Terra Nova Roundtable Review
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome to the friendly ties podcast I am here today with my friends Jonathan and Anastasia hello hey and we are here today to talk about Terra mystica light or my first Terra mystica which is called Terra Nova my first chair I like it alright so we're here to talk about Terra Nova today so uh for those of you who don't know and and probably many of you do Terra Nova is I'm not joking it is the the smaller streamlined cleaner version of Terra mystica which is a game that came out like maybe a decade ago at this point something about that um and they sort of have yeah I think so yeah it's had two expansions and then they made Gaia project which is off the same like fundamental system and then now they they said all right we're gonna go backwards because the guy project was up in difficulty so let's step it down in difficulty um go back to our core routes and we're gonna we're gonna make Terra Nova uh which is which is just a streamlined cleaner smaller version of of the Terra mystica game yeah uh and I I'll say right now I was I've been really excited for this game to come out um I love Tara mystica I've played tons and tons and tons of times uh on BGA in particular but I also own a copy myself and I've just I've I've loved it since my first play that says a lot considering yes
actually on this game yeah yeah I do I don't own any of the expansions I just owned the like base fundamental game it's in like my dad got it for me for for Christmas and my dad's German so I have like German first edition I love it collector um but I don't really get to play it with people too much because uh I've played so much at this point that like playing with anyone of my like local friends uh is is kind of pointless I'm just I'm just Leaps and Bounds better than other folks at the game just have so much more experience at it so I'm super excited for the idea of Terra Nova I'm I was hoping essentially to play a game that had the same fundamental Core Concepts but it was more accessible and then therefore more fun for other people to get into sure how about the two of you where are you at in your experience levels of the the Terra Universe yeah first I just want to pause and say that there is a Christmas parade occurring outside I was gonna ask you about that yeah can we hear the sirens and a little bit okay the Sirens of Joy it's good to hear that it's a parade because I was worried the building was burning down I'm gonna just hope for the best because I'm pretty sure when the sirens stop a marching band is gonna start I'm pretty sure that there is going to be a very loud Christmas parade going on behind us so we're gonna just hope for the best here so you know I have played Terra mystica I want to say like two or three times
I've played it on Yukata and I pretty sure I did that thing where you know I was like I don't really know what I'm doing let me just play and see what happens so like I don't even know if I can count those plays but I definitely have played it a couple times on there and it's been years but guy of project I've actually played quite a bit and it was interesting to me though because in both cases it's been a while so when John was teaching the game there was like this really lovely like he finished and I was like oh that's basically teravistica like without all the extra rule overhead like it's just like I was like cool like that that like you know that that feeling that you get when you like sort of remember the rules to the game but you remember like 70 that's exactly what the teach of Terra Nova felt like to be I was like cool I don't need to look at the rule book I don't need to do anything else like that's it everything that if I were to sit in conversation say to you what is like what are the fundamentals of Terra mystica and I was like oh there's power there's characters you know there's these actions that's it that's all the Terra Nova is and like so I must admit like when we sat down I was like this is lovely like it's just in terms of like overhead because that's what stops me I own guy project for a while and I was just like I'm never gonna play the solo I'm never gonna teach this to anyone like this just it's too much and and and even as we were playing this game there was like I was having like we'll talk about this a little bit like some almost trauma response to like the amount of overhead that goes into both of Terra mystica and Guy project the
ability to mess yourself up the number of little things you have to keep track of that for me it's a very enjoyable game when I'm playing it if really got it loaded up and I'm like really dialed in but it's a it's a it's a hard game for me to get the table and it's a it's a it's a very heavy game in my opinion that I just I don't I don't find myself returning to all that often yeah yeah um I've played Terra mystica three times guy project six I believe and and my I remember when guy project came out and I was so excited about it I played Terra mystica and then you know terroristic got in space I love sci-fi settings and everything um and I ultimately enjoyed guy projects you know I played it three times as many times as uh Terra mystica but um my big takeaway from it is is it almost did too much like it like it frustrated me and what I really wanted was a game between Terra mystica and Gaia project was kind of my my uh my fantasy for this type of thing and the Terra Nova came out and it's it's not between them it's actually it puts Terra mystica in between guy project and Terra Nova and so I was really curious to try it for sure because of that also as the rules teacher I like the idea of Terra mystica with like 30 less rules and less components and all that kind of thing um so yeah I came in with it into the with with a pretty decent expectations as well and uh I I played this one three times now um and you two we literally just played a three player game of this like 20 minutes ago and then we turned on the microphone so we're trying to capture like First Impressions from the two of you and you know I I've got a couple of games under my belt one of
them actually was a uh sponsored playthrough With Friends video on the jungus games YouTube channel uh that's gonna be myself and my friend Dave uh playing a two-player game of it so if you're curious uh that one should have come out already you can search for that and uh and see about how the game plays uh yeah so first impressions uh mine is is positive with some nuanced opinions what about you two I liked it um I'm a I'm a heavier gamer and so it's not it's not terroristic our guy project if that's what you're looking for um but it I think has that same sort of like core Loop um I've got a couple things that I like and a couple things that I dislike that will will I'm sure kind of dive a little bit more into um but I liked it but I wasn't in love with it I think because my like my gut my gut reaction I guess a better question specifically for you Nick I'm really curious about what Anastasia has to say as well but but Nick since you've played guitar music so many times um I was really curious to see your take because it really seems like Terra Nova was designed at least from my perspective for people who taramiska looked too complicated for or maybe they tried tiramis to go on something like this is too much for me um so it's not Terra mystica 2 in any way and it almost seems like it was designed not for the Knicks of the world and so that's why I'm I'm quite curious to hear what a Nick thinks yeah I mean I I think you're right I don't think that this is a this is necessarily a great game for just anybody to pick up though um I think one thing that this game lives in is that I could bring it to a
board game night and teach it to people and that's that's pretty legit but like people who are not who describe themselves as as light Gamers or party Gamers this is not this is not for them at all um it's it sits in like the I like to play you know light light Medium games like difficulty level and I think that is already a pretty flush Market yeah we talk about those games a lot in this podcast I feel like yeah yeah yeah so I'm not sure that it it fills a unique space which um I'll be curious to see how it succeeds in the coming you know year or whatever yeah yeah I completely agree with you guys you know there's been a trend lately I feel like with these games where it's like you know we take the the heavier game and then we create the lighter version right and I think what sort of started with a lot of like like oh here's you know castles of burgundy the dice game or here's TWA the rolling right or here's like whatever you know and so I think that it is interesting to now see this moving into like truly like new games like you know the the um terrifying Mars what is the Aries Edition one called Aries Expedition I think yeah okay and it's been interesting because as a rule I tend to be like you know what if I've gone to the effort to learn the heavier game why am I gonna play the lighter game right like what like like within reason except to your point Nick which is like if I really love a game ability to get
into the table although there still creates a gap here which is essentially like well if I really love the game is the Lesser game like is it still even going to be worth my time to get the Leicester game to the table even with new people like might I not find a different game or something else so up to this point I've been somewhat like I'd rather play terraforming Mars or I'd rather play whatever you know castles of burgundy or whatever within reason because some of those games they create really unique cool experiences I actually really like castles burgundy the dice game and I really like castles of burgundy so it's always going to be a like we'll see and so I too was really excited to play Terra Nova and I will say that for me this delivered like I don't know that I would buy this game and I but that's I don't own Terra mystica either but I would happily play this game now I do have some qualms with it but I think for me in terms of like which one would I rather go to if it was just like hey let's sit down and we're going to play a game I think I would pick this one up and I think because of that added complexity it was really nice to play a Terra mystica that was only the 70 of the rules that I remember off the top of my head you know I just I I think that that delivered here but I do think there are a few drawbacks to that but this is this is a game that I feel like I can play against Nick and not feel like I'm just going to get murdered out of the gate and
um well and frankly beat him yes yeah so we just finished the game and you know numbers can be interesting one number in particular we played a three-player game of Terra Nova and it took about 80 minutes um it was my third play first time for both of you but your experience with these kind of games but that's not bad you know there were definitely times in this play that we just did that I I started sitting there feeling like that that familiar feeling uh that I've had in Terra mystica and Guy project of oh I've screwed up I I you know this is a a quite strategic game of resource management there's really only one resource in this game well kind of two money and power and you know it's a game where you're going to be going through rounds and you're spending money in a variety of ways to do a variety of things and you're spending four money here six money there seven money eight money and you want to make sure that you can do do the things that you need to in time and definitely moments where I'm like I'm one money short I should have done this before that and then I looked at the clock and it's like oh we've only been playing for 40 minutes and the game is over halfway done cool like I I made a mistake I'll try not to make that mistake next time whereas you know I've really enjoyed playing guide project I've played it six times but from my recollection those plays usually took between two and three hours like they're a heavy game like a big time strategy game and then the AP really sets in even in that first hour because I'm like I don't want to make a mistake now that's gonna cause me to be you know out of the running an hour and a half from now whereas in Terra Nova it's like if I make a mistake right now that's fine the game's gonna be over in 40 minutes and I'll try to learn from it and do a
better next time all of these games have a snowballing aspect to them I think that's what people like about the game they like the economy infrastructure right there's something so satisfying in every one of these games about taking something off your board putting it into play and now look it down in my mat and that is my income it's a very very clean mechanism I think Terra Mystic was one of the first ones to really do it on a bigger scale yeah a lot of other game designs have I think taken it on since I think Eclipse came out around the same time time but they were they were right there yeah when I see that now in a game like my default is like well I'm gonna like this game like I I just I love the way that it is aesthetically and also mechanically but it it creates you know having strong economic starts in all of these games is is the fundamental core Loop to the game and I think one thing that I would Levy as a criticism strategically against Terra Nova is that because there's only one resource money I mean there's power but let's let's uh we'll come back to Power later but like since money is really the primary resource I think the snowballing in this game is even more dramatic than the other games because in Gaia project workers tend to be kind of the limiting factor but you still need to pay attention to your money and Terra mystica money and workers but usually money tends to be more the limiting factor and you can get into a situation where you've had a really strong start but you only have essentially access to one of the resources so you might kind of be choked out a little bit in terms of like yes you have a better economy
than I do but my economy is more balanced and so actually I'm having just as good turns as you are kind of throughout the course of the game whereas in Terra Nova if I explode at the beginning if I have a stronger first turn by definition I just have more resources and I'm likely to just have a stronger second turn than you and then a third turn and so on so forth basically until the end of the game yeah um so it's nice that this game is shorter because when someone starts running away um it's I think harder to catch them in this game than it is in the other ones because they're it's not as because it is smoother right it means that if you're in the lead you're less likely to stumble there's less levers to pull to to Nitro boost you back in or something yeah take a risk and whatnot a hundred percent and I want to like acknowledge that so you know we we've just finished a game of this I very quickly I came out ahead and like yes I was playing a faction that gave me three houses and then houses were rewarded at the in the first turn like there it just I kind of played into it you got more points and more money than both of us in the first round and you want points and money in this game exactly but I'm used to playing Terra mystica guy project I'm used to that feeling I kind of referenced this earlier that sort of like you know trauma responses a little over dramatic for the for a board game but what I'm trying to say is like that's just this feeling of oh God like that's not gonna last or I haven't thought hard enough about what I'm doing or this is all going to fall apart or or I need to like analyze every little thing and so Nick pointed out in like the second turn that I was like 10 15
points ahead of them and I was complaining like I was like I was like I don't know what to do I've had anxiety but like that was just gonna come crumbling down and because I feel like in this game there is there is less to do there's like there you know power is fairly static your abilities there there's so much of it it's at 70 poor you know as we've been saying from terramysica but the things that they took out were kind of the edge cases the sort of like slip around here or do this or maybe you know grab a little bit of something here and like so you can get to a position where in a round you may do two things and then kind of like have to pass because you're out of money or you're out of power I mean I think at most you took we took like two power actions to turn maybe that was like that was an extreme I think I I think I took one power action a turn if I was lucky and not even in every round and so I just I guess like you're I totally agree with you Nick that there's just this element of like because it's smoother there's less to do there's less to catch up like you said you can also kind of like stay in the lead having said that and I'm sure we'll talk about it Nick then in the last round like roared ahead and then only lost by one point so there still was a lot of balance in that and like I said to them when we finished the game I was really grateful to see that because even though I did win and I was
ahead from the beginning I only won by one point which in this game is not a tremendous amount of points so yeah I thought that was really interesting too yeah one thing that jumped out to me the first time I played this one was that because there's less going on there's no uh Temple tracks technology tracks like that whole aspect of terroristic and Guy project are gone there is less ways to score points and that you know makes sense as a streamlined experience and in each one of the games rounds there's five rounds you randomly pull out a token and at the beginning of the game so you know what they all are at the start and that token incentivize is doing a particular thing so like in round one maybe you really want to make trading posts and in round two you really want to terraform and in round three you really want to make the basic unit and and you get bonus points for doing those things then so this is a big part of the planning and the strategy of the game is is trying to get victory points from those and when it comes to points in the game those are a huge portion of them there's also this incentive to make towns which are you know clusters of your buildings and we don't need to go into those details that's another good way to make points and it's certainly something that you're angling for it but that's kind of it to a certain extent at the very end of the game there's a one majority scoring for having the most of your uh buildings that are next to each other but I I found you know I've played this game three times I found that at the end of the game you can certainly find yourself in a situation where that last round you don't actually have that much that you can do to score victory points I've had experiences where you know I've had a bunch of money like you know 18 money and I'm like okay I could build this building I could build that building I
can upgrade this I can upgrade that but why you know I realized oh wait none of those things are actually going to get me two victory points they might um the game we just played I was nowhere near close to either of you for the majorities of buildings so it's not like I could even contest that I mean the two of you had incentives to build buildings and Vie for that majority which makes sense um and yeah in the game that we just played I took one action I built a palace which was nice and it was incentivized I got points and then on my second action in the final round I passed and I got a bunch of points when I passed because of various other things there's points on these passing tokens I don't want to undersell the number of ways you can get victory points but it is true that in the last round of the game I functionally took one action and I don't actually think that's necessarily a bad thing it's just something to go into because yeah for these economic strategy type engine building games you can expect that ramp and and that's not always the case sometimes that fifth round is is maybe a little bit physically at least as far as big moves are concerned which again is not necessarily a bad thing it's just you know trying to get points is where you can and and not throwing money away at things that don't give you points yeah to really leverage I think the last round in this game it's it's like Gaia project for instance is a game where I tend to end the game with too many resources and I should have pivoted into scoring points more in the mid game when I was still kind of like building my economy and Terra Nova I think has a similar kind of feel that you are supposed to prognosticate what you're doing for the next couple of rounds round three four and five so that you
have something to do on the fifth turn of the game um and if you don't have much to do on the last turn of the game hopefully it's because you essentially cashed in your points in the third and fourth rounds and you're like great I'm okay with having sort of a fizzle end here I think that's that's reasonable but I do think that this strategically I mean like Play Wise I think it's welcoming but I do think still strategically folks who have that better sense of the arc are going to are going to have a just a a different experience a more not smooth but they're going to understand like how they want to kind of score points over the course of those rounds but a lot of the times like you're you're going to get into a position where you're like oh great like because I don't have the research track or the temple tiles from um Tara Mr from guy project that say Hey doing this thing's course points I really just I'm just I'm just scoring exactly what it tells me to do like I'm following the rules a good little terranova Nova Soldier here I mean I think that like John said at the beginning of the game he said oh well you're doing he said to me you know you're doing like a fairly traditional strategy I don't remember exactly what you said John but you were just basically you're playing towards those bonuses playing the fundamentals bread and butter like just whatever the bonus for each round was I was like trying to do it I like Built My cities and it did feel relatively vanilla so like I do kind of want to like acknowledge that for the more serious you know Terra mystica guy project fans you know but Nick you know sort of you're representing that in a lot of ways like
for me what was lovely is like I haven't played guy project or Terra mystica in a couple of years like it was just like fun this is just like going back to its roots and just kind of getting like a lovely you know 80 minutes of this game you know what a nice treat right like yeah but I was doing fairly basic stuff like and so you know the the some of the deeper strategies that you can get into in termisca or guy project like some of the things that can become like those like really cool moments where you're kind of like really playing into a faction's ability or you're really getting into different things or you have sort of a longer game or different ways to score points like that that level of play obviously is not here and so I just I think that it's important to note that like you are going to kind of be playing just a more vanilla game here which is kind of I think what we're all sort of or sort of saying but having said that knowing the general Arc of the game it's not like something you really need to warn people about or anything I think like I mean we all kind of recognized that there weren't a lot of ways beyond that to score points and it was sort of like it what there was a little bit of pacing I think Nick you mentioned like you bit off a little more than you could chew you felt like At the beginning although you you clearly put it together it was really funny is that like here we go we play five rounds John in the last round basically does one action and passes because he realizes that he can
get the most points by just going out if you don't I did have some free actions with my faction to squeeze out some extra points so like it was a pretty good one turn but yeah yeah no it was it was great it was great for him but he feel he realized that's the best to do I like built a palace because that was what was rewarded I put out another town and because it gave me the most connected buildings and then I was like cool I pretty much done Nick then after both of us have passed has this like Bonkers turn that he's been building to the entire game where he's got six or seven things yeah yeah he does like all this stuff he makes two different settlements he gets the bonus tiles and he gets all this stuff and I think Nick we figured out you scored like with end game score and you scored like almost 40 points in the last round half of the score came in that last round yeah more than double yeah more than double his score like and so it was like Nick was like in this distant third and then suddenly it was like he was one point away yeah and like I'm not sure that I mean that speaks to the balance of the game although and I guess the different strategies but I think that I don't know if you'd agree Nick I think that like in a way you almost lucked out that that all came together before the game ended it's like almost like the game wasn't going to give you enough time or wasn't going to give you enough weight to play that way I don't know if you would agree I would disagree I did not luck out that it didn't okay I feel like Nick had that that last round in his mind all five rounds I mean
it's a strategy game like even though there's less levers to pull this is a strategy game where the person who looks ahead the most will have a strong advantage and I think he like Nick was looking ahead like Nick usually does because Nick is very good at these kind of things and played towards that I feel like Anastasia didn't look ahead as much but did a really good job at the the short run things like just always pressing the button that was going to give extra points in that round and then I was just kind of faffing about you you were trying to lean into your asymmetry which is actually the thing that I I would love to talk about next because the thing that I think also so I think the boards and the income aspect is like one of the most unique things about the terracaya whatever universe or maybe not even unique at this point but thing that I think is very Hallmark e of of this style of game but the other is the asymmetry and the fact that the factions are ridiculous right like I mean that especially in like Gaia project the powers that they have are like just Bonkers and I will say that I think Terra Nova Nails the asymmetry in a game that is lighter and more vanilla still when I take a faction I've got four unique things one is my starting power two is the way that you get income on your boards is unique um and then you have two strongholds that each give you a special power so four ways that you you can essentially unlock two of them are natural to the game and then two of them are your choice if you're gonna unlock those things over the course of the game and they're not as like weird or kooky as the ones in Gaia project they are not as
imbalanced as the ones in Terra mystica uh but they are fun and I do think that like when you sit down and you play like okay like this is what I'm gonna lean into with this faction this time uh I I do think that's cool I do think that this game nails that I was worried that it being lighter it would take the aspect of that thing away it would smooth over the edges of that asymmetry and I don't think Terra Nova did that I'm very excited about that yeah the game comes with 10 factions there's five colors and each one has two different faction options so that's quite a bit of options right there and yeah I've played three out of the ten now I played three games and I've actually witnessed eight out of the ten being played over the course of those three games which is cool and yeah I agree like you know 80 90 minute game and you're like okay well this is what my faction does and at the start of the game that we just played I played The Druids and they essentially leaned into the power aspect of the game um Power is kind of the second resource there's these three pools of tokens you kind of swirl them around it's functionally identical to to Terra mystica and Gaia project except that you can't gain or lose them um there's some differences to how you get them but either way my faction was all about that and I leaned hard into that in fact I had a special thing that let me spend power to gain victory points which is something that Nick and Anastasia could not do so I spent the whole game trying to increase my uh my power generation because you know my asymmetry is spend power to get points so that seemed like it made sense and I remember when I took the faction at the
very start I told both of you I said um I am bad at this kind of asymmetry like in games you know my Mantra in general is points are boring you know even though the points are how you win games points are boring and so when the when the faction uh specific thing is you know get more points than like have a new lever to pull to get points that maybe doesn't play to my strengths and I came in third and that's fine uh again it's not my strength but it was fun leaning into it this is my third play and it was the first time I ever had tons of power like in the previous two plays I had a little bit like Anastasia said you know every other round I was activating one or two of those power actions I kind of had off rounds but in the game we just played every round I had maxed out almost all of my power so you can have at most eight to use at the beginning of around and I was pretty much there and so that was fun like that felt asymmetric to me that felt quite different than the previous two times I played um I wasn't able to leverage it very well and that's you know more on me but you know coming back to the the length of time to play which I know I'm hopping on a lot that's fine like I could see myself playing The Druids again and and trying to learn from you know kind of missteps that I had in the last time I played and I know a lot of people played Terra mystica and Guy project like that but for me when the game takes so much more time like a two to three hour game I'm like no I'm always gonna play something different until I played everything new um because I might I'm probably never gonna actually play all these whereas Terra Nova I feel like I don't know there's maybe a world where I do play this more than 10 times and I do get to invest in more of these factions so yeah it's a thing to consider yeah I actually I really like what you
just said there John like that idea that like because of the the weight of the game and the length of the game the likelihood that you're gonna see so many more of the factions that there's just like sort of an interest point there where you're like oh cool like what else can I do I mean the last game that this that kind of did that this reminded me of only in this one facet was how I feel at the beginning of Arc Nova when I'm like oh I'm gonna play a different Zoo I'm gonna do a different thing because generally I would say as a board gamer I'm not a big fan of I'm gonna call module expansion this is not a module expansion right this is playing a different faction but when you have something like a modular expansion like where it's like oh add this in or add this in or add this in that's what that's what terroristic and Guy project remind me of when I sit down it's like okay well here's the game but here's 10 different ways to play it and so we even were talking when we started this game Nick was like I'm Gonna Roll a d10 and pick one and I was like I love that you're gonna do that but like I can't do that like I I can't like I want to know what my options are and then I want to pick the best one right like or I want to pick one that seems fun because it's going to dictate so much of the game I mean this is one of those games where the faction that you play it changes the way you play I mean John was just talking about that it changed the way you played it changed the way Nick play change the way I played and so I I needed to evaluate them and actually to the credit of the game they were so simple like just all they really wanted to know was like what was their special power and it was really easy for me to
to just go through them because that's actually one of the things I dread when I sit down to play guy proud project or Terra mystica is like gosh like which which one of these am I going to want to play this time and they have best strategies and they have this and you have to like yeah it's so like so much like I was like cool this is this is this but even more so and this is actually just a product of the uh presentation of the game each one comes with this very helpful little card and I don't care how much of a board gamer I am or how many heavy games I play I love me a good reference card like the like they heard me I was like oh this little card is telling me everything I can do it tells me what my ability is it tells me what each of my palaces do so I don't have to like lift them up it it even had like a little strategy hint at the bottom in case you're like well wait which direction do I go in it was like you know what you should do this early like this is good for you and I was like cool I may or may not listen to that but like again going back to that idea of the way I felt when John was t teaching it 15-minute teach sitting down being like great that that like as someone who's played these games it's so easy to load up my faction it took very little brain power like it's been a long week what a perfect way to play a game on Saturday morning so I agree with both of you like just they they hit the ball out of the park in my opinion on how the factions play how the experience is and just and also how they're presented yeah the presentation part I just want to
co-sign I think it is it is it cracks me up endlessly that they have these like right Terra mystica they just had like the all these fan factions released and they always have like little unique uh iconography for what each new faction does and and I look at them having played hundreds of game of terrorists together I'm like I don't know what that does give me the text I can't read it and in this one they're like okay we'll give you the text like thank you finally of course I need to look at this constantly like I need to understand how my faction works yeah something you mentioned in the middle there John were you talking about the fact that you were playing with power in this game is for me the rest and peace aspect of Terra Nova I think that power in this game is not cool um I really love the power mechanism the three power bowls uh in Terra mystica and Gaia project I think it's a loser in Terra Nova um I think there's a couple reasons for that the main one is that Terra Nova does away with you being able to manipulate those to reduce rules overhead but what that means is that you're just sort of at the whim of like what's your power production is I actually am not even convinced that the three bull system makes any sense because there's no manipulation you can do for it they really should just give you another resource and they could even just call it power and you just get it you just have it or you don't have it and they could rework the numbers and everything would be fine but this like tiered movement system doesn't matter in Terra Nova because you can't cheat the system in any ways like you can in Terra
mystica or you can in Gaia project and there aren't opportunities for you to feel clever with it and so if that little mini mechanism I think is very very cute I've always been a big fan of that and in this game it does nothing for me yeah I I actually couldn't agree with you more Nick I I found myself multiple times in the game being like okay I don't have enough power I won't have enough power there's no way to get any more power so cool or there was one point in the game where I spent most of the round just hoping that Nick and John would do something to give me power and then I would be able to like accomplish the rest of my turn and like there was a moment where I was like you know Nick did and I if he hadn't I would have had to pass and it felt really good but it also felt really lucky like there's no way I could have controlled that there's no way I could have known that was going to happen and if he didn't there was nothing I could do to get around that and so I did really miss that like even even the ability to spend money for power or to eat your power like like any of those little things and I'm sure you know that that may end up coming in expansion or maybe there are people who want slightly heavier rules overhead might come up with a variant or something but I think that I I I would love to see a way where that got more interesting over that had more potential and I I see why it got lifted I like the reference point
but I too was like gosh I wish I could I wish I could tweak this a little bit more and I I did just kind of have to play into it and say okay well at most you're going to get one power action and that power action is going to come from whatever you produce at the beginning in your income phase cool okay that's all I can really rely on and that that worked once I kind of put myself in that headspace that worked for me but I missed it I missed it and I could see playing this game multiple times just kind of like wishing that there was more there yeah I I hate to say it but I I am for the most part agreeing with you um like I said I just played a faction that really leaned heavily into the power and that was that was cool like I had an extra lever to pull to spend it but I hadn't thought about it Nick I think you really got to to the core of it there isn't ways to be creative about it like I I was able to have lots of power because of income and income isn't creative yeah you know like income is good and I leaned into that and I got it but yeah in the middle of the round the only way you get powers if people build next to you and we just play the three-player game in a four player game there's probably gonna be a little bit more of that but um yeah in the other games you can burn power to gain extra also there's buttons in Gaia project to press that charge up your power in the middle of the round and yeah streamlining out makes sense but I feel like this needed another pass as well like maybe two bulls maybe it works with two bulls so that it works a little bit differently than money and it's like you have to spend it to be able to have it
in the bottom to then charge it like that makes it fundamentally a different type of resource um and then you know the the cuteness maybe feels a little bit less drudgery like having to go from all from ball one to ball two and often Ball 2 to ball three or just you know having some factions that have buttons to press that actually move those it does feel like a little bit of a missed opportunity it almost feels like the design um core idea of the game was like okay we're doing Terra mystica light well we can't mess with the three bowls because whenever anybody thinks about Terra mystica they think about those three powerballs like that's like almost the very first thing um so they like left that pristine they didn't modify that and they kind of took away some of the infrastructure for it and yeah a bit of a missed opportunity it doesn't sink the game for me but that that mechanic does feel a lot less fun yeah to give it some credit you still do have that element of building next to each other and it does keep you tight it does keep you building closer to each other there's some other ports you know that you know it's cheaper to build a trading house or whatever by building next to each other like I like that element I like that I was able to accomplish my turn because Nick build I liked that over the course of the game I got a fair amount of power because of you guys like they're they're still there's still The Echoes of what makes that system cool but I do worry with a new player to sitting down you know it's 15 minutes for us because we've all played Terra Miska guy project but the new player it might take five minutes alone just to explain The Parables and what a what an easy place to potentially screw up in your game I think that that
is is a place where I I agree with you John you know maybe there will be some other factions or some other things some other opportunities to make that a little bit more interesting and kind of like worth the overhead for for what it is within the scope of this game yeah I mean it still has the game still has the like building near people is good but of course there's always the chance that they'll block you off um getting blocked is not as bad in this game as it is in Terra mystica because the wheel is only five circles long rather than seven circles long so you know if you get blocked generally you can escape valve somewhere else and I think all that stuff is is the Hallmark certainly of a game that is just uh you know it's just the lighter version of Terra mystica like those those things are going to be a little bit less rude I am very curious about your point though Anastasia like I'd love to break this game out teach it to someone totally new and see uh you know they haven't played any Terra mystica any guy project and see what their impression of the game is and the one thing I wish that we had on this this podcast right now is one of us having had that experience yeah yeah I I honestly can't even speak I I can't take this game out of the context of of the other games that they've made and that's yeah that's kind of interesting right like it's it's I'm essentially we're at a space in board games and you you were talking about this all the way at the beginning Anastasia that we're now consuming board games in the context of other board games rather than things being like oh wow like that that's no one's ever done something like that before right and I'm not even talking
about like oh it's a deck builder like Dominion right like I'm talking about like you've played this exact game it's this but we took these things out and you're like oh you can design that you you're allowed to do that I do think that if you taught this to somebody who had never played any of this type of game before and they liked it you could so easily teach them Terra mystica at that point like this almost feels like a tutorial for Terra mystica because if you busted out Terra mystica and put on the table you'd be like okay think Terra Nova cool now we'll add 30 more rules and that's what this is what this special other board does but like it's there's so little changes like like just a few caveats it's just you know this plus this plus this plus and it's it's very yeah like you said we're looking at it from the going backwards mindset but the going forwards mindset um I could totally see that working I really could so interesting John I really that's funny I really hadn't thought about it that way I I sort of thought of this as like a replacement right like where it's like oh we have this because to your point at the beginning of this podcast Nick you were like oh I don't know I need to you know I'm never gonna get 10 minutes to get the table this is the one I'll play with you know whatever X group of people but how fascinating to think like yeah this could be how I kind of get a buy-in right like we play this and then I get I get my group to the next game I get that they they get the level of strategy here and it takes it to the next level that's really interesting John and I and I do
kind of like want to go back to something that I said you know in the middle and I was saying you know Nick was it luck there at the end and he was like uh no and so I want to like I want to acknowledge that you know I think I rescind that point that I made and I think it's important that I say that because when I'm sitting here reflecting at the end of this conversation and kind of looking at all of this this is a game that that does offer a lot of depth for what it is I mean no it's not a three-hour version of Terror you know it's not terrific it's not three hours it's not as deep as there's not as much going on but there are a lot of paths to Victory there is an ability to kind of do the generic thing come out ahead kind of like ride that lead through there's an ability to build what Nick did you know build a bunch of stuff and kind of wait and then just go Mass massive at the end there's what John did just like play into his factions power and and see how that turns out and like that's three different unique strategies of play with a game with 10 different actions that offer 10 different inherently unique strategies of play like that's really cool there's a lot of game here for what is an 80 minute game there were still a number of turns where we kind of had to stop and think and be like wait I need to think about what I'm doing so not so much down time that I ever got bored like it was just just the right weight for a game that we could all really enjoy given the level of Gamers that we are that I do think would be accessible to people who normally would be turned off
by a game of the weight of Terra miscarrier guy project and I think that is just it's a huge credit to what they've done here and thinking about it particularly in that context Sean if I was a big terimisca fan getting this game introducing this to people particularly like my significant other or otherwise like that would be really cool and I think that's the space where this lands for me like I this is not a game that I need to own just because I'm not as big a fan like of terrorism it's not that I'm not a fan it's just I there are other games I would rather play but I find both really enjoyable and I would happily play this anytime like in fact I like I like let's play next week like this is great yeah it's like a great game I just I don't need to introduce more people in my life today in Michigan but you know via Terra Nova or otherwise but if I did or I wanted to um this is a good one one point you said in the middle there I do want to um kind of hold up and that is that you know while we we talked a little bit you know oh the game is a little bit more vanilla in some ways and whatnot there's still quite a bit to think about and you know we've played a lot of games in particular with Nick and Nick frequently is a quick player of games especially the games of Anastasia and I like to play like you know lighter rule sets 60 to 90 minutes like it's Nick's turn and Nick just does the thing and then we move on and it's next turn and Nick just does the thing he's got it all mapped out and there were several times where Nick just did the thing but there are also many times in this play where I don't know Nick took a minute just sitting there thinking and it wasn't like crazy analysis paralysis or anything but I remember sitting there
thinking about Nick thinking Ming like there's stuff to think about here like you know there's definitely plans and strategies it's not like obvious the decisions are not obvious occasionally they might be like in the last round it's like oh okay well the obvious thing for me to do is to build a palace and then pass but it was the end of the game like that was the culmination of my strategy as opposed to the beginning um there's quite a lot to think about even right in the the setup of the game not too much much but but definitely something there I just want to say that I think the the sequencing in all of these style of games is so important uh because of the economic nature of the games because they they make your income which then as we talked about earlier snowballs and other things and because this game is shorter because you have such essentially like because it's shorter there's a more tighter constrained space that sequencing becomes even more significant I don't think that the decisions are paralyzingly difficult at all I think that on a lot of turns it's like okay it seems like I'm gonna maybe do these four or five things and I get to choose two or three of those four or five things so that's kind of the decision space that you're often thinking about um I think relatively accessible but you still need to make sure that you've like thought it through yeah yeah yeah but not in the same way like you said not in the same way of those heavier games like guy I kept thinking there must you know be more I need to I need to double check all of my things here and I was like no okay it's a smaller decision space but still plenty to chew on and I liked that I liked that there was still a good number of options but not so many that I
was really like my head did not hurt at the end of this game but you know it it felt like it had gone for like a lovely walk and you know yeah yeah found some interesting things along the way so to wrap this one up my take on this one after playing it three times is that I I really feel like I could very happily play this game at least seven more times to try all the factions I'm curious um there are a couple factions I would like to try again particularly the first one um that I played very poorly but I think one of the bigger takeaways for me about this is you know I'm in a lot of ways the primary rules teacher of pretty much every group I go into and I love how simple this game is to teach and I have not taught this to somebody who has no framework and that will definitely be a longer than 15 minute teach but I would so rather put this in front of that person than Terra mystica or Gaia project I will 100 do it I mean I own the game I have a copy so that will be the option that I go for and I definitely lean towards that I get rules teach fatigue sometimes especially with a lot of modern Euros there's just a lot going on um and I'm like oh I want to play that game but do I really want to teach it and this one I I'm not going to bulk at teaching it at all so yeah I'm really happy that I have it um you know for uh full disclosure I don't know but I do own Gaia project I still have that even though I haven't played it in about four years or something like that and I don't think this necessarily fires Gaia project in fact to a certain extent after playing three games of Terra Nova over the last month I kind of want a bus guide project out again yeah it kind of makes you want to play it doesn't it I was thinking the same thing so I could see both of these in my
future did anything happen like three years ago that made it hard for you to start playing I can't I can't imagine anything that would make that happen no awesome well uh that I think is going to bring a wrap for for Terra Nova for us this has been uh it's been really fun playing this and seeing sort of the evolution of this the terror World um but I'm definitely looking forward to playing this game more often with y'all it's time space I think is going to be one where we're gonna put it on the table I know a couple times in the next month or two for sure yeah um or the digital table is the case would be with us and as John mentioned earlier in this podcast uh he's gonna have a playthrough with friends for Terra Nova so you can check out him play playing a two-player version of this game I will say I think this game is going to be sweetest at four players but I think it's still going to work really well at two so you can check that out and watch it for yourself but thanks for coming along on this ride with us thanks uh Jonathan and Anastasia and we'll see you next time bye around