Simurgh: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games onl and today I'm doing a discussion over suurg which let's be completely honest no one is going to be watching this video no one is looking up samur reviews um in 2025 this game came out I believe years ago 2015 and the expansion came out a year later uh this is designed by oh God pure Luca zzy uh which I believe went on to go do tang Garden uh which I know that one was a lot more successful but this was also published by nisin games nskn games which if I remember right they went on to become Bor and dice is was the the name uh of that company before they became a lot more popular I want to say that that's the case but I think there's kind of a a time and place to do discussions like these over games that either completely flew under the radar um or just were never like just for some reason never popular or didn't go over well when they came out and I believe Sam merg is one of those games this one in 2015 I mean jez like that that era of
gaming was not like this feels almost like it was a 2012 game where a lot of like oh this could be kind of revolutionary this could be something uh to set the path for other games I feel like there were other games out there that were kind of just better than this one um but for me it has stayed in my collection since then even though I hadn't played it in probably 10 years like I've just had it in my collection and for some reason I never got rid of it so I was doing a kind of a board game Purge you know I don't like to just hold onto games if I'm never touching them So eventually uh whenever I decide to sell it I like to replay games and just see if you know what this is worth keeping in my collection or not yeah it's like I've confirmed this isn't for me anymore and suurg is a very interesting one because I think that it's surprisingly good it has a lot of interesting systems but at the same time definitely shows its age uh so one of the things that I still remembered about this game it was the mainly the one thing I remembered was this game was the the pacing of it how long the game lasted was driven by the players and I've always enjoyed games that do that where the game seems to be going quick for a lot of people and then all of a sudden everyone's like oh I want more to do or the you know the scores are really
close so everyone slows way down and I think you get a lot of that with Alexander Fister games with Great Western Trail and marra Kaio where you're just going around that Rondell and all of a sudden it's just like hit the brakes now we're going to like be very methodical about where we're going and suurg did all that uh way earlier because a a major source of resources and victory points and stuff are based off of these these tiles these expiration tiles that players put out you have ways to go get them um by using Scrolls and as a free action you can place them out and then there are new worker placement spots you have your general worker placement where you can kind of get more Dragon abilities you can get some resources you can spend resources for other stuff but a lot of that is to Aid you in these extra exploration locations and there are two types there's either extra worker placement spots where you can go and you could spend four Scrolls for 10 points or four Spears for 10 points um or you can go on what's like this green track this is like an exp this is legitimately an exploration token where you send a dragon rider up at the top and you go down and you need to spend resources each time but you're getting increasingly better rewards but at any point on your turn you can either place a worker or send
everyone back and if you pull everyone back if there are ever empty spots on a tile it gets removed and this is one of the ways that the game ends depending on the length of the game what goes in like What's called the chronicle which is basically a discard pile for these let's say you're playing a long game when once there are 14 tiles that that ends the game um and that type of kind of gameplay where you are putting out extra work replacement spots for other people to freely go to people can also jump on these expiration tiles because there are two spots and it can be kind of like a race to get down to the very bottom is super fascinating it's something I've always enjoyed because I remember back in 2015 teaching this game and there was just a moment where everyone kind of realized oh the game's about to be over yet we still have more to do but at the same time if you gained a lead then you have the ability to try and ramp the game to a to a close and hope that the endgame victory points aren't going to be you know aren't going to supersede you and you can still win because another way that the game can end is there are these public scoring places that you just send a dragon rider and you draw three of these tiles and you pay resources to place them down and these become public uh goals so like
this one is to have the most Dragon abilities um and now everyone knows that that's what people can be competing for but you had the agency to place it down you got to look at where everyone was at you could be like I have four dragons everyone else only has two and I have the capability to keep getting ability tokens so I'm going to pick that one and uh therefore if at the end of the game cuz pretty much the only thing that scores are the any that uh public objectives any that are out there are the only ones that score so you could see hey if this goes off and I'm the only one who has the most then I'm going to get 14 victory points and once depending on the length of the game again once there are a certain number out that will end the game and this is primarily I feel like going to be the one that's the most common way the game ends because the these are relatively easy to do they're easy to go and and place out um which again is not my favorite I feel like the balance between Chronicles and the objectives are is very lopsided cuz it's it doesn't cost you anything to go and pick a token except for a couple resources um and I think they did that because the balance of it would be oh now everyone can see what people are competing for so now there is competition versus trying to be sneaky
and grab exploration tiles and go after victory points that way so that's always something that I found that was special about suurg now that's pretty much it uh well I guess that's enely true uh this game is about Dragon Riders I guess and the dragons all have unique abilities on them all of them have three unique abilities and you have ways to go out and get more but you get a bunch of free actions on your turn before you just do one major action which is pretty much either placing a worker or recalling everyone back um and these can really set the game apart if you are a able to get a lot of dragons which there's either a work replacement spot to get a dragon or there are other ways to get them if you can have like four or five dragons and everyone else is rocking one or two you're going to be significantly better off than they are which makes thematic sense but can also be I don't know it it could feel very lopsided because if you're able to do free actions which is using Dragon abilities you can get really good combos of like oh I'm going to spend a token to get two meat I'm going to use that meat to uh that allows me to get three Spears and now I have three Spears so I can freely move Advance my dragon on this
exploration to get 10 points and now I get to do my action which feels really cool as the player because you get to actually combo uh combo a lot of stuff off but if you're not able to do that then you're just kind of sitting there and watching someone run away with the lead and the one thing about this game that is clearly showing its age is the resource management cuz after after the way the game ends how it it's player driven and the unique Dragon abilities there's really nothing special about this game it is honestly a Bare Bones Resource Management game you are pretty much just managing four res I guess there's six but there's stone wood meat vegetables Scrolls and weapons and you need all of them but the weird part is that there's no real easy way to get some of them there are natural spots where you can get scrolls and weapons but pretty much you need Scrolls and weapons to go to a location to get more of these tiles and these tiles are how you're going to primarily be getting vegetables or um or meat and you need vegetables and meat to get more workers and you also need vegetables and meat to get more dragons so if you are if the the locations that
are out on the board if they don't provide vegetables or meat you are pretty much landlocked I have had many games of this you know looking back and also recently of just people who are playing just going I don't know what to do and in a worker placement game you really don't want that at all you don't want people to who who don't have a lot of dragons who didn't have the capability to get dragons to just kind of sit there and be like I I there's I got nothing even though you can spend like if the all the spaces are filled in the ex in the Wilds um you could spend a spear to get rid of them but at the same time if all the locations because you can only do that for the red tiles if all of them happen to be the green exploration tiles you can't remove those using a spear so you have to just sit there and by not having natural work replacement spots to get meat or vegetable I guess there is one place to get a vegetable meat is the only resource that you just can't freely get unless you have dragons that let you do it um and that doesn't feel good that definitely feels like well you had a lot of kind of really cool ways to combo stuff which in a game at you know like this I feel is is special but then you also for some reason make a resource
incredibly tight and I I feel like that was just an odd decision um so that's that's pretty much kind of how suurg I feel is is where people resonated with it was you know this has some pretty cool ideas but the overall game still boils down to you you are managing basic resources just to kind of use them at at various locations and nothing is really all that cool uh even though for my point I actually don't don't mind the the combess of the game cuz there's other games that have come out recently where you don't combo at all and it's just boring every every turn you take I don't find I don't find that here um even with the strictness of the the resource management I actually kind of enjoy the puzzle of trying to figure out how to get those resources and how to get them in abundance which probably is the meta of get get a dragon get a second dragon early and what's nice is you don't top deck anything all the all the locations you need one you get to draft them at the beginning of the game but there's four available um scrolls are free to get those locations even whenever you place them out in the Wilds you get a free resource if someone's blocking you from a spot if you need meat this middle location allows you to get a meat if you place a place a tile there and you can
go get a spear to be able to hopefully n that one and put your own in which then can start generating you resources um I also mentioned that like one of your actions is pulling all your workers back that's not actually true you can pull any number of workers back which is nice because if you have a tile that you want to do multiple actions on and you use one of them but you want to use another one you don't have to pull this worker back to where it's like oh now it's empty it goes away um you can keep it on there and hold off and hopefully other players don't take that spot from you I don't find this game to be incredibly Cutthroat because because there's very few locations that only one person can go to most places can have multiple people uh really again it comes down to these where only one person can go to um so what one thing I will say is the length of the game if I would say do a short game for teaching purposes but after that like you're really going to kind of want to do a medium or a long game and a long game surprisingly isn't that long but you're going to run into more players going I don't know what to do in a longer game so medium might be The Sweet Spot which might be an hour it's a surprisingly clean game whenever you're teaching it it's very straightforward uh which with Bard and
dice that's not always the case nowadays and and I mean and the artwork is just phenomenal so I I think honestly suurg is kind of I wouldn't necessarily say it's a Hidden Gem I wouldn't say oh this flew under the radar in 2015 go get it right now if you can find it because it's amazing it's not amazing but I think it is good and if someone were to you know bring this out and teach it I feel like this would be a game that a lot of people would be like I have never heard of this or it's like oh wait is that that weird dragon game uh that no one played it's either one of those too um and if you're lucky enough to have the expansion the call of the Dragon Lords expansion which I do have um that is a modular expansion now I haven't played every single module but I did play a few and overall I think the best thing that came out of that that that expansion are these boards if this is the uh if this came it's been so long I don't remember but I'm pretty sure the expansion came with these oh God ter of contents call the dragon Lords yep um I don't know if these actually came with it but if it did this this is so much better than what was being used uh because it has your entire turn order what you start with and a bigger slot to store your resources um but I can go
over the expansions modules that I have played the biggest one was the Forgotten Metropolis which was this massive sideboard this alone just really takes up table space for no reason um but this allows this gives you like an extra wizard meele which there's another module where you just have the wizard but in this case um it gives you an extra major action and minor action or free action where you are spending resources on a spell book so you have these cards that you Shuffle and then you flip over and the one that has your banner is a minor action and the one that doesn't is a major so you spend those resources to get Mana points and you spend those Mana points to move along this track and uh I don't I don't think this expansion is bad for a couple reasons one it now gives you the ability to go out and get resources that you might be struggling with like a great example would be the meat example I was giving where it's like oh my next Mana spot cost two Mana this minor Tok this minor spell would give me four mana and I just need to spend a scroll and a wood ways I resources I can readily get so I'll spend those two and then I'll move along that's going to give me a victory Point as well as a meat and then it just allows you to go along a certain track this board is
double-sided uh the simpler side is where it's just one path you go one down one of three paths and the other side the paths interweave with one another and it's the first person to get to the dragon Vault or whatever it was called will um get some victory points some Dragon ability tokens and end the game this is another way the game can end and I like this I I think it's a nice expansion I don't like how big it is I don't I don't like how it blows up the the board but what I do like that I just now realized is the art the background art merges with the board game with the base game board so that's really nice uh cuz the art is just phenomenal I really really like this art but yeah like this gives you more agency a little bit of uh like just another goal a track to go up if you will to get more resources and more victory points and just another way to end the game so that one is really good I wouldn't say I necessarily play with it um all the time but I I would play with it again the other one uh that I've done one there was one just called diversity it just threw in more gold tiles and more Dragon tiles um that that's pretty much it uh the other one was the house ability cards this gives you um this gives you kind of a a
mini goal to go for to unlock a house ability and so like this one is whenever you receive at least two meat place a dragon ability token on this card and once you fill it out you have unlocked your house ability which is Hey whenever you receive at least two meat also receive a vegetable and a wood it's fine the abilities aren't cool at all like I really feel like if if I I need to look it up before I end this review because um I'm going to look it up right now NSK and games um was that Noble KN games is that I could have sworn this is who man am I yeah I swear this became bored and dice um hold on oh okay okay okay so I'm kind of close in November of 2018 NSK and games merged with Publisher bord and dice keeping the bord and dice name for the combined operation so yes I'm technically correct um so from future uh uh board and dice games the individual player powers are significantly better like toot Walk-On's expansion that gives you that those abilities are amazing and
then uh hell even the um um the game before it Zulan where you got player Powers but based off that expansion those are really good these are these are lame honestly I don't know if I ne like you honestly kind of forget about them when you're playing because you're just trying to figure out everything else that when you're like oh wait did I oh did I gain two meat when did I gain two meat and then you flip it over you finally do and you're like oh okay whatever it it'd be nicer if it was just if they were really cool Powers but honestly the powers kind of coincide with the the regular play of this game so I don't know I don't know if I'd really be Keen to throw those in um I was going to try out the quest expansion um but I really didn't like I was looking through the quest I'm like oh these are kind of these are kind of whatever they essentially allow you to get more like Dragon ability tokens so you can kind of compete for some of these because a lot of these have to do with Dragons a lot of the quests have to do with who has the most Dragon ability tokens on these specific dragons like this one in particular is hey if you have two of these or these two dragons Whoever has the most combined ability tokens on them will get nine points and quests allow you to kind
of get more of those cuz you can see uh what dragons are being competed for it's whatever uh I've tried to do the Rogue expansion but the wording on that expansion is so weird because in the setup it says when everyone receives their vassals they draw a rogue ability uh cuz the Rogue replaces a Spearman and it's just another worker but that worker particularly has a unique ability but the setup says when everyone receives all their vast draw a rogue ability and that can be tied to the Rogue and it's like oh okay so my thinking was oh whenever you actually get all your workers like when you get your All Your Dragon Riders and all your spearmen and your Rogue now you draw an ability and now it's unlocked but because that wording is in the setup that could also be oh when everyone has received their setup all their setup vassals their spearm and their dragon rider now draw a rogue ability and then you can hire your Rogue so I don't really know but looking through like the Rogue ability cards they're not like amazing um like the thief Rogue once per turn a player may spend a spear to take any two resources from one opponent with at least one vassel on the same action tile Assassin Rogue once per turn and only immediately before placing the Rogue you can spend two Spears in a
point to place the Rogue at any action Space occup by a Spearman and immediately return that Spearman back to the stock so just kind of things you still have to spend resources for um and then now all of a sudden your Rogue might just be caused just for have some Cutthroat nature for no reason so I don't know really about those either so the expansion I mean one thing that it does do that's kind of neat that I don't really recall a lot of module expansion is doing is at the end of this the module section it talks about integration with other modules and a lot of it says oh this could be integrated with any of them and no additional rules but if they do conflict then there's a section where you read where you it has like a new rule set you have to follow if you're using these modules I think that's really cool I think more modular expansions should do that so you're not having weird situations arise that might break the game but in terms of the call of the Dragon Lord expansion it's it's not amazing I really don't care for a lot of these yeah the diversity is nice it throws in some different objective tiles and some different dragons this is honestly the best part of it I don't think the the house ability cards are really all that cool the Rogue is weird to even try and get and looking through the ability cards anyway I don't think I would really like those um but this board I do
enjoy I think the wizard and the spell book thing is is a nice addition but even then it's not like this is this is worth the expansion alone this is worth spending the 150 bucks on the EXP whatever it is now so I have it and um I mean it's there and then you also have a bigger bigger sheet to keep track of so what does all this mean what did I talk for the past whatever 20 2 30 minutes about I talk about an old game a game that is 10 years old that literally no one is researching no one is coming across this game to to find out um this is really just more me doing a discussion just for the sake of content and reaffirming if this should stay in my collection and the verdict for that is still probably not I I don't mind this game I think it's good I think it has it has very interesting systems but when I'm going to play a worker placement game I have now hundreds of others I could play that is just better than this now would this be cool to see a reprint I think a reprint could really do this game wonders I think this game could be kind of modernized uh keep the art whoever the artist is um which I could easily look up on Board Game Geek actually did look it up and it was a name I could not
pronounce um keep the art but really modernize it I think they could go ham make work rep placement like the work rep placement spots a little bit I think the work placement spots should be tighter but resources should be looser like you have ways to get meat you have ways to do this combo off a little bit more make the exploration TS a little bit more interesting make the player Powers broken with uh if you want to make conditions you have to get then have those conditions where you kind of have to unlock them throughout the game but then once you get them it's like bam now it's a really busted ability uh I like this board I think that's neat I mean you can go even more wild with spell cards unique spell cards that are special actions that you can do this game could definitely I think make a comeback but there's no way it is there's no way but with the way bordon dice is now with like Daniel tassini or David tury or uh Simone Luciani H those designers could make this game sexy but they're not gonna and that's okay however um yeah I think that's pretty much it so on a scale of 1 to 10 what am I giving suurg I think I might go 6.5 I was going to say seven because I mean I think it is good but at the same time I'm not keeping it in my collection I'm not going to really ever desire to play it again even though going back what it really
did was a nice kind of uh nostalgic memory of thinking back 10 years ago when when when life wasn't and it's like ah 10 years when I was 21 when I was 21 Jesus Christ and and things were were simpler and that was nice that was a nice kind of feeling and now I'm jaded and these games are like uh God get it away from me even though oh the art is so cool but yeah that's it everyone that's my thoughts on suurg let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful time ofd is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you