Skip to main content
Loading video...

Alma Mater Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 18:03

hey everybody today i'm talking about alma mater which is a two to four player board game takes about 90 to 120 minutes to play um it's designed by a couple of my absolute favorite designers um julie and brassini um and it's published by edgar spiel now i think eckersfield do a fantastic job of balancing um great production values while still being really affordable um and if you if you probably noticed the artwork it might strike some resemblance to a game that came out a few years ago called coinbra which actually happens to be one of my absolute favorite games of all time uh this one is kind of counted touted as the uh sequel to that one or at least the next in the series of that one and obviously it shares the same designers and it shares the same artist as well that chris williams art really pops really bright and it's just a great kind of fit for these fresh new euro games so for all those reasons um our master was undoubtedly one of my most hotly anticipated games of the year um and obviously finally got it got to play it so um while obviously the the visual aspect of the game looks very very familiar to coinbra and the game is actually quite different um that one's a dice drafting game this one is a worker placement game um and like a lot of workplace games this one shares a lot of those kind of familiar tropes of that genre you know placing your um your workers down in this time in this term i think it's your your tutors um or whatever you want to call your staff and um you are collecting resources collecting money buying um or in this instance buying students buying new lecturers or to try and get points in lots of different ways

um the thing that's different about this game is the actual resources you're collecting is um has a bit of a a bit of a twist to a bit of an economic vibe to it because every player is going to have um obviously their own player color and with that player color they've got a kind of a their own style of textbook or their own color of textbook which is going to be your kind of your resources in the game as i mentioned and throughout the game you're kind of your prestige of your own textbook is going to fluctuate so some some rounds you might be the most the most lucrative textbooks and some you might be the you know the least and the importance of that is that all the things you're going to buy is going to um is going to count on what which textbooks you cash in to get those new students or to get those um to get those new tutors um so and the value or the way that kind of is dictated who's got the most um you know most lucrative textbooks it's based on this track i think it's called a um a research track and throughout the game you're going to be trying to climb that track um by almost having different criteria and i'm getting as high as you can which is going to determine the um the value of your textbooks um you can either climb up that track in different ways i said either by going up usually more than one space at a time which is i'm represented by this black cog where it might say you know cash in x amount of money or exhaust one of your workers or do something like that whereas if you go up the green track you can just go up one space and um not have to worry about paying that criteria um also you as i said you're going to be buying these um by me students which are going to be

added to your own player board almost like a tableau on engine building style way um and all those different students have different disciplines i think there's four different disciplines in the game you've got your kind of your medical ones you've got your law you've got your maths and i think you've got your arts and books kind of style theme as well and i said you're going to be caching in those different textbooks based on the current value so say for example the most lucrative students might say this is going to cost you know three books of of the first value and two books the next value two books of the other value and then maybe a dictionary and a dictionary is like almost like a wild resource um or more kind of powerful resource that isn't um tied to any particular player and then you can take those students added to your board and um that's going to kind of improve what you can do throughout the game additionally you are going to be taking these um lecturers um in that vein you're going to be cashing in certain or maybe three of one books again two of another book one of another book um and add another book um and you are going to basically assign them based on the first player who does that so say for example i was the first player to take one of those lecturers um i will cash in what i see fit um so i would maybe choose choose maybe the easiest resource that's available to me to be the most common one i cash in and so on and then i will obtain that lecture for the right throughout the game which is going to give me permanent powers based on books that i cash in going forward um which is going to give give me like a power and then from then on if anybody else wants that same lecture they're going to have to pay the exact same cost that i've paid um

minus the initial money i pay but obviously that works in my favor because i get to dictate the um you know the the resources that were paid in the first place which gives you a lot more flexibility and that's going to be pretty much the the vibe of the game you're also going to be trying to fulfill these different criteria based on these chancellors they might say they have certain kind of milestones you need to reach they might say reach certain point of the research track get a certain amount of these students and a certain amount of these students and if you do that you can take one of these um kind of fulfillment cards i don't know i can't remember the exact um terminology and then that kind of gives you either like an endgame bonus to work towards or another permanent power that you can use throughout the game which could be quite powerful um indeed and the the way the worker placement works is is quite tight i mean there's not a whole lot of spaces on the board obviously you've got your standard spaces which kind of gives you your money you've got ones that let you climb that track as i mentioned the ones that you collect the students the one that likes you to collect the lecturers um and and so on um and every time someone goes to a certain spot um or at least most of these spots the the tension of getting there is quite important because i said it's quite tight and additionally you only start the game with four of your workers and if someone goes to a spot and you also want to go to that spot you're going to have to cash in one more than the person's already there so if someone goes there and i also want to go that i'm gonna have to pay two workers and then it's gonna be three workers and so on and obviously you can't go to the same spot twice of your color so yeah the game is quite tight the turns go pretty quickly because again

you haven't got that many workers to place um in the first place um but the the another additional thing that really does um you know make the game i said unique because all the other stuff against probably sounds very very familiar is um your own player boards has this really cool um system where you are you can basically choose to place your own color books on your bookshelf which is on almost like a sliding scale um like uh almost like a market and the when you when you pay one coin for each book you place on your um bookshelf it's going to be assigned to a certain cost cost for other players to buy because when you go to a certain other spot you can buy books of other players based on those on those costs and the incentive is there for other players to go to those spots because it's a lot cheaper for people to buy books that way but obviously the money that you spend goes to the pair who's selling them so it has this almost like a somewhat of a closed economy obviously there's new ways to bring money into the game but that this kind of flow of money is quite interesting and just knowing to invest in your own books is important um knowing when to spend um you know money on other people's books but bearing in mind that you're giving them money to do more on their terms so yeah that's that real kind of um you know weighing up your options about how much you're going to spend on books how much you're going to give to other players and so on and additionally at the end of every round um that kind of scale of books you've invested in is going to slide down making things cheaper as well so you know if you just want to keep putting your books at the higher prices then um it's eventually going to become cheaper throughout the game um and that's going to be pretty much

how the game flows i think at the end of the game you're going to get points based on who's got the most valuable books um your kind of rows of students are going to be multiplied with each other you're going to get a point for each dictionary you have you're going to score points based on the different um different chancellors you've got and obviously end game kind of criteria and stuff based on the students you've drafted throughout the game and that's that's pretty much how the game works it's um the game is for a game that's fast and i mean the good i think there's six rounds in the game and i said you only get a few workers and sometimes you're spending two or three works at once in order to take an action so as you can probably imagine the games do all the turns go quite quickly and you can unlock more workers by reaching a certain amount of students or a certain amount of points on the board um but the game for me it felt it felt quite um a bit of a slog in order to get things going i mean you had to really um get or you know tunnel vision yourself and collecting a certain amount of books and stuff um money is extremely tight in the game at least from my experience and you know collecting that money is going to cost you a couple of workers at a time mostly and that's going to let you buy your books which is probably going to let you buy maybe one student a turn um if if you're lucky um also climbing that research track can be quite laborious as well i mean obviously you're i said again because your money is so tight and because your um your workers are so tight as well every time you climb up and you don't have to pay these costs it's pretty crippling i mean you're going to have to

um you know pretty much exhaust all your options at most times and as i said it's a very tight game you're never going to have a huge pool of resources um additionally to that your resource pool is based on how many students you have so if you only have a couple of students your your kind of storage space is going to be limited as well so there's quite i said it's quite a tight feeling game for something that flows quite quickly and meaningful decision-wise there is still quite a lot you have to think about obviously you want these you want the students you want to cater to your strategy you want the um to reach those milestones to get all these different chancellors which can get you quite a lot of points um obviously you want to bear in mind the resources you've got in order to climb those tracks um obviously you want to get be the first to get the um to get the lecturers and so on so there is a lot to think about and there is attention to get places faster because obviously you can be more flexible to get if you are the first to get there and um you know and do things that way um additionally the balance of the game i think is um is pretty good as well i think all the points are pretty proportionate depending on which kind of route you take um and so on um again mechanically very very smooth i mean i think player turns are pretty quick and the you know what things do is pretty obvious the only thing i would say is that a lot of the students um are all the symbology on the students because all the students are quite unique um you're gonna have to cross-reference the what the students do and what this what the um what the lecturers do to their rule book quite a lot because there's not a lot of consistent um symbology um

the the engine building aspect of the game is quite it is okay i mean obviously you're taking your income based on how many books you've got on your shelf you're getting money that way and so on but you also can get new students and new um what's new lectures which can increase your engine and give you more income at the end of each round um so there is somewhat of a progression but i would say i was somewhat disappointed at what the what the students actually do i mean some of the powers felt quite limp it didn't feel like there was something that was really powerful that you needed it was almost like just save up what you have and buy one that's um you know this fits the milestones that you need and so on so it wasn't i never really felt like there was something i really wanted to go towards it was pretty much just take what you can get which it doesn't always leave the best kind of almost satisfying gameplay time investment wise i think it was it was good i mean it wasn't again outstanding it's welcome and again times go turns go by pretty quickly but the whole feel of the game to me felt quite as i said it felt like a bit of a struggle it felt like i was kind of you know swimming through jelly kind of thing you know just very slowly getting your resources and buying something and that can be a turn and a half by the time you've done that or a round and a half by the time you've done that so it did feel like a bit of a slog um so yeah and in terms of replayability as well it's it's pretty good i mean you're not going to be using all the students each round you're not going to be using all the lectures each round scalability as well um that there is two sides of the board based on the player counts i think you've got a side of the board for four players and a side of the board for two or three

players which means that i think you get less work placement spaces based on the um on the lectures you're taking and so on the interaction on the game is quite interesting i mean particularly economic you know economically i said you you want your opponents to buy the books off you um but you want them to play kind of pay a fair price that you're getting money um that's proportionate to what they're getting um you know constantly putting your books uh or having your books at cheap prices gonna is gonna be a really good price to um you know for the other players to buy them at but additionally you're only investing them at one coin each and to put them on your bookshelf so you're always going to be getting a fair deal um back but again weighing up that decision on you know how much you're going to invest in your bookshelves is quite important and constantly having them full is while it's good because at the end of each round you're going to get a lot more income you're obviously giving more inviting options for the other players to buy your books and which is pretty much your currency to do everything in the game um aesthetically i think the game is absolutely stunning i love the way the game looks i think it's just such a fresh look i think the box art is fantastic that real kind of clean you know flat flat surface art it looks really great all the characters are very vibrant um the the artwork is reused on all the different kind of tiles so it would be nice to have kind of unique art for each type of um lecturer in each type of student but that's a bit of a nitpick yeah just lovely clean design great components and particularly the um the book resources they're really

nice plastic little books they look great they feel great i'm just nice bright and colorful aesthetic to the game which i really like and as i said at the beginning of the video um i think edgar schwab do a great job of balancing production and value and um this is just a perfect example of that so i really do like that i also really love the theme of the game i think it's a real unique approach to um you know to it to a theme you know being the headmaster for your own university is great getting the best students you know trading knowledge and you know getting the best lecturers i really like the theme i love the i love the general feel and aesthetic of the game i think it's really nicely done um progression of the game i said is is okay i mean as i said i would have liked the plat the the different abilities of the students and lecturers to be a lot more powerful than they were um it just felt like i was working towards something that was or took a long time to get there for very little payoff which was somewhat disappointing scalability is is okay as i said it's it is double-sided um additionally if you're playing with two players um there is going to be a dummy player in the game which is kind of this ultimate deck and it's going to kind of put workers out on the board automatically and put kind of books onto a shelf and stuff so there is going to be a bit more upkeep a bit more kind of um a bit more housekeeping if you're playing at two players um but it's not too big and it's pretty cleanly done to be honest um and comparison wise i mean as i said this game has so many similar tropes to a lot of other worker placement games um but that kind of economic thing is

is unique to this one and i do really like that and the fluctuating values of the resource as well which is what makes this game unique but yeah overall um it's this is a strange one because i think somewhat this is a victim of its own success i mean i i was so hyped for this game because again i've loved every other game that these designs have put together i mean they're amongst my absolute favorites this one left me somewhat disappointed because it didn't live up to those standards for me um not because it's a bad game it's certainly not a bad game but it just didn't feel like it had the bite this other games had it felt um very um very kind of mundane compared or kind of comparison to lots of other worker placement games that's out there it felt like a bit of a slog as i said nothing was really overly interesting to invest in um and it just felt like you were pulling teeth throughout a lot of the game now it might sound like it's being very negative but again it's because i'm holding this up to my expectations of the game they normally make extremely um you know extremely dynamic and fun and interesting games and this one just felt like a bit a bit vanilla i love the um the book system i think that's really cool and i would love to see that used in another another game system um up to kind of maximum optimization because it just it just didn't it just didn't work for me i mean i felt pretty uninterested by it i think the other players i played with felt a bit kind of meh on it it's just okay it's an absolutely fine game um i would play it again

if i had to i probably wouldn't recommend to play it again or suggest to play it again um because there's so many other games out there that's just better than this one um it's a massive shame because i was so looking forward to it um again i love coinbra i was like i was hoping this one would be up to that standard and have a new kind of series to look forward to every year but unfortunately um this one let me down which breaks my heart to say because i think this is the first game out of these designs i've not actually been hugely keen on um now again this isn't a negative review it still gets like you know a six out of ten for me or so but i'm expecting eights nines or tens for these designers so yeah a bit of a disappointment for me but you know if that economic feel to it does appeal to you um if you're looking for uh probably a medium weight worker placement game you know something that's a step on from your gateway levels games then this is something to look at um it's going to be nice and nice bright and appealing for um to get players interested a new interesting theme and some cool ideas as well but ultimately didn't come together in the way i'd like them to so that's alma mater it doesn't get my um sealer quality but um again not a bad game at all just not up to my um not didn't live up to my expectations so um this concludes my review of alma mater i hope you enjoyed it if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too uh for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved