Skip to main content
Loading video...

Indian Summer Review - JonGetsGames

Transcript 19:54

welcome to John gates games today I'll be reviewing Indian summer this game was designed by ube Rosenberg and the idea of this game is you're going for a nice autumn walk and you'll be placing down these Tetris shaped pieces down onto your player board that are covered in leaves every single one of these tiles has a hole in them and if you arrange them just right then various woodland creatures might pop through and give you some bonuses this game is a race and I will first explain how it plays in a little more detail and then I'll jump into my review here we have the game fully set up and ready to play each player has a backpack and in it they have these five different leaf tiles they start always with do green to yellow and one red and then they go into their first turns and on a player's turn it's pretty simple they just take one main action and there are two of these options for you on your turn the first is you can choose any of the tiles that are in your backpack you don't have to go with a specific order and then you put it out anywhere onto your board so for instance we could take this town right here and you'll notice it does have this hole in the middle of it and that means that if we were to put it out on our board just like this we will now have this little blue blueberry symbol showing up in the hole when we come down to take a closer look it is worth it pointing out that this is also a legal placement you don't have to have these treasures showing up in the hole but it's usually a good thing to do that because the moment you place us down with the treasure right there you're gonna take one of these tokens and you're gonna put it right on top of the hole to show these berries are something that we will be able to collect it later on in the game but we don't have access to them just yet with that single normal action done our turn is now complete we can go ahead and shift things over in our backpack and a

play goes on to the next player so once it comes back around to us we can take another turn and the other standard of main action option is we can said grab one of this big pile of squirrels and you'll notice that all of these are just one by one tile locations and you can put this down somewhere on the board just like that if you want to obviously this is not a great move for the earlier parts of the game but it's always an option for you to do on your turn players will keep taking turns clockwise around the table as they slowly fill up their force area more and more from the towels that are over here in their backpack they can go ahead and fill these things in and there will come a moment where they're gonna take one of their tiles and they'll place it down on the board in such a way that they will have completed one of these regions on the board you'll see it split up into six of these regions now the moment you go ahead and complete one of these regions that is when you get to harvest all of the treasures that are currently sitting on top of the holes on your tile so the moment we finish this we could take all three of these berries put them into our supply and they are now usable for us whenever a player grabs their last tile from the backpack and puts it out onto the board they are then going to immediately refill their backpack up to five different slots and you start by pulling these tiles from around the central board you have this little bush tile that shows you where you're going to start and you'll just go ahead and take them putting them in this specific order into your backpack until you have five of them left and then you can scoot this bush down and once the bush gets to a point where there are only seven of these tiles left over we're gonna go ahead and reach into this a big box of new tiles and refill more on to this overall path at this point you may be

wondering what all of these animal tiles are for they match the similar shapes to the leaf tiles but they are a free action to put down onto your board with a couple restrictions the first is that they must go down on top of the leaf tiles they can ever go onto this main board and the second more important restriction is they can only go on top of it the empty holes in the tiles that you've already placed down so that means if one of these treasure tokens is still over at one of the holes then it's going to restrict the ability for an animal to go on to that spot so in this instance we just cleared out these holes right here so we could go ahead and take this angle tile it's got a couple Birds on it and that pattern it matches the pattern of the holes on this area you go ahead and put this down and immediately reevaluate any of the treasure tokens that are sorry treasure spots that are underneath it so we see that this is going to cover up two of the blueberries which means we're gonna go ahead and take two more blueberries from the supply and put them into our area for placing this animal tile down and now we can still go ahead and take a main action for our turn it's also worth noting that there is a limited supply of these animals and at these three in particular come with a bonus treasure tile if you do this badger right here it will come with a feather this Fox will come with a nut and these raccoons will come with another berry automatically just for placing them down onto your board at this point I'm sure you are very curious as to what these treasure tokens do and if you flip over your backpack you will notice that it has a little example of what all four of them are and the top two are free actions the first is the berry it says that you can go ahead and spend one of these berries in order to gather new leaves from the main forest line so

if you already have five in your area that means you can go ahead and take a sixth and put it into your backpack but you can never go on to a seventh or if you're in a situation where maybe you only have three towns available to you and you really like the next couple that are in line that you might want to play on this turn you can go ahead and spend in that berry in order to take the next ones until you're once again maxed out at five the next option is the nut and this one is quite simple if you look right over here it says you can discard a nut in order to put a squirrel down anywhere on to your player board so this nut can go away as a free action you can place a scroll down and then you can continue to go ahead and do more free actions or do your main action this can be really nice when it comes to actually finalizing one of these areas to unlock some of the treasures that you then might want to use later on in the turn that you are currently playing next up we have the mushroom in action right here and in fact this one and the feather or supplementary main actions they are not free actions so you can do one of these instead of the main action on your turn and the mushroom lets you take the tile that is closest to the backpack on two of your opponents and immediately place those into your area so this is pretty much the main way that you're going to be interacting with your opponents you can get rid of these mushrooms to play their tiles but it's also the main reason why you have to put these tiles into your backpack in order because it's only the leftmost tile or the one that's closest to your backpack that is in jeopardy from an opponent potentially grabbing it with a mushroom if you were playing a two-player game then you're just gonna take the one from your opponent and the tile bears closest to the bush in this main line and this

brings us to the last of the treasure options which is the feather and this one simply lets you play two of your own leaf tiles from your backpack out on to your player area there is one last thing that you could do with your treasure tokens and you can see this chart let's put it out on the main area and this shows that you can spend two berries to immediately turn them into a nuts - nuts turn into a mushroom - mushrooms turn into a feather and you can always downgrade them as well so any feather could be turned into a mushroom and it used for that or down to an on - or berry so if you're in a really desperate situation a feather can be used as any other different types and this changing process is a free action for you your turn so play is gonna continue around the table with players taking one main action on their turn which again is going to be either a leaf on the backpack a squirrel out onto the board or a mushroom or feather action from the pool of treasures and they're gonna keep going until one player has finished out their entire board covering up every single spot this is a race game and when that happens play is gonna continue around the table until you reach the person to the right of the start player which is denoted by these little boots right here and at that point player sort of thing going to use it this conversion table to make it as many nuts as possible and they will immediately spend all of those nuts in order place squirrels down on to their board if they're able to complete a new region by putting these squirrels down they could gather more of these treasure tiles that they can then to convert it into more nuts and try to complete this board as much as possible once everybody has done this nuts - squirrel conversion you will see um if more than one player has maybe filled out their board then whoever has the most nuts is gonna win or if just

one person was able to complete their area then they are the winner of the game let's now begin the review for Indian summer by starting with a couple positive points and the first of these has to do with the big new idea of this game brings to the tetrastyle puzzle laying genre and that is that every one of the base tiles they put down that are covered in leaves also has a hole in it so not only are you trying to match your tile so that they fill in all those holes in the perfect way and many of these tiles are very goofy shapes like several other of this style game that goofy rosenberg has designed but also knowing where that hole is it's gonna really dictate how you're gonna place those tiles down maybe it fits perfectly just like this but the hole is in a terrible location so you instead of flip it over and put it in a very strange orientation on your map that'll be hard to fill in but it puts the hole in the tile right over that bonus that you really need that's right next to those other holes so that you could perfectly match it up so that you can have one of the animals burst up through the leaves and give you even more bonuses I just think it's a really wonderful idea trying to have this this puzzle game within a puzzle game when it comes to orienting the holes out on your board positive number two is a pretty simple one I think that this is a really good looking game when it's out on the table you have the leaf tiles with all the different changing color leaves on them and then you have all of the animals which I think are wonderfully illustrated and I think it's great that they burst up through the holes in the lead files that you've put out onto the map I think that as you're playing this game just the overall aesthetic of it is very well done and I even like that the bonus little tokens you can have a kind of a easy to read side and you flip it over

and has an artistic side so that when you put that down onto your forest floor before you have claimed it it kind of matches the overall aesthetic of everything you have going in front of you I'm not saying I necessarily feel like I'm going for a nice autumn stroll as I play in this game but it definitely matches that beautiful idealized version of what a stroll like that might be like if there was a lot of animals running about next up we have the neutral section but I only have one I want to cover here and it has to do with the restrictions on a tile laying in particular how elack's those restrictions are in this game in particular I'm comparing this one to patchwork and to cottage garden both are similar games that were - by the same designer and in patchwork you only have three titles available to you that you can choose from ever and in cottage garden you have up to four potentially as you're kind of moving this thing around the map but those are quite restrictive and based off what your opponents do you might not have access to other ones but in Indian summer you have your own personal little backpack of leaves I guess and you can pick any of them that you want to to put down onto your area which means it's very low stress you don't have to worry about other people denying you these leaves beyond the mushroom I guess that is one thing to keep in mind is that your leftmost tile can be stolen by an opponent by a mushroom action to put onto their board so that's really the only thing you're considering it's like do I want that one to be something that they that if I want that one maybe I should play it right now but if I do that it'll unlock this other one and maybe that's good for one of my opponents but this is a very low impact type of thing like in general it's a low stress picking environment which means it's also a low tension picking environment and for some people they

will actually like that I mean the overall aesthetic of the game is a nice walk through the leaves but for other people like me I miss some of that tension I feel like the game needed a bit more to make me feel a little bit more attached to the overall gameplay and the decisions I was making all right it's now time to cover a couple negative points and the first one is a little bit expansive it touches on several things so I'll start off by saying that I feel like the bonus tokens that you gathered throughout the game are two bunted two and a little too flexible with how you can and move them and forth between each other by converting now you're gonna be gathering these tokens by finishing out one of these six little regions on your player board the moment it's filled in you're gonna take all the bonus tokens on the various holes in her leaves and put them into your supply and then later on if you have matched the holes up so that it fits one of the animals they can pop through and generate even more of these tokens for you and what I've found is that by the mid game players often have many tokens in front of themselves kind of from turn to turn and I know that the rules say you know this is a race game you shouldn't hoard your tokens you should spend them but it oftentimes feels like you have so many of them you almost can't spend them fast enough or certainly spend them in a good way fast enough and so that kind of desensitizes me to the fun of the tokens like if they were a more precious resources if they showed up less often I'd be much more interested in trying to figure out how to activate them as opposed to had too many times to have the game kind of feeling like I have access to whatever I want to by converting up-and-down or just using some of the ones I have in front of me I was so dishonest I diss that I actually played one of my games with a variant that I came up with

because not only do I think there's too many of these but I think it devalues the animals and the wholes that you're trying to put out on the board in specific arrangements I feel like that idea is the best part of this game and it is unfortunate that you have to finish a arbitrary sixth of your board to pull those tokens off to make those holes empty so you can now bring an animal on so I played the game the last time I played the game I got rid of that scoring entirely I just made it so that whenever you put a tile down and it had a hole over one of the scoring tokens you didn't do anything you just left it there and it was a potential bonus that you could gather later on if you pulled it an animal through that spot so as opposed to an animal being a second activation of that bonus the animal was the only way to activate that bonus I thought this might bring in some tension to the game make the title placements a little bit more interesting and certainly make the tokens a lot less abundant and it worked like I think it was actually a better game with my variant like taking out that 1/6 area scoring it made prioritizing the shapes for the holes much more interesting for the animals but it certainly did not fix the game I feel like needed a different design aesthetic like in it I feel like that was a good way to start for house filling the game but it did not fix everything and I don't think it's something I necessarily advise other people to do I just think that that whole aspect of the game is convoluted it's kind of slapped on it's the most complicated part of the game to actually teach and I feel like it's not even necessary like I do think the game was better with my variant even though I

don't think it fixed the overall game experience so that is my kind of strange rambling at negative number one now moving on to negative number two something I have noticed is rather anticlimactic endings to the game and in particular I am talking about my first two plays of the game not the variant play because obviously that has a huge asterisk but those other games where I played it with the rules as written I found that first of all you could kind of tell when somebody was in the lead and they were doing very well but you also get you also definitely get into situations where you can no longer fit any of your tiles in and all you're doing every turn is putting a squirrel in which means you can look down you're like well I win in six turns because I have six holes so once a turn I'm smacking a squirrel down maybe you have liquidated all of your tokens to get nutso you can squeeze all of those squirrels in there right at the end but it just the ending has never felt climactic in any way shape or form honestly it's been kind of like there's never been tension with it and it's not fun when you have done all the cool stuff I mean you just have this kind of weird shape and maybe it's your fault that you have a weird shape left over but I just for the rest of the game you just like putting a squirrel putting a squirrel putting in a squirrel and you can oftentimes math it out look to see what everybody else has and figure out if you're gonna win or lose so that that lack of tension with the end game is definitely a detractor okay let's not move on and discuss the variability that comes in with Indian summer and I feel like it's less than I was expecting going in I mean this is a light game my expectation was not for extreme variability from one play to the next but I have found that every time I play

this game it really didn't feel like I was playing the same game I played last time like there's no like heavy animal strategy or blitz strategy or like different ways that one game feels different from the next it just kind of feels like you're doing the same race with the same decision set especially with the kind of a loose way that you can kind of gather tiles and play the tiles from your backpack man to bed I was expecting a bit more variability maybe not a lot to me because this is a light game so you have to go in with not gigantic variability expectations but I was a little disappointed by what the game actually provided when it comes to player counts Indian summer supports 1 to 4 players and I don't generally cover solo gaming so I'm not going to talk about the one player at all but I did play the 2 3 and 4 and I think that 3 is probably best to was okay and 4 was also good the reason that 2 was not as good as the rest is particular the mushroom action but lets you play two different tiles from two opponents well in a two-player game you only have one opponent which means you also play one tile from the middle ring which is slightly less interactive and therefore slightly less interesting and also since it's a race game if your opponent is just very far ahead of you I don't know it's it seems less interesting I mean there's not a whole lot you could do to actually hold an opponent back but if you're in a three player experience and they have really good tiles that maybe two of you can keep mushrooming to grab the really good tiles to kind of slow them down versus the in a two-player game you have less opportunities to do that but if I'm being honest I say the three players best but it's fine at all of those player counts like it's not a huge leader for one or the other poor player was okay as well I guess maybe

downtime was a bit bigger but there wasn't that much downtime in this game because honestly there was not that much overall to think about from turn-to-turn in conclusion I've played Indian summer three times at this point and I've been pretty disappointed I have quite enjoyed several of Aveiro Sandberg's other Tetris style tile LAN games like patchwork cottage garden and feast for Odin I really thought Patrick was great I thought cottage garden was fine I only played it once I would totally play it again I just nobody has a copy of it and I haven't felt gravitated towards grabbing it but with Indian summer I am definitely just very much over it after three plays I feel like it's just fluff there's not enough really there to engage me as I'm playing the game like at least in cottage garden which was less engaging than patchwork but at least you had the restrictions of where the the market was gonna be on each round you can plan ahead to be like okay this round I got this one next round baby this one and next round maybe I'll have that one sure an opponent might take one or two of them but you can plan ahead with that kind of stuff and you can plan ahead in Indian summer just the planning isn't very interesting you know you have this backpack you can take the Leafs out in any order you want to you will probably always have a berry available to you so you can spend the berry to fill your backpack in with more of the leaves that are out in the middle of the table it just none of that really ended up being compelling I felt like this game was definitely less than the sum of its parts which is unfortunate because I really like that idea of having all of the tiles have a hole in it like I think that's a really neat new idea to this overall genre and I think that if the design had really focused on that as opposed to having it almost feel

like a side idea where yeah okay I guess you know especially with the animal matching well I okay you know you can get a reactivation to get another one of those bonus tokens and that just it feels like that's where the game should have been like the design should've been focused around aligning those circles up so you can get those animals have them pop through maybe have that be more impactful to the overall game maybe not have the game be a race maybe have it be worth victory points or the various types of animals that you can have pop through the leaves but as the game is you know getting an animal or two is like a nice bonus it just adds to your growing pile of tokens and at the end of the game you just have this big sea of leaves in front of you and I just feel like the design went awry at some point and maybe the maybe they focus too much I'm trying to have this be a relaxing low stress environment because the theme of it is relaxing autumn walk through the leaves as they kind of fall on the ground but that also means that they missed the mark on having something actually be interesting like going for walks is relaxing but not an interesting endeavor and usually when I sit down to play a game I want to do something that's going to activate my mind and interest me as opposed to just be so relaxing that I figure you know what I may as well actually just go out and go for a walk as opposed to playing this game again so I cannot recommend this one I feel like there potentially was a really great light tiling game in here at some point in the development process but they just went away from it and that's not we end up getting in the box as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting my channel through patreon including all of these producer level pledges if you two would like to directly support the channel you could do so at patreon.com slash John gets games and I'd really appreciate it also

if you'd like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching you

Progress saved