Skip to main content
Loading video...

My Top 10 Favorite Board Game Designers

Transcript 27:20

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today now today I've wanted to make a video on something that I've been thinking about recently I know that if you have been paying attention to the channel and podcast I'm a huge fan of uber Rosenberg he is my favorite board game designer and I enjoy pretty much all of his games and will focus a lot of attention on them both with playing as well as with content on YouTube Etc but I do enjoy other games as well as you have noticed and I've been thinking like I I do have a set of games that I enjoy but can I group some of them by designer and can I kind of rank some of my favorite designers based off of the games that I have played from them as well as games when I hear about a new uh anticipated game from said designer how excited am I personally willing uh to play that game review it rather than just by following what everyone else is saying about a particular game or a particular designer and having you know that encouragement from the populace uh throw me into a game right and so what what is inherently my motivation to play some of these games based off of the designer in particular I've covered before some of my favorite themes I think some you can kind of gather my favorite mechanisms in

games as well but this video is solely dedicated to the designers that I've come to enjoy in the experiences I've had playing board games so as you can see there are some criteria here that I have given myself to ranking my favorite designers I must have played more than one game designed by this particular designer for this list account for example I love Arc NOA but as far as I know U Matas V is his only design is arkn NOA or I have not played any of his other designs if he has any uh to make that count towards this list so once again designers that I pay attention to especially around this season when a lot of anticipated games are being announced whether it's for retail now or for the soon Tobe future I what what would rank for me you know highly for these designers is you know how anticipated and excited I am to try their latest game and so I will take that into account as well as the games that I have played by them all of these games that I do mention that I have played as well will be rated seven or above on the scale found on Board Game Geek and in general these are games that I'm likely to replay to play repeatedly such as a digital version of the game on an app or on board game arena a game that I could play physically solo uh that I find

enjoyable or because I have a harder time these days finding the time to play board games physically with other people on the regular and so games that are available to play uh digitally are preferred so let's get into this list and and let's let's talk about some designers so my number 10th designer uh my 10th favorite at this time is Cole Worley now he beat at a lot of other great designers once again of single games that I've really enjoyed probably enjoy more than the games listed here and other designers that I've played multiple games of it's it was really close to narrow down my top 10 but uh so Cole worly just made it out and I think it's part of it is because I respect a lot of his games in addition to enjoying them I really enjoy root I think root is a very interactive and and fun game the asymmetry makes it the like the the grander of the the asymmetry of each faction and how differently they play makes the makes it have a sense of replayability as well as Mastery and that is also evident in arcs now arcs is such a an interesting game that I covered not too long ago maybe this is part of the recency bias towards the game of arcs but there's so much to explore in this game especially with the expansion and the campaign mode but but even the base game even after one round I was so impressed by arcs that I I

think ARS has carried my opinion of C rly quite far I do enjoy Pax femir especially uh or specifically second edition it is a game that I mostly respect I I would feel it is a little opaque and I I do appreciate the historic approach to this game and other PX games by other designers as well it is a little bit harder for me to wrap my head around like the actual strategy of it um and this applies to a lot of other worldly games such as oath and John Company games that I haven't played but seem to be very unique uh some of them very historically based and perhaps that's where a lot of the mechanisms come from or at least a a a period of time and and things like I'm I'm thinking of John company and from what I understand what I've heard about that game it's very much a simulator you know simulating the experience of uh creating and managing a shipping company or Etc and so a lot I think there's a lot of thought that goes behind the creation of these games to make abstractions here and there to that not only make the game Flow mechanically but also represent the atomic matter at hand uh very well and and so I I really appreciate and respect his designs and I think the interactivity and the just the smartness of how streamlined some mechanisms are to how well they tie into the overall

setting and theme at hand make it it's reminiscent of Rosenberg games which obviously are more Euro style in nature and they utilize different mechanisms that I prefer in general compared to worldly games but I think the approach is very similar and you might sense a theme as I talk about these designers in these games that I really appreciate games with a an adherence to theme with the Blended uh thematic SL mechanical presentation of the game to make them feel very you know interesting and replayable so my number 10 is going to be Cole warley my number nine designer is Simone Simone Lani and I really enjoy some of his games I I really enjoy the and respect you know designs like barrage and nucleum and Tatum uh specifically in recent memory now I do acknowledge that all of these games have multiple designers on them uh for example David tury nucleum Daniel Daniel tasini on tum but he does seem to be the denominator behind a lot of these games that I have really enjoyed in recent memory and recent plays and not all of Simon hit uh games are hits for me for example the latest Darwin's Journey was a sort of a miss for me I think a lot of the game and and there are other games too he has such a a catalog of games

that he either has designed himself or is a a part of for the majority of them I generally am very interested to see what he does put out Year bye and especially when they fall in the category of games such as these three as are depicted I start to really pay attention to and and see what those designs are and so that's perhaps one of the reasons why Simone is at a at the lower end of my Spectrum for designers that I look out for perhaps because of the fact that he does design with other people and that not all of his designs have been a hit for me but he is very prolific prolific and he has a lot of good designs that I individually hold very high in in high esteem and so yeah so my number nine is Simone Lani so my number eight designer is actually a couple of designers isra C and sh s and so this Duo has produced a couple of games that I have been really enjoying I the White Castle in particular was one of my favorite designs from last year and red Cathedral is really good too and flat iron is their newest release from this year at Essen and a lot of these games share the the uh presentation and the ability of these of these games to be small in nature physically with the box as well as comp opponents and everything the games are relatively short but they pack so much punch and provide so many uh tough decisions to

make from turn to turn and something that I I I really appreciate that in a design I due to my circumstances just you know having you know two young kids a lot of you may be able to uh understand that you know timing is is pretty limited when you have a young family and so having ample time to play a game that's 2 3 4 hours long is very hard to come by and so if you can get a really good and interesting and complex game to an hour or so or even under that is like the sweet spot for me and so that's what a lot of these designs uh offer and so their design I guess philosophy of approaching games providing perhaps not the most complex games out there but the ability to still provide a crunchy and interesting game in such a short time frame to play with is just amazing and so I highly recommend and I do follow their U releases and so I'm I'm always keen and interested to see what they come up with next and so that's my number eight is REI and shees my number number seven is Matthew Dunston now I've mentioned him very recently especially with games from his new publisher called um postmart games where they've made games like waypoints which have honestly been a breath of fresh air in a lot of the typical games that I have come across so I have Jacob to thank thank for um but even before

that like the Guild of merchant explorers having played this game a couple years ago thanks to Jae as well actually I really came to appreciate and enjoy these games I think they're among some of my favorite lighter weight games to play one because they I guess they feel they they are lighten nature and so they're easy to teach and easy to bring out with other people but also at the same time the amount of things that you can do and on each of your turns I'm I'm looking at the Guild of merchant explorers and waypoints in particular just seem to be so dramatic and expansive much more than what appears at first glance I I really appreciate his design approach to making each turn feel very I guess dramatic and and very uh like like there are so many different good decisions that you have to choose from despite it being a very lightweight type of game I guess as an honorable mention Brett J Gilbert is also listed on a lot of these designs that I do enjoy but I as a whole I think Matthew dunon if his name is on it I will be looking at those I I put Monumental up here as well just because this is a game that I've always been interested in playing but I've never had the chance to to play it yet I know it is a Matthew Dunston game it's a civilization themed game and it looks to be a little bit heavier than some of these other games that I do enjoy and so I'm excited to see what Monumental has to offer if I ever do get the chance to play it but

other than that I I do pay attention to what he has to offer each year when it comes to designs I really enjoy a lot of these postmart games as well and so yeah I'm just a fan of how uh lightweight yet complex some of these games from Matthew Dustin uh have been you know in the last couple years so Matthew Dunston my number seven so my number six is going to be Martin Wallace now Martin Wallace obviously has been touted for the number one Board Game Geek game of all time as of this moment brass biringham as well as his design brass laner all excellent designs and they follow a pattern that I really enjoy in games with high interactivity high uh and that interactivity mostly being centered on a central board where everyone is moving tokens around and interacting with uh and so there's and and the E you know the economics behind it as well it's a very economic heavy game and so I've really enjoyed those games and this game in particular I think it's probably the most to me the most streamlined and approachable not approachable but um I guess uh it's probably the easiest game for me personally to be intrigued and motivated to play while fitting in with the the more economic heavy side of board games I mean you have a lot of games like 18xx type of games train games in general which are very economic

and in their nature and by their mechanisms and that's why I put Steam here as well I do enjoy steam it's probably not my favorite theme to play a game centered on trains but I I really do enjoy Steam for a lot of the same reasons that I enjoy brass with the high interactivity on the C board as well as the modularity of steam in particular of how the game setup is different you have different maps that you can play on as well uh this kind of follows into age of steam in particular where there are a ton of maps that you can play on I haven't played that particular game yet but that is also uh Martin's design other games that I've really enjoyed tenous Trail viula is an interesting lighter weight game that follows the same pattern as brass it's it's like brass light and so um that that that's a game that we actually own and enjoy Uno 1800 is a little bit different from a lot of these other games it is somewhat economic in nature as well but it's a lot of um just really fun um like order fulfillment Tableau building and resource collection it's got a ton of resources very similar in the veins of a game like or at labora and so that I think that connection with Rosenberg is kind of why I really do enjoy Uno 1800 as well I think Martin Wallace makes it out of my top five because there are a lot of designs of his that I haven't tried and a lot of his designs that I think are a little bit too opaque for my tastes to to approach and even try in the first place um and and he does have

a lot of designs he's very prolific as well and so not all of his designs are going to hit for me but he does have a lot of you know top weight you know top hitters for me that uh make it so that I do pay attention to his games very often and the even the a small percentage of games that I do end up playing from him even if it was just these three for example I've enjoyed them so much that I I hardly I highly regard him as a designer and his approach to games and so my number six Martin Wallace so my number five is vital he's a designer that I actually have played a lot of his games thus far I was particularly drawn to his games because they were kind of like the next step for me when I started to explore more Euro style games and since a lot of his games were in the top 100 anyway such as Lisboa and on Mars it was pretty easy to kind of direct myself in that direction and play them now I really enjoy leboa and on Mars uh on Mars is probably my favorite space themed game or at least Mars themed game that I can think of even it's it's pretty close between this and terraforming Mars but I really enjoy the designs that he creates I I feel like there's a lot of um emphasis on the subject matter at hand when becoming you know coming up with The Inspirations of the mechanisms that are utilized in these games I think that especially with Lisboa I I I feel like there was so much

history behind this and it's a part of history that I am particularly interested in he is Portuguese I am half Brazilian myself and so a lot of what he you know does with games like this and Venus as well have a lot of person connection to me in in a way and so uh the only thing is that his games are very difficult to learn and process but I think after you get over that hunch or that hurdle that they become a little bit easier to play and understand and I think there's a lot of connection to theme as well that if you understand thematically what is going on in the game as you take your turns then mechanically it starts to flow a lot easier I haven't been the biggest fan I've I've enjoyed recent games like inventions uh weather machine not as much and the newest release Speak Easy has been in the hotness recently this one I am interested in trying out actually I I I've been learning a little bit about how it plays and the rules Etc and so potentially I'm not going to make any promises right now but uh potentially I would cover this on the channel as well at some point in the future but um it's just so hard to wrap my head around each new game as they are they they feel very distinct from one another and there there are things that are mechanically used over and over again or or feel similar from game to game and of course the overall impression that his games provide is that you take an action which Cascades

into multiple different bonuses and subactions that you take at this you know after you initially choose something to do on your turn that it creates a Cascade of of information and bonuses and processes that are a part of the reason why his games are so complex but a lot of people think they're complex in a very fun way in a very thematic way and I do agree with that as well so M number five Viera M number four is a pair of designers uh doen and veringa a part of splotter spielen so these guys have created games for a long time and a lot of these games I have not played yet I'm am interested in a little bit intimidated to to try some of their newer games or some of their other games that I haven't played like Indonesia the great uh Zimbabwe Etc uh hopefully because I I just don't want to be let down or anything but I I have to say a lot of what carries my opinion of these two and their their company essentially is through roads and boats uh this game was so cool to play and I think it was one of the closest games that reminded me of what I enjoyed to play uh like on the computer for from many years back and and you know reading into the history of I believe it was uh vinga he is a computer programmer himself he plays a lot of computer and makes a lot of computer games as well and so perhaps there's a lot of connection and inspiration there that I appreciate and

have subconsciously appreciated until uh finding out that fact and so games like roads and boats where it's I don't know I've dedicated a whole video on roads and boats feel free to go and and I I guess a podcast on it so feel free to check that out um if there's anything here of course that I you can't find readily on YouTube it's either on the podcast but I am more than happy to make a link of that if you ask for it but I yeah in any case I really enjoy roads and boats uh bus Horseless Carriage are some of the other notable games that I've played recently that are really fun as well they're very interactive they're very thematic very similar in vain with games or designers rather like vitala and Wallace Etc and so you know heavy economic very highly thematic games that are tough to learn well they're they're somewhat tough to learn but they're tough to master and so a lot of these games have huge potential for me to to really get into and enjoy and so I I really respect these these designs I've I'm I should play some of their other games just so I can have a complete um understanding of their designed philosophy but from what I have seen thus far I've really enjoyed and look forward to more games from splotter speling my number three designer is Jeffrey CCH so if you have been following following me recently you know that I've been very impressed with games

such as age of civilization and age of Galaxy as well as well as um epox and these three games in particular have been uh kind of the foundation of why I really enjoy his designs and I guess the designs of his team collectively at ice makes they take it's very similar to the thoughts that I've had of like isra isra C and Shay s where they take a game design or a setting or a theme and compact it into such a small package but that package provides a lot of interesting decisions and in these cases a lot of replayability as well there are it's the kind of replayability especially in all three of these games that I really particularly enjoy which is the variety of cards and or tiles that make each game feel different the way that they are displayed and offered for you great for different decisions to make from game to game and end up in different Avenues of how you decide you want to score points and and so if you could do that in the time frame which it takes to play some of these games it is amazing I've really enjoyed his Branch into a heavier and longer game with a civilization theme in Epoch you can check out my video on that from months back when the kickstarter was ongoing this will be a 2025 game but it will probably be highly rated if and when I make a video of my top games of next year uh EPO was just a lot of fun and so

yeah I really enjoy this style of game as you've seen with my appreciation for designs that are small yet complex and I think Jeffrey CC does it the best for me my number two is Vladimir sui and this may not come as a surprise to you I've really really enjoyed his games and often times will be checking out his games as he is very prolific and comes out with about a game a year it all started with underwater cities and what I really enjoyed about this game which is available on yucata to play is the variability that comes with the cards that you play onto the kind of work placement uh action combining different uh ways to take turns um when you take a turn and so that coupled with the t low building and the different ways to score points just makes underwater cities a highly rated game overall but very highly rated for me as well because I guess ultimately what Vladimir does is his games I think come the closest to what I appreciate most about Rosenberg where the variety in games a lot of the times comes from cards and the and there's an element of Tableau building and very Euro style scoring as well and he does it in a way that is not terribly complex rules-wise when it comes to games uh in in comparison like to lasa Games Etc right they're not as uh rules heavy as games in those ilk you know

they're they're very much more uh in in a sense streamlined compared to or in line with games from Rosenberg all all yeah so all that to say I like he's the one designer that I feel like mirrors and comes as close to Rosenberg as possible for me personally not to say that all of his designs follow suit in you know where I find them to be enjoyable of course I don't like every single one of rosenberg's games but I I enjoy the majority of them the same is is applicable for sui as well but I have really appreciated some of these games like Ms 1347 evacuation from last year was really cool as well once again utilizing cards to uh if you play with the advanced mode you have a deck of cards which have individualized actions or combinations of actions that you can take and so that understanding of those action cards and as well as how the game plays as well it's just this has a lot of potential for me to rise up in games that I enjoy overall uh and so yeah I've I've really enjoyed his games I haven't played them all I look forward to doing so at some point but uh yeah I am always intrigued I will try to play raafa his newest release from this year and and see if I enjoy that as well but yeah I I think he comes the closest for me when it comes to the style of board game design the way that it plays how quickly you can learn it and how how a game is mastered as well

through repeated plays I think uh it doesn't get much better other than Rosenberg for me than it does with SU so that is my list uh this video should have been called my top nine favorite designers other than Rosenberg but I interestingly I have made an a podcast almost a year ago about the top 10 reasons why Rosenberg games are my favorite and so I may or may not create that as a kind of a video and transfer it to YouTube for you to explore this topic further of why I enjoy Rosenberg games I'm pretty sure that the same material is going to be the same as it is now and so I will include that for your leisure in the near future uh other than that thank you for sticking around and and listening to why I enjoy these designers you know it it doesn't mean that I enjoy all of their games and some of these games uh from designers farther down the list I enjoy perhaps more than some of the games uh higher up on the list but I I think if you look at the games and the design philosophy and everything collectively I think this is how my ordering is when I when it comes to especially new games that are coming out from these designers and how closely I pay attention to them so thank you for joining me on this journey and Consulting with me today hope that you schedule an employment with your board gaming doctor real soon and I'll catch you on the next one take care

Progress saved