Skip to main content
Loading video...

Heaven & Ale Review - JonGetsGames

Transcript 37:30

welcome to Jang kids games today I'll be reviewing it heaven and ale this game was designed by Michael Keesling and Adria Schmitt and in it each player takes control of a monastery full of monks who are of course trying to brew the best beer possible they're gonna do this by making sure they have enough money to get all of the best ingredients to put into that beer there are a lot of things going on in this game several twists on some of familiar mechanics so first I'll show you how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review here is a player's monastery at the start of the game but before I explain how to actually play the game I want to jump ahead and explain to end game scoring so that the rest of this will make sense over here we have this track that kind of goes around the board and on it we have a Brewer token as well as five different resource tokens and when the game is over these tokens will likely be something like this kind of scattered around the different spots on the board and of this Brewer is on the same track and they may end up right here so in this case if the game wants to end right now we would first check to see where the Brewer was as in what region of this scoring board they're in we see over here they are in this spot which says three two one and what that means is we are going to reduce the value of our best good by three going one two three an order bump our worst good up by one and then we will keep doing that and you don't have to just do one good for instance you could do one two three just removing your better Goods down to gain another bump up here you could go one two three bump this up again and lastly you have one two three and in fact they've all condensed down onto this three location and then you would once

again look to the region your Brewer is in you see this X 3 and then the beer that means you multiply this value which is where your worst resource is x 3 so in this case 3 times 3 and that would be our ending score of course not accounting for the end game objectives which I'll talk about a little bit later out here we have the main player board and on it we have this circular track going all the way around as well as one pawn per player so this is the setup for a three player game and we are the red player so this one right here with our pawn means we get to go first and a for our action that we simply go as far as we want to clockwise around this path and then stop on a spot and evaluate it but we need to keep in mind that on future turns we can only go clockwise we can never actually go backward so we don't want to skip over too many things and the only restriction really for where you go down is it has to be on a spot where you can activate something there can even be an opponent's piece there as long as there's something to do there so in this case maybe we would skip over this first spot with the one of water and jump here with the four of hops and then we of course have to pick it up because we have to do an action where we stop next up we come back to our personal monastery and we have to put this down into one of the empty spots in our growing areas and we essentially have a hill here with this sign to being the sunny side and this side being the shady side and it depends where we want to put this as to how much money it'll cost if we want to put this for down in any of these shady locations it will simply cost one money for each number on that tile so in this case it's a four so that would cost us four money and you'll notice that we start the game with 25 money but if instead we wanted

to put this over here in the sunny side it's gonna cost twice this value in order to place the tile down so that would cost eight at the beginning of the game and that is probably not a great idea so let's just go ahead and say we put the four down here and we spent our five money and got one and change at this point our turn is now over and play goes to the next player in clockwise order in this case it might be the blue player for instance and now they get to do the same thing and they might want to go cheap they just go here and take this one and they put it down into either the sunny or the shady side if it's sunny it just costs two money so definitely a cheaper to get this one into the sunny side and then the yellow player may go and they may jump all the way ahead and take something like this five of barley since we're playing in clockwise order that means it is once again our turn and we might want to go all the way up here and maybe take this monk now we're gonna go ahead and place this monkey down into our monastery just like one of these resource hexes and you'll note that the cost to play this monk is printed on the board where that token actually was at not on the token itself so this one would be three the placement rules for monks is identical to the resources so we could put it down right there we know the cost of this was three so we could go ahead and to get rid of three money and then move on and then of course if we were to put the monkey into the sunny side that would have cost us six money instead coming back to the board it's worth pointing out that there are four of these locations on the map where you can actually pick up these monks and the price decreases it the farther along the map you go this last one that costs just one and you'll notice that there are can be duplicates of these monks although they are pulled out randomly and at this point I've explained it two out of the four different types of spaces so the next

one are these purple spots with these purple tokens now every time you go onto one of these locations you will activate it you'll pull that token off and you will evaluate the type of scoring that is on that spot in the first spot you'll see a B and C and those are specific types of scoring's and the last three say a / b / c which means when you take one of these you could pick any of these you choose - so let's go ahead and take this one and I'm gonna cheat a bit and add a few more hexes on to our area to show how it works let's go ahead and start explaining scoring's at first with the C scoring because that's where our pond is and if you look closely you'll see one of each of the five different types of terrain and then the scoring marker now that icon is used to show us how we are restricted in evaluating the different scoring's there are ten of them total listed on the right-hand side of all of our player boards and this means that we only have the option of doing it these five over here which are associated with the five different types of resources so in this case we could activate wood yeast hops water or barley but the one that would probably make the most sense in our current status is to go over here and trigger the hops right here that means we are going to activate every one of the hops hexes on the sunny and shady side of our Hill and so we can look out here and we can start with the shady sign we see we have a 4 and a 1 and if we look down here we see that we're actually going to go ahead and sell these things to the local town and make money for them and a rate of 1 to 1 so that's five total hops that's gonna make us 5 money which means both of these have effectively paid for themselves because it costs us five money to place these down and now we're gonna go ahead over here and look at to the sunny side

of the hill we see we have this one hops right here with a three on it and if we look down here we see this little cylinder that is moving that means this is the good hops we're actually gonna use these hops to make our beer and so we're gonna find our hops marker and we're gonna move it one two three spaces forward showing that we've actually gone ahead and stored that hops to make the beer for ourselves as opposed to selling the worst hops to the town once we have gone ahead and evaluated every one of our hops then we are done with the scoring we leave this token here which shows that we will not be able to do another hop scoring for the rest of the game and we can go ahead and move on so now let's talk about - the next type of scoring and that would be the one associated with the letter B and this is monk scoring you see the four different types of monks on the spot when we once again come down to our player board we can see that the bottom four scoring's are those four different monks so this is how we are restricted we could go ahead and take this token put it down right there which means we are going to trigger all of the white monks that are out on our area so whenever you trigger a monk they are going to activate every single tile that is adjacent to them so what that means is we could trigger this white monk right here who activates this for wood and at this - of barley but since both of them are on the shady side that just means we're gonna make four plus two or six money immediately which is certainly a nice thing to have and then we come up to this white monk here and they're gonna activate everything adjacent to them well in this case that's four plus three or seven more money so we're definitely getting a whole bunch of money with this activation they are also adjacent to this three of hops which means we go one two three with that token and you'll notice that they are adjacent to this pink monkey right here and I mentioned that this is going to

trigger the white monks which will activate everything adjacent to them well when you activate a monk all they do is move at your Brewer token up once on the level so it's only a trigger monk that activates everything around itself at this point there's just one more type of scoring that we can do and that is the a scoring and if you look over here you see all of the different types and then a big X in the middle what this means is when we come back to our board we have to activate just this top spot in fact you can only do an activation at once per game and when you do it you're gonna choose a number that goes from 1 to 5 to match this X right here and you'll activate every one of your tokens that have that number so in this case we might put that there and activate 4 which means this this one and this one are all going to become activated these two are gonna generate for us eight money right away and then this four of the yeast is gonna make us go one two three four up on the track now that you know how all of the different scoring's work you may be asking why are they in these five different pairs and that's because at the moment you score both of the spots in a pair you immediately get to activate one of these five of privilege cards that every player has they all have the same type and you simply take it and you put it down onto the board and immediately evaluate what it has some of them are simple like this one just generates you twelve money this one moves your Brewer a couple of these actually give you more resources and this one's going to give you points for the objectives that you complete at the end of the game so you're definitely scent of eyes to try and make up these privileged pairs it is also worth noting that any of these privileged cars you have in your hand that you've not played can be discarded

at any point in time to immediately take it three money from the stock although obviously you won't be able to score that privilege for the rest of the game because it is now out of your area okay now that we're totally done talking about these scoring's the next thing I'd like to explain are these seven different shed spots that are on your board now you'll notice you could put two these monks and these tokens down into any of the empty slots but never on to these shed slots and these get activated at the moment they get completely enclosed by tokens so if for instance we put this water five down right there then immediately we would score this shed and the first thing you do is you count up all of the value of the numbers that are surrounding that shed in the case of the monks they count as zero so in this case we have let's see five plus four plus four plus three plus three which ends up being a total shed score of 19 and now we go over to this little spot on our player board and we find at which spot it falls into in this case it is between 18 and 23 and so that means we get all the benefits down here the first thing is we get one Brewer movement so we take our Brewer and they're just slowly working their way up here but you'll notice if this had been a zero to seven so a very low value shed scoring we would have just done it six Brewer movements so that is one of the main ways to move this person up really fast and then the next thing we do is we take a three shed as dictated on this graph and we're going to go ahead and put that down on to the location now you'll notice that there are these little white arrows on that shed token and they point in at three of the different directions and what this means is we now get to activate three of the titles that are adjacent to the shed but they cannot be adjacent to each other they must be in

this specific orientation so that means that we could go ahead and activate this three of hops this four of yeast and this three of barley here or instead we could activate this set instead so I think getting resources it's good so we would probably do this getting ourselves one two three more barley and then one two three four yeast and three bucks is certainly a nice thing to have from the bank we can now briefly look at the other options we see that 8 to 11 gives three brew movements and we can activate any one the 12 to 17 it gives us one brew movement and we can activate two that are from each other and then the final one is 24 or more just allows us to activate any four of the adjacent tokens but we get no Brewer movements with this large shed all right let's now come back to the main board and talk about the fourth and final spot that you can put your worker down as you go around the path and these are the objective locations when you land on this spot you can immediately gather any of these objectives that you currently match the requirements for and there is a wide variety of them you always play with the same twelve and underneath is a smaller version of the big one and you can see that at the end of the game at the big ones are with four points and the little ones are with 2 points and they can be a ton of different things for instance have all of your sunny spots filled all of your shady spots filled this one is have three of your privileges actually evaluated and I'm not gonna go in through all of them but as you can see there is a bunch of different things that you can shoot for to try and give you some points but of course you do have to stop off in one of these spots with your worker in order to grab all the ones that you can okay it's now time for us to talk about what happens when we reach the end of the track you notice

these three locations and where we started well these are bonus pots that you get to evaluate when you put your token onto them so if for instance it was the blue players turn right now they could not maybe want this four right here and just jump all the way to the end they could go here which means they'll be the start player for the next round they can go here which would bump their Brewer up once this would allow them to bump any of their resources up twice on their board and lastly this would give them two money and then they would stay there they would just pass for the rest of the round until the rest of us had chosen all of these spots and it's worth noting that in a two or three player game the last person must go on the starting player spot if it has not been taken already once all players have reached the end of the track the round is over and we'll go ahead and start the next one the first thing we'll do is we'll take the next stack of monks right here they get shuffled up and put down into the four locations out on the map and then we can go ahead and take a bunch more of these resource tokens and we fill in every single location around the board and it's important to note that some of these spots where maybe something wasn't taken you'll actually add another one on to that location so that in the future if somebody goes on to that location they can buy one or both of these if they want to and the same goes with the monks they can also stack up lastly we have to refresh all the scoring locations making sure they have only one scoring token in them so in this case these will not actually double up even though they weren't taken in the previous round there is one exception for that in the two to three player game in the last round of the game but I don't need to bother talking about that right now and with that the round is fully set up and the start player is gonna be who is ever here and you will go clockwise from there and you'll keep playing the game just as I've shown

until all of these stacks have been depleted and the three player game you'll do four rounds in the 60s of the rounds of the game once the last round is completed everybody will go ahead and evaluate the ratio for where their Brewer is and then at that point you can go ahead and spend money at a rate of ten to one to bump up one of your tokens which may or may not matter in this case maybe it wouldn't and you now take your lowest spots that's a three multiply it by your multiplier that's three plus three is nine and then you add to that any of the objectives you were able to achieve in this case we got six points there so our ending total would be fifteen points and whoever has the most points wins let's now go ahead and begin the review for heaven and ale by starting with a few positive points and the first of these has to do with the highly satisfying planning that goes into most turns of the game but in particular the very first turn of each of the rounds in the game and depending on the player account there's going to be three to six rounds and that is that very first turn in the round is a particularly exciting one from a planning perspective because that is right after you have seeded the board randomly with a bunch of new ingredients as well as some new monks and after that point the round is fixed there is no more randomness there's no luck of the draw or anything that goes into how that round is going to play out it's just you versus your opponents and you try to figure out what is best for you what is best for your opponent's how can you get there first on the things that you think that you will be competing on and a particular what do you think you're not going to be competing on so what are the things that you can maybe grab easier and not have to worry about them go ahead and going after and this is very crunchy if I'm

being honest like the very first turn of the round often involves everyone around the table kind of just sitting and thinking and processing the numbers on the different ingredients the colors of those ingredients where they are on the overall path that you guys are going to be taking with your little workers and I just found that really satisfying you know trying to come up with that plan the later turns are really they feel much more consequential because you've already put a bunch of tiles out into your area you've already invested and different things you're already weakened one thing and strong another things we want to try and focus on those weak things I will say that the very first turn of the game you have just this empty field in front of you so that's probably the lowest stress moment of the game and the least crunchy moment as well but that's kind of nice because it kind of works you into the game somewhat easily because you will have an open playing field I mean everybody has the same starting resources so you are always a little bit more interested in getting barley than you are in getting wood in the earlier parts of the game because you have a lot more barley to go to get before you get to that zero marker but even so I think that the planning is crunchy and highly satisfying and one of my favorite parts of the game for positive number two I like to talk about an interesting spin that heaven and outputs on a familiar mechanic and that one is the idea that your lowest scoring token is going to be your final score and this is a mechanic that's been around for quite some time the designer writer concea is somewhat famous for putting this in many of its games like Tigris and Euphrates and ingenious but there is a pretty cool twist that heaven and ale brings to this

idea because in heaven an ale when the game is over you do take your lowest scored ingredient and you multiply that by your modifier but the difference here is that before you do that you run through this ratio conversion where depending on where your Brewer ended up you will then lose a certain number of your better ingredients to go up once with your worst ingredient and that ratio gets better the farther you get your Brewer around it could be 5 2 1 4 2 1 3 2 1 2 2 1 or even 1 2 1 which I haven't seen that just yet but I think it's a two to one at one point and what that means is you are no longer disincentivized from going hard on something you're already good at and that is a kind of a fundamental aspect to other games that have this mechanic like if you're really far behind on red and you're great at blue then it'd be stupid to bump your blue up anymore because you have to move your red anymore blue doesn't matter but in heaven an ale more blue does matter it's not quite as good as bumping up at that red but if you do two bumps on blue and you're in the 2 to 1 ratio that's as good as bumping up your red once and it is just a nice tweak I really appreciate that difference it brings and if I'm being honest the first time I read the rules I was like what the heck is this with the ratio conversion I was like this seems clunky and stupid like they didn't need to do this but once I played the game a couple times I realized what it unlocks from a decision standpoint and from a freshness standpoint for this familiar mechanism I think he is quite worth it so yeah I'm really like that tweak positive number three is similar to number two and then it also has to do with a satisfying tweak on a familiar mechanism but in this case I want to talk about the move as far down a path

as you want to action selection style now many games in the past have done this like patchwork you have Thebes Tokaido Glenmore a craft wagon and many other games but the big difference between all of those and heaven and ale is that in those games it's your turn when your token is the farthest back down the path so that means that if you do a really big jump then you might have to skip a bunch of turns until all your opponent's catch up to you so that does mean that you're on set device to do a smaller jump as possible and only do a big jump if you're getting something that is just amazing for you but when you have a game like having an ale the tweak is that instead of doing that last person takes a turn they just go clockwise around the table and you might be sitting here saying really John you're positive point is that this game implements a clockwise player turns and yes that is the that is what I'm talking about because it might not seem much in fact it might seem like a downgrade like the the last person on the track taking a turn sounds much more interesting than clockwise we've always had clockwise but what it does to the strategic implications and the planning implications is really wonderful in heaven and Alan and I will mention that heaven and ale is not the first game to do this tweak I know that lignum which came out several years ago also did exactly this but in particular just talking about having an ale and how it does it well the monks which are incredibly powerful tokens that you can put down into your fields in this game make it cheaper the farther down the path you go and they're a big reason to try and get farther down the path to try and pick up those cheap monks because the closest monk right at the very beginning cost for money which is a lot and the cheapest one cost one and

especially considering if you're going on the sunny side you're gonna be doubling that price that's a difference from eight money down to two money which is gigantic in this game and what it means is that in this game you are incentivized to do much bigger leaps than you would have in all of those previous games like there's a big penalty for giant leaps in those games and this one you would go for it became saying give it a shot like and that is definitely an option on your first turn jumping all the way around the track to like the 75% marker and grabbing maybe one of those cheap monks for several reasons first of all you get to take your turn again soon but also it puts an interesting new pressure on your opponents because in any of those previous games they look at you like you're crazy and they'd laugh and then they take a bunch of turns until it was your turn again but in this case they look at you with a worried eyes because they're like oh crap now that means they're all the way over there and there's some stuff over there that I wanted but I thought I have some time before I be able to get at it but now my opponent is really close to them so maybe I should jump all the way ahead so that I could try to get those things that I really want but wait a minute this is a three player game if I do that and my portal already did it then that means my third opponent has free reign to like 75% of the board and they'll get to take whatever they want for the exact prices they want in there right or that they want and that is not what you want to have happen to your opponents you do not want to give them edges so you are putting this extra planning pressure on your opponents to try and maybe tweak their plans and reconsider what they're trying to do based off of this big leap which the game says you know what go ahead and give it a shot so either way it doesn't seem like much clockwise turn order does that feel like a huge deal but it is a great tweak to this familiar

mechanism and I really like how it works out in this game let's now move on to a couple neutral points and the first of these has to do with how punishing this game can be this is an economy of just one resource in his money and it is a very feast or famine situation with this game you start off with 25 money and it feels like a ton until you find like four turns later that you are completely out of money and you're desperately trying to figure out how to get some more so you can keep playing the game and it is possible if you play your first couple turns poorly and buy a bunch of Sunnyside tokens that you will have sunk your entire game and you'll get several points at the very end I haven't seen that happen because every time I played I've vocalized to people like make sure you get some shady tokens down because the shade tokens are the ones that generate you money and if you get too greedy too early and trying to get those victory points on the sunny side you will definitely shoot yourself in the foot so this is a game that you potentially have to play at least one full game to kind of get the idea and the cadence of how to play it well so that the next time you let you you make sure you don't find yourself just constantly starving but that being said even when this game is played well you go back and forth going down like almost nothing and then you do a scoring and boom now you got like twelve money and then you spend it all needed scoring and maybe you go crazy I've seen people get like thirty money after a scoring in the middle of the game and then like four turns later be completely broke and then you just spend money so fast as you grab it these really nice tokens slap them down into your sunny area because that's where you want to get the points and that's gonna rub some people the wrong way like the punishing nature of the game the way you can just be starving at times and trying to

desperately figure out how to be able to do anything really on a turn because you made some poor decisions earlier some people love that and some people hate that and in particular I'd like it but it's a neutral point because it is a bit of a mixed bag with how it's going to interact with many other people out there neutral number two is pretty simple when it comes to the overall feeling around the table as you're playing this game it is a pretty dry experience and for some people like me that's totally fine but for other people that is gonna be a very large negative to the overall experience in that they're trying to get like there when you're playing this game you do not feel like you are brewing beer you feel like you were doing math yeah you're trying to figure out you know how you're gonna do this and you add these together and you know with the money you're like doubling the money to figure out if you can make this make sense and then you're taking these tokens in like four plus four and that it takes that up there and is that enough and here's crunchy country country and then crunching on what your opponents are doing and I have no problem with that but for some people this game will be probably irredeemable like it'll be you will not be able to win them over with the wonderful decisions and planning and all that kind of stuff that goes in because they just get so turned off by how dry the overall experience is and that's I've been unfortunate that's why this is a neutral point it's just something I figure you should know about going in okay let's not move into the negative section and I have two that I want to cover and the first has to do with the objectives that you are working towards as you're playing the game it's those barrel tokens the 12 of them that you put out in the middle of the table every time you play and there's two things in particular that bug me and I think are problems with this mechanic the first is that you always play with all 12 of them

so there's no variability from gaming game as far as what objectives you're trying to go for they're all available all the time and twelve just if you like a lot I think with 12 need some people to go for these and some people go for those it doesn't feel like you are super competing on many of them there are a couple that in general everybody competes on but I just feel like there's too many and I wish that some were restricted so that from game to game you would have different things to go after and the other thing that bugs me probably a little bit more is that they are all so late-game focused like if they are you know have scored all of your different fields or have one of your resources hit 20 or fill up all of your shady side or your sunny side of the field these are not easy things to do and sure you'll be able to likely accomplish many of these by the very end of the game but most of those that you accomplish will probably be on the final round of the game or maybe the final two rounds if you're in the four player game which is six rounds total and I have a problem with that because two of the locations on the overall path that you're running around the only thing you do are there is you stop there and you collect all the objectives that you have achieved and that means that you effectively ignore those locations until the last twenty to ten percent of the game and that's just not as interesting as I think it could have been if maybe there was some variable objectives so they're different from game to game and have some of them be achievable on the second round of the game because you lose quite a bit of momentum by stopping your monk off onto a spot to grab those objectives it's not giving getting you engine type resources they can put down so you can do better later on the game and I would love to have the decision in the mid game to be do I stop my monk

here in order grab those objectives or do I want to jump for once and take that four barley token and I don't like that you pretty much ignore those objectives I feel like the objectives could be totally overhauled have less of them come out each game and just have them be a variety of like late game stuff or mid game stuff and maybe even early game stuff like have an objective be achievable on the very first round around the table and maybe how it'd be worth less points I just think that this is a wonderful idea like having objectives is great because it directs the players but I feel like that mechanic in this game kind of tripped on his shoelaces and fell down now we have a negative number two and I will admit that this is gonna sound like the tiniest nitpick but I'm gonna do it anyway except when it comes to the shed scoring you add up all the numbers around the shed and then you look to this graph on your player board and there are a bunch of different regions that these the number is going to fall into and the issue that I have is that it seems like the 12 to 17 range is by far the worst of any of them on any of the other ones that you can score like the rest of them feel like they have great moments when you might want to do them like 0 to 7 gives you 6 Brewer bumps up on your track although you don't get to activate anything on your board 6 is a gigantic movement for your Brewer then you go to the 8 to 11 you get 3 Brewer bumps which is great and then you get to activate one of the things around that shed well you find the best one you activate it that's great but then you get to 12 to 17 you now get to activate two things around your shed they have to be opposite each other and your Brewer only moves once and when you go above that from the 18 to 23 your Brewer also moves once but now you get to activate three of them so it feels like the moment you

take over into the 12 like like 11 is so much better than 12 the moment he hit 12 you're really bummed and I figured maybe from a design perspective 12:17 is the most common range so they figure they had to make it a little bit worse but I will say that from the games that I played so far the best Brewer movement I've ever seen is somebody getting into just the very beginnings of the two-two-one section so no one's even gotten close to the one-to-one area and I really feel like they should have made the 12 to 17 as exciting as the rest of the shed scoring's like shed scoring is a fun a part of the game like you are constantly working towards it I don't like that the game kind of disincentivizes you from this one region like you're actively trying to dodge the 12 to 17 versus the other ones you might be trying to go up a little bit to get the thing that you want but you just never want 12 to 17 it's just really bad so why isn't it - why doesn't it go 6 movement 3 to 1 instead of 6 3 1 1 I just I don't get it I'm sure they're reasons for it from their testing but from my plays I almost want to just house rule it and just make it a 2 so that I feel less bad about doing those 12 to 17 scoring but again this probably feels like huge and a pig but I want to bring it up it's something that we have definitely talked about around the table when we've been playing okay let's now talk about the variability for heaven and ale and from my perspective I think it's just slightly less than I expected going in and there are two things that are kind of pushing and pulling here the first thing is pulling and that should have made it way less than expected and that is the thing I already talked about in negative number one I feel like having all 12 of the objectives out every single time you sit down to play the game does not incentivize you to play

one game differently from the next it kind of said as well you kind of do everything that you you're gonna get there's an objective for kind of four high strategies for low strategies for some strategies for Shane strategies they're all viable every single time you sit down to play the game and okay that's fine but from a variability perspective I want more I would like one game to be like the shady one came out and the sunny one didn't okay in a prioritize shade and that kind of thing but the reason that I'm not saying this is way less than expected just a little less than expected is because I have noticed that every time I've sit down sat down to play the game I have evolved into a different strategy based off of the options that have been presented towards me like the order in which the ingredients are randomly dispersed around the pen down on the path are gonna change things you know I don't sit down and say I'm gonna try to do a high-value game today I sit down and I'm like oh really good move for me is to take this five and the next time I'm like how does the five over there I'll get that one that's a pretty good move for me and then the next one I'm like well I have two fives already I should get another five because I do that X chorong and get a whole bunch of stuff and before I know it I have six fives around my table and I have barely filled in anything but I have this really high value strategy and the next time I sit down to play maybe I fill in every single spot on my board with all this low value stuff and my Brewer goes really far so the game does push and pull you in different ways to play differently from from each time you sit down to play the game I just wish that the objectives had been tweaked so that the variability would be quite high as opposed to being not quite where I had hoped it would be when it comes to player account heaven and ale supports two to four players and I played all those player accounts and my feeling is that the two player game is it's okay

the three player game is great and the four player game is the best way to play this game and this game does a couple funky things when it comes to player account different than I would normally expect so in general with board games they try to scale for a certain time frame that you're gonna be playing like if it's a four player game you play less rounds so that it takes about same amount of time as a two-player game and how to nail it's the inverse in a two-player game you do three rounds in a three player game you do four rounds and in a four player game you do six rounds and so that's a lot of extra rounds that you're doing and I get the idea of it because in a two-player game there's just one opponent who's gonna be gathering at these different tokens and you don't remove any of the tokens from the path so that's a whole bunch of different actions that you could do and I haven't mapped it out but it wouldn't surprise me if in a two-player game you do a similar issue of actions to a four player game because in that four player game there's all those opponents who are just eating up all those different tokens but the difference is that well there's just a lot more thinking that goes into play when you have six rounds versus three like that's six different plans that you're making as opposed to three different plans and I found that the two-player game was like 40 ish minutes long that the three player game was a little over an hour and the four player game was close to two hours and part of that maybe just analysis paralysis and the the players that I was playing around the table but there is a lot of stuff to think about there's a lot of planning a lot of country to do and so normally in given all this data I would say that three player is the best way to play the game but I feel like four player game is the full game like the way it comes in the box in particular because of those objectives in the three player game that's just one

less person who is going to be vying for you trying to compete for grabbing some of those objectives with 12 different objectives to go for that's a huge variety in the three player game that I played I picked up six of them and only two of them my opponents were competing with me for like four of them I was just completely uncontested I got them with no problem and I think at a four player game it would have been much more likely that somebody would have been trying to contest some of those and pulled some of those points away from me so yeah I think that it's fine and all these player counts and three was quite good but I remember after doing those four rounds in the three player game I kind of felt like yeah it just when you do six rounds it just felt like a more complete version of the game even though it might have been a similar number of turns but either way I would definitely play all those player accounts again two was fine I mean you definitely get the fun having male experience at a much smaller time frame but I will also say from a planning perspective it's a little less interesting because it's just one person and one action between every single one of the pics that you do around the map and so it's a little less punishing which is gonna be good for some people but not necessarily something that I gravitate towards in conclusion I played having a nail three times at this point and it has honestly surprised me I've really enjoyed playing this game and I went into it with some pretty low expectations I picked this one up as a review copy at essence field last year and I heard that it was a move down a path as far as do you want type game and I do like that but then I also heard some whispering about this weird clunky scoring at the end and that kind of turned me off a little bit so then I ended up sitting down reading the rules and I remember feeling like okay that's straightforward okay that's straightforward that makes sense that makes sense and then I got to the very

end with the ratio conversion that multiplying that by a modifier based off where your Brewer got to and I remember sitting there thinking what the heck this is stupid like why would they design the game like that like that just seems so dumb and did that disincentivize me from playing the game and it honestly it took another good month month and a half before I got it played and once I finally did sit down and be like you know what I've got to try this game lots of people are talking about it lots of people are enjoying it I should see if it's as bad as it seems on paper and I played that first game and I was like whoa actually that was really cool and then I played a second game like three days later and I was like woah no this is really cool and I got a third play in like just a couple days after that and I don't usually play a game three times within a seven day or so time frame but that did happen with this one and every single time I played this one I loved the decisions that I was making I loved the planning that I was doing and I grew to love that weird scoring that happens at the end of the game because of how it kind of tweaks this kind of familiar scoring style of having the lowest thing be the thing that scores for you like I like that if I'm going heavy on water for instance the game doesn't hit me with a stick for taking more water like I may as well like I'm denying water for my opponents I already have a bunch of water down on here in fact if I peg out I'll get even more money for hitting that twenty and then every time I hit it again I get more money and money is definitely a good thing to have around I just was really surprised by how much I enjoyed this game even though it's a relatively dry experience just the way everything came together worked so well and I will say as a caveat but I have not lost this game yet and in fact the last two games

that I played I blew my opponents out of the water like almost doubling their score in the four player game and actually doubling their score in the three player game that I played so I have to admit that maybe that's part of the reason I enjoyed this game so much like winning is fun but at the same time the actual process of playing and in that that three player game I honestly was not convinced that I was going to win in the middle part of the game but are still really enjoying the decisions I was making and the plans I was making and the tension of trying to figure out you know how much can I push my luck can I go ahead and grab this thing right next to me and that monk will still be available on my next turn how likely is this person to take it how likely is that person to take it and yours constantly crunching one of my poems gonna do what are they gonna are they gonna get my way oh they're not gonna get into my way when they go ahead and do that thing that I desperately wanted you like throw your hands up you're like ah that was my that was what I wanted to do ah man that there with everything and but usually when I say that every person in front of me is like nah dude I would have done that too it's like okay well I was never gonna get access to that I guess I miss playing that one time to come up with a new plan and I do enjoy the planning when it comes into this game and I just really feel like the big problem with this game is the objectives I really really really wish the objectives had been designed differently so that they would have injected injected much more variability into each play of the game in particular to actually have doing achieving objectives in the middle part of the game be a viable thing I just really hate how they're all endgame objectives like at this point I almost feel like they should just be in game scoring like why even bother having the spaces on the map if you only ever go into them in the very last round or maybe the second-to-last round it just it feels

like a bit of a trip up and an overall very enjoyable gaming experience and way more fun than I was expecting going in and I'm not sure how many more times I'm gonna play it if I'm being honest like the variability is a potential issue I do think I'm gonna play it again because I'm pretty high on it right now I've really enjoyed the plays maybe next time I sit down to play it I'll just get smoked and I'll be like okay cool it was just a fluke for those first couple games I played but either way I do recommend this game it is much more than the sum of its parts from what I have been able to see it's been a highly enjoyable experience and definitely one that feels different than your average game like it does not feel like oh I'm sitting down to play worker placement game or I'm gonna sit down to play sex election game I feel like I'm sitting down to play a game that feels new and different and that's not always a good thing like not everybody's gonna enjoy that but I certainly have as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting my channel through patreon including all of these producers level pledges if you to like to directly support the channel you could do so at patreon.com slash strong against games and I'd really appreciate it also if you like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved