Skip to main content
Loading video...

ISS Vanguard - Board Game Review - Epic In Scope & In Rules

Transcript 25:50

thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk kiander stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on audra's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so today's game on the table is ISS Vanguard where do I even start yeah this is a big one this is the newest release from awaken Realms and if you know me in the past I've tended to speak quite highly of their games mainly from a thematic standpoint they really know how to do a solid theme and make a game feel immersive and Atmospheric they that is really their strong suit but that being said as much as I have some favorites like tainted grill for example they do sometimes have some mechanical issues that I either have to house rule or gloss over or die you know if only this was done slightly differently and not all of their games have been a hit effort fields for

example I played had a few problems with that one didn't quite gel with it but then I loved tated Grill potato Grill and even the newer one the second version that I previewed recently really enjoyed that this one I didn't back on Kickstarter because I wasn't certain mainly just for that I need a massive campaign game in my collection but also because I just wanted to see how it played out this is essentially the basic version of the game so yes I don't know when it's getting a retail release but all this is is a standard box with the Miniatures I got on the side but that's literally it there's no other like massive expansions or anything like that so as far as I can tell this is kind of what you would typically get in the Box minus the Miniatures so ISS Vanguard is essentially a big sci-fi epic immersive game and I'm gonna do my best here to avoid all kinds of spoilers but what essentially is taking place is that you are a crew on a ship you've gone into deep space you're following some kind of message shall we say and you eventually find the source and then it leads you on to other planets and other things and you have to you know discover a new no make discoveries research you know build stuff on your ship yo upgrade your ship recruit more crew and what you'll do on the planets is you'll go down to a planet you'll land on its surface and through a dice mitigation puzzle you'll effectively

control a couple of characters roll dice try to get symbols play cards to mitigate those uh those dice rolls and you'll discover more of the plot your game World cards which lets you upgrade your ship and get more cool stuff for later and all the while you're listening to well you have a choice you can either read from a log book like proper Journal of reading all the paragraphs or you do what I think most people doing myself included is that you simply grab your tablet or your phone or whatever get the app for this and you basically just get the ISS Vanguard app and let it read all your logs for you where you've got incredibly cool voice acting and it just increases that immersion Factor that's kind of the gist of the plot per se and I've got to keep this overview very summarized because I don't want to spoil things but a lot of people have talked about various aspects of this game and I want to give my views on each aspect as well as my overall feelings of the game in general bearing in mind I've played for about five I think five scenarios I've played Drew so five proper missions from start to finish that I've played through in this campaign and that's not even scratching the surface of the content that is in this trust me but much like another game I reviewed recently oh Swan you're gonna notice some similarities with why that's the case so let's Force talk about the rules for this game this is a big game to learn and I mean a big game this has a

pretty sizable rulebook I mean that is pro yeah that's a lot there's a lot you get in here okay and that's not even including all the rules because you also have this a log ship book which I don't want to spoil too much but basically it's a folder with a bunch of things about how to resume a game Bridge uh your production crew your hanger Mission launch procedure how to begin exploration how to dock how to unload stuff you may have noticed some cards in there that's just from my campaigns but you won't have seen anything that was a spoiler but yeah there's a lot to learn quite a crazy amount in fact however there are some good and negatives here negative is that there are so many rules in this game that if you dare even think of putting this to the side and packing it away and maybe taking a Hiatus from the game you're gonna have a hard time coming back because there's just a lot to learn and I had this problem tenfold having to put this away and then sort of go right well I need to get on with other stuff and then I'll bring it out again because I want to play it oh man what did I do how does that work ah quite a bit that's a problem however I gotta give props where it's due this has the best or one of the best tutorial systems I've ever seen it's a brilliant tutorial there are some people who have given this rag for

having a tutorial because they didn't want a tutorial well that's your problem throw yourself in next time your stupidity the tutorial is great in this and if you decide to ignore this tutorial then on your own head be it frankly the tutorial is half of this rulebook it basically holds your hand and I mean hold your hand and tells you how to effectively set up the box set up all the components so you've got everything in the place you want how to get these various books and that ready and you know how to get started and then when you get into the ship book and you can tell that Paul Grogan had his hand in this because pretty much she you know had a massive helping with the development of the ship book yes there's a lot of rules but every page explains step by step what you do at each point right I'm resuming a saved game I have to take this envelope from the box I have to take the scanner out I have to take the tokens blah blah blah okay right turn the page go to the bridge right install Bridge cards generate pools check situations reveal new ones it takes you through everything you need to do step by step to the point where if you forgot everything you were meant to do in this book you could resume it pretty well this is fantastic in the way it's written and designed but the tutorial is also really good it gets you into the action relatively quickly Hold Your Hand teaches you things in steps and by the end of the tutorial you know if this is a game you're gonna enjoy or not

problem with that is it holds your hand a little bit too tight because once it's uh it's kind of like you know you're holding the hand of the child and it's just like oh this is nice daddy you're sick yes why would you do that whoa whoa actually that's pretty dark but you know what I mean it's it's it holds your hand so tightly to begin with that as soon as it lets go you're on your own you're scared you're like what what okay uh how did that work again okay I think that's how you do it hang on we didn't cover this in the tutorial because not everything is in the tutorial and so it's as great as that system is you almost feel like you want to go through the tutorial every time you come back to the game this is definitely not one that rewards putting it away and coming back to it later if you can have this on your table for months on end or whatever and go through the entire campaign without putting it away if you remember the good shot but it's not really a casual put it aside come back to it later Style game that's just far too much to learn in here and believe me if it wasn't for bull Grogan and for the development time that was taken on this rule book and the tutorial in the book The Game could probably have been unplayable I reckon but the fact that you can play it from this with a rule book this big and the log book on the side is pretty paramounted genius development skill it's unreal so Props where it's due but this is not a light game this is not an

easy game there's a lot to absorb a lot to learn you're gonna have to deal with that for the most part you're investing in this logbook as well as some of the spiral bound uh you know Mac boards as well as you know I mean the Miniatures are a separate thing we'll get onto those a little bit later as quickly but mostly it's about these cards and all the stuff you've got on the app for the log books I mean you have got log books that are in the Box down there I haven't bought them out because frankly why would I need them I'd listen to the app but you've got a lot of cards tells you how to sort them out and they've got all things like discoveries and points of interest you know all the I mean this is points of interest this is as much as I can possibly see on all these various planets okay then you've got missions big bumble all the missions that you could come across okay how about crew well here's a ton of crew um oh God try and get it out there we go that's all crew members oh these are different crew members and that's not including discoveries and equipment and events there's a lot of cards in here there is a lot of content believe me you're getting your money's worth even though it's not the cheapest game in the world so certainly good from a component standpoint artwork where you see it is gorgeous it looks beautiful I love the you know the rule book is set out really nicely but I like this planet up here as it's called I don't want to

reveal too much so I'll just open it at the tutorial page because you're not really you know losing much from there but each of these spots you know it's got lovely space artwork you know all these nice little cards there the other cards I've got artwork on them as well and it's a simplified layout but everything just looks really beautiful really nice it brings out that sci-fi theme really nicely so let's talk about my favorite aspect from the gameplay perspective that book the ship book you might argue is just a glorified admin phase and in in some respects it is but one of the favorite things to do when you're playing these kind of big immersive story based games is the idea of leveling up your character well your character is effectively your ship and your crew it's a bit like you know the Enterprise and Star Trek being kind of like a character of the show well your ship is kind of like that as well but in here when you're going through the different stages after coming back from a mission you're getting the choices of like oh wait okay I get these different objectives I'll put them I can upgrade my tech level work on morale okay well what do I want to do well let's see I need to scout for another mission so okay let's grab the system map book and decide who where do I want to go today well that system looks cool that one looks a little bit dangerous maybe I'll go to a different system okay all right we'll go to there we'll land there eventually but then on your facilities you've got you know going to the research laboratory you can get cards that allow you to you know when you cash in the discoveries you can unlock new equipment unlock new stuff the production crew you can stick stuff in

these queues that tick over over time but you can boost it with other crew and so when you do that you improve your ship maybe get new landing craft get more like biome suits more you know weapons stuff like that but then you've also got the you know the hanger for your various ship you've got the barracks to get more crew members 20 minutes later this bit is highly addictive really addictive it's kind of like the best comparison I can think of I think Tom vassell used the exact same comparison as well and I was singing the same thing x-com you know any XCOM video games when you play that you have two phases of the game you have the combat phase where you go off and do the Tactical aspect but then you've got that strategy section where you're in your comms HQ and you're doing all the various stuff with upgrades and your crew members and checking on stuff and that that's that part of the game is really addictive I really enjoy it this is basically that in a nutshell so if that was if that was something that appealed to you this is going to repeal to you yes it is kind of like a glorified admin phase going through this folder step by step and doing what you want if anything kind of hurts this book a little bit is the fact that you have to spend command tokens to do a particular facility and for the first few campaigns I've been playing you only get two tokens so you're only really triggering two of these facilities out of like five or six that's not a lot that feels very restrictive I'm sure that probably opens up as you go through the campaign but to begin with I'm like come on I want to do every facility why can't I just do them all why have I got

to like only do a couple that just doesn't seem to make much sense especially as when you're cycling through which planet you want to go through you have energy tokens that you're supposed to spend and if you don't land on a planet by the time you've spent all those tokens you go adrift which makes your morale decrease why would you go with drift I mean you're not a drift you've just decided to spend some time doing other things but it's forcing me to land it's forcing me to do things and trust me getting morale back is not easy so it's not something you want to let go down I would have just maybe liked free form don't give me this adrift thing don't give me this restriction with command tokens just let me do as much as I want with the book and I'll be happy but yeah I really love this book it's a great way to immerse yourself in what it is you're doing and to feel attached to the characters and the you know the ships and the upgrades you've got it's just a really cool fulfilling system yes it's mostly admin but it's fun admin now the dice phase isn't as good as that but it is still decent but there are some problems I do have the idea being that you have you know I've got the Miniatures at the moment but you'll basically have a miniature that starts off where your lands or like down here for example and you can move to different locations it tells you to read certain logs different cards will come out with that mission log and travel and everything and you roll these dice different color Dice and you're trying to get the various symbols

this game has you know there's enough mitigation to a point but it is still quite limited mitigation so a lot of the time you are trusting to good and bad dice luck here but the other problem which this game does have and this is something that I swear awaken Realms are just never gonna stop doing it's a Trope by now and I wish they would stop it is they just don't seem to think that any game should be remotely easy whatsoever tainted Grail is a difficult game ever Fields is a difficult game this is a very difficult game because you have got a lot of stuff to do here you've got all these different cards with different things that can get you bonuses or pass and fails and they're all based on rolling very specific symbols or spending a ton of dice and when you spend all your dice you have to do a rest action to get it back but you only get some of it back and it uses up supplies you only have limited supplies and so you know that's already punishing enough but then you've got Frets on some of these planets which are like really nasty and they hurt you like crazy and it's like takes multiple roles multiple actions to take you know take them down or avoid them and even stuff like the the landing on the planet probably one of the weakest aspects of the game before you even get to this point you have to do a landing procedure with your craft which essentially is the basic craft you get it's not a spoiler but you essentially have to like you're on a little timer and you go through the logs

and depending on what you've upgraded your ship with or what choices you make but mostly just based on a random die roll dictates what happens to your landing craft and it's always bad stuff it's either nothing or bad much like the events in tainted Grail this game just wants to throw in 101 different ways for you to have bad stuff happen to you and it gets a little bit annoying when you're basing it obviously on die rolls I mean the landing is literally luck of the dayro there's no mitigation it's just total luck why put in a punishing aspect like that but then on top of that just the fact that this is very punishing as well and it's not fun to be put on the back foot all the time you know at some point I want to feel like I can use this equipment for cool stuff or you know have enough supplies to really explore the planet but you do feel very constrained very restrictive and as much much as it's really immersive and I want to progress the story I'm not as keen on the dice aspect where I'm thinking right I've landed on this planet okay cool I've taken these two people with me all right fine oh they want nothing but these green symbols and that's it otherwise it's not impossible and I had that you can scan a planet if you want to spend the energy to see what sort of roles will come up and it's not a concrete way of telling and even then I want to spend that energy on other things not just scanning a planet and so if you do a situation like I did where I landed on a Green Planet and I didn't have certain symbols in my repertoire it

made the mission impossible like there was no way I could have physically done it you would have had to have spent so much dice so much that you required so much luck on die rolls that the planet became impossible to help you a little with the dice aspect you do have your own station with Section cards that you draw although depending on the rank of your car character depends on how many you get these allow you to do some cool little things like mitigate some die rolls but they also allow you to use some of your unused dice to trigger other bonus effects the only thing is a lot of those are quite situational they're based entirely on your die rolls you don't have many of these cards in your hand at one time and there's a lot of duplicates most of them are just re-roll or die I'd rather have more cards that let me set die to actual values they exist but they're in rare they're a rare commodity most of it is just re-roller dream re-roller blue or something and it's like well re-rolling is not good enough because my dice Luck sucks I want to be able to say that you know what I'll spend a bit extra but I want to fix that to a symbol because I'm willing to do it but you could re-roll the dice as many times as I can still not get the thing you want in which case that difficulty problem does come back but you know it's cool having your own station with you know your character some abilities they use the different dice which you can buy more dice as the game goes on so you've got slots for you know to acquire more dice but it's not the fastest leveling up process I mean you'll start off I think with four I think maybe or five you end up with a sixth die relatively

quickly but then it's going to take a lot of experience before you get up to another die Etc but even with this many dice you don't have a lot of options when you go down to a planet and I wish it was just just tailor that difficulty down a little bit awaken rounds give us an easy standard mode and then give us various tweaks to make it harder don't give us nightmare level on Doom in terms of hellish difficulty and then give us the same thing but blindfolded for a harder difficulty some of us just like to play and experience the game not be punched in the face while we're playing it your kids are soft so ISS Vanguard when it's firing on all cylinders is one of the best most immersive narrative story driven sci-fi games have ever played when when it's all going well the app listening to The Voice logs without you in the background it's wonderfully immersive it feels like kind of like a retro sci-fi thing a bit like the first alien movie but then I love going through this you know the ship book at the end of the day and you know leveling up my ship and getting all the research projects deciding oh do I want to research that first or that first yeah what do I want to make what do I want to do there's endless scope for trying to play the game the way you want play it even going off and exploring planets I mean I can decide you know what I've got three options of where to explore what do I go option one two or three um you know what I advise you this option I'm gonna go over here and see what happens it's there's a lot of scope for your campaigns to feel different but that's not to say that I want to revisit planets on a regular basis

because of the high setup time because of how many hours I need to play this game how about the constant amount of rules relearning I need to do the tutorial in the ship book is done brilliantly you must use the tutorial trust me you must but once you've had your hand held your hand for ages and then it's let go yeah almost back on that foot of like ah I don't remember how half of this works now and again it's that commitment Factor much like oh Swan oswarm is a similar problem it required 75 plus hours worth of your time to get through those 20 plus chapters and I just don't have the time to devote to a game like that not when I've got play other things and not when I play games with a lot of different people on a regular basis as opposed to having the same group that can commit with this honestly I don't see the major need to play this with more players I think just playing it Solo or two player is all that you really need for this because I enjoyed my time fine playing it solo I just wish I had more dice to manipulate more stuff to do but like I say it wasn't too difficult to Pilot solo but even I can't find four hours per session to devote to this I can't devote I mean I don't even know how much content is in this because I don't know where the end point is this could be an 80 hour 100 hour 120 hour it could be ridiculous amount of content in here and I just don't have the time if if I didn't have a day job if I didn't have a Blog if I didn't have other things to do in my life then I would gladly want to play this game all the way through I

would just put in a few house rules to make the difficulty a little bit less punishing you know make it a little bit easier and a little bit nicer to do like for example don't do to The Landing procedure it's pointless and arbitrary and it's just a die roll so ignore that bit entirely but then I'd also kind of say well do I get extra dice or can I assist easier or can I remove one step off all the tracks when you're going on cards because that's quite punishing in itself like oh so I need to get the exact symbol on two dice and I need to do it four times to get this track to move from A to B come on that's a little bit harsh and it's just those sort of things get in the way so this is a tough one I don't know if I'll get the chance to finish this and that makes me sad because I genuinely think it's good I think there are some people out of this that are gonna really adore this they're gonna think it's one of the best games ever and I can certainly see why I wish I didn't have to look through a filing cabinet of cards on a regular basis like seven continents fine but it's these things hold it back for making it enjoyable the time length the setup all the rules sifting through the cards all of these negatives add up but everything that it does well it does so well so so well I I don't know what to rate it really I think overall it's getting an 8 out of 10 overall I still think it's great and Thai No Object I would play this to death but those negatives are a big deal they take it at a distinction level I just

don't have the time to commit there's a lot of cards to sit through there's a ton of setup there's a lot being asked of you and this is only going to be playable by heavy Gamers because there's so much in it so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see please remember you can thumb up the video especially on Board Game Geek if you see it consider the patreon but most of the tool get your comments down below I want to know your thoughts on this game particularly if you've played through most of the campaign or all of it does some of the negatives I have alleviate themselves over time how long did it take you to get through the entire campaign if you've played it I'd certainly like to know how many hours or days or months you had to commit for this because it's certainly going to be one that takes up a lot of your time but you know is this a theme that interests you did you like the the app did you like the ship book did you like the tutorial I want to get your thoughts down below and respond to them accordingly so until next time you can check out more content on the channel including the two live streams I've done including the recent one I did with Dan from chairman on the board but also check out the oh Swan review I did where you can get some similar thoughts to the whole length and setup and all that I did here from that review as well so you can see where I'm coming from until next time remember as always regardless of how much time you want to devote to your mission to deep space it's still only a game bye for now

Progress saved