Sobek: 2 Players Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at sobek two players which believe it or not is a two player only board game designed by bruno cathala and sebastian paul sean this one takes around 20 minutes to play on average before i get into my thoughts on sobek i want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kianda dot co dot uk who are my go to online retailer here in the uk and if you use my link in the show notes or the cheeky qr code there then you can get five percent off your first order okay so a game of sobek two players is going to look like this we have this main board which has been filled up with all these tiles now there's two types of tiles you've got these good ones and which are all these different kind of resources and livestock and things and you also have these character tiles which have been placed face down now the character tiles are all referenced on this very useful little player sheet here which shows what all the different powers do and um so you know what to use when they come up you've also got these bonus tiles or tokens which have been placed to the side of the board here so there are five of these which will be acquired by the players when they end up taking an action to sell goods but we'll talk about that later and there's also some bonus tokens here which can come into play if certain characters are activated you've also got a bag full of devon tokens here now these are like bonus coins you can get which are worth victory points at the end of the game um each player is going to start with a couple of starting tiles and you're also going to have one of these little tiles here to show where your corruption tiles will go and we'll talk about what that means later you've
got this arc piece which is going to be used to navigate the main board you've got the towel stack and so on okay so how does the game actually work so first turn in the game the first play is going to start wherever they want on this middle square here and they can place this ankh um on one of those tokens so let's just say um i took this one here just start collecting this um this hay or wheat whatever it is and then the player who took that is going to orientate the ankh in the direction where these lines are so you can see here on the tile i've just taken it's got a horizontal line so therefore the arc will orientate like so now what this means is that the next player can only ever move on a horizontal line so let's just say they ended up going uh here like so so they'd land on that tile and then they would pick that one up and add it to their hand now you can see that one was pointed diagonally so the arm could end up like this therefore the following player could move in a diagonal direction like so they might jump here like this and add it to their hand and again it would stay in that orientation however you do not actually have to take the first tile in that row or the direction that you're traveling you can't actually skip over tiles so let's just say the falling player chose to skip over this car on because they're not interested and they go to this one like so again they would take that into their hand as normal but the one they skipped over this one here would go on to their corruption tile like so and that could be worth negative points at the end of the game so besides from moving the ark and
collecting a tile and potentially corruption tiles you can sell some goods and when you do that you're going to have to have at least three of the same type or you can use these sobek tokens as wilds and when you do that you're going to have to collect those three tiles that you want to sell or more you know there could be four five six no matter how many you want to spend as long as it's at least three then you can sell them for end game scoring now the way these score are that you're going to multiply the number of goods by the number of scabs on that good or on those goods so at the moment we've got three here times two this is gonna be worth six points at the moment and also whenever you take a sell action as long as there are some available you are going to have a look at these tokens here and utilize one of them and these do all different kind of things and you can actually look at any of them and take your pick but let's have a look at what some of them do and again using this rather useful little sheet here so you've got this like pyramid one here that lets you take a full turn again uh you've got this one here where you can place this token on one of your previously sold sets corresponding to one of the three types shown and it adds two scarabs to that set so it makes it a lot more valuable you've got this one here that adds all the tiles currently on your corruption board back into your hand so you can actually sell them rather than potentially suffer negative points i got this one here that gives these some tokens to your opponent and they must keep it close to the corruption board and it counts as extra corruption points you got this one here which is simply worth seven points this one here where it says you can keep this token and to grant you two points at the end of the game also you get to draw a devon token
from the back we'll talk about the devon tokens shortly this one here lets you draw two dubbing tokens and keep one and this one here lets you place this token on a tile of your choice amongst the ones in the line indicated by the orientation of the ankh and i believe your opponent has to take that one so you can also see that some of these tiles have a coin on them and this is what the debian tokens refer to so if you ever end up taking one of those tokens and say you weren't really you was not really interested in starting to build up one of those sets you can sacrifice that tile in order to draw from the bag here and these bags are going to contain tokens which look like this and these range in values from three to nine i believe so there's quite a swing in the value of points that they are worth now the third and final thing you can do on your turn is to use one of these character tiles so let's just say for example um in a previous round this play would have taken this one and taken this character tile they would have had it in their hand but it's going to take a whole turn to use it so you can either use it for its ability which we'll talk on in a minute but you can also use it as a goods type so you can see that all these characters have a particular type of good there so you can actually put it in a in a little set here to sell it rather than utilize its ability and all the character tiles abilities are on the sheets here so you've got this architect that lets you randomly draw three of these tokens and use one essentially uh you've got this high priester here which lets you remove some of the tiles on your corruption board from the game and you can either choose between all the sobek
statues including the architect or all the tiles of a single goods type so you'll actually shed some of your potential corruption you've got the quarter sand here that lets you add one or two tiles from your hand to a previously sold set of tiles the merchants lets you take any tile currently available anywhere on the market into your hand without moving the arm or taking any corruption and so on as you so you can see what these kind of things are going to do now if there's ever a time where you cannot take a legal move then you are going to have to replenish the board back up with the remaining tiles however if there are no tiles left in the stack and nobody can do a legal move then the game is going to end and then final scoring is going to get calculated so at the end of the game you're going to work out points as follows bearing in mind that you would actually have more tiles than this i'll just use this as an example um so of course you're going to multiply your goods by the scarabs on them and these are the ones that you've already sold so you can see here this is going to be three times six for 18 points because it's three good types times the six um scarabs on them uh this one here again is going to be three times two for six points this one here is going to be one two three four five tiles times two scarabs so that's going to be ten points you're going to add any of these dubbin tokens and also if you have any tiles left in your hand and you can make a set of them you are going to just discard them however if you do not have a full set they are going to go into your corruption pile as follows and then
corruption is going to get worked out now the way that the corruption works is that you are going to calculate how many tokens you've collected as corruption as the game goes on or tiles i should say and compare it to your opponents so this player here has five corruption and this player here has eight i've worked out as and the player who has the fewest or the you know the least amount of um corruption is going to draw a bonus sobek tile and add it to their final scoring tally like so um and also for every three tiles that you have less than your opponent so again this player has eight this player has five and you're going to get to draw another devin token so you're already incentivized to try and at least stay level with your opponent to stop giving them that luck of the draw okay so now we know how to play sobek let's share some thoughts on the gameplay and some of the core mechanisms here and let's start with the orientation of the art because i think this is a really neat idea you know wherever you take from and not only are you going to of course collect that good but you are going to always kind of lay the foundation for your opponent's turn and you want to be using that quite carefully because you don't want to be leaving them core opportunities or key opportunities to grab the tiles they want you know if they're really collecting um cows you don't want to make it easy for them to get cows or at least if there is going to be a cow in their path you want to be making sure they're jumping over the other other tiles so they start gaining corruption which i think is a really neat idea so not only do you have to worry about what you're doing you also have to worry
about what your opponents are doing and what opportunities you're leaving them and you can actually use some of the other facets of the game to your benefit to you know to kind of manipulate that because if you have character tiles in your hand like like this one for example it's going to take your whole turn to use it therefore that you know you know that your opponent's gonna have to take two turns in a row basically to move the ankh which can work in your benefit you know if there's no goods that you wanted at all you might want to force your opponents to do to move it so therefore you can take the next turn which could be a better opportunity and you know tailor awards more towards your own personal strategy and the owns your own sets that you're trying to collect and that also ties into the selling mechanism because um you know you can use this selling mechanism as another stalling method can to make your opponent move the arc when you don't want to and but also that comes with a kind of double-edged sword really because you want to be selling things relatively early in sets of three you know when you first collect that set of threes so that you can get the benefits from one of these bonus tokens because these can be pretty damn useful and work to your benefit however you have to be quite careful um not to always sell them as soon as you get a set of three because you are taking a big risk because you could only ever sell them at least in a set of three meaning that if you sell a set of three and then you only end up collecting two more that's going to count as corruption points at the end of the game so it might be worth or equally useful to sell up door to save up all your goods tiles and then sell them as one big group you can mitigate that risk of having those remaining pieces and potentially costing you end game scoring now the corruption mechanism itself is a
really cool idea i generally love the idea of kind of risk and reward you know really wanting something that suits your strategy perfectly but to do that you're going to have to sacrifice something else and you know for example if i really wanted this so big tile i'll grab it i really want another one and so i jump onto this one but i end up taking this one as corruption so i love that idea however this is something that i didn't find influenced the game as much as i would have liked or hoped to um from the games i've had of this one it always seems like we played it relatively conservatively and ended up taking very few corruption titles however that is completely player driven so this is my own personal experience and i'm sure if you have more um kind of you know risk-taking style players um who aren't scared of taking that corruption then that's going to equally influence the other player because they're going to have that more wiggle room and leeway to take corruption themselves so it's a player driven thing um which can really can swing the game and on top of all that i actually do really like the scoring mechanism in this game you know multiplying the goods by the scabs on those goods and that means things have different worth you know if you are collecting a bunch of um the same tiles but you have hardly any scabs then you know that's going to be worth next to nothing for you so you're going to have to really go for where the scarabs are i also do quite like the flexibility but you can use the characters not only for their ability but also for the good on them gives you more flexibility and can again give you some back you out of a corner sometimes if you really need that third piece for a set
so we've talked about a lot of the positives here let's touch on a glaring negative at least in my opinion and to be honest i think most people would agree with this and that is the swinginess of these debin tokens because they do value in ranges from three all the way up to nine meaning that i could do the exact same thing as you do i get nine points you get three points and as the game goes on yes i mean the probabilities will say that they'll probably balance out and however that's not always going to be the case you know sometimes i could take a couple of devon draws i could get the eight and the nine you get the three and the four through no fault of your own i've gained a big net gain on you um and that could quite easily determine the winner and that for me considering this is essentially an abstract strategy game it feels really jarring and very deflating even if it works for or against you because you didn't do anything to earn those extra points and something that's less objective and more subjective to my own personal tastes i'm not quite sure i enjoy the mix of the kind of player powers and bonus tokens with such an abstract strategy game i tend to like abstracts to be as simple and as pure as possible because you can so you know deterministically do what you want to do and know how that affects other people but when there are these face down character tiles someone's going to land on them and then they're going to do something that you just couldn't predict and it's going to completely mess with you know your predictability of the game um now i understand that that's what cathala is kind of known for he has that kind of spiciness of all the different characters into his games and that's probably why i tend not to get on with
this game so well um but again that's more of a personal thing i just think the the hybrid of the wackiness of the characters with the abstract strategy nature of it it just doesn't quite sit right for me and despite some of those criticisms i do have to give the game a bit of grace because it does only take around 20 minutes to play and the level of depth here in you know in relation to that time frame is pretty damn good so you know even if you are a bit disgruntled because of a lucky tile draw or something um you're not gonna hold too much malice against the game because it is a simple quick filler the production for this game is fantastic to be honest um the ark piece is nice and chunky you nice wooden the tiles themselves are really good quality they have this kind of glossy finish to them and all the artwork on them is rather charming and it looks very pretty when it's on the table just a good quality well polished product and the same goes for the bag the player aides are really good you know nice and useful to put on the table for people to use and i believe on the reverse side of one of these you've got the score track as well to help you calculate those points at the end of the game okay so let's get into some final thoughts for sobek 2 players now i'm going to come straight and say that this game isn't really for me however 90 of that is due to subjective taste um because to be honest i think objectively the game is very well designed if you are a fan of abstract strategy games this one is definitely a top notch one um and if you like that kind of added spiciness of the player powers and tokens and things you're going to get a lot from it and this is definitely one of those games
where if you have two players who enjoy the game and you are consistently playing it with each other you are really going to raise each other's game and you're going to start getting more and more from it as you start to read the ball a bit better and be really careful about each opportunity you leave your opponent because yeah this is very deterministic in a lot of ways you can pre-plan things and can be very savvy and use a lot of intrigue to um yeah to really ramp up the tension of the gameplay now that being said um i do think there's an objective criticism here about the swinginess of the devon draws um i think that this is quite an easy house rule just make all the tokens the fixed value um but yeah i think i think most people would agree with me on that it just feels a bit again very deflating if you are just getting completely shafted through no fault of your own by drawing all those low tiles but everything apart from that works as it should it's smooth it's fast there's some good decisions here i like the scoring method the corruption mechanism is cool especially if you're both willing to go for it and kind of compete with each other with that corruption rather than completely being so risk adverse not to tap without style of the game but yeah i can certainly see why this would be up there for a lot of people in terms of quick two-player games because that ratio of gameplay to the time it takes is spot-on um to be honest now that being said um you know cathartic games are generally i've mentioned before generally don't jail well with me because i don't like all the player powers and things um and i do actually think that cathala has made a couple of games
that do this thing but a bit better and that is the reason for that is because all this part is stripped out so again more more a personal thing but the games i'm talking about are a rather simple game called okiya and also a game of thrones themed game called hand of the king where you again you're moving this piece up and down these rows collecting things for sets those are a bit more pure and a bit more to my tastes i can definitely see why people would prefer this one to those other games because it does have a bit more flavor going on just a bit more to sink your teeth into um so yeah i can't really criticize it too much it's just a personal thing that that's going to prevent me from playing it much more but um but yeah i think if you like the look of this one and a lot of the kind of elements of the gameplay are up your alley then you're probably going to like it quite a bit so that is sobek two players