Skip to main content
Loading video...

Perennial ►►► Our thoughts on the prototype

Transcript 25:46

Hey everybody, final thoughts. Time for Perennial. But before we get to that, please remember folks, this was a sponsored preview. And with that out of the way, hello Kimberly. How are you doing?

I am doing fantastic. I'm so excited for our joint final thoughts on Perennial. How are you?

I am doing great. And this was so much fun. Uh longtime viewers of the show might remember that Kimberly and I did this a few years ago with another FlatOut game, uh, Knockturn. And uh so when FlatOut contacts us and said, "Hey, could you do that again?" Well, I think we both agreed it would be a blast. And um what was really interesting is the Switcheroo because when I've done this in the past with you or with Amy and Maggie, um you always started the game and then I finished or no, I'm sorry. I started the game and then you finished because that's more work. Finishing a game is much harder than starting a game, I have discovered.

That's fantastic. That's so good. But I did want to hear about your experience picking up my game because you know how when you play these and we're working on so many rules and trying to explain and like walk through like our turns and justification. There was one thing as I was editing my video and I sent it off to you that I was like kicking myself like a decision I made where it was like a subpar choice next to like the best like and I was like h I wish I'd done this instead of this place to flower instead of something else somewhere and I was like uh oh well. I hope I set you up well. Don't sweat it. You set me up fantastically and you probably haven't seen the second half yet. I only uploaded it yesterday. And um you'll be happy to know that our combined score was 95 points.

Oo. Okay. On the scale, I don't think I have the solo scale.

I looked it up. The scale that is considered that is considered an excellent. We were five points short of amazing.

Well, there we go. That's awesome. Maybe my strategy. We'll talk about some of those pawns and features, but my strategy of really pressing hard on the feature side. Maybe that was or the pawn side um was maybe the the the factor. I don't know. I'll have to hear.

Oh, I'll be honest. I didn't quite live up to that. I did deliver on your your big investment that got the full five points, but I think the other ones, they just got what they would have gotten if you had just gone nonp um you started out playing just the basic game. And when I continued with in the solo mode, I uh switched over to the advanced game. So I looked through the I think the game comes with like 27 different objective cards and I kept searching till I could find three that looked like oh my gosh, it was like Kimberly was trying to achieve these objectives and um and so I kept playing with that in mind. So I had a bunch of extra stuff I had to deal with as the board tightened up. Um, yeah, but uh, you know, those things combined put us over the top and and I got to say I I had so much fun doing it because both Jen and I have really really enjoyed this game. And I don't know if you have played FlatOut's previous game from designer Emily Vincent um, Knitting Circle.

Yeah, I have. I have.

Yeah. Well, I did. How did you like that? Because I got to say wi between this and knitting circle between perennial and knitting circle I've got to say Emily is definitely a desire to watch. I have been super impressed by both of these games.

Absolutely. I think so too. I I think perennial really surprised me with a couple of the mechanics that as they say it's like really easy to learn and teach, but then the implementation of it with the the small choices here and there add up and really create this lovely puzzly

spatial thing. And I I'm not like I have some spatial challenges. Let's just say that. Um especially with abstract games. And so for me it can be a real challenge but this was delightful. I have to absolutely agree. Um the polyomino grabbing right the kind of like taking in that first uh stage a phase and then putting it in the second one using the same polyominos but in a different configuration on your your garden map. So cool. Like absolutely cool.

Well that's really interesting to me. Um you know Jen is the same. She is the type of player who whenever we're playing Isisle of Cats or something like that has to pick up every cat and rotate them around on her board to try to figure out because you're right, she has a a hard time kind of visualizing how they're all going to snap together. And it sounds like you uh you know struggle with that as well and I'm sure plenty of viewers do as well. Why would you say this maybe you didn't I mean because here's the deal. I'm in awe of the fact that you were able to do playing two separate characters back toback, you and Lewis's boards without cuts. You know, I mean, I I I I think my me brain would have imploded if I was trying to carry that weight. Um, so what do you think it is about this that works better for you? Um, so for me, I think I even mentioned while I was playing, it was really hard to keep my kind of commentary or my judgment out of the run through because there was things that were so welld designed and thought out and and the very first thing is the tool. So when you have your tool card, they actually show you the inverted version of it. So I've got one of my cards right here, the tools. So you can turn it, you can rotate it, but you can also see the inverted version so much better. And I did have to kind of place my card over the spaces I wanted to do to kind of see it. But it's really, really easy. And it makes it easy for people like me who might struggle with actually seeing it put together because my husband's the kind of person who looks at a shape uh far from him and then sees every

implementation of it on his player board and knows exactly where it goes and how it fits. And I just like can't do that. So yeah, he kind of does it with ease and then I sit here. But but the way that they've designed the cards and then the way that it functions in that two-stage process makes it so much easier and I think it's just yeah straightforward and simple to use um and and again tons and tons of choices um with that. But it's it's really nice.

That is a

yeah that's a really good point. I mean it is the fact that I mean this is a polino polyomino tile drafting game. It's just that you're creating the polyomino as you're drafting it, but then you're ripping it apart and recreating it into something else. I mean, just saying that out loud sounds like that's so much more heavy lifting. But I you're I didn't even occur to me until you just said it. The fact that they put the mirrored shape on the card, which I don't think other games do because most games you're just expected to pick up the tile and you have to physically flip it over to be able to visualize that. The fact that they just give that information to you right there on the card is a a small thing, but I bet it makes a really big difference. It hadn't occurred to me.

Yeah. And and it's just stages or like steps like that all throughout the rule set, the cards, the tiles, the player boards, everything is so user friendly and so clearly labeled and it makes it easy to get into this game. And I really do want to come back to it. And that's something that not every game provides because maybe there's just a whole bunch of diamond setup and there's a whole bunch of diamond breakdown or there's like a lot of fiddly bits throughout.

No, you even have your own player board that says the gathering phase, here's what you do. The planting phase, here's what you do. The round end, here's what you do. And the entire scoring is on your player card.

And the seed actions, we haven't even talked about the seed actions. There's four really cool seed actions. They give you like ways to manipulate those phases of the game and it's just right there. So yeah, they give you everything to enjoy and have fun and it's it's really really well presented.

Is you're right, very nice design. And actually, you know, you mentioned that

it's a very subtle thing. I I think most people when they look at this game, the number one thing that's going to jump out at them is, you know, the really kind of clever, oh, I've got to draft a shape and now I've got to apply that shape to what I'm taking. And then I take all these components and I use that shape a second time in a completely different context later on. That is really cool. And I I guess that's like the most innovative thing about this game. But to me, probably the single biggest smartest design decision Emily and you know the folks at FlatOut made.

Yeah.

Um was very subtle. It's the fact that and you actually mentioned this in your run through um at one point when you were strategizing out loud. Uh the fact that hey, if I get a size three contiguous area, that's three points. If I get a five, it's five points. If I get a six, it's six points. It's not until I get to a seven or better that it's an eight. And it's a very tiny thing. It's only one point. When I first saw that, I thought that's really weird. The way this is supposed to work is, oh yeah, if I get two, that's a little bit, but then if I get five, it's a big jump. And if I get 10, it's a huge jump. And you know, these games always incentivize you to try to make those big contiguous groups. And that's like the big puzzly challenge of the game. in this game, you throw that away. Um, you know that it it's it's there is no reason for you to chase getting that size five because it's no better than your size four. Um, it's just as good to create a size two over there in addition to your size four.

That's as much as a size six would be. And so you you you have that much more flexibility in how you are trying to reconstitute these polyominos as you deploy them. And I mean, you know, it it it it I I think it just gives you more freedom and and um you know, more self-expression that you don't get boxed in quite so tight because this game will box you in by the end when you've only got seven or eight spaces and everything you have to do is five tiles big. Um, you know, the fact that you have the freedom to say no, I mean, it's it's so rare, you know, and most games it's only if oh, is there an uh, you know, a an objective that tells me I need to have a bunch of small groups? Okay, I'll do it because nine times out of 10, otherwise, I'll always try to fight so hard to get that one big group. And in this game, you don't have to. I thought that was really sharp. And I hadn't seen other games do it. It's just fade. It's just assumed that of course a bigger contiguous group is better. That's just the way I mean, ever since Ticket to Ride, Ticket to Ride made that rule and this game breaks it to its bet to its betterment, I think.

Yeah. And I thought that was fascinating, too, because I wanted there to be that ramp. I wanted there to be the thing that we kind of expect with the more um that you have in your flower grouping, the higher the victory points, but they make those two ledges from zero to two. And so, you always want to get two side by side. You don't want to have just a single flower. Um, but then there's that one gap towards the end. And there's also a flower goal card that I think is like your groupings of 10 give you three points, but that's even harder to get get 10 in a row. Um, so if you have that as one of your goals, then you can do that. The advanced play, you get your flower goal, your animal goal, and then your pond or feature goal. Um, but yeah, by the way, one thing that is one of the goals we shared.

We did we did actually win off of that that specific, hey, get, you know, get a group of 10. um which I was able to pull off because you had set me up so well. But anyway, I'm sorry. Continue.

Oh, that's fantastic. Oh, the very one that I mentioned. Yeah. Um so, but but speaking back to the polyominos and you're taking the shapes from the board. I think the really cool simple rule is that you can take any of the four and I like the flexibility of any of the four sides. It's not like you can only take from the side that you're facing or something like that or you have to pay something to get something else. No, you can get any of the four tools that are on all four sides of the garden uh pool that everyone's pulling from. And then one of those spaces needs to touch the side of the tool from which it came. That's it. And you can take that shape all over and it's just kind you never really get hemmed in. And I feel like sometimes when you have these turn-based um drafting um in like these phase ones of a lot of the games that I looked at um when I was kind of reviewing some of the flatout games, sometimes there's just not the tile you need or not the thing you need. And it's back to you and you're like dang it.

Well, not in this game. I never felt like dang it. I was like there's still so many possibilities.

You know,

you build your tiles in this game. Yeah.

Yes. Yeah. Yeah. So, I I thought that was just so cool that there's so many choices in the first phase of the drafting, but then the polyominos when you put them into your garden board, if you don't use all the spaces in your tool, you just discard the ones that you don't use. And so, you don't have to have perfect fits. And that's another fantastic rule that makes it just feel less stressful. You still have to pay. There's still a cost, but it's not that ruin everything.

Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. I mean,

yeah. I mean, a game like this could have been hugely demoralizing. Um, you know, and and and granted for some players, they really want that. They want that game to be just cruel and brutal to them. I'm looking at you, Calico, specifically. Um, but um yeah, this one it's I mean, these days there is a very popular adjective for certain board games, cozy. um you know that they they they can they they are an interesting puzzle to solve. They are engaging. They're lovely produced, but they they're cozy. It's just nice and relaxed uh to to sit back and enjoy. And usually usually cozy means also lightweight gateway familyfriendly style game. That's generally what it's synonymous with. But this is a game that's pretty rare. I can only really think of one other game that is this cozy in that it gives you the flexibility and freedom to do your best no matter what and never feel like, oh, I'm ruined now. I'm trapped. There's nothing I can do. Um, but still giving you such a wonderfully crunchy puzzle to to gnaw on. The only one I can think of is from Oh, what is it now? It's from the uh publishers Bad Comet uh the undersea one. I can't think of it. It's about uh coral reefs and fish.

All I can think of is Aqua Garden and that is not the name of it, but it is excellent. And um yeah,

Gotcha.

You know what? I'm going to look that up cuz that's going to drive me crazy.

But I'll let you keep talking because I just wanted to shout out. I loved that game for that. And it's interesting. I recently played the expansion for that and it added back the tension of a game like Cascadia or Calico and I realized, oh,

I don't know if I wanted that tension. I thought it was kind of nice to have a break from just the, you know, teeth rattling um tension that you get in tight little Azul like packages like this.

Yeah. You know, I speaking of the tension and the kind of, you know, conflict that comes when someone goes in front of you their turn and then they take the thing you need and that was the only thing you need to make your points or like what your strategy is going towards. Um, I feel like, and I don't know if you were able to take a look at the fungal forager mini expansion that comes with the game,

but there are [clears throat] mushroom tiles that you can add into the game, and instead of flowers where you want the same kind of flower grouping um, adjacent to each other, you want mushrooms that are different, and they have a scale of a a one by itself is a two point. A second one um, that's nearby. I believe it has to be nearby. Let me double check. Mushroom jumpers are the same way. Um it says number of unique mushroom tiles you have in your garden. Oh, so maybe just anywhere. They just want to be anywhere. So maybe it's even more flexible. But the second one you get is five points. And then the third different kind you get is nine. So that really like you want the you want that final one. It's worth four more points. Um, but since there are only three types and there are only 12 tiles, I can imagine these mushrooms getting lost in the bag because there are so many tiles in the bag

because they don't come out or if one does come out, the person in front of you snatches it. And so I'm feeling like the mushrooms are really cool, but at the same time maybe creates the conflict of the scarcity that I that I am not missing in the base game. scarcity. You know what this is? This is a post scarcity tile air. That's what this game is. Um because yeah, you are always have a rich and bountiful selection of choices. And I think that's really what stands out. And the other game I was thinking of is Shallow Seas. um which is another excellent beautiful little tile layer that you know follows in the footsteps of Azul which has basically spawned an entire genre of game now of which you know uh perennials is a particularly standout notion. Um I and I realized I mean I have always personally ever going all the way back to the beginning of my board game journey gosh it must be coming up on 20 years ago now when I fell hard in love with a gricola because it was so mean to me you know it was just so brutal and like oh I you know I overcoming this challenge makes me feel good about myself and I've always chased that in every game and that's one of the reasons I I mean calico is so brutal um but you know but I'm maybe I'm getting old maybe uh my gray hair is showing and I'm starting to appreciate, you know what, sometimes it's okay just to sit down and feel good about a wide variety of choices. It's interesting. This is something that Tom Vassel of the Dice Tower has always gone on about that he

uh personally finds it frustrating to um be boxed into a corner. I've always thought, "Oh yeah, those are when the game is its most exciting. How will I get myself out of this?" Especially if I put myself in that corner with my own choices. But, you know, a game like this in a game like Shalliz makes me think, well, no, there there's something to be said for cozy. At least crunchy cozy, which I don't think is that common these days, but maybe that's going to be something we see more of because yeah, that really hits a sweet spot for me and my wife, Jen.

Yeah, I agree. I feel like this is Yeah. crunchy cozy because I've played a lot of cozy games lately. There have been a lot of available um you know games that for you know purchase and I've tried them and I've played them and they're really easy and casual but this has the crunch. has that puzzle to it where yes, I am competing with the people I'm playing with, but at the same time, I have my own thing to worry about. And yeah, having two puzzles when I played two players with the run through, it was splitting my brain a little bit. And I was I was like, "Oh boy, I feel like maybe I did disservice to my Louis character, but I was trying a couple things." But yeah, it's it's just a nice thing to kind of dive into. And it's the kind of game, like I said, I just want to come back to I want to do it again. I want to like, oh, I did this before. I tried that there. I want to flip over my board. The thing that they've built into the game is that every single board is double-sided. And they have different placement, so you're not playing the exact same configuration of your seeds that activate whenever you place the same flower on top of it and it goes into your seed bowl. And so, yeah, I'm like, this is great. This is something I can just keep coming back to. Uh, especially with the goals. The goals kind of just

do another step up. kind of elevates it a little bit more with like more points and more strategy, but it still has the cozy feel.

Yeah. Yeah. I I think it was smarter them, too. I mean, I think if I recall, I believe there are 27 cards, you know, of the three different categories, I believe. Could be wrong about that, but that the rules say, "Hey, uh, if you want, you can just have one or two or three." Um, and I I think that's a smart idea, too. I mean, I think it's something Flatout is known for that you don't see a lot. Hey, okay, here's our game. We are clearly game geeks. we've made this for ourselves, but let's not limit the potential of this game to only hardcore game geeks who, you know, want to have a cozy experience or whatever. Um, the prototypes we've got, the rule book I have actually has a whole page devoted to family rules that are going to take what you and I showed and simplified and streamline it down so that you could play this with anybody as their introductory go-to game. I don't know how they work. I'm sure on the crowdfunding page that information will be available. And I personally don't need it, but I love that it's there because man, this would be a game. You know, I've used Cascadia now several times as a gateway game, and I've always felt this is not the best use. This is not the best gateway game out there.

It's it's so compelling, but it's a big hurdle for somebody who's only ever heard of Monopoly.

This is perfect. Um, and I think really well realized. So it has another utility I think on my shelf as well.

Yeah. And it just kind of reminds me of you know the the patchworks the kind of flower power kind of like you just it's just oh I grabbed this guy but of course there's the new innovative polyomino you know getting and then breaking apart which I really really enjoy. And they've balanced it out perfectly where they say no more than three seed tokens and no more than three tiles left over at the end of the round. So, it forces you to play and to get more things and to really kind of like maximize your turn. And it's all simultaneous. It couldn't be smarter. I mean, that second thing is when you're playing, you don't have to wait for anybody. You're just sitting there going. You're just you're just like doing the muttering under your breath kind of thing. And then if I do this and you're just doing this and it's just so delightful. It's so like rewarding.

Personally,

you are right. That is another thing that's a real strength of this game. Um, is the fact that you have a hard limit. You cannot carry over more than three seeds, more than three tiles, which means this game actively encourages you not to hoard, which is I, you know, a certain a behavior I see in my wife all the time that will definitely contribute to her analysis paralysis. Dare I use this bonus tile now? I regret it. Three turns from now when I need it even more. You know what? Three turns from now, you will have thrown them away if you don't use it now. And I think that's another strength to this game. um that you know on the surface it seems like oh that makes it harder that boxes you in more but no it gives you the excuse to play more loose because um you know effectively use it or lose it now and I think that's another strength of this game it's actually probably the biggest strength of shallow seas the other game I mentioned um so I just got to say again Emily wherever you are

very impressive and uh yeah flat out just

oh I totally agree

you know

yeah it is incredible how flat out just does this year after year, you know, produces these wonderful just perfectly tuned little

joyous masterpieces.

Yeah, I know. It's like they're they're they've got this fantastic um solo designer

four flat out and then so it goes to one and almost to four or five, it depends. But they're all 30 to 45 minutes, same box size, same quality. And yeah, I'm like these designers are just like knocking it out of the park.

Yeah, they've got a good formula and they know how to do it. Um Yeah.

And so yeah,

long story short, folks, I I it sounds like both Kimberly and I agree. This is fantastic. Um is it my favorite? Does it eclipse Cascadia and Calico? I'm not sure about that. But I do think ultimately this is one like um a knitting circle before it that you know I don't have much shelf space. I I I have seen your place Kimberly. You have so much more shelf space than me. Here in Ireland I do not have much. I feel like I'm going to have to make room for this game on my shelf. Uh because I I do think it's a keeper and I can see its definite value. Um yeah, it's just it's so smart. So smart. So, I totally hear you. And even though I do have way more space than you, Richard, I am having the problem of like my collection and like where I can keep it and put it and we've been working this summer really hard to kind of call our collection and keep [clears throat] the games that we want.

And I have a really nice flatout game shelf and they're all there. And I really do enjoy having a collection like that. And I know for a fact, we talked about this. I know that this one is going to come out more and more and more because it just gets away from that scarcity and just gives you the joy of

just puzzling out your own game and playing it and it's so sharable like you say it is so easy to get into and to kind of like access like you think yeah

new gamers here we go let's play this

um and it's not necessarily like some of the other uh labels or other titles so for me I I am going to say right now perennial is joining my collection. Um, and I'm just looking forward to playing more of it. Yeah, sharing it with more folks.

It will become a perennial favorite, one might say.

Oh, look at that. But

I apologize. That That was a That was unfortunate. That was a bad way to end it, but this is where we're ending it on a really bad dad joke. Um, all right. So, if you have any if you have anything more to say in closing, otherwise uh we will tell folks that there are links down the show notes if you want to go check out the crowdfunding page. And otherwise, have a nice day. Talk to you so long. Goodbye. But I'll let you sign off with the final thoughts.

Oh gosh, you did great. What do you mean? This was fantastic. Good to talk to you. And yeah, go and check out all of our notes uh and uh perennial.

All right,

we'll see you later.

Bye-bye.

Bye-bye.

Progress saved