10 Greatest Board Game Expansions of All Time - Casual Friday ft. Kyle Frost of GIVEPAUSE Hobby
Transcript
hey everyone this is jack from the cardboard herald and i am joined by kyle frost of give paws hobby here and we are talking about our favorite expansions kyle's got five i've got five and we are going to be building up the definitive totally objective irrefutable list of the greatest expansions that have ever been designed created published whether they have been played by us or not the ones that we haven't played they don't count they cannot be considered are you ready for this kyle i am don't add us it's science everybody who's watching this yep it's gone through the machine this is absolutely going to be etched into stone for time immemorial and as a little bit of bookkeeping i do want to say that this is something that kind of came up as kyle and i are fans of each other's channels and we thought that it would be a great little you know team up like a marvel team up or something you know i'm not sure which of us is luke cage and which of us is iron fist but we are doing two videos we have this one that's going up on the cardboard herald and then we'll have another list that's going to be our five love at first play games each so hopefully 10 by the end unless we have some overlap going on at give paws hobby so be sure to check that out and i've been talking for a while so i'm going to need you first before we get into the top five kyle what was your scientific reasoning
for picking some of your expansions um for me it was uh expansions that really took a game to the next level and for some of the ones on my list there were games that were already well established like they were hitting the table regularly and then the expansion hit and the game just kind of got bumped up and um at least for one it was something that took the game from something i was not at all uh interested in um and it brought it like way onto my radar um so there are games like expansions that had an impact on the base game on mine the ones i was looking at because there are tons of different types of expansions out there and there are so many things that you could do in order to kind of cultivate this list but i used some of the same kind of perspective when getting my five and i didn't really want to reward fixing a bad game like if it made it like the best game ever then maybe i would consider that but i didn't want to take a bad game and then an expansion where it's like okay well this made it an okay game yes it's a substantial increase in quality but it's not taking a good game and making it great it's just taking a bad game and making it okay also i i really have a problem uh with having expansions where there's just aspects of it that i fundamentally do not use uh and if there's a big chunk of an expansion no matter how good part of the expansion is i just i i
can't make it work and i think that may come up as we uh discuss some of these things on our list but that sounds like a great starting point and let's uh go ahead and get it started with your number five what do you got kyle awesome um so on that last note you might be queuing into this because uh as you're saying it i realize they're part of this expansion i don't really touch but it is uh pandemic in the lab um and uh on the brink was the expansion that like really brought pandemic to like where it was when i first got the game because i had the purple disease and i loved that um but after a while just getting used or having to get those five cards to cure the disease is just such an onerous task it's such a bummer like get rid of everything else that when i played in the lab for the i didn't even know it was around um the first time i played it and it it was something i couldn't even imagine going back to playing uh pandemic the other way um it also has the little vials the little like you keep it you moved it um yeah those are so adorable and they just feel good to have around but you're right i think of pandemic and when i think of the the mandatory next expansion that gets recommended on the brink is the one that everyone says this is the next step so like can you think of a fundamental reason why you would recommend this one over on the brink i i said it before and i'll come back again that like five card to cure it is just such this like overarching i mean that's what pandemic is um but
it's it's it's nothing aside from the one guy who can have more cards in his hand it's it's you can't really get around it but in the lab allows you to go off and do things in a different way and piecemeal out that that uh you know curing the disease so it's more of a process rather than like oh i finally did the thing thank goodness i can get rid of these parts and i can look at the next thing like you can dole it out and also it makes i think it helps with the quarterbacking problem a little bit because the person who's in the lab title line they can like focus on that um and the people can focus on their different parts as opposed to you know the the one uh uber brain telling everyone the best term that they should be taking yeah i like that it kind of adds a level of asymmetry and not just asymmetric powers but also like fundamental different roles in what you are trying to achieve in the game well my number five is an expansion that is really to expansion so already i'm kind of cheating here uh it is uh champions of midgard valhalla and dark mountains now i consider these one expansion they were released as separate retail products at the same time and i don't know to me i like throwing it all in at once i feel like they were designed as compatible expansions and they were just separated in kind of a shady way i mean sure gray fox do whatever you want to do uh and i know that some people may like one over the other
but to me it makes one cohesive super indulgent experience now there there are aspects of this expansion that that make it just feel like there's so much on the table uh but this game the the fundamental nature of dice chucking in a worker placement game in order to play these different probabilities kind of makes me want this massive build up of all kinds of stuff and having all the different options for how you approach the game and interact with monsters just gives it this this brand new feel and bottom line if you hated champions of midgard because you're like dude what happens when you get a bad roll well now the souls of your vikings can be spent on awesome stuff it's a win-win scenario if your vikings die in a blaze of glory this is not a game that i've had a chance to play yet but you know bad roles leading to uh viking souls being used as currency for something awesome i can absolutely get behind that 100 and low-key favorite thing about the expansion i mean you have the new dice that are in there you have the leader dice you have the pink berserkers you have the green archers or rangers or whatever they are uh but you also have the bergazars coming from the mountains and i'm not sure that that's how it's pronounced but that's how it's pronounced in my house so just saying berg's ours over and over again between my wife and i and whoever else is playing just feels fantastic it's a game i like already and this kind of takes it to
11 in a way that i feel like the the theme really deserves yeah i mean like uh what is it spinal tap right exactly exactly so all right so my number four uh for best expansions is uh lords of water deep um and the scoundrels of skullport and um this there have been games that i've kind of like gone on to from lords of water deep um but i just remember uh when that expansion came out it wasn't it not that just that it added the two uh this was one they did not separate into two box expansions um and uh but it fulfilled anyone who like got right in on lords of water deep i think you can remember that sixth player exactly there's a little grey meeple icon on the board and you're like what's going on i mean come on guys and i can't remember i should have i should have looked at the rule book to see if it mentioned it i can't remember if they were just like coming soon um but when the expansion came i was like it has a purpose um i never played them because i always play the harpers and i don't know that's the one game where i only play that faction and i it makes no difference so i don't know why but it just gives you those the options like again uh 211 with the under mountain expansion where just everything is bigger and then um the scoundrel the skull port with the the skull just like watching your friends either become like these like goopy evil just like under city dwellers of just
you know doing all the back alley trading and getting all this corruption or becoming just like the total rules followers and total buzz kills you're like no corruption for me it's such a fun uh such a fun change to that game yeah it was this really strong contender for my list i mean lords of waterdeep is one of my favorite games even still after playing it a bajillion times i still love coming back to it and this expansion is something that i always use the only reason why i haven't included it is because my undermountain remains neglected the only time when i play with undermountain is when i have someone who's like i don't like the corruption stuff it's dumb and i'm like you're dumb but okay fine at least we'll play with something and so like it feels to me like i i have this chaff on the side and that that may be uh something that other people get a lot of use out of i mean it does feel really good when you're like dude i got a 40 point quest but at the same time the the core that i love is the the skull port stuff and having to separate out the the different cards for undermountain versus skullport or if you combine them all and i never really liked the mega game of everything there in contrast to um to champions of midgard which is a game that gets a lot of comparison to uh lords of lottery but i i i think that it's just such a
fantastic expansion it's something that i always include except for maybe teaching someone but even then i mean it's something that i i use a lot now going on to my number four uh is kind of similar i i view it as a similar type of expansion and that's concordia salsa which i am someone who eats a lot of burritos and tacos and that kind of stuff and so i think of salsa as you know a spicy sauce that i'm going to add to my game i do not think of it as salt but then again i am not a centurion living in the roman empire so i guess that makes sense have you played concordia i have not okay well this is one of those games that you got to get to the table especially if you like german style euro games and to me concordia is kind of the the apex of that i mean i i know that there's a lot of love out there for the cavernas and agricolas so there's a lot of love for the power grids out there and this to me just represents a particular style of game uh an economic euro that the expansion i think takes it to a whole new level it introduces a new resource to it and more fundamentally than that it gives you a choice a reason why you might not exhaust all of your resources uh earlier on in the game as opposed to later if you don't know in concordia you play a card from your
hand you resolve the action on that card and then once you play your final card your tribune or tribunal i'm trying to remember the actual terminology you pick up your entire hand you can play that card at any point so you could play a card and then pick up your one card in the discard or you could play your entire hand out which is what you normally do because you don't want to lose efficiency and momentum but this introduces this market of one time and permanent uh like powers that can be acquired based off of how many cards that you pick up and there may be a really swank one in the four card slot and you're like well i still have four more cards left in my hand but i want to pick up the cards that i have in order to get that before someone else does it just introduces a really nice dynamic that that messes with what is the optimization of the game but in a way that feels empowering instead of disruptive right like like uh in a totally different game on the century golem edition or spice road where like you want to pick those cards up as few times as possible exactly to short circuit that that would be a super interesting like gameplay element so that sounds i okay it it is definitely on my list of in the after times yes it gets disabled yeah when we can actually travel and i can go down there you can come up here then we can actually play it together at a convention that sounds fantastic so what's next on your list so mine is also actually uh economic
euro which is tesla versus edison and the powering up expansion so this is the one i was referencing where the game tesla versus edison completely went past me without like tipping my interest whatsoever and i i don't honestly know why because um even the base game is something that would be interesting to me but the when i did get interested was when um powering up was on kickstarter and uh it just adds so much and it also a like just sort of adjusts the way the base game plays it adds um the automa you know your robot opponents which is it i love whether it's just me playing solo or adding them to the other meat pegs around the table it's just another like something that everyone could be like ah robo tesla uh and just get angry together but it adds um the headquarters like you're building up your you're asymmetric because they're all different by the scientists which in the first game i could see where you wouldn't they all have like a different power but the headquarters cards are all different so your like strategies in the game can be completely different based on and honestly there are some it sort of pigeonholes you like certain scientists if you're going for the like zerg rush the map with projects or whatever you're probably not going to do so well with a certain scientist so that you know has to be taken into account but the the event cards are in there the madame cj walker who's awesome um the and the end game again i never
played the base game but i heard from most people who who who enjoy the the expansion that the end game is just so much more engaging than the base game because the first base game was just like add up all your stocks and tie to whoever has money in hand and stocks are like a huge part of the board they're a huge part of the game but you get points from so many other things again one of those things is completely different based on your scientists so it just adds like a ton to the game and it's one of my all-time favorite games you know this is another one of those critical darlings that for whatever reason i just haven't been exposed to like i i've seen it i've heard discussions about it and just in the myriad of games that i could get to the table that you know i i could see at conventions and that kind of stuff for whatever reason never got to it uh but i have to know for uh prioritization here of how soon i got to get it to the table uh is tesla as depicted as played by david bowie uh he is not this is well that brought it down a few uh matches there and as edison do you end up being forced as a player to electrocute an elephant to death i'm not gonna say edison needs to but it is in the game again okay so it's it's so like it's so cool and this is a game that might there are certain games like my wife which is like i don't know how you like those games and this is one she's like no we're not playing that game and i'm just
like but there's so many historical things in it and that is absolutely one of the things that is in the game but again wow he's not edison specific i can't tell if that makes me want to play it more or less but either way it's a really intriguing game and a really good recommendation by you uh now for my uh number three uh i have viticulture's tuscany essential edition and this actually kind of dovetails into what i was thinking about when we were just spitballing ideas for lists that we could do and top five expansions was one that i thought about because we've had a lot of really good expansions in the last year one of those i personally am a really big fan of the new wingspan expansion oceania but i really haven't had enough time to let it kind of ruminate you know to to kind of absorb to make a objective uh decision that this is permanently going to be etched in history as one of the all-time great expansions but it drew on a lot of the feelings i had for tuscany which i do think is just a monumental expansion now there is a little bit of weird history here viticulture came out then tuscany came out and then tuscany had a bunch of garbage in it and so jamie stegmeier went okay we're going to make viticulture essential edition which takes the best parts of tuscany and incorporates them and i think viticulture essential edition is one of the best board gaming packages ever made like if someone was like you know what what's an easy
recommend as far as a board game i mean that's right up there with like jaws of the lion just like this is so cohesive and a great experience for beginners and experienced players alike but then tuscany essential edition was just a few modules that could be wrapped in into that on top of what was already put into essential edition taking out all of the the the chaff the garbage that never really made sense in the original tuscany and it's glorious my favorite thing about it is that it breaks up the two seasons of viticulture essential edition into four different seasons and that creates such a cool momentum of play and considerations that aren't really in other board games these four distinct worker placement phases within a single round uh and it adds the um addition of special workers that could be acquired that uh you have some of the most adorable uh man and woman professional meeples that have ever existed the area control aspect is okay but more fundamentally it's another source of resources that you can acquire in a pinch uh to help you out i i think that tuscany essential edition is just like so polished and so perfect of an expansion right and it gives just like you said going from two to four it just gives you that many more i mean gaming is all about those interesting decisions and and those like moments where you're
like it's it's working or it's not working and it's just like yeah it it's a great addition to the game for sure so um next so for my next one is uh spirit island branch and claw and um this one i i really wrestled with because i'm loving uh going through spirit island jagged earth um again i i don't know what it is this is two in a row the spirit island was game that completely just like went right past me but this one i was consciously like i don't think i like that game and i finally you know i'm gonna i'm gonna credit where credit's due the cardboard herald was like you come coming back to spirit island enough times just like you know what i'm gonna check this out and and as soon as i played spirit island i it was it was just awesome and i immediately looked for branch and claw and i was lucky enough to find it and the fact that it takes the game that you know if you can kind of map out some things and in base game spirit island and it just like throws a couple of things in your way some some obstacles sometimes it helps you out with the events that go on and the different um you know the different tokens that you put on the map i'm not a huge fan of the two spirits that are in uh branching claw they're not two of my favorite but the way that it changes the game makes it for me a more critical expansion than jagged
earth whose spirits i like across the board am liking a lot more than uh branch and claw i i did want to include this but there's a couple reasons why it just didn't rate on my list you know things like made it a little bit murkier it is something that i love and i do always play with the events and the island tokens i think are fantastic but it's not something that secret that this expansion branch and claw was designed alongside the original spirit island and our eric royce has talked about how it was originally intended to be played as one experience this was an element of the game from the get-go that they ended up breaking out in order to make it a slightly more accessible game i'm not saying that that was a bad idea but it's been hard for me to really view it as an expansion because it was released alongside the original game it was designed alongside the original game and by designer intent it was part of the original game so it was just one of these ones where i was like do i include it do i not and i i just ended up not putting it on the list the other part is that the best parts of branch and claw the events and the um or i guess not best parts because i do really like both those spirits but the the things that make it evolve or or change or level up spirit island the events and the island tokens are also included in the more recent jagged earth and
jagged earth has what more than four times the amount of new spirits to add but then again jagged earth was this new expansion and it didn't necessarily innovate in the way that branch and claw did so i didn't include that either even though i really love both expansion so i'm glad it's getting the credit where credit is due uh on your list here i just uh i i just didn't end up putting it there it's also how i carry all my spirits in that box because i that is that is hands down my favorite box in the series is the branch and claw one so all of them are just this like dense brick of awesomeness inside of that yeah well uh my next one uh is kind of an interesting one uh and it may be more sentimental reasons than uh anything else and that's uh caverna the forgotten folk uh are you a caverna fan or just an uve rosenberg fan in general the gricolas the cavernos the patchworks that kind of stuff i do like a lot of his uh his stuff and i have played converted but i haven't played with uh forgotten folk okay yeah so caverna is just this immense sandbox of a game and some people love that some people hate it to me i like that this game just is full of possibilities and you can kind of just shape your own destiny in the game which is really great but it does eventually start feeling kinda samey after you've played it a lot and i've played it a lot and that's not necessarily a bad thing but everything is always
available from the get-go and there was a fan variant that started on the bgg forums where someone posted like hey i'm trying to come up with some asymmetric powers i don't know just fantasy things we'll see how this works and i remember that i had this game flagged as a game to send me notifications on uh on bgg whenever someone creates a new thread and i was like oh this seems kind of cool i play tested a couple of them and was like oh here's some feedback along with tons of other people you know i wasn't the only one in this but it was something that i noticed early on and i thought this was kind of neat and lo and behold he ends up getting contacted by the publisher to be like yo what if we talk to juve rosenberg about making this like the real deal and sure enough like mark wahlberg in what was that rock star uh where he got to be the lead singer of steel dragon or whatever this ends up becoming the real deal and a legit expansion that creates asymmetric powers for you to play as and that's a great thing in almost every game to have asymmetric abilities and it adds a lot of replayability to the game because they they each introduce new buildings that replace other buildings that can be accessed by anyone anyone can purchase these buildings but it also kind of changes what the limitations are in the the sandbox of the game itself so it just
gives this nice sort of um again disruption to what you anticipate in koverta when you sit down to play it gives you all these imaginative powers and it has a great story attached to it i i really love it yeah i was gonna say that the origin story is almost worth it alone just to be like hey see this guy's name here next other like much more well-known name here like yeah that's that's just awesome um okay so we're at the the peak the peak of expansion mountain the my peak at least um and that is uh root underworld and uh this is one that like part of me is like absolutely hands like it's this is absolutely the peak and another part of me is like well the reason i started my channel in the first place was to make content about the clockwork expansion like i was so excited about that expansion when i during the underworld um kickstarter that i was like is is there not anything and there were some things that i could seek out just like get scratch that itch before i had the game um but you know when people have asked about if i'm just getting into root which expansion should i get next hands down i tell them underworld um for two reasons one as much as i love the clockwork edition and anytime i can get more kyle fahren art i do right right totally that's a good rule to live by um but you can get the better bot project files for free on board game beacon they're not all the same and i mean some would say
you know with the directors cut edition like they've even gone beyond the clockwork expansion now you're not going to get the pretty like pieces but you can people pnp stuff all the time but the what's included in underworld is just so good and the at the top of that is a third militant faction that really stands toe-to-toe with either the cats or the birds because while cats is an easy one to kind of pitch to people and get on the board i found that birds can be a tougher one to teach or for people to stomach like just that you know programming aspect of it so to say like here are these moles that you get to like poop out all over the map and like you put the little crowns on their heads and it's it it opens up so many more uh variations for the game but the corvids are incredible the two maps are a ton of fun um and they add like really interesting twists into the game it's just you know it's just such a such a great expansion that i can't imagine i i love river folk too but i feel like they went and that's kind of known as like the weird one like the and it's it's which is great like i i love the otters and the lizards lizards are one of my favorite factions but they do not they do not open up the uh the variety of matchups nearly as much as underworld and to me that that makes that expansion just like absolutely the first if you like root based game underworld yeah and it provides that stability like you
were saying that that to me is the most important thing about it is that the moles allow for so many more match-ups especially at three player you know you can have your one janky weird faction like the otters or lizards on the side so long as the moles are kind of tying things together or the cats or the birds but you need one of those anchor factions and so that still just exponentially increases the variety of things that you can play and some of the most imaginative kyle ferran artwork is in those moles i mean i love looking at the the underground duchy the kingdom there they look so great and i'm alaskan so i'm surrounded by ravens constantly they're important to alaskan heritage they are hanging out in my front yard all the time they are like one of the symbols of alaska so having these like little dastardly corvids throwing out bombs and snare traps everywhere was like yes this is the best the only thing is like when you call the birds with like the eerie dynasty it's tough because now they're not the birds they're those birds well even still you can't just say corvids and expect everyone's going to know what's up because yes it is the korvik conspiracy but blue jays are corvids you know when you get right down to it they are part of that family of uh birds so i mean what i'm really saying is cole patrick get your kings play chess on fine grains of sand down before you
start naming all of your different uh factions within root uh but yeah that expansion sounds great i'm really excited or not sounds great that expansion is really great i'm excited for the expansion on the horizon where they're introducing the minor factions and the i i think the only reason why i didn't include root because again one of my absolute favorite games was it just didn't uh for me um like it it didn't elevate root it like expanded root which you could argue that's exactly what an expansion should do uh but i already love base game root and i think that if you sit down and play bass game root it's just as good as playing root with any of the other factions or any of the other maps it just adds more variety which is so good as well but in how i was ordering these it just didn't uh come up there but it i i love everything that they put out for that game and i can't wait to see more um which brings me to my number one which is uh maybe no surprise for people who have watched my channel uh a bunch but is terraforming mars prelude now this is interesting because terraforming mars is again i would say right now root spirit island terraforming mars are kind of homogenized into my top three and you're making me pick between my babies if i have to pick one of those but terraforming mars is so so good but unlike spirit island and
root where i love everything that's come out for it terraforming mars i'm kind of like uh pretty much everything that's come out except for prelude and then the alternate maps have been i might play them if i really feel like i need to change something up so there's a lot of stuff that i don't really care for it's okay sometimes it's kind of bad sometimes it's pretty good but nothing knocks it out of the park except for prelude now are you a tm guy terraforming mars player you know i i have tried both bass and and prelude and that was one that i kind of was like oh this is going to be one i'm going to like and it just didn't work for you but it's it's not one uh that's like at the top of my list but i i absolutely you know everything that i hear about prelude or i heard about pray before i played i was like okay i totally understand what they're saying now because i played base game first as many people did and then did that was like okay i see what this is going for and what it does yeah so i mean terraforming mars i love the engine building aspect and i love that you cultivate this this engine with such precision as you add more cards and it just becomes this expansive automated factory of resource production and it just feels really good for me those are the things i really love about it is just introducing one thing after another and then you start just seeing all the parameters
for terraforming the planet go up uh extremely rapidly by the end of the game uh and that feels really good now if you don't draft the cards which i don't always love drafting when playing because it kind of slows things to a halt you're not always getting the cards that are going to add to your engine or your specific thing but prelude introduces just this like kickstart to the game it's a very small expansion it's the most concise expansion on i think either of our lists at this point uh but it just gives you these four cards of which you choose to at the beginning and they give you a boost in something either resource production extra cards extra money um or other resources right off the bat or or something that's going to further give you a nudge just beyond your little corporate identity card that gives you your slight asymmetric power in that and it dramatically speeds up the start of the game and gives you that that little edge to lean into so much earlier and it just feels amazing i absolutely adore it and i think that uh if you were measuring impact to game for the the size of component introduction ratio prelude is probably one of the best expansions of all time truly objectively just like you get to skip first gear like you get to just start making the
more interesting decisions because you don't have to like oh i need to do this just to get this resource i'm you're already a little bit further down the road totally totally all right well that is going to do it we actually ended up with 10. so now this is the definitive 10 greatest expansions of all time we know that you know you're entitled to your opinion if you want to let us know just know your opinions wrong if it's not one of these 10 but please do let us know in the comments uh what your favorite expansions are what are the ones that you think that we missed or if you think we're completely wrong on some of these picks here particularly on the brink all you pandemic lovers you know go after uh kyle here uh and be sure to check out the sister episode to this that will go up on give paws hobbies uh um channel and you can uh see us talk about the top five each of the games that we loved at first play and definitely give the whole subscribe and check out all the other content on that channel kyle it has been awesome having you on here thank you so much it's been great to talk about expansion except i'm already thinking like what expansions are going to come out now and like potentially break the list which is it's a a blessing and a curse to be part of a hobby yeah just constantly expanding you're like definitive 10 and then something comes out and you're like let's go back and re-record it yeah yeah exactly
you know well then i'm looking forward to re-recording this talking about how we were so wrong a year two years five years from now i'm definitely looking forward to doing more of this with you all right thanks again for coming on to the show kyle thanks for having me if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald