Arkham Horror - The Rear View
Transcript
this video is brought to you by board game prices calm find the best prices for board games at board game prices calm kyouda and welcome to the rear view on a Kimura this is a new and very irregular video segment that I'll be doing about games that are out of print or no longer available for some reason but a games that I feel like discussing at length because of their significance to me or their significance to gaming in general so all this video is is a detailed look at the legacy of Arkham Horror from its original version back in 1987 all the way through to the latest edition and as part of the series I want to talk to the designers and both of the games their thought processes behind them and how they think the legacy of the game has held up so to this end I reached out to Richard Lewis designer of first edition Kevin Wilson designer of second edition and Nicky Valens designer of third edition and got their comments for this video so sit back and enjoy the ride when most people think of Arkham Horror they think of the 2005 edition in fact I recall a lot of people being surprised that the new a Kimura was third edition because they assumes a 2005 was the first edition but it wasn't the first edition came out in 1987 and it was one of the very first cooperative board games that alone makes it a significant game in the history of board gaming so
let's take a look at the original board and you'll see that the town isn't actually that different fundamentally there's still the same areas that you could go to in this game that you couldn't see can edition or even third edition the Curiosity Shop Hibbs Roadhouse all of those locations that are now so familiar but also above the board are the outer world locations which was kept for second edition and changed for third the doom track is there and that gets carried across into second edition as well but one of the big differences in this game is it wasn't encounter cards they were role encounters for each location so across the top of the board you'll see their encounters for the different other worlds and on this page you'll see some of the encounters for the other locations that you'd roll to d6 on and it will cut through the characters and you'll see that they've got health and sanity they've got skills and a lot of these characters are still popping up in the Arkham files and that's something I really quite like I believe Ginny Barnes in particular has been in every iteration of the game and all of the Arkham files games and most of the others have been and almost all of them now my personal experience with the original Arkham Horrors kind of limited a friend of mine had it or I saw it at a convention way back in the in the early 90s and I don't actually know if I played it I don't think I did I think I took it apart had to look at it read the rules and played around a bit a bit but I don't think I actually sat down and played a full game of it so most of what I know about the game is from hearsay or from reading other people's accounts of the game but that doesn't mean it hasn't had an impact on me because without this game there is no second edition there is no third edition and it's probably no mansions of madness or any of the others I asked Richard lore Gnaeus what is driving force to make the original
Arkham Horror game was and what was his overall vision for the game here's his response we just moved to Rochester New York and we had two small children and my wife working evening shift and I was working day shift and taking care of the children at night having paid the call of cthulhu RPG I decided to spend my time after the kids went to bed designing a board game in the Lovecraft universe that could be played solitaire or what burner out of that idea came Arkham Horror the original vision for the game was more pulp than mythos but with the investigators running around town fighting monsters having encounters and jumping through gates my focus was on story and adventurous fun and what was ultimately created and published by our exceeded my initial vision I also asked Richard if he could go back in time and change one thing what would it be and his reply was there are many things that could have been changed in the original game but I think the single thing I would have added would have been the addition of a single unique skill for each investigator I added this in the revision and Kevin Wilson took them even further but just a unique skill associated to investigate his profession would have been a really nice thematic bonus in the original game so was Arkham Horror before its time was the world not quite ready for cooperative gaming at this point it's probably true like cooperative gaming just wasn't a thing in the 80s it wasn't a thing in the 90s and really wasn't a thing until the 2000s the interesting thing about this game is it wasn't a massive hit it did quite solidly but it wasn't one of those games it was an evergreen it was in stores constantly feed decades and decades it wasn't a Settlers of Catan as what I'm trying to say and while Richard never really abandoned the project it
did sit 18 years between different editions but 18 years between editions of the game there's a hell of a long time but Richard have been thinking about what to do and Fantasy Flight Games were interested in making you knew dition and that would become the Edition that I'm most familiar with second edition ass Richard what inputs he's had to later additions and he said I had already redesigned the game from the first edition so I'd already addressed additional skills adding an ancient one to battle at the end of the game and many other small things but what was fortunate was that Kevin shared many of his ideas of me and included me in the second edition development the same is true of many of the expansions and Corey had also come to me to play about eldritch aura and Arkham Horror 3rd edition when they were in the early design stages I've also been able to place this many of the beta editions and provide feedback I think every now and then I have provided something of value but the simple truth is of the folks at work the Fantasy Flight Games are brilliant designers and do a great job it has certainly been my pleasure to work with Kevin Koury and Nicki to whatever level possible to make great games in the Arkham Horror line I find this really fascinating that Richard stayed involved in the line not necessarily as a designer but as a contributor as a consultant as a tester it's like being the elder statesman of the Arkham files and it pleases me that he's been kept from the loop and kept involved I think that's really nice of the designers and the companies involved to keep Richard involved get his
insights and get his input into what would become the Arkham file games now picking up the designer hat for second edition was Kevin Wilson now Kevin was one of the designers in Fantasy Flight Games when the company really took off and some of those designs from that period are classics that have really shaped how Fantasy Flight Games has gone Kevin since left Fantasy Flight Games and is living the life of a freelance designer I reached out to Kevin and asked him what he thought when he found out he would be redesigning our Kimora and what went through his mind at the time and he replied I was pretty pleased about it I ran into Richard at origins and given him my business card after playing his return to Arkham oversize prototype there it seemed like a pretty good fit for Fantasy Flight Games since we were already doing the Call of Cthulhu CCG then I also asked him what his overall vision for second edition was Kevin said mostly my thoughts were how to modernize some of the mechanics and how to build more replayability into the game rich and I also have thought to use the great old ones as game modifiers so that a game against Cthulhu was different from a game against an earlier hearth end I also asked him what single change to the second edition was he most proud of and he replied probably the change to the great old ones previously they were just in the monster Cup but in second edition there were a much bigger deal and we got a ton of mileage out of having them affect the whole game I also asked him if he could call himself from 2005 and suggest one change of the game what would it be he replied I would probably suggest a change to spells they were never quite as useful as I would have liked since the sanest eCos was ultimately so high and to reply to given that's one of my partner's favorite character is Daisy
because she pays less for spells Stephenie absolutely loves Daisy I also asked Richard what he thought was the best single change to the second edition and he replied in the second edition that would be the addition of the ancient one that has a slumber fixture in play and then maybe battled at the end and it's interesting that the two of them are quite lined up here that brings us to what happened with second edition and it blew up it became a really big popular game a huge seller and brought co-op games to the foreground there are 44,000 copies registered on BoardGameGeek at the moment and we know that's just a small section of the actual number of copies in existence they ended up publishing eight expansions for this game which is massive the game has to be selling consistently for a very long time to get eight reasonable sized expansions four of those with big box expansions - at this time I'd like to have a shout out to Tibbs who ran something called Arkham stats where people could log and record games and he tracked well over 10,000 games of Arkham Horror with the investigators who they were fighting how it was won all that data and that's all available online so if you ever want to pick up your game and go we want to challenge licks let's take the hardest great old ones and let's try to win it the hardest way possible you can actually jump on there have a good look around at the data and pick out those insights to shape the game the way you want it to be now my personal story of a Kimura is quite interesting and quite personal because 2005 when Arkham Horror came out was about the same time I got very very sick so I had something called pericarditis and my car Titus and that's
a virus that attacks the heart and I was unable to work for about 18 months and I had flu-like symptoms and had to bounce in and out of hospital I was living alone in a boarding house arrangement where I basically had a room that was big enough to have a table in it and it it and no internet or anything like that I come was the only solo bull board game I had at that time I left at semi-permanently set up on my table for that 18-month period and sometimes I'd play two to three games a day because I couldn't leave the house and I couldn't really do much else so getting up from bed pottery gather to the table and playing a solo board game for a while to occupy my mind was one of the few things I could do so if anyone says the games got no replayability you can have a fight with me about that now Arkham Horror hasn't been everyone's cup of tea a lot of people have derided it for being too complex too fiddly taking too long to play and I can understand some of those arguments I have played it with people who have taken an exceptionally long time to play it also play of eight people does sound like torture to me I think the ideal amount is four to five characters and not four or five players but four to five characters so here we have our Kimora selling like gangbusters reaches a natural conclusion of its life cycle with the Miskatonic horror expansion which is one of my favorite expansions ever published for any game because it doesn't really introduce any new ideas any new concepts it's just more stuff but all the previous expansions and it's a great way to cap off a game and say this game has done this is complete this
is how it's going to be from now on and that's one of those interesting things about board games is that people think when an expansion stop getting published that somehow the games did I come Horace still alive if you've got a copy of it you can still play it yeah it's hard to get these days but there's no reason you can't play it anyway the success of Arkham Horror led to the creation of the Arkham files now this video is about Arkham Horror primarily so we're not gonna dwell on these too long just sort of talk about them briefly but you had the original mansions of madness which was a dungeon crawler type game with someone playing a dungeon master type character with these expansive scenarios now I loved playing mansions of madness but I hated setting up mansions of madness but it's still a wonderful game I've still got my copy of it we haven't played it in quite a while but the big problem is when you're the keeper you have to set up all the cards and decide how different paths would go and that can take an awful lot of time there's also L decide which is the lightest of the games in the Arkham files basically Cthulhu Yahtzee with some character stuff built into it I've played Elder Sign to death on the app so it's not a game I own anymore but it's a game I have played north of 200 times just because a game veiled aside was the exact length of my bus trip into town but work probably still the best launch point into the archive files
games for someone caring for the outside it hasn't played games before because the dice manipulation system is really intuitive and very easy to understand for anyone who's play games like Yahtzee then we have eldritch ro which occupies a fascinating place as like an ahkam horror 2.5 edition or an Arkham Horror third edition world edition it's a curious one to place because a lot of ways it is a new edition of Arkham Horror but in some ways it isn't because it's not sitting Arkham but the fundamentals that make Arkham Horror what it is are still in eldritch are so it's it's like a side game elder child was also a stunning success possibly more so than Arkham Horror 2005 many people embrace the streamlining within the game and I believe this games also come to the natural end of its lifecycle with a whole bunch of expansions being published so eldritch Horrors now for all intensive purposes a complete game and if you owed all of it awesome you'll be able to play that till the end of time then we have the Arkham Ahura LCG which was an exceptionally ambitious game design idea a cooperative story-driven collectible card game and just saying what it is sort of gives you an idea of how much work would have had to go into this thing and I tell you what it's a great game like we've already played the first two pains but they were fantastic I've fallen behind buying the expansion packs because they're quite hard to get in New Zealand for a reasonable price but I'm looking to source from overseas the big box expansion and the next six-pack so we can do like a whole campaign at one time I kind of wish they sold it in a
big box instead of the way they do it with the distribution model with the six expansion packs it's just a pain to get hold of them and you forget which one you've got you have to order it it's just annoying but playing it at the table it is the closest thing I've played to a real RPG still using a board game system we've really got into our characters when we're playing this game and it was top-notch fun and finally mansions have banned a second edition which for me is a high bar on how you can take a pretty good game streamline it and make it an exceptional game I really like mansions abandoned second edition I love how the app integration works the removal of the keeper which was my single biggest problem with the game was the setup boom that's done you just pick up the app see things up and start rolling I think Mickey Valens did exceptional work with matches about a second addition and for me it's one of the best second additions I've ever played right up there with Arkham Horror a second addition funnily enough so that stunning success under about it made perfect sense that they pick nicky to lead the design of Arkham Horror 3rd edition so I asked Nikki looking back at the moment you first found out you'd be redesigning our Kimora what went through your mind and what were you feeling she replied elder child was the first project I worked on with Fantasy Flight Games when they told me what I would be working on on my very first day I was
pretty shocked I knew Eldridge would be a success at Arkham in many ways and I knew of Arkham's popularity I was surprised but happy they trusted a brand new employee with such an important project and as far as first projects go I think it did a pretty good job with it and after working on Eldridge and its expansions for a couple of years and also leading the design for mansions of badness I had a feeling I would be the person to design our chimera third edition if the company ever decided to do it so when I was asked I already had some idea of what I wanted to focus on with the new addition I then asked Nikki what her overall vision for the third edition was she replied the most important goal was to capture what players loved about second edition research indicated that the atmosphere and character stories were the most important aspects to the majority of players so that's where I focused most of my energy other goals of course included making the game more accessible than the previous editions and to bring some new life and modern design mentality to the project I also asked her from a game design perspective what single change to the third edition are you most proud of she replied rather than a single big change it is the many small changes that were all made with the same goal in mind accessibility I was able to reduce rules overhead and play a busy work considerably in a number of different areas of the game without losing mechanical depth things like skill sliders monster movement combat and other one exploration had deep and complex systems in second edition I feel I was able to capture the goals of those systems in
simple ways that frees the players to enjoy the game more instead of feeling that they're repeatedly needing to check the rules or move tokens around our kimura third edition has been polarizing it seems I think it's probably better for new players and people who haven't played second edition to get into it I definitely think it's more accessible and friendlier to a new crowd but conversely it's also very different for someone from a second edition back ground and those people who really love second addition could find third addition quite a different experience my defense of that is that there was no point third edition just being sick in addition we already have second edition we have second edition and eight expansions that game didn't need to exist so what Nicky did with creating third edition was create a game that needed to exist and perhaps it's unfair to judge a game with just a core box against a game without expansions well at least we know expansions are coming according to my sources who by the way I'm not the designers interviewed here in case anyone's wondering but Fantasy Flight Games are working on expansions for this game right now however the focus of this video was on Arkham Horror 2nd edition so let's dig into that game in the form of a long laborious unboxing video so this is how I stole Arkham Horror in three big boxes and one small box that I keep separate which I'll explain why later
everything from Arkham Horror is packed away in these boxes so X crack them open one at a time and have a look what's inside each one so the first thing in the box of course is the main board and we'll set that up and you might notice that this board is a bit darker than some versions you may have seen that's because it's one of the first printings and they change the brightness on the board and redesigned it slightly for later print runs underneath the board in the Box are these two small boxes which I'll get into later and all of these cards now need some good hand strength to pick up all these cards at once this is all of the core mythos encounter Otherworld and final battle cards in one spot there they are the other world encounter cards one of the things I really liked about the other world encounter cards was the scaling difficulties he had red yellow blue green in terms of the average difficulty of the encounters so you knew if you were going really Oh which was a place where you could only draw hidden yellow cards it was gonna be a lot harder than say saliano which was only blue or green cards and then there's the giant pile of core mythos cards now these are the mythos cards from the core game and the Miskatonic horror ones as well so mythos cards I would use in every game and mythos guys break down into three main groups headlines which is sort of one-off effects rumors which are ongoing horrible nasty things you really have to deal with and environments which change the game then there's a 9 in candidates for the nine core locations here it's just the core games and counters I'll talk about how I add expansions and later one of the clever things about these cards is that each card has three different encounters on it one for each
location in that neighborhood and just that idea reduce the number of cards you would have in the game by a third I think it's a really clever design idea but also allowed them to do things like create the inner sanctum which is a special location you can only go to if you're in the silver Twilight Lodge and have a silver Twilight Lodge membership and finally tucked away in that box are the gate markers each leading to a different Otherworld which leaves us with these two boxes I'll cover later and this is the inside of the second box and you'll see another small box in there this one has all of the character cards and the great old ones in it as well as the items skills and allies Dex all of the various rule books and rules pamphlets that have come aboard of the expansion's yeah there's a lot of them and finally at the bottom of the box are the three expansion boards which of course is the Dunwich horror board the king sport board and the Innsmouth border so let's look at some of the stuff in this box we've got the common item dig some of my favorite things in this like the elephant gun which was a super-powered gum that you had to pay money to reload at the Press Pass which was exceptionally powerful and gave you an extra clue when you got clues the athame which is a weapon that got better against people with magic immunity and magic resistance and of course the shotgun which would be the most traded item during an ancient one battle as you just load up the shotgun load up with clues and spend all your clothes or so there were shotgun shells then there's the unique items which are similar in some ways to the combat items but usually more powerful or more interesting the most famous of which is the elder sign which is a powerful item
that allowed you to seal a gate my favorite items and the stick are the masa directly in Pasig a which allows you to bring on the endgame early so you pass a check and use some of the ancient ones straight away which sometimes can be an exceptionally good strategy the gate box which allows you to return to Arkham from any other world so you jump into a safe place like saliano and pop out and close the gate to relia and finally joining the winning team which I've never managed to pull off because it requires you to sacrifice for allies at these four locations in which case the game stops being a cooperative game and becomes a traitor game where you are the only winner I'd never seen anyone pull this off in any game I've played the mission itself comes up very infrequently and it's really difficult to achieve but I love that it's in the game then we have spells which fall into three main categories which are defensive offensive and utility my favorite spells are find gate which is one that allows you to skip a turn in the outer worlds and come back earlier which dramatically improves your chances of winning by either closing or sealing gates sore spirits which is a zero sanity cost spell which allows people of high law to use their law instead of fight really good spell and our chemical process which is just a way to print money especially for Daisy and she doesn't have to pay them sanity cost then there's a plethora of skills in the core game the skills will at +1 speed +1 will but as the game expanded they got more varied and more interesting and then there are the kaleidoscope of available allies so they
recommend only playing with 11 allies but what we tended to do was play with all of them but when the Terra asks you to discard an LA we discarded two or three depending on how many allies were left so that if the Terra track got to ten most of the allies would be out of the deck but we just liked having them all in there and finally the small cards we've got the personal stories which are introduced quite late in the piece but will really neat part of the game is something we always play with now so each character had a pass or fail objective and if they passed they would get a substantive benefit and if they failed something terrible would happen just one of those little additions that just adds a bit to the game then we have the great old ones and boy either an awful lot of great old ones in this game here's probably the four easiest from the course set as a thought for example takes a long time to awaken with a doom track of 14 better be awakens you're all dead and yeag who honestly there's no point closing gates just shoot him in the face and we had the four hard ones from the original set including of course the iconic Cthulhu it was very much the hardest old one in the first set but as you had to find out as we go through the old ones got harder and harder as the game went on this is the first expansions old ones and should male became my go-to one for teaching new players how to play because it's difficulty wasn't that high but the effect of creating earthquakes was really neat and evocative a path seth agua and clucky are all towards the higher end of difficulty compared to the core games great old ones as well in the next expansion got real tricky ethic
naka is really difficult completely changes how you play the game a lot of the game you focus on closing and sealing gates a hack naka doesn't care about sealed gates they'll just burst through and I really liked how I hope it works every time you close the gate and do other things new end up getting these little brood tokens on you and if you get too many brood tokens you'll explode and die and yep still requires a heck of a lot of difficult management as you can only carry five clue tokens which is the exact number you need to seal again so you have to make it all all the way through the outer world to the end of the gate with out spinning clues if you want to spend clues to see legate then we got eighth grade old ones in the Innsmouth expansion including cuatro otis who has a unique dust dick which you slowly burn through during the game and gets progressively nastier nasty until it's pretty much just pointing a finger at people and destroying them and then on to the final all here including zyre who is exceptionally tough because this is a good chance he spawns two gates each turned grant egg off who's just going to awaken really early and he's very very hard to fight and no clue who that's a cool thing with his tentacles popping up and attacking people then we have the massive selection of characters from these games I'm gonna talk about each of these characters because there's 48 of them but what I will say is there's very few characters I don't enjoy playing in this game and some I really really like like Diana Stanley the redeemed cultist one of my favorite characters just because of their background and the fact that she starts with a silver Twilight membership then there's Daisy Walker who is my partner's absolute favorite
character and if we're picking characters she will always pick Daisy regardless of what game it is it doesn't matter if it's a Kimura second mansions you name it if Daisy's in it she'll plant and Rex murthy character who starts cursed and can't get rid of curses so in some of the game esther all sixes with everyone else is rolling fives but he's exceptionally powerful once you get his curse off him we have interesting characters that came out later in the game like tres Scarborough who broke the focus rules and used focus completely differently and finally Patrice Hathaway who is without a doubt the most broken character in this game if you play doc Amara second edition enough you'll know why Patrice is pretty broken and if you haven't played a Kimora second edition just know that she is exceptionally useful the special ability of being able to allow people to spend closed-off is just papers over the cracks in so many issues you'll have in the game next we come to the four small boxes that are full of a bunch of different pieces this one is where I keep all the character figures which is why I keep it separate because we use the same figures for matches of badness for the Arkham or LCG and for any other Arkham files games we're playing I actually went out and purchased all of the individual Arkham investigator figures when there are and what I've been doing is as mansions of andis brings out new characters I've been swapping out the old ones and painting up new ones so this photo has a mixture of my painted characters as well as the older characters from the Arkham investigators line the second box contains all of the core stuff you need
for every game so that's bags of clue tokens Health Saturday money sliders all that stuff that gets distributed at the start of the game and of course in that box at the sliders which are one of the things that's been maligned by this game but it's actually one of my favorite parts of it so if you don't know how sliders work you place them around your skill pairs like this so in this case this character would have one law and for luck and you have a focus step which at the start of the turn you're allowed to move these sliders that many spaces left or right so what it means is if this character's picked up a tome and wants to read it never requires a law check they can spin their focus and shift their law two spaces to the right make up some three law this too and for me that's a level of control and preparation and planning that I actually really enjoyed in this game this box also contains the player guides which just remind you of some core factors that change based on the plaque out and also on this box are the Herald's which are modifiers you can play to a game you can add the dark Pharaoh as an extra sort of pre great old one to supplement the old ones and they're also institutions and guides who can make the game easier to play so you can mix and match these to make the game slightly different each time you play then this box has all of the status markers and stuff in it so if we open this one up you'll see inside that things like the blessing tokens the retainers the injury cards I don't actually set these up at the start of the game I just keep them in their baggies until they're needed when someone gets a blessing I'll just reach in and grab the blessing bag and check it to them if no one gets a retainer or game there's no point having
the retainer cards set up there so they just stay that box until they're needed and then the Lua crook a threshold box now this box doesn't need to be open most of the time because it contains all of the tokens for the individual old ones Herald's and other things that they only appear in certain games so in one bag you've got the mask monsters and in other ones you've got eye hearts brood tokens and another one you've got the tokens for vast again there's no point setting the stuff up if you not using it in the particular game you're playing so that's why they stay in that small box and then finally the big box which has all the expansion stuff for them so each of these bags has all the mythos cards and counter cards and special cards from each of the expansions so for example if we crack open the dark Pharaoh you can see all the cards here and the reason I keep the expansion stuff separate like this will be explained in the next chapter also on this bag of the neat little gate holders I've got for the game as well as my Elder Sign tokens I got these don't come with the game this is optional extras but you know they're cool anyway and finally the monster Cup now I actually got this for a monster Cup it's a cheap Egyptian style vars but it's really cool and here are all the monsters from all of the games chucked into that one Cup so now that I've shown you what's in the game and how I store it let's talk about how I enjoy the game and the way that is is we set up the core board and we only play with one expansion at a time so we use the item
cards unique items and spell small the expansions and the characters but we only use the encounters methis cards from one expansion at a time so we set the core Encana decks and we shuffle in the encounter cards from that one particular expansion and we also set up two piles of mythos cards one for the expansion and one for the core and what I do is we draw alternating cards from the different piles and I use a subtle marker like the Cthulhu Wars Cthulhu to remind me what part I'm supposed to draw from next and the reason for keeping the expansions so separate and using this method which was introduced in the dark Pharaoh as the travelling exhibit model is that I found if you put all the expansions together the storages gets diluted dunnage might not have a gate open and a full game if you're playing with all the expansions put in but if you're playing with the Dunwich horror and just the core then that flavor of the Dulwich expansion really comes out same applies for all of the expansions and it just makes it more thematic and also a lot less to manage if you're only worrying about one expansions extra mechanics it's a lot easier to keep in your head it means you don't have to have all nine of the wrong sheets available at any given time so the main way we end up playing this game is either solo with three to four characters or with my partner Stephanie with us playing two characters each and also enjoy playing with my established group of friends which is a group of five and we plan total of five characters and I think those play accounts are about my favorites so one person with three to four characters two
people with four characters or four and five people playing characters we also always play with the final battle rules which makes for a harder final battle with the great old one but a more interesting one so that's always something we add in I asked each of the three designers that are they able to sit down to play any of the Arkham games what four investigators would they pick and which great old one would they choose to face down Richard responded Joe diamond Ginny Barnes sister Mary and Harvey Walters I'm very old-school actually very old now but I think about it and I love the story these characters create in each game and for an ancient one you cannot do than Cthulhu well though I like a lot of variety here when I play Kevin Wilson responded I like playing Wilson Richards the handyman or ashcan Pete myself I also think it's nice to have Kate wouldn't drop the scientist in the game beyond that surprised me on the investigators and honestly I like to play random investigators anyway so here we go Kevin I'm going to surprise you with an addition to your team of Kevin Wilson the board game designer and for a great old one Kevin picked gotten a TOA or alternatively the earlier ho temp and Nikki stake was many who following me on Twitter know that my favorite investigator is windy Adams to back her up I think I picked Daniel Reyes Lily chin and Agatha crane those four badass ladies can get the job done and done right even against a militant beings like yog-sothoth and if my life was on the line and I needed a team to win this game at any cost I'd pick I pick Daisy Walker because
Stephanie would play with me then but she's also the best spell caster in the game and can give you a lot of utility Mandy Thompson is a good all-rounder who's good at closing gates and if special ability is a lifesaver frequently Hank Sampson is probably the best street sweeper that keeping monsters off the streets because if he beats them it doesn't take any sanity loss and patrice as mentioned just papers up all the cracks in your team and I'm gonna choose an old one to take on to really challenge myself it'll be Zaher Zaher awful so what is the legacy of Arkham Horror cooperative gaming is now thing now is that a Kimura responsible is pandemic responsible are they both responsible probably but a Kimura was very much a trailblazer in that cooperative gaming space was definitely the game that got me into cooperative gaming I asked for three designers what they thought about the legacy of Arkham Horror Richard replied I think Arkham Horror was groundbreaking as a cooperative game and possibly even more valuable in making the story of the game more important than winning or losing I seldom attended convention when someone doesn't come up and share a story from one of their Arkham Horror games the scribing is as someone might describe an event in a movie or from a novel sometimes the event occurred more than ten years ago and they still have the good memory of it that is special kevin replied I think Arkham Horror was a significant part of the rising popularity of cooperative games which is appropriate since first
edition was one of if not the earliest co-op and that's a great thing since I love to play coops me I don't always want to play against my friends so coops make a really nice change of pace and Nikki replied in many ways they opened the gates for cooperative games they pushed in new directions in terms of both storytelling and player choices and helped to define what co-op players expect from games today and I think I agree with all of them here what made Arkham Horror special and it's legacy it's not that it's a cooperative puzzle or just a cooperative game but it's a cooperative game that creates moments that create stories it creates experiences and anecdotes so you can share for years and years little ones of miner the time that afraid of mine Tomas was playing and equipping Clues spawning down at the woods so he kept going to the woods and every time he went into the woods the Sheldon gang beat him up every single time five times he went to the woods in that game and got beaten up by the Sheldon gang and got a clue at the same time and then he would go to a hospital heal up and come back the next turn and so finally on the sixth turn they offered him a membership to the gang clearly this old guys not going away so welcome to the team partner and that's one story from dozens hundreds loads of anecdotes I have about this game from the moments of created with my friends the created with my partner and even the moments when I was playing solo although those are slightly less interesting to share and that brings us to the designers reflections on the games I asked him what was their fondest memory
of the game whether it was a development the fan interaction playtesting or anything else nicky replied at Arkham Knights in 2015 we ran a 16 player eldritch horror event called cycle of eternity we printed off a huge oversized board over 50 inches long and got 16 players all working together to save the world it was great seeing everyone working together and discussing their strategies we read their encounters and the mythos events allowed for all to hear adding our own dramatic flourishes it was a really spectacular event that I know they all enjoy and at the end someone got to go home with a huge game board kevin replied I think my fondest memories of the game are the long meetings that Richard and I had will be hashed out a ton of details and came up with dozens of ideas for how to make the game a reality we met several times and origins and had long lunch meetings that's where we first came up with a great old ones mechanic and when we planned out the various city expansions and how the boards would all link together through the train station very early on I had a list of cities we might visit dunnage Kingsport and ensberg and Richard replied it's hard to whittle it down to one thing as I have enjoyed all of it working with great designers at FFG running demos at dice tower con and various other conventions and every moment of designing the game and hand painting the original Arkham Horror boards and creating characters it has been a true joy in my life on so many levels I guess my overall fondest memory of the game has to be attending the Arkham Knights events and watching the crowd of people playing all the various Arkham
Horror files games and the fun they were having I experienced this to a lesser degree at conventions when I run the game but Arkham Knights as special as it is two days of all things Arkham by people that love the universe and one or more games in it and what are the future of the Arkham files where do we go from here as I mentioned Arkham Horror theater edition is getting expansions and may go through a long cycle of expansions as well but what about an outcome horror fourth edition some decade from now to finish off I ask Nicky Valens what advice she would give to a potential designer of fourth edition and she replied your heart and listen to the players but remember that you can't please everyone I know the work I did with third edition is admired by many and hated by others ultimately second or third editions remain different games with the same design goals but different executions a future fourth edition would likewise be both unique and similar to the editions that came before it thank you for taking the time to listen to this and I'd like to thank Richard Lewis Kevin Wilson and Mickey Valens for taking the time to respond to my queries hearing their insight into the game has been really important to me and it's quite humbling but as busy people they took the time to talk to me about this it's one of the great things about board games is the community aspect and that people are approachable when you ask hey you want to fill out this questionnaire for me so thank you all of you I really appreciated it this video is made possible by patreon here's a list of our backers for the channel at the moment so if you want to get involved in the channel and and help me decide where we're going and what we're going to
cover I just sign up on patreon even a dollar a month allows you access to our polls which determine what videos get made thank you for taking time to listen to this video omi and if you enjoyed this video like it subscribe to the channel and check out our patreon