Carcassonne Review — The Tile Laying Classic!
Transcript
At the turn of the century was the release of this legendary tile-laying 30-ish mini game, Carcassonne, which I had no idea was an actual city in France until I made this review. That's right, the word Carcassonne is so essential, so popular in the board game zeitgeist that it's kind of synonymous with tile-laying. So, with the storied past that's probably been long overplayed by many, I figured now is the time I should play it after many people have been burned out on it. But actually, despite all the Walmart discounts and all the Amazon discounts, this game is far from irrelevant today, over 25 years over its release. And with that amount of time passed, there's a bustling, and I mean bustling, board game arena scene where players online will humble you while playing. They've humbled me a lot. Lastly, this is my friend's Carcassonne Big Box copy, but we're only covering the base game rules, including the farmers. Perhaps later I could cover the expansions, but today is not that day.
Game is for two to five players, and I've played it at every single player count. The number of plays is kind of unknown at this point. It's probably over a dozen, I think. If you do want to look up rules, but don't want to go through the rulebook or can't, I want to introduce today's sponsor, Table Coach. In my time using it, it's really, really good at going through rulebooks and answering questions. Like if I'm confused about the farmers in Carcassonne, bam, there's answer with the page in the rulebook it came from. Brass: Birmingham iron vs. coal usage? Of course. If only I had this program while going through Grim Coven and all those other games that tilted me in rules. Anyways, you can get a free month of usage with our code Shelf Side, link in description below, no credit card needed. Like seriously, this is an awesome program in my time using it, and publishers can opt out. Just send them an email, no lawyer or formal notice needed. They're continually adding to the game database. I've even been personally picking games they've missed, so I'm sure it's going to keep getting better and better. And you could probably comment below what games they've missed on the website, and they can add them. Yeah, so now, back to the video. How to play. Goal is to have the most points by the time all the tiles in the game are placed, which ends the game. To do that, you'll want to have your meeples on the board to score points for you in different ways we'll get into. On a turn, all All is put down your one tile in your hand. It can be connected to any other tiles edge in the game, except that the connection has to make sense. Okay, what do we mean by that? Well, it means that you can't cut off another tile. So, a road must be connected to another road, grass to grass, city to city. Then, after you place down said tile, maybe rotating it so it's legal, you can place a meeple from your supply on the tile. Generally,
you'll place it in one of three ways: on the road, later getting points for how long the road is, on the city, later getting points for how big a completed city is, or on the farm, end game getting points for how many completed cities are in the general grassy area. Okay, there is a fourth one, it's kind of weirder, it's called the cloister, the monastery-looking thing, where you get one point for itself, and then up to eight points for eight surrounding tiles, so up to nine points. The restriction is is that you only have seven meeples, and so if you have all of them on the board, you can't place any more meeples down. But, of course, you can still place down tiles. So, to return meeples, you want to complete a road or city through a tile placement, which just means that the road or city is closed off. Like here, we end the road through an intersection placement, and this will have the meeple or meeples immediately score and go back to their owners. Farmers in the grass don't ever return, and monks in the cloisters don't return unless they're completely surrounded. Game ends when the tile deck runs out and the final tile is placed.
You do final scoring, which is getting points for incomplete roads, cities, and cloisters, then do farming scoring, which again is a little bit different, so more details in bros. Yeah, Carcassonne just looks and feels great. There's a lot of different versions, but I'd imagine they'd all kind of have this quality. The tiles Mhm, it's just a delight to touch. Draw them, rotate them, it all feels good. The art is super legible on the board. Meeples are even more obvious, there's even the difference between standing and face-down meeples, which serves gameplay. Also, there's probably no way the art is AI because this game was made way back when before such black magic existed. There's even little details on the corners of some of the tiles, which look so nice to add texture to maps without ever being distracting. Like, they even made intersections look like proper rest stops. This just makes the map just feel way more alive. If you look closely, too, there's even some humans sneaking up on the monastery. And the gameplay facilitates art because you literally have to have the art make sense. While you get some maps that probably seem a little bit weird if you think about them deeply, with weird loops and way too many small cities, they don't look terrible at a glance. No Frankenstein maps here.
Component-wise, playing Carcassonne is just really non-fiddly. You're only ever touching one tile. There's no text on it. It's super clear what it does. It rotates nicely in your hand. And so, everyone's actually looking at the middle. So, that opens up a lot of room for eye watching and overall trash talk about locations. Like, you don't have to fuss about a player area because, well, there it's pretty much nothing. Just meeples. Oh, yeah. So, then it's really easy to tell how many meeples someone has left. And because you're making the map as you go, the game is actually dirt easy to start. All you have to do is get this starting tile, the one with the slightly weird back, put it down, and you can actually just play like from the box. You can have all these tiles in the box and just draw them out from the box as you're getting your hands. And then, to teach the game, yeah, the core mechanics are super easy to just learn and do. Draw tile. See tile. Uh when on your turn, place tile. Put down meeple on tile if you want.
That's it. In total, you'll only have seven meeples in front of you. And this is just so simple compared to any Euro. This game is pretty much just micro game in terms of the gameplay loop. It's also a really nice reward loop of put down meeple, and then when it returns, you get points to move up other component. You definitely feel like, "Oh, wow, I did an achievement." And when teaching the game, you can even demo a meeple going down and instantly scoring a road, which really gets those motor functions working. Put down thing with hand, return with right hand, move up points. Lastly, I never had any problem with the rulebook as I went between this one and the dedicated online one. I mean, this game has been around for 20 plus years, so you'd imagine they'd probably get it right by now. Haha. Some text could be bigger, but whatever. Now, it's time for gameplay pros, and where do I even start?
Sheesh, I suppose we can start with how darn good the tile laying is. It's simple, it's interactive with other players really well, it interacts with the meeple's really well, and the decision space keeps building up because how you're building out the board, and just wraps up to be a very elegant package. While only playing down one tile sounds really simple, you can place it anywhere that's legal, which really isn't much at first, but the decision space can quickly start exploding. Think about how every tile someone places immediately changes the possibility for everyone. Everyone is pulling the map in their desired directions, and while novices will accidentally help others, veterans understand that because the map is so interconnected, often to do a strong play, you're going to end up marginally helping someone. So, hopefully that person is someone that is trailing at points. And the counter play is real, as since the maps have to make sense, you can easily block off people by making the completion for their city or road quite unlikely, or in some cases, just straight up impossible once enough tiles have been used up. There's one tiny rule about point scoring that completely changes the game, that is, when an area completes, the points go to the player with the most meeples in that area. So, here we have one yellow meeple, yellow player gets the points.
But, say there is one yellow and one black, then no one gets the points. If there is two yellows and one black, then the yellow player gets the points. So, yeah, you can actually be invested somewhere with a meeple and get zero payout for it. But, you can never place a meeple in a place where someone else has one. So, how does that work? Well, to actually do such a hostile takeover, you have to carefully build away from their meeple, and then join it together. To get two meeples to do this requires even more planning. So, you can actually start using meeples offensively or defensively to steal people's hard work from them or prevent people from stealing your hard work. All of these potential plays really inform the personality of tiles. There's just so much depth from knowing all the ways to use tiles, like double end caps, blocking people from trying to merge cities, or how grass adjacencies love each other because you can connect any grass with any grass,
or stopping roads before they get joined with another road. The list just really goes on and on. Notably, there's only one crossroad tile
and only two of these specific city plus curve road tiles. Oh, and then some city tiles are stronger than others because they have a pennant for that tile to be worth double points. Monasteries are a great inclusion because they kind of warp the normal dynamic of roads and cities as those monks want space around them, but it has to be grass. So, ideally they want to be in the middle of everything so you can even block potential monastery placements by placing roads that go to nowhere. But, uh make sure it's two roads if you really want to block it because there's a monastery tile with one road. There we go. Two roads monastery impossible. Actually, since we're talking about all the different tiles here, we have to talk about the different meeple usage. It's amazing. There's a really nice balance of placing meeples to score now or actually saving them for later. It can almost be a push or luck feeling of deciding to commit to a region. Like, let's say we commit to this city here. And this can reward you for placing somewhere where you think other people are going to be placing or not placing around if you think they're going to be counter playing you. It's good to long-term commit, but you generally want to keep one meeple to snipe something to do a hit and run insta scoring. So, then you actually want at least two to three meeples to maybe invest for other long-term commitments or medium-term commitments.
Like, think about if you draw a monastery, well that needs a meeple. So, you just can't have one in your inventory, right? Because then you get to zero really fast. You're basically weighing your board presence versus flexibility constantly. And when you get to two or less meeples, you really feel the constraints. This makes it all the more satisfying for when things complete, especially when multiple meeples come back to you due to an opponent's placement and you really feel recharged. And then you're quickly looking to see how to drop them again cuz you got to do something with them, right? They also will all score partially at the end of the game. And the whole way that meeples balance just makes sense and are different. Thieves complete roads, which are lines. Knights complete cities, which are blocks or circles. Farmers never complete because they just sit on the board. Monasteries, well they just want a lot of influence cuz they're religious. So, everything they're touching regardless of style.
But then, these old Catholic monks are slow in particular, so it's written in their books that they need exactly eight tiles around them. So, it's the only way their job is complete.
So, as you first learn Carcassonne, you'll go like, "Okay, well, it's like mostly a road and city scoring game." But, probably Carcassonne's most understated pro is the simple, humble farmer that just goes face down on the board. So, let's show the simple incentives. Knights to score cities will score two points per tile and also two extra points per pennant on these tiles. So, you can easily score double digits off a city, plus you don't want to leave cities empty because someone can just put down a meeple and just claim those points. Like, compare the cities that you can stack up really well with a lot of city tiles in the game to roads, which are only one point per tile. Uh, it's not as interesting. Those will probably stay single digits. So, people will start competing like crazy over cities trying to be the champion to get the most meeples to have it all for themselves. Okay, so then others will see this and try to close off cities so they don't get too big for one player.
So, then the interesting balance comes with farmers. Because farmers will score three points per completed only completed city. Oh, okay. So, maybe now people will not want to be dividing a big city into multiple smaller ones. Oh, this actually starts to inform all road placement because you can give farmers a boost by playing curves instead of straight lines. Or screw over a farmer by making his farm super small. Or sneak in two farmers on a grass nearby that connect them. So, yeah, it's just like fighting over cities. Now, you get this entire grassy area. So, early investor farmer players always have to be heavily on the lookout for counter play. There's no sitting and getting guarantees here. Farmer ends up being this high risk, high reward play to really dial up the tile placement up a notch, making scoring feel tense all the way until end game scoring when the farmers actually score. Because three points per completed city can be a heck of a lot. It's kind of just perfect to contrast them to roads, which are the ultimate low risk, low reward play.
Because they always score one point per tile end game, even if not completed. And due to the nature of having less connections, it's hard for someone to take over road majority. So, you're generally going to be able to score points without hassle. And these are also great to easily balance meeples back as there's quite a few of dead ends. And you can even close loops.
And then maybe another player trying to do farmer counterplay can actually help your road length for your thieves. Man, this game is just so well connected. And while not a huge focus of the gameplay, once you start to get to know the tiles, there can be a real sense of bluffing
as you'll only put down your secret hand in a certain place if you think others have specific tiles at hand. Or maybe whether or not you'll commit a meeple to it. But that's pretty next level and you might not get there unless you're playing super regularly. And then Carcassonne just scales really well from two to four players. Yes, it does scale to five players, but that might be a little bit too much downtime for some because yeah, you're not really doing anything on your turn besides looking at your one tile in hand. And while there's nothing you can actually trigger on other people's turns, well, your meeples might bounce back to you. Not the farmer. A knight or thief might bounce back to you. But yeah, the most important thing is the person right before you's turn. And then yeah, the game can balloon to 45 to 60 minutes if you're playing with four to five people, people are taking a little bit too long on their turn. So, I would say two to four players to be safe. Two to three seems to be the sweet spot. Then lastly, you have this X factor of the tile gameplay where you can just expand it to make a bunch of silly maps and silly stories.
But this also makes replayability really high, especially for a game where the starting tile in the middle is always the same and you're only drawing one tile to start.
It's not like there's faction powers or anything, but still, there's a lot of reasons to keep playing this game again. And then quickly you'll start to go, "Huh, wasn't that pretty funny where that game where there's two monasteries next to each other?" So, it was a big grassy area and then there was another monastery that popped up. And this is also heavily informing all placements. Or how it's bound to happen where there's one or two mega cities which people will keep expanding but will never quite complete. But what if?
So, seeing at how big the cities can expand to, or what certain knight counterplay can definitely keep you excited for the next game. Cons. So, for component cons, I'm a little confused why there isn't some sort of player aid going on, but this game is old. So, surely this was made before
that was standard, but also this game got reprinted a lot, so what is going on? It'd be really nice for newcomers to see the four different meeple placements, and also some numbers for the tiles because I constantly get asked when I'm teaching the game, "Oh, how many of this tile is there? Or how many of how many of this tile is there?" So, there's currently one page in the rulebook that has really small text, but come on, it's super crucial for good planning to know that yeah, there's only two city tiles that connect everything around them. Like there's only two x of these city tiles which connect such and such. As a Carcassonne rules explainer, I'm always telling people if they should or shouldn't play tiles based off abilities, but this would be so much smoother with a player aid, especially if everyone is new to the game. And the player aid would help explain the farmer mechanic because yes, it is an amazing mechanic, but it does lead to some confusion in point scoring, especially how Carcassonne is framed as a gateway / family game. Cuz yeah, the meeple's down and people go, "Wait, what do you mean? Like what do you mean my meeple doesn't come back? Like I need him back. I need him." And I have to say, "Okay, well, it's like for every completed city is three points."
Huh? The farmer mechanic has so much end game loaded depth that it can just throw off new comer expectations of point scoring. In some version I've played, it's named as optional, but surely the game is lacking without it. Luckily, if you put it in and are confused, the game is fairly short. Okay, so now I have one teeny teeny nitpicky con. It doesn't really matter that much, so feel free to jump ahead to scoring if you're really not picky about RNG. You can go now. Okay, if you're still here, let's dive into it. So, Carcassonne just inherently has a lot of randomness with only one tile in hand, which is fine when you're learning the game, but it can get exhausting if you're taking the turn seriously. It can. Of course, there's always a lot of room for skill in tile and meeple placements. Note how one tile can have multiple meeple placements, but sometimes you just get screwed or have really weird turns. Like sometimes you draw only roads or only cities. And remember, you have to place it. It's not like you can save it for later. Now, there is a lot of places to place it, but it's not super uncommon to have some feels bad turns where you're just placing in the middle of nowhere, and it feels like a complete throwaway turn.
Granted, the more comfortable you get with how many copies there are of each tile, the more you can play around or anticipate weird draws, which in turn leads to better meeple drops.
And this is just the consequence of a game where your hand is only one thing, despite how many ways you can rotate it or place meeples on it.
It's why a popular player count for competitive is just two players, because you will draw specifically half of the tile deck. So, you get to see and go through a higher percentage. And there's only one other person placing stuff to have less board variance. With higher player counts, it can feel a lot more like gambling placing some meeples down, because you just don't know what tiles people are going to place and if they want to go after your area. This is where I'll introduce the somewhat popular house rule where your hand is three tiles. You pick one to play, then draw back up so you're looking at three again. This vastly changes the game and pretty much solves the randomness issues. It makes monasteries feel way more strategic, too. You can save them, but Carcassonne also feels like an entirely different game with it. Like this is so heavy on strategy and planning that I found that turns, at least using three tiles in hand, maybe I could try two, but three tiles in hand just makes turns way, way longer. So, then the game isn't really 30 minutes anymore, it's more like a 45 to 60-minute plus game, but you have way more control of everything. So, yeah, you can mix and match what mode works for you, but you have been warned about just a single tile in hand. Scoring. So, now it's time for a recommender score on Carcassonne from 2001, where we try to critically evaluate the aforementioned pros and cons, while acknowledging we're not completely unbiased, but we're trying to be. And so, this is going to get a recommender score of a nine out of 10.
It is excellent and I'm going to give it Shelfside Certified for just really, really being the standout tile-laying game in my head. I know I'm late to the party. It's just overall phenomenal if you want something cheap, because it's so cheap on so many different sources now, even secondhand. It's under an hour, it highly rewards skill, and it's thematically extremely inoffensive, so you can play it with pretty much anyone. There's also no reading. If you want to play with more skill and skill expression and you have a little bit more time, then I would recommend trying the strategic variant for two to three tiles in hand. Carcassonne is versatile. Like you can keep it casual with the bigger group and there's no intense reading you have to do, but on the other side you could play it two-player and it is an abstract duel fest of furiously counting tiles. But the more I thought about Carcassonne, like yeah, it is pretty much perfect game play wise, but for a gateway game for a gateway game and trying to keep it casual, I'm not really exactly sure where this game's place is. And that actually keeps this game from being a 10 out of 10 masterpiece recommend a score despite the pros being so overwhelmingly good and the cons being pretty much negligible.
So yeah, I'm really on the fence about nine or 10 out of 10, but I went with the nine out of 10. So one recommendation hesitation is that Carcassonne is surprisingly mean for what it seems like. So yes, the board is very interconnected and you can do something like place down a tile and that will either on purpose or by accident make it way harder or easier for someone else to do something. That is the magic of having this interconnectivity meaning lots of placement restrictions. So yes, even if you weren't trying to mess with someone, it can feel really bad for some people. A really great comparison was Brass: Birmingham. Yes, Carcassonne is way less warm fuzzy than this a very popular but way more rules heavy game cuz that is actually helping each other. It feels good. You share some beer, get your economies better. But Carcassonne is saying, "No, you don't get to complete that city. No, you don't get your meeple back." This is why for two players, like especially couples, I'm a little hesitant to readily recommend this over other dual games like Splendor Duel or even Lost Cities, which are not exactly trying to be warm fuzzy, but they are just they just are a little bit less prickly than this game. Like they have a lot of interaction and it doesn't have the feeling like in this game where, "Oh my god, you wasted my meeple. Oh my god, honey. I'm sorry, honey. I'm sorry.
I didn't mean to. I just I I already put down the tile." Yes, Carcassonne technically has cooperation if you're slightly working together to complete roads or cities, but that isn't the right way to play. You shouldn't be giving your opponents any edge and points, especially when you can place anywhere on the board. And with playing with newcomers, yes, the game is definitely simple, but it is kind of easy to be in a situation where you have zero meeples left and you're just sitting there and it feels bad. You can't really score any points. Overall, getting good at scoring, especially for the farmers, is way less intuitive when you compare it to other games in this realm like Catan or even Splendor. Like, oh, you didn't like getting blocked off in Catan? Well, that can happen pretty much every other turn in Carcassonne. I love to bring up a Catan, but yeah, they're not really in the same conversation. There's no casual friendly dice rolling, there's no free gaining of resources from not doing anything, there's no resources to spend to buy things or trade with others, which is way more intuitive and universally appealing, and the progression of Carcassonne is not as feels good.
There's no dev cards to distract you or alternate ways to get points, and there's no politics with a robber. This classic is a lot more complex, has a much steeper learning curve, and is meaner than it looks, and is something that to fully enjoy, you should get in deep. Because if you play it casually, there's much better gateway picks nowadays. That's why this recommended score feels so weird. Like, yes, this is incredible value for money, the more you think about the gameplay, the better it is, but it really is just a hardcore abstract game. Like, it's much closer to Tigris and Euphrates than Splendor. But, if you buy this game today, just like if you bought Tigris and Euphrates, I don't think these games are going out of style anytime soon. This is all to say, Carcassonne is as evergreen as it gets. And for those looking to get even deeper into the hobby, but still want that gateway-like charm, this could be the game to rope in all your buddies that maybe have a more serious side to them. Back in the early 2000s, this would be an easy 10 out of 10, and for the number to drop by one point to a nine out of 10 decades later is pretty crazy. And for this game, you don't even have to buy it to play it right now. You could play on BGA like I did many times and get whooped by people on there like I did many times.
[screaming]
My personal score for Carcassonne is going to be a five out of 10. Okay, so it was a five out of 10 after playing it just online, and then when I played it in person about three times, I'm like, "Wow, I'm impressed." I raised my score it seven out of 10. This is seven out of 10. It is good for me. First off, it's extremely refreshing to play a game that has such little rules overhead. Like, it's really quite short with a very few components, but the gameplay is so deep and it's so replayable that when I'm looking at the board, I'm like, "Wow, I I want to play this game again." When I first played Carcassonne, I was thinking the gameplay feels so dry, but the more I play it, I actually don't think so because the tiles have such personality that they form really deep placement and the game is 30 minutes anyways. Actually, I'm a little bummed that I played this so much over BGA because the experience isn't really well translated to in person. Like, sure setup and scoring is automated, but that isn't a problem in a game this small and straightforward, too. What I did lose online is the joy of seeing the map come alive before me, being able to rotate and feel tiles at hand, and following my friends' eyes for way more interaction.
And when I really started paying attention to those farmers, the game went from, "Oh, well, it's kind of dragging, but I guess this is enjoyable enough to, whoa, this is really deep." And like, wait, the game is over already? There's so many more things I want to do. So, I'm actually pretty surprised I'm so high on this. At first, I was thinking there's no way this could be higher than a six out of 10, but it is a seven out of 10. There's no one moment I'm just like, "Whoa!" fawning over, but the tile placement all feels good unless I get supremely unlucky, but not very common as I said in comments. And then I just don't want to extend the game to drawing three tiles at hand and analyzing so hard because I think that just takes away from the simplicity of this game. It makes it more of a medium even medium heavy experience. Some people are just so good at this game on BGA. But yeah, I think this game is going to live rent-free in my head in how well the tile laying is implemented. Now, it doesn't get to an eight out of 10 for me, but something really tells me that I'm going to be picking up a copy of Carcassonne for myself in the near-ish future. And so, yeah, there's no climactic clash of swords and the game is just a VP going up, but how to get there feels like a real battle. And this also made me think of Tigris & Euphrates, which feels like carefully crafted cinema verite that I will retroactively give Shelf Side Certified, but I'm not actually sure if I want to play Tigris & Euphrates again that soon, especially with three-plus players, but I'm very happy to own that game. So, Carcassonne kind of gives me the feeling of that elegance in just a way more friendly and intuitive package. And I can play it with mostly whoever, at least my more board gamer friends.
Lastly, I kind of suck at Carcassonne. I played it a lot and I've only won like twice, maybe three times, probably just twice. That means that even games I'm teaching to newcomers, I'm getting rolled. Partly because I am going nice, but also partly because I just don't see all the connections out there. Maybe I have bad spatial reasoning, especially in BGA. I do think my gameplay in person is stronger. And this really has a sticking element in my brain in the onslaught of these huge boxes with so many rules and so many components and miniatures and pieces and like yeah, actually Carcassonne just tiles. Wow, that's a game night. Good game night. Impressive. Impressive.
Anyways, that's it for Carcassonne, yeah. Thank you to our patrons for making videos like this possible. This one was a long time in the making, just slowly working at it. So, glad to finally get it out there. Let me know what other classics you want me to cover. I don't know, Castles of Burgundy, Trajan. Yeah, try to always spice it up for you guys. Yep. Um yeah, I want to, you know, go old, new, old, new, just all that stuff. Stuff. Yeah. Okay, also thank you to our mad lads of cardboard over here. That's it. That's it for Carcassonne. See you guys. Bye-bye.