Skip to main content
Loading video...

SPARTA! Preview: Peloponnesian Punch Up!

Transcript 19:34

hi everyone tally and Pharaoh here from Board of it and Welcome to our preview video for Sparta we've very kindly sent a prototype copy of Sparta by the publisher plague Island games and in this video we're gonna tell you a little bit about how it plays and give our opinions and thoughts on it and this game is out on Kickstarter as of when this video goes live yes so you can go and check it out and we'll put a link below essentially the kind of brief on what spotter is is a two-player head-to-head kind of because I guess like primarily an area control game but in the style of kind of GMT games you know you've got the card play of Twilight Struggle you've kind of got the area and influence control of 1960 and obviously it's kind of been put in a Greek setting welcome to Sparta just gonna go over how you play and then we'll get into what we think uh so I think they're called the reverse or differently but I'm going to call them what I like so it helps it be straight in my head but you'll play six rounds and in these rounds you'll have like

basically six turns each um and the the end game goal is to control more territories in your opponent or region sorry so the boards split into regions kind of like any classic Athens vs Sparta game where you know the ionian coast Attica Sparta and whoever controls the most regions at the end will win at the end of the sixth round now in a round you're going to have the six tens that I said about and you'll start the round by kind of doing income and you get things and resources and money based on which regions you control so the more regions you control the more you get that kind of sets you up for that round then you'll draw six cards and like in GMT games Twilight Struggle would be the best known one you're going to have these six cards you basically have to play them all so sometimes the order is going to be important sometimes they'll be good for you sometimes they'll be bad for you sometimes it'll be in the middle so a term will kind of be that you will play one of those cards and then you'll kind of do a lot about your armies or your navies in terms of interacting with the board so there's in these regions you have cities and each city has a kind of influence value and if you have enough influence there to you call that value you control it which here is represented by these round discs and uncontrolled kind of building

influence is represented by these cubes and you know Corinth has three influence so I need two more to control it uh and you can kind of you know obviously take away your opponents or gain your own but you can't both be there at one time so you'll start you kind of turn by looking at the board and if you have anyone on the board that is in an area that doesn't have a token next to it a Siege or a raid token you're going to resolve that so they're going to rate that space and when a space is rated it means that that space doesn't count towards counting up the influence for who controls the region and you count up the kind of total influence you control not number of cities so if you have two big cities you might control that region even though another player has like four or five small regions it's all about how much influence you have total so raiding takes one of those cities out of the game basically and then you can decide once you've raided to keep your army there and Siege it which is basically rolling dice to try and control it yourself if you get a success you remove an influence and when you remove all your opponent's influence you get it um so that's up to you or if you just want to raid and kind of knock it off and come back because sieging costs money you can bring your army back so you'll first you'll do that raid resolve it then you'll play your card one of your six cards and obviously you'll have less as you go through the

terms then you can mobilize any units that are ready to be mobilized because when you move these units you kind of have a I guess you could say kind of conveyor belt because you have to line them up where on the kind of turn one you pay to kind of get those ready units ready to go out turn two you put them on the board somewhere term three you resolve that raid with them so you've kind of got a pre-plan ahead yeah you can't just mobilize and Deploy on the same turn because you have to do the steps in order so you have to also like kind of forward plan look at where your opponent's doing yeah so if you have anyone ready to mobilize you can mobilize them then next you can pay to get people ready to mobilize then you will if you have a Siege like here you'll resolve it spend money to roll dice as we said and finally if you have two of the same Army type so the kind of Navy or Army in the same space you will battle uh and battling is pretty simple it's it's no dice rolls or anything it's kind of more tactical I guess you have you kind of look at different things who controls the region when the battle's taking place who has the most army or navy strength who uh has the most kind of military Assets in different areas and just every time you have the most of something or you control that area whatever you get like one point and then

you kind of attract add and subtract yep but you can't travel in a spanner can't you because you always draw a battle card before the beginning of a battle and of course you might have some in your hand already so it's not always just as easy as looking at what's on the board and knowing who's going to win of course so someone can play a battle card and slip it back by the way so they can really shake things up basically but yeah so that's a general term structure you've got the card playing you got these kind of um kind of army Maneuvers where you can Siege your town or Raid it to take it out of contention or fight someone else to get them away from sieging your cities but yeah I mean that's that's the kind of quick overview so yeah so you have uh yeah what is it the six turns because you play the six cards and then do an income how many income so we're out so six as well so yeah by the end things will have gone back and forth in each of those like income rounds right so in turn one maybe one uh player controls more territory and then you kind of Cam that up and then they'll get the the money as you said and their military assets So in theory you should be kind of winning more and more as the game goes on because the more you own the more you have to fight with and improve your stance but it doesn't always work like that it can be a bit of a tense battle like back and forth but yeah the idea is that you should be accumulating assets and money I guess because it makes it easier for you to take over more territories yeah well easier said than done right in theory okay so going on well what what do we

think yeah I think we we liked the battle aspect and okay the first game was not tense I'm not gonna lie because I lost miserably I'm not that good at these territory control games to be fair the second game it was tense and because you do this count up six times you know every six actions it is really uh it motivated me because you do the count up and you're like right okay I've got some more money and you get a bit more reinvigorated every time you stop and you pull new cards and even if you're in a bit of a worse position you're just thinking okay right I'm gonna try and go through this this turn try and get a bit more money next turn so because you kind of stop every time for me I liked I liked the kind of like reset Point almost yeah and then you could like go back in again and try a different tactic or try to take over uh different territories um I think it was full of interesting decisions you could let your opponent just kind of raid and take over some of your territories maybe they have less influence and maybe they just want to get one more influence in that region to take control but because it's quite hard to mobilize and deploy and like you said you have to plan it it's not always as easy as just stopping them right so you have to have someone ready pretty much exactly but that costs money which you could be

spending doing something else so it was always a really interesting decision for me to say you've come to my uh Town you've come to my Gaff to try and raid everything it's so annoying should I try and stop you or should I just go after your space because you can't be in both places so you're always having to weigh up the risk reward and the pros and cons and maybe you just need one more influence to kind of take control of that region somewhere else so then you just say you know I'm just going to let you take that one because I need to focus my effort somewhere else you always kind of recalculating based on the new board situation yeah and I also personally found it um maybe a little bit less complex than those kind of GMT games that you mentioned just because the card play element you don't have to make a decision about whether you play it for Value points like like in those games or the action you literally just play it for the actions that kind of takes the decision away the only thing you have to decide on is uh if it gives you um some of them say like send envoys to a certain region but you sometimes you can choose and you might choose that but some of them just tell you what to do right so it's more about deciding in what order you play it and you could try to take over a territory right at the beginning of your turn and play that card but then that gives the opportunity to your opponent to then take it back because sometimes you're like well I just do that right at the end exactly

that's a good point and not be able to do it and of course like you said some cards are negative for you but you basically have to play them there is a mechanism to kind of discard cards out of your hand but it's quite hard to do and you almost don't want to because you have to spend the resource that lets you kind of boost the cards a lot of the time so it's like yeah maybe not worth it but also there's not so many that you might as well just kind of tank it I think yeah exactly but it's like should I play that beginning of my turn just get this bad thing out of the way so then I can try to recuperate by the time you come to that next sort of uh territory check point or do I leave it right to the end because then I'll understand the state of the board a bit better or so yeah it's just quite a lot of interesting decisions so yeah it's bounce off what you're saying I think your first point I liked that it kind of organically created these like battle situations where just one round suddenly I don't know um what do we have thessally would be like where everyone was going for and we just have like all these wars erupting there and it'd be really like hard for battle and then for whatever reason the next turn it will move somewhere else to the pelvanese or something yeah and I I just I quite like the organic kind of like a tough fighting in like one region to gain control yeah then it makes it interesting some of the cards will like double the value at the end of the game of regions but maybe only one to one player so then it's like you just let them have it or should you take it away even though like it means more to them

yeah exactly so I found it really interesting some of the regions that have the like more towns like you said you could just take over one city there which is where three influence points or you could go for volume and actually take over three towns or four towns even though their opponent might control like the main city in that region but you could still have overall control so it's like about balancing should I just try and take over that one city because it's worth a lot or just go in for volume if the kind of car play yeah supports you in doing that so I think just before we get to maybe some of the things that we weren't so fond of just to point out that this is a prototype um so it's like the dice for example at the moment we're just using normal dice but these are going to be kind of customized because you don't really use the numbers you have successes and fails and like blanks so there's going to be like custom dice in this um then I think yeah I mean some components are kind of subject to change I think things will be tweaked here and there I don't think anything major will change but some leaders might be tweaked some of the rules that we've been playing with as well but actually one thing as well is quite nice because does it kind of send an army or an aviant battle you have to have a leader and these leaders have powers I think they make quite an interesting choice as well yeah because sometimes you like Ryan I'm going to use this leader to Siege kind of say back to what you're saying because he has a Siege power but then you kind of send

someone out like oh I mean he's not really great for that but don't want to stop you or should I just go with what I was doing exactly yeah so yeah okay so moving on to I guess some of the things that didn't like or maybe not even didn't like but should be aware of is that because when you're sieging you have to pay for it and you have these dice rolls and that the terms if you succeed or fail uh that could be something that some players don't like right because you could spend almost all the money you make in around trying to Siege the same place over and over and just fail every time and you know in a kind of a hard for knife Point strategy game maybe that's something that some people won't like didn't really bother me too much I don't know about you but it's just to be aware and also I found the battle cards are a bit swinging as well that they can really actually you could play one if you're in the right position that suddenly like completely flips it if you know what I mean so that can be something that I guess I kind of liked that because it was more dramatic though because I was usually on the losing side let's say so for me that felt nice I feel like I could play one to get a Edge yeah just because I think without it you could just see on the board who's going to win the battle so I think it's nice that they're sometimes a bit swingy and dramatic because otherwise I think it would be a bit flat yeah um because you can just calculate if I'm looking so another thing as well is I again not

necessarily negative but something to be aware of or that didn't really I not didn't like but because it's easy remedied but essentially as a thing you touched upon earlier when someone starts noticeably winning or losing in this game so let's say losing you're going to lose more because once that kind of you know the balancing on night Point once you fall off that even slightly because it's such a tense game and because controlling regions gives you resources so if you're winning you're controlling more regions which means you have more resources and a loser has less resources so they can do less you can do more it just basically starts sliding once broken and what I would have liked to have seen is a basically another endgame trigger because there's only one get to round six yeah because you can have a game of this where it's round four or five and you're like well I mean it's over like what's the point of playing on it would be nice to have that alternate condition but I did speak to the publisher and they basically said actually so I mean I think it's always difference of opinion that they originally had that okay and apparently people didn't like to be told that they'd lost so I think they might put in as an optional rule to be like if this is how it is then you can yeah consider it like done so that's fine then I think you had something as well that you yeah just again not uh negative and I actually think it's really great in a way but just again something to be

aware of and just something that I maybe struggled with a bit in the beginning so all of the kind of player guys and their terminology is very historically accurate which is great I like that I like to learn new things but it did mean that I struggled to get into it and in the in the first game to be honest and maybe that's just totally me but when it was using different words for like Army and flea and I think maybe just because it maybe didn't match up to here I'm just like yeah is this the bow is this the Army because it's like hopalai uh yeah you're right it doesn't say it here it doesn't so that's maybe why and again this could change because it's a prototype but um that just confused me a little bit and it just made my first game a little bit difficult to get into because the player guide is very very comprehensive which is really good but when it was using there this kind of yeah terminology and things I hadn't really heard of before um I just found it like a very small barrier but once you know what it is it's fine right it's not a continued problem once you know you know uh so just I think another thing to add is that's not like um the criticism let's say just to be aware is that actually it comes with a lot of um so it comes with like two scenarios the thebian war and spotify's Athens which have like different cards so you kind of you have like this deck and you divide the Cards into ages because specific cards go with specific ages and

it means that you kind of have two scenarios to play which start differently and then within those scenarios you have a lot of setup cards that they don't necessarily change things so much but because of the way this game is they change it enough that you do get quite a game with a different trajectory just by picking a different setup card for the same scenario and obviously it's also nice that you have different cards as well some of which you won't see in one scenario and so on yeah so yeah yes but I think that's what we have to say about Sparta so we don't go on too long but yeah I mean if you're a fan of the theme which I actually really enjoy uh if you like GMT games you know if you're a fan of the system where you have to play the card and it might be bad for you what order did you play it in and also I kind of like that outside of that the card play you have the system of sieging and raiding yeah that you can do outside of that so you have this flexibility even when you have say bad cards to just go and do something that's true so if that sounds like it's for you it's worth checking out it's live on Kickstarter now as we said the link will be down below yeah and thank you for watching any questions exactly comments would be happy to answer yes see you next time bye

Progress saved