Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tapestry Board Game Review (Including Plans and Ploys Expansion!) - By Board of It

Transcript 14:23

hello everyone talia farrell here from board of it and this week we're going to be reviewing controversial stonemeyer game tapestry tapestry is an engine building strategy civilization game for one to five players it was controversial for a few reasons but the main one we believe is that it was marketed as being a shorter more accessible civilization game but in reality what people got was something quite abstract and nothing like a classic civilization game furthermore there were complaints about gameplay and issues of balance however we are huge stonemeyer fans so we probably would have got it one way or another but when the expansion came out which we'll also talk about a little bit we saw the base game was on sale heavily discounted so we snapped it up and now having played it a few times let's discuss tapestry

one great thing about tab street is that it's really easy to learn how to play and it's easy to do the teach for you can only do one action on your term and you only ever have a choice of two actions one of these is called income and this will mark the end of an error of your civilization essentially this is when you get resources you use civilization powers you can play tapestry cards you can invent stuff and you'll do some light vp scoring now you can only do this five times throughout the game so you only want to do it when you have no other recalls and your very first turn of the game will be an income turn to get your starting resources and when you take your fifth income turn that will mark the end of the game for you what you'll be doing most of the game is advancing your civilization to do so you pay the cost in resources move a cube up one space and gain the reward there are four tracks to move up science technology exploration and military essentially you'll move up these tracks and make some tough choices should you get some houses out so you'll get more resources for your next turn or should you focus on doing the primary track actions which are more likely to get you vps and other bonuses speaking of houses you also have a player map which represents your capital city as you collect houses or landmark buildings which are usually gained by being the first into a new section of a track you can fill out those spaces completed rows and columns provide vps

whereas completed districts provide immediate resources just coming back to the tough street cards these are really powerful cards which you can play and they could swing the balance of the game in your favor if you get the right ones at the right time you only get to play usually three of these throughout the game and these can cause you to have a bad game or at least feel like it they're really swingy and situational and you know what you get could depend where you are in the game or what tracks you've been researching on and they could be really good or they could be kind of useless to you and they say that you're supposed to draw a lot and try and cycle through them and have a big hand so then you don't get this problem but sometimes that's just not an option and it might not alleviate the problem however this isn't something that you would see every game but if you play enough you will see it just as an example in my last game i got a card that let every player have the opportunity to pay one resource to get 10 vp but i had to play it during my first play of a tapestry card which is quite early in the game and this is a time when resources are at a premium and you can't really afford to lose a turn because you have one less resource because it's kind of a snowball effect throughout the later rounds so nobody around the table took this opportunity and then as a reward i just got one

measly resource for the card but there's cards in this deck which a give you 10 vp for nothing or another one which i think gives you like 8vp and a resource again for nothing so it's quite clear that that card i got and had to play is a lot worse than those other two cards and it's just this bit of a weird thing where you see these cards and you can clearly see they're not very good compared to other cards there are also similar issues with the civilizations and that they are well known not to be equal civilizations are asymmetric factions which provide the player with some sort of edge and potentially provide guidance on a route to take since tapestry came out stone meyer have published a rata to try and balance out some of these factions it might also be fair to say that you might lose the game because of your faction versus another for example the inventors let you upgrade four inventions ignoring all prerequisites and gain the bonus however this might only provide meager returns when compared with the heralds which can copy another players or their own tapestry cards essentially allowing them to play eight tapestry cards throughout the game the thing is we like the civilizations they're a cool idea they're all pretty different and they give players direction which is always a great thing and between the base game and the expansion i believe there's about 26 different civilizations and that's a lot of variety and you know

each time you play tapestry then you're going to have a somewhat unique experience because of the different directions these will push you in but you know tapstery is a game that you just have to be okay with a little bit of imbalance sometimes and do the best with what you're given plus at the start of the game you're given two civilizations and you pick one so hopefully as you become more familiar with them you can avoid the ones that you really really don't want to play as tapestry is a strange one in terms of post-game discussion in one aspect every game is the same and we mean this in that the tracks are all the same nothing about them is ever altered in each game 90 of what you do won't be any different game to game but it's really hard when you look back if you have a great game or a terrible game and try to figure out what you did differently to cause that deep down we believe this is because tapestry is a very swingy game what tapestry cards did you play and when what was the state of the board when you used your civilization power what spaces are other players on and what cars did they play and this can be quite annoying in times of trying to improve and do better each time because you can never quite put your finger on the difference yeah and just as a personalizing vote following on from that i think my worst ever game was about eight or nine games in and i got really miserable score and i just had no idea why or what was so different to any other game and it's quite frustrating because

obviously you always want to improve but on a positive note the simplicity of the actions in tapestry are a strength this is because although they're very basic they're all easy to understand and they all contribute to your civilization they make it more efficient and they make it stronger so then in each subsequent era you're getting more actions and doing more things it's a really pleasant little engine builder it's also a very interesting puzzle to work out because you know slight changes in how you play such as different movement patterns or taking different actions on the same space game to gain they will really alter the trajectory of your civilization so the biggest problem with tab street and the reason we can't recommend it outright is the price i cannot believe how expensive this game is and it's quite clear that the high price comes from the inclusion of these 3d buildings and quite frankly we find them garish and horrid the colour scheme genuinely offends my eyes i can't understand why this is a thing that they decided to make so fancy and overdone considering it's such a small part of the game and in fact some of the civilizations will have you actively ignoring the little buildings capital city mini game and by association because you're not caring about the city you don't don't care about the landmark buildings either and secondly they are such a bull egg

to set up because they all look the same and it's not really that clear which is which and what goes where and it's even worth trying to put them away because there's no storage labeling i got this game on sale and i would personally not pay full price for it i don't think the gameplay is deserving of the high price and the inclusion of these likely expensive buildings doesn't add anything to the game i don't understand why they couldn't have just used cardboard tiles for the spaces instead and then made it more affordable for everyone we think tapestry would be a good game for a group that wants some player interaction but doesn't want it to be overwhelmingly stressful or negative think root the most stressful action is probably the conquest action in which you simply just overtake another player's territory like so most of the other interaction just comes from piggybacking of other players locations on the board or cards in play or racing to grab a landmark or an achievement and if you want to avoid the player interaction you just simply keep to yourself thus you can keep everyone around the table happy unless somebody is just out to cause outright misery so now let's talk about the expansion plans and ploys this is a kind of expansion that just brings more stuff but the good news is because it's just more stuff it's very easy to

slot into the main game so first let's just talk about quality of life stuff that they've brought you have this canvas bag which is nice material and in this you put the expiration tiles and this means you can just randomly draw them whereas before you kind of have to shuffle them and make piles and i think everyone knows that shuffling tiles is just kind of tedious and annoying so this is a really good way of doing that so we appreciate this although i don't really know why they did this for the exploration tiles and then didn't do it for the space tiles but anyway then you have these landmark tokens which go on the board over the old circles which showed the buildings and these are a quality of life improvement because the old circles aren't colored in and it made it really hard to tell which building was which because some of them look similar especially the small ones first of all player when they move in that space is reminded oh i take this i get the building and secondly it helps the setup then on to the kind of more stuff you have more factions or civilizations and you get 10 new ones and they're all quite interesting and diverse and we haven't played any that we've found to be bad and you also have more tapestry cards and these are kind of more balanced cards they're less swingy a lot of them are in the style of trap cards that you could play you know in in a certain moment or you can just put them down on your board as a normal tapestry card and get vp and goodies then moving on to the kind of meh stuff of the expansion one of the new

you could say gameplay things you get is the landmark cards and on here you essentially get a card at the start of the game it gives you a little personal goal to do and when you do it you get the landmark building put it in your city and these were designed to give players something to focus on in the first half the little goal and direction but i think the whole thing's just kind of superfluous because the buildings and the goals just like aren't that interesting and these we find are something that they kind of just get forgotten and i think actually some of the landmarks are kind of almost actively harmful as a direction because they require a lot of effort whereas other ones you do organically so they seem to be somewhat imbalanced as well in a kind of summary i guess what i would say is that if you're a big fan of tapestry then it's definitely worth getting it's more stuff none of it's bad and you know it gives the game a bit of longevity if you have tapestry and you thought the game was a bit broken and maybe you're waiting for an expansion that fixes everything this is not it it's just more stuff but they do include the errata but you can also find those online but they're not really like it's give or take a resource or minus some vp or plus some vp so it's not a lot but yeah so that is plans and ploys to sum up tapestry is a flawed but fun game there's an enjoyable engine building center here and for the most

part you're gonna enjoy your time with it however if you're looking for a civilization builder or any theme at all you won't find it here this is probably one of the most abstract games in relation to theme that we've ever played also from time to time you're going to run across issues that will hamper your enjoyment from pathetic factions to unlucky top street card draws i make worse is the very worst is a very high price of the game which is unforgivable because a lot of it comes from these very large and very unnecessary and very eye hearty 3d buildings but we don't want to put people off because this is a game we enjoy and it's also a game we're going to get out time and time again it's just that people deserve to know what they're getting going in but this is the end so thanks for watching please if you enjoyed it like and subscribe and we regularly post board game content always with a hint of dog guys bye bye

Progress saved