Skip to main content
Loading video...

Awkward Guests 2: The Berwick Cases Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 17:07

hey everyone today I'm taking a look at awkward guests 2 the Berwick cases now this is a two-player only deduction game that takes 30 to 40 minutes to play and of course this is a sequel to the original awkward guests which is my favorite deduction game of all time and when I heard that a sequel was coming out naturally I was very excited i' and I've been fortunate enough to get an early copy here this one is of course a Spanish language version of the game um but it is eventually coming out in English and all the components I'm going to show you today are language independent so this game will be launching on Kickstarter on the 1st of April 2024 so be sure to keep an eye out for that one so let's take a look at the components here and if you are familiar with the original or guests this might look somewhat familiar to you where each player's player sheet will look like this we have this kind of blueprint of a mansion and you are trying to solve who the murderer uh in this case of the Berwick twins are so you have bernes and beatus each player is going to be kind of the um the investigator on one of these murder cases and The Mastermind of the reverse one of those um and youve got a bunch of information on your sheets here you've got all these motives that all the different suspects have the evidence the potential murder weapons of course again you got the Mansion itself here which shows the roots that they can go through to get to the crime scene and you have all of your murder weapon types and Tra they leave on the body um Etc

now you do have this player board here which is where you're going to be dictating your actions from through this new dice system which is completely new from the original uh each player is going to have their own player Shield which has a good breakdown of the setup and all the different actions you can take throughout the game and unlike the original instead of having that big um deck of cards each player is going to have their own deck of cards which they will use to formulate their murder mystery so again unlike the original guests this one you are setting the challenge for your opponent by deciding who the murderer is deciding what the motive is and the weapon is and also the um the path they've taken to the crime scene and you're going to do that by using these different cards like for example you can choose the the rooms or the roots they've gone through you can choose the murder weapon and of course you are choosing the suspect itself as well as the motives and some potential kind of red herring leads so I'm not going to go through the entire setup procedure here because it is just that it is quite procedural and you do need to be quite meticulous about it because as you can imagine with a deduction game the smallest of Errors can break the game so you do need to go through through that procedure quite carefully to make sure you've got everything correct and but as you can imagine you are just making sure that one of these suspects has both incentives to do the murder as well as having the evidence um and of course being able to trace through that route to get to the crime scene so you can see here my opponent has set the murderer as um yoro Yagami

she's going to start in this little coffee room here and then she's going to trace this path through these rooms collecting a murder weapon on the way in this example it would have been um the uh the number four which is this um kind of um which number is here this kind of big pot of scolding water here um and they're going to go all that way through to the crime scene and it's going to be my job to solve this mystery and it's going to be this player's job to solve this mystery that I've set for them now the game play is going to be quite simple where when it is your turn of course you are going to be asking the questions of your opponent and trying to work out who the murderer is now unlike the original as I mentioned you are not going to be going through this um smart deck of cards I think it was called the brilliant and deck system in this one you're going to use a dice system instead where you're going to roll uh these three Dice and then you're going to potentially use them to take different actions so there are a bunch of different actions you can take and will go through them um individually but you do have the options um to have a roll in almost like a yachy fashion and you can even discard a a die in order to flip another die to the exact face that you want so you do have a bit of autonomy to get the exact outcome that you want but you may have to sacrifice an action in order to do that so let's go through all of the individual actions the first of which is this waste coat action which you can use in two different ways the first of which will be placing on this spot on the outside of the board where you will simply draw two cards from the deck that you are

investigating and rule out two connection points um that the murderer has not gone through so you can see here in this example the connection point between the gallery and this kind of plant room has not been taken as well as this kind of cloak room and the diner so that's one of the ways you can use the um use the waste coat action and of course you're going to be ticking those things off on your play sheet to rule those connection points out the second way is to place it in a specific room where the Mastermind must tell you um three of the suspects that have not been in that room and again you can tick that off by ticking off the footprints in those individual rooms the second action you can take is this interrogation action which again can be used in two different ways now when you use this action you will choose two of the suspects from the deck here and each one is associated to a letter and um you are going to be get given information either concerning which of their starting rooms these suspects were in which of course can be relevant in relation to which rooms they can access um as well as the option of being able to ask what their preferred weapon is so you can see during the setup each person has a preferred weapon type and of course you can potentially rule them out if the track is not going to cross through any rooms with that weapon in the third action is this testify action where you will pick again two of the characters

that have not been used previously in any other inquiry and you will see if those characters testify against each other so you can see here that why eure Yagami has protest um has testified against Quinton quills in this example that doesn't mean it's going to be the um the murderer necessarily um but it is a good kind of indication that it could be uh the murderer the next action is the evidence action where the Mastermind will let the investigator know if any evidence relating to any of the suspects was found in that specific room so in this example with the dining room uh there is evidence relating to uh Quinton quills um and of course you would Mark that off on your sheet because again that is one of the pieces of the puzzle to determine who the murderer is and the final inquiry is this forensic one like this where you will simply draw a card off the um the deck that you are investigating from the forensic deck here and it will show you a particular method of injury that was not used uh in the murder that was not found on the body so in this example I would take off anything with this particular symbol on because I know that was not the murder type used and that is essentially how the game works you're going to be using that information to try and deduce uh who the murderer is and at the end of each round when each player has taken both of their investigations you'll simultaneously choose from these deck of cards whether you want to continue continue with the investigation or whether you want to try and solve the murder if you do try to solve the murder and you are unsuccessful you will take

off one of these boxes here cuz that's your three attempts essentially but of course if you do solve the Mur successfully um then you will win the game okay so let's share some thoughts on awward guests 2 at the Burwick cases and I suppose fundamentally this game still has all the things that I love about the original or guests when it comes to the deduction in part you know I love this logical puzzle this tangible nature of having this blueprint of the Mansion where the suspects have started which rooms they potentially accessed which connection points have not been accessed you can rule certain points out you know which weapons have been used which haven't been used who's got the motives who's testifying against who it all comes together in a really thematic package that um really does elevate the kind of um just a deduction genre in general so that Hallmark of the a guest what Mega Corp and do really does shine through here as you'd expect because to be honest for me they are kind of pioneering the deduction genre at the moment something I've noticed about this game is that you are given and provided access to information in a lot faster manner than you are with the original uh awkward guests because you are not recycling cards between the other players like the original this one again you are given quite um quite pertinent information really quickly especially you know with certain actions you know if you draw a couple of these forensic cards because um several of the weapons have multiple methods of injury then you can definitely um rule out a lot of information really quickly so it

definitely does give you um a great forward momentum in this game and it definitely prods you towards trying to solve that mystery um sooner rather than later so if you want your games to be a bit more Punchy because this game is definitely quicker than the original this one only takes around 30 to 45 minutes then that's certainly something this game provides that being said I do like the touches that you cannot keep on spamming um the same actions because not only are you subject to uh the dice rolls of course yes you can get fortunate by getting the exact roles that you want um but the chances are you're not going to do that or if you want precise information you might have to sacrifice a die in order to change another one to the exact face that you want now I suppose some people might not like that because you are going to be subject to the luck of the role but because again that information dump is quicker it does not bother me at all and actually quite enjoy uh that mechanism there's also some additional touches um when it comes to asking for specific um inquiries that you cannot use these same characters for more than one inquiry that round so again a nice way to stop you tunnel visioning and keep on spamming the same character again and again to get all the information about that character and I suppose the unique thing about this game and one of the unique selling points about this game is the fact that you challenge your opponent by making that scenario your myself I can't think of many other deduction games if any that do that which I think is a really cool touch especially if you are going to consistently play this game with the same player there are quite a few little

tricky things that you can do by you know offering you know false leads know are you going to spread the information really thin amongst all the different suspects are you going to compile them amongst a couple of suspects so there are some really kind of intricate false leads there and the more you get familiar with this setup system the more you play around with those man-made scenarios so it's quite nice that you have some autonomy and ownership over the scenario itself rather than playing from a generic deck so you can really kind of personally challenge your opponent and make them fall for those Mis leads now that being said um the setup process is quite arduous as it is with the original uh awkward guests now it is going to take you know 15 20 minutes maybe to start with to um to get that set up correct but the more you play it does become simpler and the process is actually pretty logical once you get your head around it but that first time or two you play the game it might be a little bit jarring because you are going to be so precise and not getting anything wrong you know some cards have to stay in the deck some cards have to come out of the deck you need to make sure a certain amount of misleads are there um you want to make sure that you know certain routes are taken Etc to make sure that all the information is spot on otherwise the game will simply crumble so you know be prepared that if you didn't like the original Walker guest because of the longer setup time this one is probably not going to be any quicker um at least for the first few games another thing that I've noticed with this game is that because it is a head-to-head Style game

where when it is not your turn you are still having to participate as The Mastermind and provide truthful answers to your opponent and what that means is that when it's not your turn you don't really have that downtime to bury your head in the sand and look at your sheet to try and work out what the mystery is so sometimes when the game draws to a halt you both have to Halt and try and you know map things out rather than taking the time on your opponent's time to try and map your puzzle out again because you have to be engaged at all times there something to bear in mind there something else I found with the game is that because this game uses a dice system rather than the cards um you do miss out on one of the kind of redeeming features of the original which is when you are given information in the form of a card the card would tell you exactly what to cross off on your player sheet and this one because of course it's all kind of language independent and there's no um clear symbology on what happens when um sometimes it's easy to forget or get confused about what each symbol means again this is going to get ironed out with repeated plays but sometimes you're going to have to keep on Cross referencing with what each action actually does now you know the um Shields here are very useful they do give you what you need to know but it's not going to be as smooth maybe as the original again at least not in the first couple of plays there are a couple of additional foibles that I've noticed

which are probably more on me than um than being a fault of the game which is because you are constantly flipping between you know your side of the sheet and your opponent's side um sometimes I did write the um the results on the wrong side of the sheet and of course that can create a whole um Cascade of wrong actions that you are you need to backtrack on and cover up your mistakes and I also found that sometimes I was drawing cards off the wrong deck again more on me probably me being more of an idiot than the game itself but these are little things that you need to be on the ball with otherwise the game can fall apart so um just be cautious of those let's briefly touch on the production um I'm not sure if this is going to be the final version of the game here or a pretty Advanced prototype but if it is the final version I'm perfectly happy with there all the quality of the components is really good um you know the dice are nice um obviously purposely made for this game uh itself the sheets I think are well laid out nice and clear and the cars are of good quality and it's not like you're going to be shuffling them a whole lot anyway and uh it's got that classic awkward guests look with that kind of grotesque uh cartoony art that I personally really like I know it's not for everybody but I think it's got a unique look and it stands out from amongst the pack okay so let's share some final thoughts on Awkward guests to the Burwick cases and as you'd expect you know Mega corpin know what they're doing with deduction games you're going to get that satisfying deduction puzzle of trying to solve a really enjoyable and engaging uh

murder mystery I do like this idea that you can set challenges to your opponent by know purposely making a bespoke scenario for your opponent to solve which makes it that much more engaging and more fun when at the end of the game you know you're explaining through your thought process and you know the M the the red herrings that they took Etc that's a really fun process now as I said be aware that the setup time and the procedural nature of it can be a little bit laborious um at times but that is I suppose somewhat um nullified by the fact that you are given information a lot quicker here in a you know a lot quicker succession and you can very quickly start ticking things off on your player sheet and if you're good at deduction and um you know you use this dice mechanism to your advantage you can probably do a pretty good job of burning through this information very quickly and um heading to a you know a successful um murder mystery being solved so that race nature that head-to-head nature is really going to shine through if you and your opponent both invest in this game and are of a equal skill level so um again if you are going to regularly play or consistently play a two-player deduction game with the same person then definitely give this one a look if you like the original awward guests but you generally cater to higher player counts then i' probably say keep with your original one you probably don't need both of them but again if you are regularly and more often than not playing two-player only this is a good one because of that nature of being able to set the challenge to your opponent

being a little bit quicker and um again unlike the original where the two-player game you'd be recycling cards back and forth this one isn't going to have that because of this yachi dice system so um again this one is launching on Kickstarter on April the 1st 2024 so keep an eye out for it

Progress saved