Magnate The First City - Cash the Property Market! A Board Game Review
Transcript
so you don't need to be a good property developer or real estate to know how the game and to do well simcity the board game pretty much magnate the first city what we think of it what it is about coming up
hi everyone it's taryn and stella here from meepo university today we are going to display this giant box game magnate the first city yes so you don't need to be a good property developer or real estate to know how the game and to do well because our last game the winner was somebody who has no experience in those but win your brother yes indeed so yes this is by james naylor of nayla games recently off uh crowdfunding yeah yeah of crowdfunding we just say crowdfunding like these days there are so many right or not that many yes crowdfunding we it's fresh from crowdfunding yep and this is so the game pictures itself doesn't say it on the front but it says it on the side the property game for the 21st century um which yeah there's a there's a bit of um what's it called a bit of irony a bit of cynicism involved in that correct um but in a good way yeah but you'll see how it works in the same context yes yes yeah so we're gonna show you a quick overview of how it plays and then what we think of it yes so this is the magnate city here and it's made up of six individual tiles and a seventh central city tile which actually doesn't change at all it just sits there and
forms part of it kind of helps and there's four types of buildings that you can do and through the game you're going to be building you're going to be buying plots of land sorry buying plots of land and then building up buildings renting mouth to tenants and trying to make a profit yes trying to sell it for a profit as the property market goes up before the market crashed ding ding ding yes so that's where the uh the cynicism of the 21st century property market comes in the whole thing is a giant bubble and at the end of the game the market is going to crash hard yeah and so a big part of this game is about getting the property getting as much increase in value as you can and then selling out before the market crashes because anything you're left with is going to be worth a lot less so you you begin this game with two million dollars there's all this uh all these big wads of money here to represent that money yeah uh you begin with two million dollars and the land price is three hundred thousand and you will begin by buying plots of land so plots of land will come out randomly based on these tiles when they get drawn and more of them will come out each round so you can buy these plots of land and then you can start constructing buildings on them and there's four types of buildings there's residential there's retail there's offices and there's industrial and there's a small version and a big big version of each of them
they all have these big mini pieces so here for example i can build a nice little house here or there's a a big apartment block that you could go for build a little retail unit or build a huge shopping mall nice like that so each round you'll get three actions that you can use to buy land build properties or try to sell properties and that's one player one action at a time and going around yes and then at the start of each round so the round after you've built something you can try to bring in tenants and bringing in tenants is a dice rolling exercise and it's also a matter of the city building up all at once and this is this is quite a nice um nice feature of the game a nice uh thematic part of the game yeah so when you're trying to bring in a residential tenant for example you look at that tile and the three tiles around it and figure out how many retail tenants and how many office tenants there are and you roll dice equal to the lower of those two numbers and as you roll these dice you're trying to hit combinations that will give you certain types of tenants and if you're playing the if you're playing the advanced game that can range for residential for example between students and
a professional couple and families and you'll get more rent and more bonuses for the better ones but you need to roll better dice to get them in and there are dice mitigation as well of course yes you can advertise advertising will give you uh turn some dice into fives so you've got that mitigation and um when you've got good things around you it can attract more tenants better tenants better tenants yes so this house here for example is next to some nice parkland and that gives you a modifier on all of those dice and makes them higher helps you bring in better tenants so it is quite thematic as well in that way you know there's like different type of tenants the better tenants give you more income and not so good tenants is like anyways continuing worse income and no benefits yeah and in the same sort of way retail you roll dice based on how much residential there is around that retail offices likewise you need residential around to build up the offices and industry is either supported by residential or other ins other industry and so you see you can't specialize on just one thing you need to build everything up or at a similar sort of pace at the end of each round so this is where the the crash mechanic happens at the end of each round you'll look to see how heavily the market's gone into so if if there's any types of tenants that are completely empty here you'll start drawing risk cards
and the risk card may uh move you down so you've got this little stock market on here it may start to move you down on the crash track if the land price is too high uh then you'll start to draw risk cards for that if players have not been advertising then the market gets shaky and you'll start progress cards and certain tenants are empty as well of one type and then you might get risk card as well or if lots of players have been selling yeah that's also going to start drawing risk cards the market gets all suspicious the more people sell the higher the price goes but the risk will go up and eventually you'll get you'll get to the point where you've drawn enough of these risk cards that it will crash the market and the price might be up here at this point the game ends immediately and then you look at all of these cards it will tell you how much the price drops from the crash so here it's a five across the cards i've drawn here you would plummet the price by five and then everyone sells anything that's left at this lower price and that's kind of how the how the game works you get your tenant you get your your big profits on the buildings as well so a building is going to building has a fixed cost based on the building the land will depend on the land price but then when you sell the
building you count up the land the building all the tenants that are inside and any of these bonuses like this one here on the adjacent squares and you multiply that by the land price and so you can get huge amounts of money um off just just a little house or an apartment building full of students so there is one important mechanic that we didn't really think of it at the start but as the game goes like okay that's really important which is the first player bidding so the first player marker is so cute is this this little excavator thing that has got a bit of a wheel at the bottom and then you can move it like this like that thanks excavated you got excavated so yes it's a little wilty yeah so um is it necessary probably not do i like it yes it is very important because uh with the first maybe the first turn the first round doesn't really matter but then you realize oops there are limited amounts of tenants the first player get to roll the dice first for all of their buildings so that they can get the better tenants or the tenants not ran out and they can get tenants because you don't get 10 and you don't get income rental income and the price doesn't go up that's correct that's correct when you sell it yes um and then they are so the turn order auction yes and it is a straight option it's it's paying money to become uh first player in an open option
that is yeah a critical part of the game as well and important to have money at the right time yeah so you probably want to sell things at the end of last round but then if you sell things at the start of next round then you probably get more money because land price most probably going up and there's also determine who can take the first action which means you know you if you see a good plot of land that you think is going to work for you for your strategy and you just want to get in there first and then buy it yes because there are plots of land that um that quickly become more valuable a a house that has a lot of families a house that has a family in it is going to make a nearby house better and we're talking about the advanced version of the game there so there are two versions the simpler version uh all the tenants are the same but it doesn't add that much complexity to uh to go to the different types of tenants and so yeah it takes higher die rolls to get say a law firm versus a tech company but you'll get more rent you'll get higher property values from that from that extra sort of tenant indeed it was let's just share what we think of it shall we yes all right it is fun game it is a fun game if you first we're going to talk about the components it is it is very necessary probably not can it be a little bit smaller maybe but i am enjoying oh that's so cool i mean this is this is the big office building here yeah it's
huge and it gets in the way of the tokens but it does lend to the fun of the game it is it is it's like big box fun it is the easiest way to look at what building it is the color definitely oh yeah this color obviously for non-color bun but color blind can just see the shape as well so either way it's good the um the board it's actually not that sprawling it's just that it's quite large but it's not that sprawling so that's okay still fixed footprint it doesn't grow yes yes regardless of the number of players and player will get their own you know little play area it doesn't actually take that much space all you're holding is money and advertising tokens yes
oh that's awesome uh and the money over there yeah i love it i love us there's something about paper money we did not play with this last time because we play five players and we kind of like feel like okay saving a little bit of space there some dry snacks as well around the table take up some space anyways so this is actually really cool like just something about um paper money and the paper money is actually the backers like if um you saw it right like some of the backers are oh you can back more and then you appear on the paper money or you nominate somebody to appear to pay money which is cool life's really cute look at this it comes with a wallet where you can put your money um that that's a component um the game wise it is very fun it is it does feel a bit like one of those sim games like i know i'm sure there are lots of sim games city building maybe you know city skyline type of thing just really down not as complex you buy a land you sell maybe not city skyline it's the other type of sim game tycoon sim tycoon whatever yeah city tycoon uh yeah it feels a bit like little so you can flip a house you know the next round to make quick cash or you can hold on to it get income and then hope that you sell it at a better price later because price usually increase so it's that sort of like economic speculation fun um i used to work in real estate in
property management which is which deals with rental so this is not sales but it's kind of like real estate um also i did not do that well but uh one of my friends was like you should do well you used to work in real estate right like yeah but your brother won and he has no uh no experience with real estate so no you don't need real estate experience no you don't need to be property developer but yeah i think it's just a fun way of building and then looking at what other people are doing it's quite interactive as well because it really affects your turn and the bidding of the first players is really fun yeah i i like it as well i think i think it's a very good fun game it is i think it looks more heavy or overwhelming than it is it's actually quite a um yeah it can be a family level game or it can be a light gamer game i guess housing counting the tenants could be a little bit you know tedious yeah that's the one bit that looks complex is where you've got to count all the little populations on the tenants count all the little bonuses on all these tiles it feels overwhelming at first but it's actually pretty simple and by the time we played two or three rounds everyone was was fully in tune with what was going on um you know the game the gamers out there are going to say oh what are these dice things that are making it uh random whether i get my tenants and there is a huge part of the game which
is really the the win or lose is going to depend on there'll be one round where everyone is selling everything because they can see the market about to crash and whoever's coming second or thirds like you know what i'm gonna hang on i'm just gonna try to hang on and hope it doesn't crash and who wins or loses is probably gonna depend on whether it crashes that was really fun yesterday because i think two people hedging on markets gonna crash this end of the round and then two others uh like like the others like neutral oh it's like you like you two right two was hanging like 101 is thinking it's going to crash and then just like betting on okay i'll buy more land but then it got crashed it was so fun yeah so i mean if that if that sort of wild swing doesn't appeal to you then this game's not going to appeal to you but it is a fun play yes no doubt and it is even like with five players it's pretty pretty quick in between turns because each player will just do one action and then go to the next player until every once it goes around three times until everyone does three actions yeah if i think you know when i when i look at the things that there was only really one thing that frustrated me about this game which was the turn order auction well sorry the first player option rather than a turn order auction because you can definitely particularly when the tenants are running thin
you can benefit substantially just by the person on your right right right yeah more than the person on your left that's correct um and i mean that's i think that's one of my big it's one of my triggers in a general set not triggers but it's one of my kids it's one of my things in a general sense that um that can frustrate me about a first player thing you know it's it's the classic thing everyone knows terra mystica um that was one of the things that annoyed people about terra mystica that it only had a first person to pass was first player but then it was clockwise and then the everyone house ruled that you the passing order became and then and so on i said a lot about that so yeah that that is from a gamer standpoint the one thing that frustrates me um it could do with a full turn order option um and maybe even an in in in indonesia indonesia style too you can't even see the same like the country i am from maybe even that splatter indonesia type turn order auction where you you bid the money but you don't lose it um you just put it in your end game scoring pile um but which is sort of like it it means it's more complex though making it slightly more complex makes it more complex but it also lessens the cost instead of yeah instead of costing the money entirely it just costs the opportunity cost of that money yeah but i'm sure it's been like playtested so many times i've seen it around like people play
testing and i'm sure it's it works to make it live a game yeah that's the thing it's it's it's appropriate for uh the complexity of the game yeah um i would immediately be looking all right how can i house rule that to um to make that this is just an automatic thing that we do and us especially taryn yeah and it didn't it didn't harm me at all during the game i was like paying small amounts to get first player early on i know and then i was sitting to the right of you to the right of you so i always like last play i'm like no but then um our friend to the right he actually did uh play a big amount the last round i was like yes i'm second player yeah i can see that what you say also the round i'm thinking of where this happened like four players built office blocks on the same round so it's actually each subsequent player who built an office block knowing that that was going to be tight um intensely because there's four different types of there's four different types of buildings here um even in a five player game if everyone's um building at different times then you'll have a bit more a bit less of that competition yeah yeah that's actually true on soft type of thing but um yeah that that's yeah that's the only place i can fault this game for what it is it's um the race is fun yeah the rest is fine and i'm i'm yeah i'm only going to say fun because it's not your heavy game random things are going to happen
but you're going to have a good time exactly i think i think you do if you don't take it too per like too seriously and the dice roll is probably my nitpick of the day of because i usually roll bad there was one time where i could not get the right one well oh yeah that was that time when i was i was second player in a turn and i thought i was gonna get a good one because that was really competitive to get tenants in the office building i didn't get the good ones so i was so sad because that dice roll i mean it's probably me as well i didn't invest more on advertising if i did then i would have probably got better tenants they should have a property manager expansion a lot to get better tenants let you yeah level up the tenants yeah um as we said the advance the only difference really between the beginner and the advanced game is that you've got three different types of tenants instead of a generic tenant um it's not that much anyone who anyone who's played any sort of heavy game will be able to go straight into the the heavy one as well it's also got a tutorial set up there's this whole deck of tutorial cards i guess this is of that you know the modern style of thing where instead of reading the rule book you just pick up the cards and read the cards out the game is not that complex to require that in my opinion depends if it's a family type of game would probably
benefit more on that sort of tutorial possibly anyway that's um that comes with the game as well it's got a tutorial set up where you de-randomize some of the setup things um but yeah the full advanced mode is pretty easy to uh to jump straight into in my opinion so in summary we both enjoy it i think all of our other friends your brother also enjoyed the game yeah everyone had a good time yeah ever had to get it it's really a fun time where you're like oh no this person built that oh no that person built it oh no it's gonna craze it's gonna crash oh no you stole my tenants like that sort of things so hopefully you get to play this at some point and then enjoy it um but please do let us know if um maybe you agree with taryn with the turn order things have you played terra mystica have you played anything that's quite like this let us know in the comments i'd love to see your comments and then replying to those anything else tan no i think that covers i mean we could we could talk more about some of the ways that the game play the different sorts of strategies like i built i bought the best land early on and then everyone just built around it and then i came in late um and made a 300 000 micro profit on it because the game ended earlier than i hoped and then you built something a house and then your brother brought the price down by building an industrial unit
you can also build you can also buy land next to some of your land even if the sale hasn't come out it costs double but sometimes it's the position that you're really yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah like it's pretty magical there's just enough little things that doesn't make the game complex yeah but it gives you a lot of things you can do yep indeed it is also six of also six of these tiles oh yes sorry twelve of these tiles so you can get a random six and you can maybe it's a more industrial heavy landscape or um yeah they all have different different sorts of benefits and that is it magnate the first city yeah well it's got this like little like big not little like still little but big building and that um yeah it let us know if you have any questions any comments um please write thank you taryn right below um anything else aaron i think that's it that's it that is magnate and if you find this useful it will be really helpful if you could please hit the like button thank you for that and subscribe to us if you haven't already done so we do video like this like a review we do my stella sean suite which is an overview fun usually costume taren does have to play we do live play for every weekend and every thursday evening whatever and so on and then you know other bits and pieces video
and i'm also on instagram hopefully we'll find each other there and hopefully we will see you next time bye