Can We Trust Xbox?
Transcript
can we trust Xbox? let me start off by showing you this when Tango wants to go do Hi-Fi when everybody probably thought they were doing evil ithin three um I want to give the teams the creative platform to go and push their ability push their aspirations Xbox closes down Tango Gameworks a year after the release of HiFi rush in terms of our commitment to the game absolutely the team at Arcane is on taking the near-term feedback we're still working on the 60 frames per second uh we have a good timeline for that we we're we're committed to getting that done and we're going to continue to to work the game I think we've we've shown a commitment to games Xbox closes Arcane Austin and redfall development stops Matt booty after a town hall meeting the day after closing Tango Gameworks we need smaller games that give us Prestige and awards hi-fi Rush had over 3 million players was nominated for a number of Game Awards and one BAFTAS praising its art direction and music after the release of hi-fi Rush Aaron Greenberg the VP of marketing at Xbox had this to say hi-fi Rush was a breakout hit for us and our players in all key measurements and expectations we couldn't be happier with what the team at Tango Gameworks delivered with this surprise release back in 2016 Xbox closed Lionhead Studios after a failed push into live service and vowed to learn from its mistakes we acquired Lionhead in 2006 shut it down in 2016 a couple years later we reflected back on that experience what did we learn how do we not repeat
our same mistakes you acquire a studio for what they're great at now and your job is to help them accelerate how they do what they do not them accelerate what you do a lesson that Xbox did not seem to learn lion head and Arcane Austin's Journey were very similar a game Studio acquired by Xbox thrust into a live service Direction a studio known for a particular genre was unhappy with the switch to life service and therefore struggled was left to its own devices despite push back from the troubled company and suffered the same fate of closure despite Xbox vowing to not repeat it same mistakes with Lionhead Studios they walked that same path again just a few years later with Arcane Austin as you can see this is not the first time that Xbox has said one thing and then their actions discredit any previous statements the cycle is repeating itself and looks like it may continue with many mentioning that as much as it pains me to say it if hellBlade 2 does not perform well then Ninja Theory may be the next on the chopping block a pretty heavy intro I know but one that sets the stage in what we are looking into today and the news that has hit the gaming industry but before that I'd like to say a quick thanks to today's video sponsor one thing I do love is being able to play games anywhere anytime and something that helps great with that is today's sponsor awesun remote desktop and it's fantastic game mode allowing me to play games like no rest for the Wicked at any time remote controlling my PC from my phone awesun just needs to be installed on both devices log into the same account add your device to the
device list and you're good to go for a remote control awesun remote desktop is available on iOS Android and Windows with links in description awesun remote desktop is available in three tiers with the free tier you can connect to your PC from your mobile device allowing you to remote control and even transfer files with me working in it this is very helpful if you forget to do something on your PC and need quick reliable access the pro tier allows for Android phone support and CMD for more experienced PC users and the game tier allows you to play games remotely with an adjustable virtual keyboard supporting up to 144 frames per second to allow for gaming anywhere anytime awesun remote desktop also sells smart plugs that allow you to power on your PC remotely with one click and safely power off when you're done for fast easy access and you can try awesun remote desktop now to see if it's for you click the link in the description and use this code for a 7-Day trial of the game tier be quick though as this only works for the first 200 and if you enjoy it aweSun remote desktop is having a sale with game and pro tiers 40% off awesun remote desktop is a quick and easy way to play games remotely and thanks to awesun for sponsoring this video now the games industry has been hit with some pretty heavy news four Studios have been closed by Xbox these studios are Arcane Austin Tango Gameworks Alpha Dog Studios and roundhouse games Austin known for Dishonored prey and redfall Tango Gameworks known for the evil withhin ghost wire Tokyo and hi-fi Rush Alpha Dog Studios a mobile developer and a step in Microsoft's mobile dev
Ambitions and roundhouse games formerly human head Studios who had assisted XBox with a number of releases so in an email sent out by Matt booty outlined the studio closures with three of the four Studios closing and roundhouse being absorbed to zenimax online Studios the developers of elder Scrolls online with this email quote today I'm sharing changes we are making to our Bethesda and zenimax teams these changes are grounded in prioritizing high impact titles and further investing in bethesda's portfolio of Blockbuster Games and beloved worlds which you have nurtured I'm not even going to continue reading this this is just to justify the closures of these Studios so pretty much this sucks and it sparked a lot of outrage online and rightfully so as some of these decisions just don't make a whole lot of sense Xboxs Phil Spencer and other industry heads have made a number of statements last year and the few years before but these sudden Studio closures discredit everything they have been saying making it very hard to trust the Xbox brand let's take a look at the situation with redfall and Arcane Austin to get a better picture we need to rewind back to when redfall released last year during game previews red fall did not look so great facing a number of delays it was apparent that this game was not ready and was certainly not the big game of the year Contender it was being being made out to be so redfall releases and it was bad there's no denying it it was a bad game but so bad and unfinished that there obviously was a bigger picture on why it was released in the state but despite it releasing in this bad State Phil took
it on the chin and even showed up on the kind of funny xcast days after the release of redfall and its crippling Critic reviews Phil Spencer at that time seemed very real a change of pace compared to the usual corporate responses we see from a lot of other game companies Phil seem like he was hurting and committed to Red Fall's future development however that redall support that was promised never happened but how did redfall end up like this there was something more to what happened at arcane Austin but thanks to Jason shrier report at Bloomberg we learned more of the situation at Arcane Austin and the situation around redfall Xbox had purchased the studio in 2021 as part of the zenimax acquisition Arcane Austin was already in a bad state with parent company zenimax wanting to shift the studio into a monetized direction and capitalize on the games as a service Trend quoting Jason's Bloomberg article the acquisition gave some staff at Arcane hope that Microsoft might cancel redfall or better yet let them reboot it as a single player game instead Microsoft maintained a hands-off approach Microsofts Spencer would later say in the kind of funny interview that Xbox didn't do a good job early in engaging Arcane Austin so Arcane Austin was already struggling in development doing a game they did not want to do and outside of the expertise Xbox did not do anything and left Arcane Austin in its already broken demoralized state but a similar situation also took place back in 2016 lion head Studios were shut down during the troubled development of the next Fable as they were pushed in a live service Direction unfamiliar to the
company that they weren't comfortable with as RPGs were not a big enough genre according to Xbox and then when this live service push did not work they shut this company down and within that same time period of releases Skyrim went on to sell over 65 million copies and The Witcher 3 went on to sell over 50 million two games in the single player RPG genre the Xbox deemed as not big enough as quoted and covered by Eurogamer it was Microsoft's idea in around 2012 6 years after it had bought the once independent Studio to shift from the single player RPGs it was known for to a free-to-play live service multiplayer game in Fable Legends lion head Simon Carter told EURo gamer but in a now too familiar story story it and its genre was seen by Microsoft as just not profitable enough this happened with Lionhead and Xbox to not repeat these mistakes but the same situation happened with Arcane Austin but what was it for they weren't making a game focused on the player they weren't making a game that the studio even wanted to make it was not an expensive RPG experience or an immersive Sim none of this was the goal the sole purpose was to make Xbox more money another blow that makes no sense is the closing of Tango GameWorks Tango Gameworks was doing well they released a new IP with over 3 million players not massive numbers but still a great amount as well as critical praise and winning multiple Awards and as previously mentioned hi-fi Rush hit all key measurements and expectations for Xbox on release so if considered a success why the studio
closure and to make matters worse a day after during a town hall meeting at Xbox Matt Booty said we need smaller games that give us Prestige and awards where could they find a smaller game a game that wins Awards a game that gets Prestige as a fresh new IP another puzzling thing is Xbox has always wanted a bigger presence in the Japan gaming Market Tango Gameworks was the first step in this direction a Phil Spencer quote I've talked for a long time about our desire to have more of a first party presence in Japan this is a great step there after acquiring Tango Gameworks back in 2021 Xbox has always struggled in the Japan gaming Market but in the past few years had been putting in a lot of effort working with developers and seeing Japan developed games such as like a dragon Persona and the Tales series all coming to Game Pass the closure of Tango Gameworks is the complete opposite of all the work they have been doing with no Japan first party Studios they are now back to square one and now no Japan developer is going to go near the Xbox brand after seeing what happened to tango Gameworks as an example of what happens to a studio out of fear that there may be next on The Chopping Block many people people may attribute the leaving of Tango gamework founder Shinji Mikami as damaging the studio morale but what people may be unaware of is Shinji Mikami has had a hands-off role in the studio for quite some time Mikami was known for wanting to give younger talented devs more of the spotlight in this case with John Johannes who served as game director on The Evil Within 2 and then hi-fi Rush another statement that came from
the town hall meeting after the closures Arcane Austin and Tango were both looking to hire more employees as they pitch new games which is the main factor as to why they were shut down if a studio is seemingly punished for going outside the creative Zone other Xbox studios are going to take a lot less risk for fear of what will happen to them if they don't meet the mark and what's worse several people across the Xbox division have been told that more cuts are coming so all this paints a very Grim picture for the Xbox audience the inability to trust anything Xbox says for fear they may do a complete U-turn in the next 6 months it's a grim future for the developers under the Xbox umbrella such as obsidian machine games and Ninja Theory what makes me very nervous is ninja Theory's latest game hellblade 2 is about to release these Studio closures have come about after a title has come out and as the studio looks to move on to the next project these developers will be working in fear the fear of one wrong move or in Tango gamework case a seemingly good move they could spell the end of the studio and it's a grim picture for gaming as a whole where pushing the creative Ambitions and pursuing our ideas seem to be punished and stifling the Creative Energy that we need so desperately in the gaming landscape it is a tough time for Xbox and gaming as a whole but let's hope this doesn't last but as history has shown the next big closure might be right around the corner you acquire a studio for what they're great at now and your job is to help them accelerate how they do what they do not them accelerate what you do Do you trust Xbox?