Forbidden Stars Review - The Grand Space Opera Strategy
Transcript
each producer creates a good in a non gray world in the place Tableau it's like there's a magnet between these sentences each producer creates a good on a non gray world in the place do you know what this role for the Galaxy rule book is just as obnoxious as the race for the Galaxy one you do you know do you know the Grim dark future of the 41st millennium yeah do you know there's like only war in it yeah but they must have like pickles nope no girkins all right but they must have ballet no only War all right but they must they must have to go and Wei somewhere well I think actually Space Marines have a thing in buil in their armor where Conn from inside but what about Orcs they don't wear armor tough
forbidden stars is an odd game a little bit like that Uncle that you know who spent the last 20 years living in a seal Sentry trying to discover the intricacies of their mating habits but maybe odd is not the right word to use here no maybe like your uncle that has negative connotations maybe the word we're looking for really here is unusual cuz this game feels like it's from a bygone time when Twilight Imperium 3 used to roam through the desert and Android was the 7h hour romp that you wanted it to be and this is a long game and you see board games throughout time they've sort of condensed themselves and became crisper sweeter shorter two three hours is the perfect length this is not a 23 hour game in fact I think time seized existing when we were playing it and there was only War left yeah it's a long game but it's not overly complicated in fact we felt it was quite like a 4X game or at least 3/4 of a 4X game you haven't got the explore element because you can see everything from the beginning but you have got expand exploit and exterminate and there is a lot of extermination you will fight a lot of battles in this game and that is what makes it feel a little bit like a war game but at its heart at its core it really is a board game because you're still building your units you're still
building factories and cities and bastions and you are upgrading your uh combat cards and all this this ties into the grand scheme the grand plan that is forbidden stars like Len mentioned it is a simple game because at its heart all you're doing is you're issuing four different kinds of orders but it's the limitations that are inbuilt into those those orders that make it deep and complex and I know it's deep because when I played forbidden stars there was this moment where I resolved an order and thought Oh god there was so many other things I could have done and that's where I know that there is depth and decision making in the game and these orders are really really cool because the limitations really make you think about what you need to do so for example the deploy order where I can make make more space fish and put them on the space Bas or make more of these guys which are believe it or not called knobs um you know it sounds simple you spend some money and you put them down and voila Presto but actually it's not as simple as that because first of all you have to buy the spaceships uh units and then you have to buy the ground units and only then you can buy buildings but you can't put buildings on a space that doesn't have your units but you cannot put units on a space that has buildings and then you can only build units if you have a factory in the system and on and on and on it goes
right and you think oh my God there's a lot to it and yes there is but is it cool my God yes it is the depth doesn't just come from which order token you decide to play but also the order in which you want to play them cuz if I pop my order token down here and then my opponent the knob that he is puts one on top it's gone on the stack so my order token won't resolve until his does so you're trying to think about the order in which the tokens are going to resolve and what your opponent is doing and the last token that you might place might in fact resolve first and that can lead to a little bit of analysis paralysis because you might have This brilliant plan of exactly what you're going to do and exactly in which the order tokens are going to resolve and your opponent might just mess that up however all is not lost because if you've placed a token down that you really you you really can't use now because you know maybe you wanted to build something but you don't have enough material to build it anymore because of what what's happened in the round you can sacrifice whatever you were going to do and instead put your token on here and turn it into an event card which will resolve at the end of the round event cards are cool because not only do they smell grade but also they are specific to each faction and they will do onetime effects at the end of the round that will either trigger immediately or if it's a scheme card then you can save it and Trigger it at a specific time but the other thing that they do is they move the warp
storms and warp storms are these tokens that are placed on the board that effectively block movement because nobody wants to book a cruise on a fish ship to go to the warpstorm and that changes the entire layout of the battlefield because whilst the map stays static and the way it that it is movement no longer follows the same patterns and certainly a planet you thought you will be able to take next round is just no longer there which puts you in a bit of a predicament and forces you to rethink what you were doing fortunately it doesn't happen often enough and the lucky part is that every player gets to move one of these tokens but it does bring enough variance into the game to make it just a little bit less static and more Dynamic and exciting but that's not it the event cards aren't the only thing that's different for each faction the fact are asymmetrical so your units are all different your faction special abilities are different and your upgrade cards are different as well and the upgrade cards are pretty cool because um each faction has their own specific combat deck that comes with 10 cards and there's a sort of deck building element going on here and that's not to say that these cards are very basic like in Dominion where you just get like a victory point card no there's there's depth between choosing which one to play however you get another faction specific combat upgrade deck which is chalk full of awesome cards so you can swap them out from the basic deck and when you buy these
upgrades put the new babies in and they're they're really good they're very good all of them and we found that when we played the game they the units were very balanced as well the armors were really balanced so although the units are different they're all kind of on the same level so if you have a a orc knob fighting an elder Faith guard it feels balanced and this says wow that says wow that isn't even it's not a word yeah it is what does it mean it means charging into battle it's noobs they're charging into battle can you use it in the sentence um Bye Mom I'm off to the shops w we built this map specifically for the review and this is the scale of the map for a four player game but we actually never have played a four player game I'm not sure I want to because already with fre players the game takes so long and with three players it would look something like that the map would be just a little bit smaller and the same thing goes for a two-player game if you want to play a two-player game again you just take bits away and you have this and this feels very different to a free player game actually because it's more like a local Skirmish between two factions whereas a free player game feels like an actual Space Opera and possibly the free player game is best although the game really does scale very well I think there's just more Intrigue between free players
however I do have a caveat here a two-player game can take only up to 2 hours which is nice quick and Punchy whereas a free player game can really really expand that play time up to we played for seven seven is a long time and the reality of that is that you have to choose what's right for you because the game is awesome either way forbidden Stars has a really cool flow to it where for the first couple of rounds of the game everyone's just going to be building up they're going to get units they're going to get new upgrades they're going to get new buildings and it all seems pretty cool and like you're kind of planning what you're going to do the next round you're going to get even a cooler unit like this W KN things are going to be great but the thing is the game is played for objective points so determin on by the number of players you will try get certain number of objective points that are on your opponent's planets and eventually in about round three or so someone will see an opportunity and they're just uh they're just going to go for it they're just going to grab all their army put it on that planet and and they're going to go for it and after that it's like a domino effect it erupts into full global scale War it's like a global Turf War of some sort on a global scale I'd rather hear both sides of the tail see it's not just about races but places faces and so you might be having this massive Galactic
battle the biggest in the Galaxy with your Titans and your gargants and everything and you might think it's the most important battle in the Galaxy but you've got a lonely cultist here in an aspect Warrior and they're battling it out themselves uh for this planet here and if only the cultist can get the planet from this aspect Warrior that might just be a game Cher I'm not going to spend my life being a color come come sit down right next to me and I'll tell you all about combo because that is the most exciting part about forbidden stars and I'm not even joking yes we said there is a lot of combat in this game but my God have they worked on combat really really well it's not just chucking dice at each other and seeing who gets a better result and that's what makes this game so spectacular yes there are Dice and actually they're really really cool looking I don't know what it is about them but it's the color pattern I think for me that makes them I very urable I don't know I just want to eat them maybe not um but eventually you will resolve an advanced order many many a Time throughout the game that will create a conflict area and they can be either for ships or units but you can only resolve one conflict area per Advance order and once they do move in there you're going to tally up how many dice your units have and they are listed on your faction sheet right here and
there is a maximum of eight dice per side and yes there are exactly 16 in the Box in case you were wondering um and once you've done that you'll roll the dice you'll get some results and there are three different types of results the defense results will basically mean you get one defense and The Balter results will basically mean you get one attack and there's also another very very important symbol that is morale so um you have some initial combon strength that the dice determine but what's going to happen then is you're going to cheuck in reinforcement tokens if you want to and you're going to draw five cards from your combat deck and that's exactly half your combat deck and for three consecutive rounds of combat you will play one card secretly at a time and that card will not only add more results to the dice but also uh it has two different abilities one will trigger globally and the second one will only trigger if you have the specific unit listed and that means that when you upgrade these you can upgrade these with a specific unit build in mind so for example if you go for an army that just has a lot of these tiny aspect Warriors you can make that re Army really really good by simply buying combat upgrade cards that are suited for aspect Warriors and yeah actually a bunch of aspect Warriors could very easily take
out this gargon which is the best unit that the Orcs have because they have the right combat upgrades and oh the decision making is just wonderful because it's it's not just about who gets more attack or more def defends at the end of three rounds if there are still surviving units on both sides it's actually the morale that determines who the winner is and each unit has a morale value and the dice add morale and the cards add morale and you're simply trying to see who outlasted this combat best and did I mention reinforcement tokens yes there are reinforcement tokens and it's a really clever thing because then you're not just thinking about this particular combat because hey yeah you can blow your reinforcement tokens if you want to and you'll probably win then but if you don't save them up for the next fight that's likely just around the corner you you will you will lose that and here's the thing about combat and other reviewers have mentioned this right yes only two people at the same time can participate in a combat and if you are playing with more than two players yes there will be downtime for the other players who are not involved and in addition to that combat is probably one of the things that makes this game really really long a session of combat can last anywhere up to 10 or even 15 minutes and I can see that probably it will put some people off but and this is
I'm being completely honest to me I don't mind because I just found combat really really engaging to watch even if I wasn't participating because number one everything that happens in this game matters whether it's something you're doing or your opponent's doing and at times I found myself rooting for the underdog because you know someone in one of our games someone attacked a city and we thought hey if you move into a city don't you and that's one of the structures that are available in the game don't you just automatically overtake it no actually it creates a conflict area and you still have to fight it and the city doesn't get any dice to roll to begin with OR it doesn't have any hit points but you can spend reinforcement tokens to make those things into Warriors and then suddenly there is an actual fight going on and oh my God was that exciting because for a while there we really thought that the guy who just had no units on that planet and just just just a couple of reinforcement tokens was going to win and it's not unpredictability because you you can look at the board and you can go well I have these two Titans surely they're going to take down two cultists and chos Space Marine maybe but just like in Warhammer 40,000 it's not about how many units you've got it's about who has the most daa daa we couldn't do a review of forbidden Styles without talking about the artwork because it is just so nice I mean look at this combat card for the biker knobs you can almost smell and hear the planet
being torn up as he Roars into battle and on the faction sheets the artwork is taken directly from the Warhammer codex and on the back of them there's some story and background to for your factions as well and we haven't even talking about the minis yet look at this ship I mean really look at it look how nicely it's done for how small it is there's detail in the wings and you can see the mechanics of the engine of how the ship flies Okay so they could have just put in red yellow blue and green porns and be done with it but they didn't they made them so detailed and so nice to play with it's like they're just scaled down Warhammer Minis and for us that's just what we wanted to see I think the 80 uh retail price point might put some people off because that's the same price as Star Wars Armada and it's also the same price as a small tin of caviar but it has a lot more components in it than Star Wars Armada and it certainly has more replay value than a tin of caviar it doesn't have quite as many components in it as Twilight Imperium but Twilight Imperium is 9-year-old game uh and it's kept about the same price for the whole of its 9year life so for us I think we we feel that it is worth the 80 price point because they put so much effort into the art and the design and the making everything just work really really well together okay let's
talk about Rule books a little bit no no no wait wake up pay attention this is important right I know Rule books aren't very exciting but I think what Fantasy Flight games are doing here is exciting they're recent games have had two Rule books instead of one one that's a learn to play kind of thing that includes the main rules but amids the intricacies and all the intricacies are in the advanced rules and that's cool they're trying to get people to the table as soon as possible and playing the game and that's exciting I I like that someone's innovating on how these are written but I think they have to a way to go before they get it right unfortunately because one of the things that cropped up in our game he SE our game is that during the last round we decided to check hey wait a minute this this says that there are no tiebreakers in the learn to play and then it turns out that in the advanced rules there are tie Breakers and finding that out after 6 hours was painful for some people and kind of sour the evening and I wouldn't even be mentioning this but do you know what I think the reason I am is because now you know and now you don't have to make the same mistake I did when I decided not to keep my mouth shut and tell everyone hey actually no yeah there are tiebreakers and you're not going to win I am that was mean I'm sorry in the words of the ever wisdomous and Majestic R it is final for time everybody and OMG do I love forbidden Stars it is a grand Space Opera and that's exactly what I wanted this game to be it's so cool and every single inch of this box is filled with decisions decisions
decisions I love making decisions and it's just like do I do I spend my early turns just attacking everyone and trying to look out and grab the objective tokens but then if I don't succeed I've wasted all my turns doing that and not building up my Army whilst the others have you know all the combat upgrades or all the upgrades or both or maybe they haven't built up enough units what building am I going to get am I going to get two two is a lot it's really expensive can I afford to and then I won't be able to build units on those plans and it just keeps going and I'm just going to stop my man's playing now and let Ela talking hide behind this nepr playar as EA said there are a lot of decisions to be made in the game and I used to be indecisive but now I'm not so sure and for me when EA said about playing this game I thought I'm not going to like this a lot because uh the theme of it you know War Haram in space I mean really is that doesn't really appeal to me but then we started playing it and it was so good I just enjoyed every decision in that game so much and it was only about after 5 hours or something I was enjoying playing the game but I suddenly realized that I actually desperately wanted a win I wasn't just having a nice game on a Sunday afternoon I so wanted a win and I'd invested so much time and energy and effort into where I was placing things placing order tokens and ships and units and whatever and that for me was when I
really realized that I love this game it's hard to say just how balanced this this is because it's going to take the marvelous Community wisdom of board game gig to actually figure out whether a certain strategy is just more viable than the others and you know play testing this game for reviewing is is very timec consuming because it is incredibly long and that is going to possibly off-put some of you and you know who you are if you heard it say oh this takes about five or 6 hours and you don't like that you're not going to buy this game and you heard us say that there is downtime in analysis paralysis and if that's the deal breaker for you then you're not going to buy that game and that is completely fine but on our buy play or stay way scale which we know is ridiculous by the way for me definite buy yeah for me definite buy as well so we went to Birmingham UK games Expo a couple of weeks ago and some really really cool happened there you guys were coming to us and saying hello and that that really never happened to us and it was so nice to meet all of you except there was one person who I feel very sorry for because I was really busy and demoing a game and I think your name is Jonathan and I had to say I'm sorry I don't have time to talk right now and oh
my god do I still feel really bad about that so if you ever see me again just stop me and we'll have a chat because it was it was so cool to meet all of you and hi and we really love doing this so if if if you enjoyed this video you need to click the Subscribe button because we're we're building a board gaming Army here and it's going to be awesome