Shards of Creation Review
Transcript
Is this trick taking game worthy of honor? Or is it full of ruin? Shards of Creation is a new trick taking game set with characters from Brandon Sanderson's Cosmere. If you are a fan of Sanderson's books like I am, then no explanation is needed. But to those who don't know, the Cosmere is a shared universe where different stories he has written take place. In this universe, the god-like figures who hold enormous powers are called shards and are depicted artistically in this trick taking game. Now for the game. The quick overview of how it works is that you choose four or five of the eight shards provided depending on the player count. A shard is randomly chosen to be the trump suit each round and each shard brings its own cards, uh trump abilities, card powers with special actions you can take during the game and at the end of each round or affecting how your scoring area is scored. Whenever you win a trick, you choose one card from the trick to keep in your scoring area.
You play three rounds of 10 tricks each and you score at the end of the game based on the number of shards you win as well as the number of complete sets of all the different shards you're playing with and whoever has the most points wins. Thematically, I think this game is really cool. You have shards like Preservation having pretty much the same number on each of the cards that he provides except for one, which really hearkens to the book, of course. No spoilers will be mentioned. The uh character of each shard then, you know, comes through in card numbers, card powers, last but not least the artwork, which is awesome to see, and great to know that it's canon to the lore of the Cosmere. In addition, the theme shines in a few ways mechanically that depicts how these shards can be opposites of each other.
For example, Dominion and Devotion, which are linked together in the Cosmere lore, have abilities that are similar but different where Devotion has cards with abilities that can be added to other shards in the scoring pile aside from Devotion herself while Dominion does the opposite where other cards are treated as Dominion cards for scoring. Ultimately, did I enjoy this game and how does it stack compared to other trick takers out there? Usually, I would first turn to a peer review when I do my reviews and mention what other people have said about this game, but since it's so new and going straight to retail without a Kickstarter or anything like that comments are sparse about this game. And I've tried looking online for reviews and thoughts about the game and once again content was sparse aside from how to plays and gameplay videos.
So, my thoughts about this game is that you know, it's a fine trick taker. It doesn't do anything too crazy or unique. And so, it's not one that I would find compelling in and of itself to come back over come back to over and over again. And I think that's why this game is perfect and let me explain. When hearing about this game a while back, I remember finding a video by Brandon Sanderson where he mentioned that this game was coming out and why he wanted this game to be made. To paraphrase, he wanted a game that was easy enough to teach others particularly who are fans of his books but perhaps not avid board gamers or trick taking gamers as well. To understand and play. To have a taste of something from the Cosmere in a tabletop experience aside from the RPGs, of course.
With that motivation and goal in mind, I think that this game nailed that goal in its approach to being a standard, unassuming, streamlined tit-trick taking game that isn't too hard or weird for non-gamers to understand, but still had some fun elements that a trick taking veteran might know how to utilize and exploit and still enjoy a trick-taking experience for what it is. Now, I'm not a an expert in trick-taking games by any means, but I have played a few. There are over 3,000 games on BoardGameGeek that are listed as having trick-taking as a mechanism. And of those, I've played around 15 or so, not really counting Arcs, which kind of feels like a stretch in that regard. And I've enjoyed these games for what they are, but I wouldn't say that any of them are among my favorites to play of all, you know, of all time to play over and over again. I find them to fall into general categories as well. For example, trick-takers that can be super competitive, you know, like Hearts and Spades.
Uh I feel like you could play those games and and potentially play them, you know, for money. Uh you have cooperative trick-takers like The Crew and Lord of the Rings trick-taking games. You have trick-takers that are also more fun forward. Uh games like Skull King, which does offer a bidding experience, but is it feels more like a party game to me, which is why I kind of like it. Uh and you have of simpler trick-takers like Marshmallow Test that are, you know, made for perhaps younger audiences to include them in the experience and therefore are a little bit more fun forward. My thought is that Shards of Creation lands somewhere in between a competitive experience and a fun forward one. Where the basics of trick-taking can be explained you fairly simply. Uh they can be exploited a little bit for, you know, those once again, those veteran players who know a little bit of strategy with trick-taking.
But there isn't a very unique catch or hook that makes this game stand out amongst its peers. Like, for example, how Cat in the Box has suits that are decided once you play the card, which seems to be a trick-taking mechanism that is fairly different and unique. So, while Shards of Creation doesn't stand out mechanically among other trick takers, it still provides a standard experience that a wider audience can enjoy, especially those who want a splash of the Cosmere to feature as the art for this game. I had a good time playing it with friends and family. It wasn't a bad experience by any means, but do go into it knowing that it may not deliver in a very unique or compelling way with its gameplay. It's a fun game. It's a fine game, but perhaps that's all it's meant to be.
So, those are my thoughts on Shards of Creation. Let me know what you think about the game, especially if you have trick taking experience, much more experience than me, and if this game does shine in a way that I had not expected. Let me know in the comments what you think. And once again, thank you for watching this video, and I hope to catch you on the next one.