The Game Makers Review: Panda Express Yourself
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vasel.
I'm Joey Evans.
I'm Mike Leccio.
Have you ever wanted to learn how a game is made?
Yes.
The game makers, I think in their advertising like learn how games are made. Guess what? You'll still know nothing when this is over.
That is true, but
But this is a meta game about making board games. In fact, Bezier Games, the company who made it, got the rights to so many other games. They're on the cover which I would kind of tilt towards you. I don't want to move it. This game is a giant game as far as we can tell this is the only way to get it right now. This big It was a Kickstarter game.
Yeah.
I don't know that they're making a more retail version as far as I can tell. But is it worth it? Let's talk about how it plays and we'll be right back. In The Game Makers, the whole thing revolves around this central board. Each player is going to have these three little forklifts here. And they're all going to start here. This board is randomly built where there are six different wedges in it and each wedge has pieces that are attached with it. And so on each turn of the game simultaneously, players are going to take pieces from where they are in this wedge that's surrounded by this yellow striped line. And you're going to place it in one of the three open spots. Wherever you place it, you're going to get a resource of that type. So for example, if I place it here, I will get a level one wood. If I place it here, I will get a level two plastic piece. If I place it here, I'll get a level three die.
And so the farther out you place it, the better the level will be. So maybe red places all three of theirs there. Blue does this and green does that. After everyone has done it and taken these items, then the board will rotate. The next turn, only these four pieces are going to be spread out. Now, they can take tiles, a level three tile from the bag. It's randomly drawn. So, maybe red does does two of those, and red and white each take a level one plastic building. And then this moves again. Now, cards are available where you'll draw cards from the top of the stack that show various games on the other sides of them. And then finally, after it moves after that point, it will get to wild where you'll be able to take a level three resource or a level two resource. It will show you. So, that's the general way that the game is played. Each player is going to have two boards in front of them, one board where they're going to be keeping track of everything that's going on in the game, and the other board that's going to be showing their collection. As the game goes by, you're going to be making games, producing them, and placing them in various spots on your shelves where they'll score points at the end of the game.
Each game is one of four types. We have the red ones, which are war fighting games, the blue ones, which are collection or card games, the purple, which are cooperative or team games, and the yellow, which are engine building or strategy games. Each of these has a certain number of components that they need to get built. So, for example, Rebel Princess needs four cards and a level two tile. Darwin's Journey needs one card, a level three tile, and a level three wooden piece, while Camel Up requires a level three tile, a level one wooden piece, and a level one die. You can always use a better piece. So, if I have a level three die, I can use that to build this. And you can build these at any time on your turn. Each of them is going to score in various ways at the end of the game, most of the time based on where they are placed on your shelf. Players are going to start with a couple resources. You'll have a couple cards. You'll have a contract. This is a game that you're building and you'll also start with a worker up here. And so the point of this game is whenever you collect anything.
So let's say I collect a level two worker. I can put it in my components where it's just a wood component. Once it's there, forever and always will be a component or I can put it up here where it can be a worker. When I get a plastic building, I can put it here where it's a plastic piece or I can fill in one of these buildings that you either randomly get or draft at the beginning of the game. And when these these are full, you can get end game scoring conditions or special abilities as the game goes by. When you get a die, you can put it here where it's a die resource or you can roll it and spend it right away. Well, you roll it no matter what and then decide whether to keep it or die and move up one of these tracks here that many spaces. Moving up these tracks here is one of the main way to score points as the game goes by. When you get tiles, again, you can put them here or you can build them in these spots out here. Now, the reason you're building tiles in different spots is because as the game goes by, if you get three of the same thing in a row, you'll have a discount. So this is a level I have three workers in a row. So now instead of a level three worker on these, I can use a level two. If it says I need a level two, I can use a level one. If it says I need a level one, it's I don't need that component at all. But also, as you fill in the different spots here, you'll fill in these little squares and then you'll put these tweenies. You can pick one of these tweenies. I hate this name.
Um you'll put it there and get that bonus. So this one for example gives me a level one building. And workers can be spent like I said to go down here. Sometimes they let you when you get cards, you draw more cards or you when you move up the tracks, you can move farther up the tracks. You can place them in two of them together here to take a level two of anything you want. And when the line go gets to break room on the main board, then all your workers get reset. Um also, as the game goes by, various things when you get to certain number of games built or you discard a bunch of abilities, you might get trees and trees are also going to score you because you're giving back to the environment at the end of the game. And then finally, cards. As you get cards, as you take each card, you have to decide whether you're going to put them out as resources or if you're going to put them out as a game that you are working on.
At any point on your turn, you can turn in these resources and put the game out here. At the end of the game, you're going to score. Each build Each of the games that you have built is going to score based on it. Some games, mostly the yellow ones, don't score at all when you build them. You often get some pieces, although this one just gives you one point. Some give you points if you have different cards in columns or like for example, this one gives you one point for every card in these two columns. And then there's a maximum of six points that you can get from it. They each tell you how many points they can score. You're also going to get points for each of the different types of buildings and for the number of trees that you have built based on how far up each of these tracks that you've moved. And each of them scores differently. Your engine building, you get one per column times the number that you've reached on here.
One for every two blue cards. Here, the cooperative games, you get points if for everyone else who has cooperative games and if you have at least three. And the red ones, the war games, you get two points for every player that you have more of than those times your number. And then trees, three points for every three trees times the number that you moved up to. There's a few other things that you can get at the scoring, but the game will end when somebody gets to fills their board with 12 and then uh everyone gets one last turn and that's how you play. Before we go um and talk about our overview, I do want to say that they just have a ton of cards. I know some extra came with the Kickstarter, so I'm not sure which of these are from the base game and which but I know that the base game has tons and tons of games.
So, you can see any fantastic game that you might think of is in here. Uh even though sometimes they might take you a while to figure out what it is. Like, is there even a game here? Is this blank? Oh, that's Kingdom Death Monster. But, lots of great games uh are in here or bad games depending on your opinion of them. And so, yeah. Um let's talk about our opinions.
Okay, I'm going to start by saying I like the game and I I need to say that because I'm going to say a few small negative things. Well, the production the production is the production.
Uh-huh.
It is it is extravagant and I don't necessarily hate that. I love the little forklifts. I love the magnet that you have and I forgot the name of that.
Brody the Brody knob I
The Brody knob
which I bet it would be called on the on the actual forklift.
buy one for my car cuz I really like having them. Um
You can get those.
I know. I just keep forgetting to buy one. Anyway, I like that that all works well. There are some things that don't work as well though. One is I think the bags that the tiles go in fitting in that tray is a little janky.
Sure.
I don't know of a better way but it just feels weird. The storage in the box is once again Game Tray is kind of saying, "Look what we can do." And I'm like, "That's clever." But, I have to remember how to do it.
Yes.
And that's kind of a pain. Just putting the whole thing back in the box is a pain. It's big and probably most egregiously there are some errors on some things. I haven't noticed many but the internet has like lists of them. I don't think it's that big of a deal but keep that in mind.
I agree. Um just speaking about the production one thing uh I thought was interesting to mention is the the kind of the partnership with Panda which is the biggest uh you know, producer of board games uh in the world, and this is a partnership with them, and I think that that kind of all ties into this meta thing you're talking about. This is a game that I kind of liken in a way to Foundations of Rome, okay? Because it's appealing to a very particular type of gamer. They're appealing to people that like collecting board games, right? That's what this game is kind of about. It's you're you're you're putting your collection out there in front of you. Yes, you're building them, you're manufacturing, but the production, I think, for this particular game suits what it's doing, just like I think that first edition of Foundations did. But, you're right, there are a couple little errors.
I didn't find as much of an issue with putting it back. I thought they did a pretty good job with with the insert, but you know, cuz some of them get so convoluted.
Another thing though is also, again, it it's the game goes to six. On whose table? We have a game tables here.
that's very true.
Each player's area takes up so much space. I cannot I mean, gameplay itself, I don't mind the [snorts] six because everyone's simultaneous. It's not a big deal. But, where are you sitting on the table? You'll be like, "Ah, move my piece there." But,
Yes.
You mentioned this is for gamers, and that's definitely the case. And I think so much of that because if you're in this game for the gameplay {slash} scoring,
Mhm.
I think you'll come away a little disappointed, especially since if you like the gameplay, the same designer, Ben Rosset, has made a game for Maj. Just play for Maj. You know, it's a half 1/3 of the size, easier to play.
Mhm.
I play this game because the journey is fun, moving the forklifts and getting the pieces and stuff, and I'm building games, and I like [clears throat] putting those games in my thing. I built Gloomhaven.
Yep.
That's satisfying to me, and it's more satisfying to me than the end of the game scoring.
Yeah, there are mechanics in there I like more than the actual I mean, building the game, you say you you put it in your shelf. When you I don't really feel like I get the feeling of building a game since I have to use two dice, call it and all that stuff.
That's how games are made, two dice and a card.
do.
You do. But, there are like really neat like one of the things I like is the dice, you know? You can either roll the dice to increase your marketing or use it as a component. Some people don't like the luck of a die roll in games.
Oh, you know what? I should have shown you the dice are actually they're not normal dice.
Right. The bigger die is like 4 5 6. The smaller die is 1
custom die.
like 2 1 2 3 or something like that.
Which is very clever because then you have to take into account you're like So, it's your choice whether to take that fully luck roll, you know, on I want to increase my marketing, but I might get a 2.
You do get to roll first, which is a big deal.
That's very That's actually a huge deal because yeah, you can make that decision and
You lost ones.
Yeah, and it and it plays with this idea of small, medium, and large components, right? The big die is going to be giving you more of a chance of rolling those big numbers, and you might be thinking I really want this to build this game, but I just rolled a six. I can shoot up that track, you know? So, I like the way the dice work, too.
Yeah.
Yeah, that's to me everything using it on the board or not is fun. I think some things are better than others. The dice I think is the most fun choice followed closely by the tiles and cards. The meeples are interesting. The plastic is the I think the the weakest part of the game to me because you may or may not love your buildings. And once your buildings are built it's not as interesting. Um but the the tiles are like oh, I can get discounts and I get to put in those
Uh what are they called? Yeah, the little things.
Tweeners. Tweeners, maybe.
Because they're in between. I hate that name so much. That is the one thing you overlook at the beginning. You're like I'm not going to worry about this, and then somebody else is doing you're like how are you
Oh, yeah.
Should have done that a while back. Yeah.
Yeah. Go ahead.
I wanted to talk about the end game scoring, though.
Okay.
So, the end game scoring is not particularly difficult. It looks very complex. Everyone has a player aid that explains and the cards themselves only score I think four different ways.
Yeah.
I think the scoring is fine. There's a few things I don't love. I don't love that you have to use a scoring sheet for each person. You're going to run out so fast that way. You're going to have to You're going to have to laminate them because you use this whole score sheet. It makes it easy to score cuz you score each card. Sure. Um the scoring the different types I'm I'm slightly less enthused. It's Again, it's fine. It works except for I just I I know it's supposed to be thematic. I think the co-op one is just I have to explain it every time multiple times and at the end of the day you're like, "Okay, so co-op gets me points, but really only if everyone else is also getting points. So, who cares?" While the war game is much easier. Do I have more than you? Haha. And and I I don't know. I just felt like that was the weakest part of the scoring the co-op games.
I I I suppose you're I would agree in the sense that maybe it's not as potentially exciting, but I look
But it's I don't know if it's good as a game cuz if you get seven points, I might too. The only difference of who markets their co-ops better.
Right. Exactly. Right. Yeah, I get that, but I mean I don't know. I I don't mind that a little bit for the trade-off of I just like that thematic connection. I think it's a neat idea. You know, I mean and and it kind of brings that co-op element to it a little bit, but yeah. I mean I get it. It doesn't bother me I think as much as you.
It is very thematic, but I do it's my gladiators. I look at it at the table.
Yeah, I don't know. For me I'm I I probably diversify too much. It's I think it's probably best if you if you you know, kind of focus on one particular type of scoring, but I'll be honest this is one of those games where it's light enough that I often times are going to go for building the games I want to build and then I'm going to try to score as best as as I can with those, but if I have a choice between two, one scores me slightly better and one is like in my top 10 games, I'm going for my one that's in my top 10 games.
That is a good point. Yes.
And I think that comes down to the recommendation part of this for me. Yeah. It's a big game. It replaces three other games in your collection if you're if you have a limited amount of space. But if you love board games in general, you like collecting games, you're going to like the theme. For me, the destination here is I mean the journey is better than the destination, by far. I like playing the game. I like moving the forklifts. I like every turn, there's almost no downtime cuz everyone's moving simultaneously. You're moving a bunch of pieces, you build things, and it's that's entertaining, and then the end result is a shelf full of games that I like a lot of them because again, when I'm picking, I draw some cards and I'm like, which one am I going to build? Well, I like this game. So, I mean, I I kind of lean that way. So, I I it's just shy of being excellent for me, but I think it's very good. It's an eight out of 10 for me.
Um who's next?
I'll go next. I'm actually a 7.5 on this. I like it a lot. Here's Here's the difference. I like the gameplay of this more than Viticulture. I just do. I think maybe it's the theming, I don't know what it is, but I'll play Viticulture more, but if this is set up already, I would more I'd be more happy to sit and play this. It's just set up, it's all that stuff. But that being said, I think it's perfect way it is. It just takes a while. When you said the journey, I thought you were talking about like the journey of getting this entire thing out.
No. No, I'm talking about the cuz that's I like playing the game. We get to scoring, I'm like, okay, who won? You won, I don't necessarily care cuz I had so much fun playing.
Exactly. Now, I will say I still love that mechanism about what action am I going to take? If I take it way up here, I'll get something so much better, or I have to wait. I That is becoming quickly one of my favorite mechanisms in games, and this does it so well. Everything is so fun about switching that gear. It has so many parts to just shine about it.
I like it a lot. I like it more than both of you. I'm I'm giving it an 8.5, and I think with more plays it could even go up. Here's the thing for me. Yes, space-wise it is a concern, it's something, and I am someone that is very conscious of the amount of space I take up, but number one, I kind of disagree with the setup. I think the setup for a game this magnitude is a breeze. Like, it's
it's tear down is he said setup. I think tear down is a bigger a bigger
I think you can do both much quicker than a standard Euro game. I really believe
Possibly.
probably. Um so, I don't think that's an issue. I am so happy that there's a game that is this theme that is not convoluted because every game that has been about making games, collecting games, it seems like are usually games where there's like, "Why are you throwing in everything in the kitchen sink? Can we take some This game feels like it's not bloated. It's It's been pretty streamlined. It's not hard to teach at all.
really not.
hard to teach and play it. Plays in a in a really reasonable amount of time because so much of what you're doing is simultaneous. It gives you that look what I built thing at the end of the game, which is fantastic. It fits in really well with the theme. I think they did an excellent job with this and it is going to be one of those um uh what's the word I'm looking for? Like a um not a lifestyle game, but a a uh something you're you know
Cult classic.
No, you're paying a lot of money for it and you're you know, you just have to know that going in. This is not something you're going to be picking up off a shelf at a Target or something like that. Unless they decide to make a retail edition in the future. You know, this is leaning into the collector, you're a gamer, all of that.
gameplay is good enough, too. If you want to play it, yeah.
That's the thing. The gameplay is really solid.
Yes.
I'm also very thankful that they spent whatever money they spent to get the licensing here.
Cuz it's better than you know, Gloomhaven.
I I agree.
And all that nonsense. They're They're just the actual games. And they went out of their way to get good games. There's a few games in there I'm like, "Huh? I'm not even sure what that game is." But, that's very minor. Most of the games are very popular. Most of the highest rated games in the world are in here.
Yes.
And I think that kind of also points into what the board game hobby is as a whole. One of the things I think a lot of gamers love is that you do have the opportunity to go to a convention and meet some of your favorite designers, to see the publishers, and interact with them. And I think this is a good kind of showcase of that.
imagine this happening in Hollywood?
No.
No. Not a chance.
Not a chance.
Cuz whatever publisher made it, whichever movie studio made it, it would be only their stuff.
That's correct.
So, there you go. It's the [clears throat] Game Makers. I'm Tom.
I'm Joey.
I'm Mike.
We're making a game.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.