Notre Dame Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about notre dame by stefan feld now this is a board game for two to five players it takes about an hour to play um it's a euro style game where you're trying to get as many victory points as you can um and obviously the game is set in france um so the kind of main mechanism of the game is um card drafting where everybody starts with an identical deck of cards and you are drawing three cards off the top of that deck and then in turn or simultaneously you're all going to pick all the players are going to pick one of the cards out those three and pass the remaining cards to the player on your left and you're going to do that until you have three cards in your hand and then in player order you're going to activate those cards in order to get the abilities assigned to them so the game is pretty simple because all the actions are very straightforward and pretty similar in their kind of feel and concept so one of them simply gives you money one of them gives you kind of points one of them gives you extra cubes which can kind of give you kind of more power as you get stronger in kind of doing things and one of them lets you fight off rats one of them lets you travel around the board and um one of them basically gives you um like a dummy work or kind of a dummy um pawn which lets you kind of activate any region when you want but the cool thing is when you play these cards which kind of corresponds to the cube action you place one of your cubes in your supply pile onto a corresponding point or place on your own individual board and for example the first time you place one you might get one coin if you're playing the coin card and then the next time
you place one you'll get two coins and then three coins then four coins so it accumulates you can really generate um powerful abilities or powerful kind of turns as the game goes on and there's also an element of i guess kind of area control in the game where one of the action cards lets you kind of nominate or dedicate or tribute money to the um to building the notre dame cathedral where you pay a certain amount of money and the more money you pay the more points you're going to get and then you put a cube onto that central cathedral and then at the end of um the round where the three cards are played um in fact everything's after three rounds um whoever's got the majority of um cubes in that middle section is going to get a bigger portion of the reward that that cathedral gives out um that's pretty much the gist of the game um at the at the end of each round there's going to be um well throughout each round there's gonna be three um kind of character cards that are revealed and then you're gonna have the chance or the opportunity to pay one coin in order to activate one of those cards abilities and they can do a lot of different things such as moving a bunch of cubes around from one section to another or they might give you points um you know in correlation to you know every area you've got at least three cubes you might get points or they might let you move cubes to another and activate it so you've got loads of kind of manipulation on the board which can you know help you going forward and just help kind of cater the game to your needs because the game does have this kind of nagging tension throughout because there is as with in a lot of steffenfeld games
there is an element where the game fights against you so in this game um there are rats which attack you at the end of each round and um basically those rats correspond to a track and um the amount of rats that kind of come for you are printed at the bottom of those character cards and they can range from you know i think it's zero up to like three or four and per card so um in some rounds you can really get um absolutely obliterated by these rats and then if you go above the kind of i think it's the nine on the track then you are going to suffer a penalty by losing um a couple of points and also taking a cube from your player board which can have quite ongoing you know negative effect for you so you've got to constantly worry about that and the way you can kind of counteract that is by dedicating cubes to the hospital because then every rat that's kind of going to hit you at the end of the round is going to get negated by one for every cube that you have on the hospital so that's just another thing to worry about and another thing to kind of um not ignore in the game so you can't just keep on you know generating points and points and points and points because you're going to get um you know hit hard by the rats so there's just something to always bear in mind some games it's going to be a lot less you know significant than others because i played games of this when the rats have been pretty manageable and then i've played games which has been completely overwhelming and i just couldn't overcome them and um ended up suffering quite um you know quite a hit because of those rats but it's a really fun tension and something that i generally like in stefan fell games i mean a lot of his games use this mechanism
such as like amerigo and trajan and merlin so a lot of those games use that you know that ongoing nagging tension of having to deal with something or suffer the consequences so yeah mechanism wise this game is very clean very pure um pretty simple yeah just a very basic card draft very basic area control and a bit of kind of action selection i guess with the card characters that you're using and you've also got that element where you are i guess it's kind of a set collection on the loosest term where you're traveling around the board picking up these different tokens and which can give you points or money or stuff like that and you can't get another one of the same color until you um until you get the whole set so just a little bit something there and obviously just like with everything else the more cubes you put on that the more kind of the faster you can travel around the board and that adds a bit of the play attention as well because there's only one kind of um token of each type um so you want to get that before the other players do um balance of the game is great i mean the card drafting i think is always a great kind of idea anyway because you you know you've got to be willing of or normally you're taking something um not only to bear yourself in mind but to bear what you're giving to your opponent as well and they're doing the same so obviously they're going to have to sacrifice something and then they're giving it to you so a balance i think pretty much works itself out um the time investment i think is fantastic i mean this game takes about i said an hour tops to play um which is great for a failed game um because this one does it does still feel like a failed game even though is
pretty much on the lighter end of his games i think the only kind of thing i would or the only game i would um compare this to in terms of its complexity is maybe something like carpe diem where i think it's a very um you know it's more than doable to introduce us to a new player to the hobby whereas most of steffenfeld's games i i wouldn't even fathom doing that um uptime in the game as well is great because card drafting most of it is simultaneous that's one of the great things about card drafting is that you don't have to wait for other people to take their turns and when you're actually activating the action cards it's very smooth and very quick just put a cube on the board and get the reward um replayability wise i think it's decent i mean it's not the it's not got a ton of variability and stuff like that but there is a bunch of um character cards that um are you know are put in the box in the game so you're not going to see the same ones every game so you're always going to get a slightly different feel to it and the way the tokens are laid out and stuff and obviously when you're drawing cards into your hand you're always drawing a different kind of variation of them so a decent amount of replayability but it's not got um tons and tons of variability um player interaction as well card drafting is a great um i think it's a such a simple way to integrate player interaction um because as i said are you going to take something for yourself are you going to take it to um you know just in spite of your opponents um you've got the area control mechanism in the center where you're going to be constantly trying to at least match your opponent um ideally you want to take the lead but um you know they can kind of snatch quite a big portion of points away from
you if you ignore that aspect of the game um and aesthetically um this game is by um are printed by alaya so i think their kind of graphic design in general was pretty minimalistic um the component quality and stuff is you know it's passable um they don't really go put bells and whistles on their games because i think they're they're more focused on the game itself and the mechanisms and the the game play and that trumps um their production quality and stuff so they're very much um worry about the actual substance of the game rather than all the you know all the superfluous gimmicks and flashy stuff so um you know it goes well with that but don't get me wrong it's perfectly well produced and it works fine it just doesn't look spectacular um theme wise as well it doesn't really make sense but with a lot of euro games it's not doesn't really matter um it's fine i've set up for 10 hour time as well it's really good with this one um i love the the way that the player count kind of manipulates the setup of the board so you've got different kind of cubes or different kind of central tiles which you build your own player boards around which makes the game look different each game depending on the player count and it's very simple to set up to give people their own deck of cards a bunch of cubes and you're pretty much good to go um i love the the cadence of the game is great because as i said the the whole cube mechanism when you're putting stuff down and getting more and more reward in return and that's great so it does have that feeling of progression it does tick along nicely um scalability wise as well um card
drafting again great way to nullify the the bogged down time in terms of player downtime so scalability is really good and um in terms of compare comparing this to other games um i don't really have anything or can think of anything to the top of my mind which i would compare this to but obviously most card drafting games are similar in their feel and that element of this game is you know just feel very similar to those other games but but yeah overall i'm really happy with this game i mean digging wrong i stefan feld is pretty much one of those games or all those designs that i also kind of qualify because i love all those games i think he's just such a great designer and this one is one of his older designs i think it goes back to 2007 but it still holds up really well it's a lot of fun you can play in a really concise amount of time which is great because sometimes you just haven't got the time to get one of those heavier games to the table and this one does feel that niche really well um so yeah i recommend this one it's a great fun um a great lighter weight game on his you know from his kind of catalogue and um definitely check this one out because if you like your car drafting um then he does i don't think he's made a lot of games that do or any games that use card drafting and um this one does it really well and it's um as i said a lot of fun so um i'm going to give this game a very good verdict which is our thing i've given about 7.8 out of 10.
so um yeah a very strong endorsement from me um i hope you've enjoyed this review and check out notre dame so uh for everyone else please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye