Skip to main content
Loading video...

Forum Trajanum Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 19:24

hi everyone today i'm talking about forum tragedy which is a two to four player board game designed by stefan feld and published by stronghold game uh this one takes around 90 minutes to play and came out in 2018. now if you're a fan of the channel you'll probably know that stefan feld is one of my favorite designers ever i'm definitely the designer who i own uh the most games of but forum trading them despite only being a couple years old didn't really hit the heights that a lot of other stefan feld games did and i suppose uh this video will uh maybe give you an idea why that should or should not be the case so um there's quite a lot of components in this game you've got this main player mod here um and i should say this is what the game is going to look like towards the end of the game and not at the start um a lot of the actions that want to be taken here um one of the main parts of getting the um or getting victory points which is naturally your objective in this style of game um is the uh the forum here where you're trying to line up as many of your little tokens here as you can to get victory points by surrounding these eagles and um again trying to connect them you've got these different tracks around the outside which give you bonuses when you build buildings which we'll cover shortly um and you've also got these end game or sorry round by round objectives as well um which again are going to correlate to your individual player boards that look like this they're quite large and initially they are going to purely be made up of these placements of these um little um i suppose citizen tiles they're gonna be filling every one of these um every one of these squares on

this grid um and the the gameplay is quite unusual you know normally you'd think stephenfeld games are you know very mechanical and i think this is probably the strongest example of that out of any uh failed game i've played before so how is the game going to play out so first off the main kind of part of the game is going to be drawing two of these cards and of course there's going to be three rounds here but this is purely the last round and as you can see these cards have two different symbol or individual symbols on them so this one here has this pantheon symbol and this one here has this horse and chariot symbol and what you're going to do is you're going to look on your player board like so for those matching symbols and then you are going to take one of these um tokens from that matching row or column so you know if this pantheon was well i've got none here but uh with this chariot one i could for example choose this one and um you know let's just say for example sake i chose this one as well um you can always use one of these white workers to ignore the restriction of the um of the symbol and then what you're going to do is you're going to pick one of these two to keep and you're going to pass the other one on to uh the player on your on your left and the other people are going to be doing the same so you're going to end up with two tiles and out of the two tiles you're left with you're going to choose one of them and you're going to discard the other now they are going to give you lots of different things as you can see here you know different worker types these builders these assistants you can give you coins they can let you move this little track along the top here which i'll explain

the relevance of later but yeah you've got all these different worker types which allow you to do different things um and let you build different things so i mentioned what these white ones did earlier they can let you ignore the restriction of the card but they also let you um or by cashing in two they let you keep both of your tokens you've got all the workers of the different colors which let you build different buildings you've got the assistance here which let you basically change the color of one worker to another and you've got the grey builders which are good for and building the gray buildings because as you can see you've got four different colors of buildings here and you've got the gray buildings with different symbols on and you've also got these double tiles here which you can build things um you know a lot quicker but of course you're gonna have to still pay the resources by matching the um correlating builder and the idea is you're going to be building them onto your board trying to get different objectives so first off um you know you've got the colored buildings and the color buildings are important because when you place those you are going to place um one of your one of your little tokens onto the main forum of a matching color so you know if i built a um a red building as i have here i can place one here and the idea is that we are trying to get offset these um eagle tokens because if you get an orthogonal position then you're going to get a point at the end of the round but also uh depending on your largest chain of um of um kind of tokens you are going to look at your little track here and have a look where they are so if i

had a chain of eight to nine um people then i'm going to get eight points at the end of the round and um i like this how this works and you kind of shimmy along and um increase the points you're going to get the other colors for example the um the gray buildings are not only important for um getting instant bonuses because all these relate to a different track so if you get one of these scroll ones you're gonna go up the track and get these different bonuses as you go um same with correlates to the kind of lower one and uh this one here as well but the the ones with these kind of um columns on they give you points based on the current round so if you build them on the first round you are going to get three points second round you're gonna get two points and the final round you're only going to get one point for um whenever you build those but that also um is important for these corner tiles as well because whenever you choose one of these by revealing the um the construction site below it then at the end of that round you're going to score a uh a number of points equal to the round based on the uh the column there for each of the matching colors you have so you know in this example i'd only score one point for one blue building but you can probably imagine how um how you can rack up points that way if you play uh appropriately additionally um there is some quite importance of these grey buildings because if you have a different symbol out the four different symbols you are going to look at the correlating row here and score and points accordingly so for example i've got two different types here and i've got

one of these citizen tokens which means i'm going to score two times two because i've got two different building types in this second column then i am going to score four points at the end of the round and these also give you additional bonuses if you were to select them um and let you kind of interchange workers um get double bonuses by completing these forum sections um and uh doing different things as well so they're quite nice give you powers and also give you multiply or bigger multipliers when it comes to scoring so doing that is quite important but keeping those on your board is not the easiest thing to do because whenever it comes to the end of the round you're going to have to pay a coin for each one of those to keep them active you're also going to have to bear in mind these trajan objectives because at the end of each round you're going to be assessed on the criteria on these cards so for example in the first round if you have a colored building in between two grey buildings then you are going to score a number of points equal to where you're again where your slider is but where your trajan head is here so you guys are gonna be in this three bracket in this five bracket or in this seven bracket um these cards also have two types of um goals to go for not only the actual spatial puzzle aspect but also this kind of collection bonus so if you have a spare white worker and a spare coin in your kitty then you're going to score those points again and you can do these multiple times so that's something to work towards this one here as you can see um has you have to have four colored off any four buildings in a square like i've done here for example and um and this one here just have three different gray buildings um in a

column and again have these collection bonuses so these are constantly um you're working towards these while still trying to um get the different um get the different gray buildings in these different rows to get bonuses as well and of course um building colored buildings to fill up the uh forum and of course climb these tracks as well so there's quite a lot of things you have to consider when you build anything and when you take any actions and also always bearing in mind that you are restricted to the row and column that you're going to actually take the tile from in the first place so that's going to be pretty much how the game is going to play out so um yeah it's a very mechanical game as you can probably um tell but let's talk about how i feel about the game itself so first off decision wise there is quite a lot to consider here but while still being somewhat tunnel visioned in what you can do um because of course you were always subject to the card draws here about which envoys that you can reveal in the first place and obviously you are trying to work out which areas you get to clear so you can build into them in order to get the most points as you can um but that is not an easy decision because you know there are so many things putting you in different directions you know you've got to know when you are going to use these white workers to ignore that rule but bearing in mind that some of these trading cards want the white workers left in your supply in order to get those points and also you're always trying to move your um you know your slider across to get more benefits by adding all your um envoys together and quite an interesting

rule here as well is that you can't actually start a new colored region until the current one is complete so that can be uh something to consider and you've got to be careful at which opportunities you leave your opponents when it comes to finishing one of these regions because if they do then they are going to get one of these bonuses which are not insignificant so that's also something to bear in mind and you've got to consider about what opportunities you are leaving your opponents so this gear there's quite a lot here to consider and um you know a few places to spin in order to be as optimal as you can um in terms of getting points you want to be building these um these columns as quickly as you can because if you do then you're going to be getting three points per one you make and also these cranes as well and if you go top heavy on investing in a certain colored building and then trigger that crane then again if you do that early then you can be getting a lot of points that way because you're gonna be getting three points rather than the one if you were to do it in the uh in the phone around but you know in order to do that you're going to have to neglect something else so that really is a an optimization puzzle here in terms of balance i think all the different routes you can go are pretty um well considered and i don't think there's going to be a you know a runaway method to go down i i took a very balanced approach you've got to consider the the powers you want to invest in the first place because you've got some pretty good ones here you know for example this one here lets you score when you're in the corner of the eagle tiles rather than just orthogonally um you know this one here when you take

one of these completion bonuses you take another one um you know this one slides your track or flips your track over so you're getting better bonuses and also when you upgrade it you're going to these fir trees so again there's a nice little um player powers here that you can invest in and make use of but you have to bear in mind that you're going to have to pay for them when it comes to the scoring phase otherwise they're not going to be worth anything so i really do quite like that and there is a nice amount of resource management and just weighing up what you want to do and what what kind of resources you want to keep back and what you're going to use them for also the economy of getting these workers isn't the um isn't the easiest because of course you are against subjects to these towers that you're going to be drawing each round you know do i want the grey worker in the blue work i don't want the yellow worker and the red worker and bearing in mind as well that the other token is going to go to your opponent which might be what they want so yeah lots of decisions here lots of um options and it all comes together in a really nicely um balanced way um mechanically there is um you know stefan feld is known for his uh mechanically sound games um and i know he gets a lot of criticism for being so unthematic and um you know basically just being a bunch of mechanisms smashed together to make a game and i think that's probably the reason why a lot of people don't like steffenfeld games i know he's got a huge fan base such as myself and i think this is going to be a strong example that's never going to change anyone's mind on

unsteffenfeld it's going to in fact probably reinforce their opinion if they don't like him because this is pretty much um everything that somebody who would criticize feld um would look as a kind of an example of him doing what he does um but it does come together quite well i do quite like this option of it's almost like a draft you know picking these tiles passing them on choosing which ones you're going to use um and yeah so there is some you know mechanically it does work nicely there's the traditional tracks here of course you've got the objectives as well so a lot of pretty standard euro stuff here but with some twists as well you know how this forum works and um yeah i suppose mainly your tire placement and the way you're going to use your individual player boards has a slightly different feel to it than a lot of other tile placement games um time investment you know the game takes an hour and a half to play which is about right for a game like this certainly didn't outstay its welcome and i'm you know only three rounds um with with four turns each i suppose four turns so it certainly doesn't take too long it doesn't feel like it's um you know dragging its feet um yeah it's not a game that outstanding welcome at least in my eyes uptime as well is pretty good because a lot of it is simultaneous you know you're picking your tiles at the same time um you can do a lot of things such as taking your resources from the tiles you've selected at the same time and it's just a matter of building ready but yeah there's not much scope for um you know losing interest when it is another player's turn because

the actual turns themselves are quite rapid um interaction um it's not a hugely interactive game um the only kind of i suppose the main part of the game or aspect of the game that is the most interactive is this forum because you do want to be getting in these orthogonal spaces um you do want to be closing the regions off to get these built to get these um bonuses here and of course you can try and cut people off to try and stop them getting the bigger clusters of their envoys to get bigger bonuses here so there's a bit of interaction and it's it's not quite passive that is is somewhat direct but um in a in a rained back way there's it's not really in your face and you're not smashing what you know smashing the work of other players it's um it's pretty straightforward in that respect um so yeah in terms of interaction it's loose but that is a little bit um aesthetically um i like the way the game looks it's got a traditional euro feel to it certainly doesn't try too hard of what it's trying to be um the board looks nice yeah i do like this um this look it's got a nice traditional euro feel that's um it just feels right before the game um components as well really good quality you know got some all the meeples themselves are fantastic nice thick chunky pieces um all the cardboard stock from the buildings and stuff perfectly good quality um so yeah no complaints whatsoever with the production values uh all the way this game looks so yeah thumbs up in that regard um theme it's a stephenville game it's a

very loose skin on a game but i think his james games tend to marry this romanesque feel quite well um and settlement teardown time to be honest the setup time is one of the biggest drawbacks i think for this game there is a lot of separate pieces as you can probably see here you've got to set up the player boards all with a token each um you've got to set up all these buildings here and these are double-sided so you're flipping half of them to be this side you're flipping half there there's just lots of different cards and things um and it's a little bit fiddly um you know picks a bit longer than your average game to set up which was a little bit of a bug bear and of course you're putting them back in the bags and stuff as well it's going to be a bit tedious um progression is pretty good as you are opening more spaces on your board by you know revealing those um envoys and of course you're trying to add you know link up all your forum envoys together so that does have a nice forward momentum as you're building towards these objectives as well um and of course bearing in mind the depleting score uh the points you're going to get for your building so it does have a uh a forward motion to it and it does change as the game develops um which is perfectly fine um scalability as well um i don't really see an issue wherever player count this is going to be at the forum is going to be extended to um you know to be bigger and depending on that player count to uh you know make a a more tighter or more open game so yeah no complaints at all with scalability i think it's going to be absolutely fine at any player account

um see overall i think this is a solid design as i said uh probably even more mechanical than other failed games which is saying something i enjoyed it do i think it's one of the best spell games absolutely not i can see why this didn't land with a lot of people i know some people speak about it highly um i think it's good i i will say that um certainly not in the top of tfl games and probably not even in that middle tier of failed games i put this probably about the same enjoyment of a game like carpe diem which ironically came out at exactly the same time but has a lot lighter feel to it than this one um i think people are going to have a bit of a hurdle to overcome um how dry this game is um and you know i think a lot of our games will fail fans will overcome that and not really think of that as an issue but this isn't a game that you're going to want to introduce to you know players who aren't sold on the whole euro genre of games this is only going to kind of push them away i think whereas if it does appeal to you i would recommend checking it out because it does have some pretty neat ideas um but some pretty unnatural and um almost um jarring um mechanisms that don't that are just as are just that just a bunch of things cobbled together but certainly i don't mean that negatively it just um you know it just it doesn't have the kind of flow and um natural kind of rhythm by you know by by reading the rules themselves once you play it it's absolutely fine you know it does work

pretty pretty nicely um but yeah it's it's certainly not up there with his best of games um there's a lot of things i do like about this one i really love this track here and i'd love to see this used in another game you know where you're working towards kind of linking things together and wherever you are you're gonna get points and um that's kind of a sliding scale i really do love that idea and i'd like to see that used again um yeah so yeah i can't i'm certainly not gonna speak negative this game you know talking saying is a lower tfl game is still high praise because i i've never played a full game i haven't enjoyed but um i can see why this didn't take off the way a lot of other games or his games did it just doesn't have what you know while it's mechanically sound it just didn't have that sprinkle of magic that a lot of his other games do at least for me so i don't think this is going to be a keeper for me but i am glad i played it it was fun and um you know it's a solid design in itself so that concludes my thoughts on forum trade genome uh if you have enjoyed the review please hit like and subscribe to our channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved