had this massive big payout that was like, yes, that was work worth all the work and all the investment and all the plates spinning brain stuff that I did. It just I just kept ignoring it and being like, uh, I don't want to do this. And of course, I I played it because I had to for this review. But if I were to play this again, I honestly would probably just ignore it and just play all the basic stuff and just be like, "Chris, you can go play with the trains. That's fine."
Well, here's the thing. I'll just be more straightforward than that. I don't think that this expansion is worth it. I It doesn't add enough fun and enjoyment to me for the amount of work that it adds. I don't think any of the modules is really that strong. And I think that the biggest module that takes the most rules and takes the most real estate and everything is the worst module, unfortunately. And I feel rough saying that, but I I don't like playing with the trains at all. I think very very high level players are going to love it. They're going to enjoy squeezing every drop of juice out of that lemon. Uh and and at some point, I just think I'd rather just I'd rather not. I would no longer like to squeeze because I'm tired of it and it distracts me and it makes me a slower player at this game.
Final thoughts and and scores, I think, because less we keep repeating ourselves here.
Sure. Sure. So, final thoughts and scores. I'm coming in at a five for this because of the expansion. Like I mentioned, base game for me, nine. Absolutely love it. The expansion, like you mentioned, the board, it's just not fun. It doesn't add any good elements for me at all when it comes to that train board. And that really is the bulk of the expansion. Sure, having new player powers, that's nice. Being able to put animals on the same space because of said player powers, that's a cool little thing. It's unnecessary. Uh farmers market, don't really love them. They're fine if they're out, whatever. Um, you know what I mean? Like, I just go through all the modules and I think the the best one is not that amazing. So, it's just yeah, it's a five for me.
I'm I'm not happy. This was a big disappointment.
For me, my favorite part of the expansion is just the what we call on the Dicer channel, the more stuff,
the more stuff that you already had in the base game. More port tiles, more end of round scoring, more clans. That's awesome. I really like those. Every other module I could take or leave to actively dislike. Uh, and so at the at the risk of repeating everything that you said, including down to the number, this is a five for me.
Oh, it's a five for you, too? I I don't I don't think it's worth it. Uh, but what I will say is if you enjoy Terrammystica and Gaia Project, those level of games, and you like Clans of Calonia, but wish that it was more like those, this is the g this is the expansion that introduces all that extra work, all of that extra, can I sacrifice one of these QVEC cubes in order to get two of the blue stuff and one coin in order to be able to move up this track, which gives me back one of those and turns these two into that all so that I can do this other move for two extra points that I could have if I had just done this more obvious and straightforward route and this is the expansion that makes this more in line with Gaia Project. I think that Terrammystica and Gaia Project are very amazing games that for me are not worth the amount of effort and that's how I feel about this expansion. It's brilliant and I think people who are highlevel players will love that extra work.
That's interesting because I'm fine playing Terrammystica and um
Project. Yeah, I'm fine with those and I don't feel like they're too much work, but I'm not going to ever be amazing at them. This one I I still feel like it's too much work.
So, there you go. Unfortunately, yeah, five from both of us for the Clans of Calonia industry expansion. Thanks for sticking with us through this review here. Uh, hope that was insightful for you. But of course, if you really enjoy it, comment below. Read below. Yeah, read the comments below for maybe alternate opinions, of course, because this is just our takeaway from it.
That's fair. All right, thanks for joining us today. I'm Wendy Ye.
And I'm Chris Ye.
And go ride them.
Chew.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from the Dice Tower. Hey, do you want to learn more about us, communicate with us? We have a Facebook group. We have a Discord channel. Lots of different ways to get involved with the Dice Tower. You can find that in our link tree link below. So, just click that. It will take you and you can communicate with us on Facebook. Join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of the Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Vassel.