Skip to main content
Loading video...

Moon - Board Game Review - Rover Parking Simulator

Transcript 15:36

thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences so today thanks to a review copy from Sinister fish games I'm taking a look at the Moon this is the third in their stark white series whatever I'm going to call it they don't really have a name for the series but they're essentially games that come in this stark white box with this type of artwork first you had villagers which was a pretty decent hit then you had streets which didn't take off as well as villagers did villagers are still regarded as the better of the two and now we have Moon which is looking like to be the meteor of the free so certainly the one mainly for gamers shall we say so in terms of the game itself basically you have a space settlement that you're building and you draft cards with other players and with resources that you can gain from production buildings you will use these resources to play cards into your Tableau which will either produce more resources or give you Flags which are prerequisites for playing certain cards but also for scoring points at the end of a round the slight twist here is that amongst these cards you also have an expedition card which grants a special bonus to you for that turn only so when you get given a new set of cards you have a new bonus card that you can use that's like oh I could get a bonus resource or trade one for one or do some other like weird Shenanigans maybe score a point by doing this aspect and so you're thinking in that Terra no I don't want to use it or not but we'll see because once you decide you know once you've done your turn there goes the hand now you got a new card for you so

um play continues through three errors in this fashion you get new cards these structures that you play get more and more upgraded but on top of that you've also got these little Rover pieces that you can park on other people's cards in order to utilize the production bonuses or the flags that they have but the Rovers go to them in their supply when they're done and count for as a tiebreaker for scoring at the end of the round aside from that that's pretty much most of what the game has you continue for three euros and of course total up the most victory points of all your buildings and all your flags scoring and everything and all the hearts that you've gained from reputation cards and of course the one with the most of course so as you can see they've kept their usual style of boxes which I got to admit I'm not a big fan of these type of boxes they don't stack well on shelves but the biggest problem I have other than the fact that they do get dented rather easily is that this is the Box lid fully on at this point this is something that takes a lot of effort though because you take the lid off and you're left with all the pieces and the cards that look like they're nicely arranged and the rule book down the side because if you put it on top it just won't work then you try to get the box lid back on well that actually worked out well for that but most of the time you put it on and it catches on the rule book or it catches on something else and you're content like hang on a minute just that just that you know it you know you almost want to like take a hammer and chisel the way it sometimes in order to get it in because it's got a ridged sort of backing there you can see in the box that interferes with a lot of the contents I would have been happy with just a typical box size you know a small box of some description I just think

this whole rectangular thing with the lid is more trouble than it's worth but I say that's a nitpick and a personal thing it doesn't really detract from the game per se because honestly the component wise you know for the money that you're paying is pretty solid you get free you know cool little touch boxes here with the various pieces in the rovers are cool you know like wooden pieces screen printed pieces so they actually do look like mini little Rovers that are cool you've got the resource tokens are you know they're wooden they're thin but they're wooden and they're clear and they've got different denominations on each side so component Wise It's very nice the one component I really hate though is these Hearts I hate these hearts these are what I use to score victory points that aren't printed on cars and these are just fiddly as old get out because you have to place certain numbers on the flag scoring in order to do that at the end of the round and those numbers are plentiful in the first round but then the fours and the fives are barely in this box other than for those flags so you pretty much have to take them out in advance and hope no one's actually used them but even then you are constantly changing these things up because you've got one on one side then you've got a three on the other side of that and then you've got the fives then you've got fours that you shouldn't be using then you've got a 10 flip to 20 and you've got 100 flip to 50 it's and you're constantly just blending half your game ticking around with these hearts and I would have been totally satisfied with the point track you know if you've got a board you've got board in here that just literally shows the hearts for flag scoring and a couple of rules that are easy to remember I would have done away with this board and simply just had some

cards to represent the flag scoring and then made this a point track that you could have just had a little counter on or something just having Hearts all over the place does get a little bit fiddly and irritating now I know that you need to have some hearts in the game because some of the cards score each round based on how many hearts are on them fine have a small box of hearts for those but having hearts for just about every other bit of scoring in the game just gets a little bit annoying yeah but your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could they didn't start to think if they should these are little component nitpicks what is the game like to play the game itself pretty decent I mean if you're in one of if you like drafting you're already going to have a pretty good time and if you're someone like me that likes to do sort of combo building and you're thinking oh if I play this building that allows me to produce this which will let me produce that next time but I can't play this card yet are you likely to build it probably not it'll come back round then fine I'll take a chance and all of that is in the game in nice and juicy I also particularly like the Expedition cards now some clearly feel a little bit better than others it must be said where are the Expedition cards here they are yeah you get a decent amount in the box but other than the first player ones you do get some a decent variety of these to use in Era one two and three but there are some that are just always used and some that are very situational I mean you know getting a bonus resource and around you will use that every single time but getting rid of a resource for a heart or getting rid of a Rover for a heart I mean you'll use that now and again but you're not going to use that all the time but they'll go around all the players and it should be even turned so

it's not you know a massive deal but these are just quite a nice little twist on the whole drafting thing just being able to get a cool bonus every hand rather than just simply every round and having different ones in each era it's a nice little nice little twist and I do with like this inclusion a bit tricky with the cards though is that they've gone out of their way in order to make everything look quite spacey but sometimes you have white text on fairly light color backgrounds which makes it tricky to read the font is not particularly large in a lot of these cases you know they explain what the symbols do but the symbology is a dance like bigger than the text on the cards then the reputation cards particularly suffer from this aspect where you're trying to read like nine of these objective cards across the table with very small text on the bottom it's a little bit problematic given that this is not exactly a compact game yes it comes in a compact box but when you get all your settlements out and all the stuff in the middle and the nine reputation cards and all these tokens for what you get in the box is a bit of a table hold when all said and done and being able to sort of go hang on a minute let me just check what those objectives are ah again there's a few little clunky aspects like that with the hearts and with those the small text that does get in the way of the game at times now the rules are pretty straightforward to learn it's not a difficult one to teach you know it's easy to tell what's on the card although again you know small iconography you know they make the picture nice and big but aspects that should be bigger are made quite small which is kind of like not the way you should go about it you know the variety of the different buildings is pretty cool there's not a

huge amount of replay value from that perspective though because you will pretty much see every single card in a three or four player game and most of them are kind of duplicates of each other or rinse repeat but you can try different strategies you can go for the flags only you can go for Expedition I'm sorry Expedition the the objective cards the reputation cards you could decide to just produce a ton of resources and burn them into certain buildings that convert them into points and there's quite a few different strategic choices that you have and again that's a cool thing that opens itself to that kind of play the player scaling though not so good because really the only interaction you have in this game if you ignore the fact that you're drafting with other players the only true interaction is the parking of The Rovers and these Expedition cards because if you have more players more of these are in the game but I don't want to add that much time length to the game in order just to add more of these in so really the rovers are the only aspect That's player interaction but all it is is you simply Park a Rover on their card and utilize it you can't you're not taking the decision to play a card thinking whether someone else is going to park a Rover on it it's just a case that you get to look at somebody else's settlement and go well I need a Water Resource right now well you have a space for it fine I'll give you a Rover isn't that lovely and that's literally it other than that the interaction in this game is very minimal at Best But when you add more players you really do add more time to this game and especially at four players it goes too long you know with you have a certain number of cards for for player count I think you have eight with two seven with three or four and six with five now the transition from two to three is not as huge a deal

you go down a card yes you add a player but three players is a pretty good sweet spot for this game I find but it's weird why you don't go down the number of cards for four players so you still have seven cards in your hand but you've added another player with no other time mitigation which means that a fourth player added to this game does nothing but add time it adds no other benefit whatsoever and with that it goes on way too long at four players I mean at five players I wanted to shoot myself or reject myself out of an airlock it went on far too long yes you only have six cards but five players isn't that a good way to play this game five is right out and it's partially because it's not simultaneous drafting it's turn-based drafting you take it in turns to do your turn you basically draft the cards and then one two three four five draft again one two three four five which means there's a lot of downtime between your turn and when it gets back around to you in a five player game and it's worse bearing in mind that the first expedition card the one that dictates turn order shoots around every time you draft the cards which means that you might have gone you know first in one round and then you go last in another you know it's that whole snake draft thing yeah a bit like the problem that uh great was it not Great Western um Grand Austria hotel has where you could have a turn separated by a ton of turns before you get to act again same problem can happen here I just don't recommend this as a four or five player game stick to two or three solo on the other hand solo is pretty neat it's a fairly easy system to use you basically

use these cards for a solo deck which has a weird sort of construct on it that if you're a South Park Fan kind of looks like the the parody Dalek that they used in one of the episodes this looks disturbingly similar to that I just kept getting that image in my head but this solo deck is pretty easy you essentially play with piles of cards on the table and you pick them up in turn order from left to right as your hand to use what you want to do the AI doesn't produce you ain't got to worry about that and pretty much all the AI does is it just reveals a card from its deck builds it and applies its hearts and flags and various effects and you're just trying to get more parts than it at the end of the game but during each round it will take out some of the piles of cards so you have less options as the round goes on it's pretty straightforward and honestly I think it's my favorite way to play this game because you don't have to worry about the first player card Expedition for these you just have like new Expedition cards on the piles so you don't have the boring Expedition card you don't have the added timelapes you don't need but you still get to do all the cool janky city building stuff that's fun in this game it really doesn't make me not want to play this outside of solo mode unless maybe I'll play it with two or three but even then two player back and forth with the same drafting cards it's fine but then I'd rather play a quick two-player drafting game like tides of Time Madness or you know Caper that people say is really good you know I don't see this being the two player game of choice so really I'm playing this at solo and free players which is a weird you know mix of

player scaling that I want so Moon overall is a pretty decent game to be honest I mean I think it's my favorite of the three villagers streets and uh Moon included streets didn't really work well with me I didn't like the whole fomo mechanic where the meeples went to various places that was kind of weird and villagers was good up to a point in the replay value kind of went down this one though still has that replay value issue but I think that the game itself is just more interesting to play with the drafting plus the city building aspect with the janky little Combos and different strategies you can do but also I like the Expedition cards as an inclusion and I think the solo mode is incorporated quite well here you know to you can tweak the difficulty to your heart's content in terms of uh you know yeah I don't think there's I can't remember if there's difficulty modes in the book but you know you could do what you like to tweak the difficulty with this but I felt it was a decent enough Challenge and it allowed me to do all the fun aspects of the game without the added downtime and time length which this game really suffers from particularly at four or five players I don't recommend this for large groups I just I mean putting five on the box is usually an a recipe for disaster anyway but here I actually don't think I would play with four unless I house rule that you go down to six cards you know you've got to have eight cards at two seven at three six at four maybe even consider knocking the card off those seven at two six it three and five at four you know consider that yeah your score might be lower on BGG but who cares at least the

game will finish within the time because you're supposed to be able to get this done in what like 45 what does it say on the backs here I don't know if it says the time length on this game which is kind of weird but you know you're supposed to be getting this done in about 45 minutes to an hour good luck trying to do that at the best of times it's uh it does take a while to get through free eras but the game itself pretty solid so overall I give it a 7 out of 10. I I recommend it and I do think it's good I think the player scaling issues and the downtime do hold it back quite a bit I really do find these Hearts quite fiddly I think that a better system should have been done for this but the rest of the components I really like I can get over the fact that it comes in the Box I'm not a fan of that's had no bearing on the rating at all that's just personal preference you know same with this board but I think a solid solo mode and some good fun gameplay makes up for a lot of those shortcomings but still keeps it out of the region have been great but I still think this is good and I think it is probably my favorite of the three I still stand by that comment so that's it for me on this episode if you like what you see then please remember to thumb it up on YouTube and also thumb it up on Board Game Geek when you see see it posted on there of course check out the rest of the content on my channel including the videos I have done on the podcast to preview and review the UK games Expo where moon was I believe being demoed at the time thanks to Sinister fish for providing me with a review copy of this game and of course remember as always regardless of whether you want to share the moon with a weird makeshift bootleg Dalek or not it's still only a game bye for now everyone

foreign foreign

Progress saved