Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Old King's Crown Second Printing & New Songs of Home Expansion - Kickstarter Critique Review

Transcript 24:49

I'm back again today for another Kickstarter critique where I take a look at a different Kickstarter tabletop game project every weekday at 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. Give my honest thoughts on how the project is being read. If you enjoy that sort of content, please be sure to click on that subscribe button or consider supporting my upcoming Kickstarter later this year where you'll be able to purchase your own Kickstarter critique as a gift for grandma. Uh but today I am absolutely fascinated to check out the old King's Crown second printing and new Songs of Home expansion. This is a game that I know absolutely nothing about except that it is much beloved. Looking at the main image, I see art. Unimpressed. I'm sure it's nice art, but I'd like to know more. Player like time count, age, awards, mechanisms, anything. But we've got this game people want. And look at that. 49.7 to 13.3. That feels like a dang good conversion rate right there.

This is from Eerie Idol Games. The Old King crowns a one to four player large scale strategy board game of skill and intrigue. Set an ancient crumbling kingdom where every card is a window into a fantastical land. Clash with your opponent's forces across the map. V for control of political councils and journey to wild sights of power. The kingdom welcomes you once more with a second printing of the old king's crown, as well as an expansive new expansion that introduces new factions, neutral kingdom cards, and exciting ways to help you claim the throne. Okay, man. Like to know more like know a little bit more mechanisms aside from competitive multiplayer fantasy card game. But hey, I'm intrigued. I suppose I honestly I'm more intrigued by why is this thing doing? $2.3 million. That's a huge chunk of cash. As always with the video, I'm thinking of three things. Do I want it? Can you do it? How much is it? That's what you can got to convince the Kickstarter backers to get their money. Let's see how they decide to do it.

The old kingdom welcomes you once more.

A song drifts over fields, tilled and sewn, stitched in crowns of gold. It is joined by the south voice keen and high like wind amongst the rushes.

Dart and theme. It is sung by people of land, those of root and bud, and by the bright abundance all about them.

And let's be quite frank, it's not even really that much about theme. It's mostly just them talking about stuff and art, but they're not talking about the theme of the game. It doesn't feel like I don't know. The song travels to distant shores and finds the last of a line of knights and heroins of old.

Oh, okay. Now we're getting the theme.

Those who traveled too far and too long and in their wandering forgot who they were.

Was that a Borg? I think that was just art. More art.

Now their voices join the song, remembering the land and the home they left so very long ago. Finally, the song takes on a new chorus, one of chrome and alabaster stone, sung on a ship of gold that sheds the anchoring weight of the world and rides always against the sun, to the city, over the sea. Imagine how much this video would suck if you were blind. Like, that does not feel like a good Kickstarter video. I'm not excited about this game. Like, hey, you have artwork. It looks nice. Cool.

Moving on. But they're like, nah, we got to go the first one minute and 28 of our 1 minute and 45 seconds to showcase artwork and loosely loosely tie the theme. Ick. Dual layered boards, nice looking components, lots of text. Okay, that was that was a fun game.

And which will be your song of home?

Okay, you mentioned the expansion there. Cool. Uh, after the video, do I want it? No. Can you do it? I got $2 million. So, yeah. And it doesn't look like it's a fairly impressive game component-wise. Not to insult the game by any means. I mean, like, making that board game does not look difficult to manufacture. And then, how much is it? Uh, it's a big box. I know that. What's this? This is the announcement trailer. Let's see what this can skip to this time. Oh,

okay.

To create.

What? Actually, you're going to talk about some theme here and how it works.

Is this a different Is this a spin-off game?

Okay, we'll get into that. 70 bucks. That's not a bad price, though. That's how we started off there. That's great. And that's a uh Okay. So immediately, how much is it? Not bad at all. Like I know this is a muchbeloved game. I wish you would have spotlighted some rewards. Hopefully you are some awards that you've won and all that stuff and why people love this game. But that's a great way to lead off. Uh let's check out see what you have done in the past. Old King's Crown second. So they that's the first time on kick uh game found. So let's see game. Oh no. Kickstarter. Let's check out the track record over on the old Kickstarter. Tale of Royalty, Rebels and Russes. It's by Ruses. All right. So, it made 435,000 bucks. Wow. Good for them.

They're up for over a million. Excellent. Let's make sure people got their stuff though. Eerie Idol Games. So, just one. This is their baby. Okay, cool. Love to know more about your game instead of your art. All right. So, let's make sure people got their stuff. I'm going to assume it went well if they're making over this millions of dollars. Hello everyone. I hope your weekend's off to a great start. As promised, our most recent update. We're back with another of our free guides for Old King's Crown. This time with a focus on two things. Uh, okay. Cool. My copy arrived in Fuket today. A big shout out to Andrew K and your rattles. Cool. Getting in South Africa. So, people are getting the stuff all over the world. Cool. Good customer service it looks like. Excellent. So, can you do it? Yes.

Do I want it? Still out there. How much is it? It's nice. It's not bad at all. Kickstarter reasonable, especially for that big box. Honestly, it doesn't feel like a terrible price at all. Return to the Kingdom. The Old King's Crown is a competitive one to four player strategy board game of royalty, rebels, and rues. The soldout game returns for its second printing alongside expansive new expansion. Songs of home. This I already read that. Okay. So, one to four players bumps it up to 60 to 120. Great. Some theme. It's a board. It's a game. Hey, it looks like this. Neat. Sharps it down. Said, "The Old King Crowns is a phenomenal board game that absolutely deserves your attention. This type of rare box that's able to induce the kind of bounding enthusiasm, the excitement that gets you daydreaming about when you're next to get it to the table that promises that sends a little shiver through you as each rule rattles rich with possibility."

So, I get why they have this first like a shut up and sit down recommendation creme creme, right? Like of of YouTubers. I would say one of them, right? So, but what specifically about this game? They just they just told me how great the game was. I still am like, okay, but but why? Like, what what makes it great? Is the Old King crowds 2025's best board game. Okay, so there's a video you want to watch. Awesome. Likely that. Love a quote. Well, there is a quote. I love a quote that actually tells me more. Gameplay that favors wit, strategy, and decisive gambits. Multi-use cards that encourage clever combos and creative thinking. Nice high replay replayability and varied ways to approach interacting with players in the kingdom. Now that's the one I like. Regions to claim councils to hold sights of powers to journey towards over 200 rival cards, 30 plus deluxe wooden pieces, dual layered player boards, a lavish kingdom board, and much more. An innovative and expansive solo mode that allows you to forge new automated rivals that alter the very rules of the game.

And that shot right there, that's a nice one. Okay, like it like how we start there. A grand kingdom board. I wish you was in I wish all You know what? I like this, but I wish you would have just put that in there in your video instead of just, hey, here's some art. Here's a guy who's got green eyes. Neat. Over 200 beautifully illustrated cards. We got it. We get it. You like your artist. Moving on. One of the 30 large screen printed wooden pieces, plus a fullyfledged solo over 100 cardboard tokens more. Excellent. Excellent. And 70 bucks. Reasonable price. A note for existing owners of the old King's Crown base game. If you own the first print of the old King's Crown base game, please note this second printing is identical in terms of components, rules, and wordings. No need to repurchase and you are looking unless you're looking for an additional copy. That's nice to know.

Game of the year from noon included. This is what I'm talking about. This I go back to that main image and how much I don't like it. I feel like this right here could have gone so well around the outside. But the fact that we're here, great. That with a $70 price, I'm in. Good videos. They do they get any quotes for that? They just got the awards. Okay. Hopefully they answer the quotes scattered about. The Wild Kingdom, the game's first expansion returns now with a second printing under the new title. The Wild Kingdom. Uh The Wild Kingdom, the game's first expansion, returns now with the second printing under the new title. Oh, it's now the wild. It's the waking kingdom instead of the wild kingdom. Okay. Wonder if that was like some trademark thing or something. Who knows? So, they're reprinting this the expansion that was out. Okay. Whatever. People want the game. They're getting another print run. Free golden ship coin. All backers who order it. Great. Cool stuff.

I'm in. How much am I paying for everything? This what I know. Oh, that's the anulment. So, this is the other thing. You got another game you're shoving in here. Trying to get on that Gwet thing, you know, like, hey, we got a game in the game, guys. Neat. I don't really want it. Uh, I guess if I wanted to know more, I could watch these videos. Feel like a personal touch would have been nice there. Like I feel like that would have been a nice way to like kind of wrap that up in the video. Like, oh yeah, we also have, you know, a game inside the world. But we'll see how they sold it here. I don't think it's going to be great. An amalorean wooden upgrade pack screen printed wooden player faction markers. I think it will be roughly one to one though. That's my prediction. I'm going to go one to one. The deluxified with the expan. Well, actually, I don't know. This is a hard one to gauge because it's going to be because it's not returning backers, is it? Because returning backers already have the expansion. They just changed the name of it. I don't know. I have no idea how to gauge this one. Very interesting. All right, so we got uh add-ons.

Okay. Love the prices of your other stuff before you start talking about the prices about your add-ons, but okay. Here we go. This the shipping prices. Oh, it's it's We're getting there. We're getting there. This feels all out of order. Quick 2026 delivery, English edition. Quick 2026 delivery other language. Quick 202 combined 2027 delivery all languages. Okay, so they're taking advantage of that new game found feature. Love to see it. Means Game Found's got a hit. If if people are like, "Yeah, we want this." Publishers are like, "We need this. This is great." Uh, quick delivery. You must block this. I got it. Already owe the old king's crown. You do not need to choose a reward tier and can instead skip straight to the add-on section. Okay. So, that's what I was thinking.

Yeah. So, 70 bucks for the base game, 8,232. Wow. Good for you. People are just chomping at the bits for this game. Let's see where this thing racks up. Board game key. Wow, that's a heck of a number. Old King's Crown. Why? Because I didn't put the Come on, PG. You know what I meant. You know what I meant. Top 10,00. Yeah, makes sense. Top 10,00 reprint with uh weird expansion, but it's not an expansion. Just changed the name. All right. The Old King crowns base game. Other languages 500 print run. Old Crown's base game. Add any language. The late one, 1200. Okay. I don't need it now. Is it different? Is it different in price? No, it's the same price. Okay.

Allin add-on bundle. new content plus the Waking Kingdom expansion. So, is this a new expansion? I don't even know. I'm sure if I'm a fan, this is much cleaner to understand because either yes, I have the expansion or no, I don't. I think it's really interesting how they chose to do everything in the add-on section. And I hate it personally because it gives us less information on what people are purchasing, right? like this pledge right here. I was excited to see how many people were going to be like, "All right, we'll get the deluxified, but we'll also throw out on this enulment." Then it's like, "Oh, yeah, we'll also go deluxified enulment." And now they take away that information by putting in the add-on section, which, you know, boohoo to us. But still, it does make it feel more organized, right? Like it's like, "All right, different language right now or later.

Expansions. Cool. Add-ons. It's clean. It's clean. What's in the box? I feel like the organization was poor, though. Uh, okay. So, 52 bucks. This felt like should have been way higher, but whatever. No, no, no, no. Whatever. I totally 1,000% think this should be way higher. One kingdom board, one council tile, four dual layer player boards, uh, the large screen printed wooden heralds. But yeah, cuz you were telling me about the prices of add-ons, and a bunch of other random crap before I even got to this, like showing me what's in the game and how much I should pay for it. Looks good. Fancy art. Tarotized cards. Yippity yappity. Looks good. Okay. Is this the expansion? What is this? We just got to Oh, this is the solo thing. Awesome. How to play.

Yep. Yep. Oh, okay. So, we got a full how to play video. We got a couple. Wow. Couple. He put the definitive guy. I should do that. What I do? If I ever copy somebody else's rule book. If I ever do I shouldn't say copy. If you ever do a how to play video of someone else that's already somebody's already do a how to play video on I just need to put the definitive guide. That's actually not like if you saw that you'd be like I feel like I should click on that one. Especially if it's newer too it's like two years newer. You'd be like what's changed? Nothing but I tricked you. All right. Meet the factions. Okay. Cool stuff. I don't care. Solo mode. Neat. How do Oh, this is fagger. They got some great stuff down here just buried. Uh, how to play the solo mode. Awesome. Free gift. Oh, we talked about this earlier, I think.

Maybe. All backers who have the songs of hope expansion to their order will receive a deluxe metal gold ship coin as a free gift. Bottom line is they're still selling nearly 10,000 of the base game. Like, that is so good. Like, just kudos to them. And you know what? It honestly makes sense. I'm not typically a big fan of that whole like, oh yeah, here's this other game we're also just kind of flopping out for you to check out like they're doing with anulment. Like, we kind of care about it, but you know, it doesn't deserve its own Kickstarter, but it's like, yeah, you have 10,000 paying customers already. Why not just take those numbers, play those odds that they'll throw on the extra 30 to 60 bucks, you know, while they're already just giving you Yeah. Like, I get it. I get it. I think it's smart.

Oh, hey, that game we were talking about. It's got art and uh fancy components and uh stuff. It's got a rule book like deep 5642. That's my board game geek prediction for that game right there. 5642. Why? Because it will inevitably disappoint people that like this game. And besides, 564.2 is not a bad rating. Like that's like more hits than misses for sure. Uh, play it on tabletop. Read the rule booklet. Oh, it's Why am I I don't care about that. All right. Oh, so hey, here's the Waking Kingdom. The Wild Kingdom returns with a new name. The Waking Kingdom. This new packaging of the expansion features all the same gameplay for the Wild Kingdom, but removes the metal influence tokens and cloth bag. Don't worry, these are still available as part of this campaign is separate add-on. The Waking Kingdom includes seven modules that you can freely mix and match with the base game and each other. So they took out some of the expensive stuff and changed the name.

Weird, but hey, I want it. I need it. Tabletop simulator rule booklet languages stuff things go. Great job localizing that. All right, shipping. What do we got? United States 13 bucks. That's quick delivery 2026. Home in and out 90 bucks. That's not bad. 90 bucks for a top 1,000 board game geek. Probably what, like 120ish, 130 if I'm getting the expansion. That feels reasonable, right? This feel clearly feels like a boutique style game, a game found style game, you know, with the big tarot cards and oh, the the box that's an interesting shape like it it's got that uh like that what is it? The Vladimir Sushi. Is that his size too that he uses kind of roughly that size?

I'm thinking of the guy who does stuff for Eagle Griffin games. Quote, I think on Mars. Okay. Campaign page. You know, they got a lot of stuff there, but it actually was pretty brisk, right? Like I felt like they fit a lot in there. It answered all my questions. Let's check out the comments. I was going to check out FAQ updates comments. Give it a grade. Overall, solid grade. I think that that award thing was really well done. I think it should just be higher and more prominent, right? Like put that on the outside. Showcase those awards updates. Developer D. The art and theme of the abundance. Explore the first of many developer dials as we take a closer look at the art and the theme. Thanks. Okay. You know, and here's the thing. I don't get it. And I don't have to get it. I know people love it. Like when I hear people say, "Oh, I bought it for the art alone." Like a part of me just dies inside. I'm like, "Really? There's so many great games that are way better potentially than that game." at least ranking wise and like ah uh but then again I'm also a content creator a I call myself a reviewer I don't know I hate the word term content creator honestly I like reviewer but and and I so I'm used to prototypes with no art at all so it's always just been mechanisms that that I really care that much about but there's a huge chunk of people they're getting into this good for them they're leaning into it and if that and here's the thing that's their brand now right this This is how you develop brand loyalty. They're going to get the people

who really like how deep they are going into the art and the theme and how like so great. I don't want to be the kingdom of that kingdom. This is why I love the one of the old kings crowd. Have the courage and love for one's own universe to follow what feels right instead of falling into the trap of an overused stereotype. Chooses depth over cheap edgginess. Okay. I don't know. I read it with that tone. I don't even know what I'm talking about here. But yeah, people love it. Top 1000. I want to play it because it's top 10,000 game and I also love the fact you're localizing it. Like the fact that they get this all these different languages, great for them. I'm really looking forward to the game and I think it'd be a great experience in our board game crew. However, as a German back, I'm a bit lost confused. I understand there's no German version of the campaign and that it'll be available from Spiels. As far I can see though, only the base game will the expansion not be available in German. Oh, okay. Nice. They already have people localizing it in the different countries which means they can offer it. Oh, which I imagine makes it really potentially nice for them. uh the game found having that new feature. Oh, that's interesting.

Will the expansions also be produced by the Italian Italian language partner? Just is this is that should be that feels like an FAQ of the first two people asking that feels like an FAQ. Will there be changes between the first Well, is there no option? Can I still use trash bay? Not addressed. So hopefully they put that in there because it feels like that is the hot button topic right now. With the massive backlog of pledges on the projects, do you believe this will affect the timeline for the campaign either positive or negative? I know it's a hard question. Give the logistics about it. With the massive backing of pledges on this project. Oh, hey, it's a great question. Know the number of backers shouldn't have any significant thing. Cool. Yeah, like board game manufacturers, the larger the print run, the more excited they are, right? Like, and this is coming from someone who worked for a board game manufacturer. I got to take a tour of other different board game manufacturers in China. And it's like, yeah, that's because if you can set up an assembly line, it makes everything so much easier and you can pump it out and you can come right back to it easier.

And it's so yeah, they will the manufacturers will be like, "Oh, yeah, you want to go from 5,000 to 15,000." Yeah, we can make that happen, right? It seems for the YouTube feedback, the rule books, the first edition is a bit hard to read. Did you update it? This is the second printing rather than the second edition. So there are no changes to the rule booklet. Thanks Andrew. That's really strange here because the rule booklet got overwhelming your great feedback. The majority of content I've seen. However, I think the specifics of action commands is probably what they're referring to. Great. In here doing customer service. All right. Final grade. Do I want it? I don't think you did a great job selling it to me in the video at all. Like a really terrible job. Just

the song travels to distant shores. Like just just if you're not here for the art, this video is terrible until you get to like the last 16 seconds. I'm like, "Oh, that looks like a fun game." If you're here for the art though, yeah, can you do it? I think you're over the moon. Whatever. Um, but once we got into it, you started to showcase the awards, you know, medium weight, 60 to 120 minutes, the components, the quotes, like there's tons of videos, a plethora of information to make an informed decision. So, the can you do it? The do I want it? I feel like they are eventually both answered yes. Now, the how much is it? Doesn't feel bad. And probably part of the reason why it doesn't feel bad is because they don't have that stupid $240 pledge that's just sitting there, right? Or the 190. It's all okay, 70 bucks. Then you go add everything else on the back end. You go you take this to the take this to the cash register and we can figure out what extra stuff we want to ring you up for.

And I think it's I don't think it's I I don't think it's bad. I think it makes for a cleaner shopping experience for what they have going. I don't think it's for every campaign, but I think for how much stuff that they have in the add-ons and how varied it is. Because look, we got expansion, we got a different game, we got just metal influence tokens, we got just metal this, we got this, like that. like one, two, three, like four, seven, 10, 13 SKs right there. So, yeah, I think they did good there. So, how overall sounded great. Going to go with a A minus. Yeah, I think A minus is fair.

Like leaning off with that quote and then, you know, segueing down to key this key features part right here. Honestly, as a gamer, I still think they could have done even more. Like top 1,000 on board game geek. But right here, this did it. I would put this higher, but this did it. Game of the year, nine out of 10, 10 out of 10. Top 10, Tom's 10, you know, boom, done. Like much beloved, reasonable price, a minus. Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for the old king's crowd, second printing, and new songs of home expansion. And if you backed it, did you get a nullet? Let me know in the comments below. And if you have a request for a specific project you'd like to see covered, be sure to leave that in the comments below. Have yourself a good one. Bye-bye. That's the wrong thing. It's It's uh It's this one.

Yep, there it is.

Progress saved